Chapter 1: Because You're Mine
Halloween was just around the corner, and Brittany was thrilled. She'd convinced Quinn, Santana and Rachel to do a group costume. Santana agreed as long as she could still be something sexy. Rachel insisted that there had to be a musical element. Quinn, well she was just along for the ride. If Brittany did the work, why would she say no?
"Hocus Pocus." Brittany said to the girls congregated at the dining table in the Lopez-Pierce household.
"I told you sexy Britt. Witches are the total opposite." Santana argued.
"I suppose I can't complain, that I Put A Spell On You song is quite nice." Rachel said.
"Good. And San, I listened to your request too." Brittany presented a Binx costume to her wife "You get to be a sexy black cat."
"Isn't Binx a boy cat?" Quinn asked, and Brittany glared at her.
"Does it matter?" the dancer said, looking to Santana for the final verdict.
"Eh, as long as I don't have to turn into a dude like in the movie I'm all good Britt Britt." Santana smiled, trying on the cat ears.
"Good. Now to split up the Sanderson sisters. Obviously I'm Sarah." Brittany said "So I'll let you two decide who's who between Mary and Winifred."
"Rach?" Quinn asked the brunette "You pick."
"Oh! Well since I'm a star, I think I should be Winifred. Right?" Rachel asked, waiting for a sparky reply from Santana, but the Latina had run off to get in her sexy cat get-up.
"Rach, that's fine with me." Brittany said, peeking her head out the bathroom door where she was putting her own dress on.
"Splendid. Quinn, shall we try these on?" Rachel asked.
"No time like the present. We'll be in the guest bedroom B." Quinn said as Rachel pulled her away. Brittany laughed as she watched the tiny diva drag Quinn off. She was really glad they'd gotten together. Sure Kurt and Blaine were great, but having two other women loving women around was nice. Especially for Santana. Plus it got Quinn to hang out more, and made Rachel tolerable.
"Babe" Santana said, interrupting Brittany's thoughts "I need help with my tail." I took the blonde a minute before her blue eyes cleared and she helped Santana secure her tail.
"You look hot." Brittany said, looking the woman up and down.
"The same can be said for you. You chose the hot witch huh?" Santana said, taking the eyeliner and giving herself whiskers.
"You know it babe." Brittany smirked.
"Where's the dwarf and Q?" Santana asked.
"San" Brittany scolded softly.
"Fine, where's Berry and her puppy?" San tried, earning another glare, but a badly hidden giggle, from Brittany.
"Getting dressed. And you need to be nicer or I'll let Quinn make fun of you being whipped." the blonde threatened.
"I am NOT whipped." the Latina crossed her arms.
"Of course not…" Brittany leaned down and whispered "not if you don't wanna be a whipped creamy mess." Santana gulped and looked at Brittany hungrily.
"Babe?" Santana asked after a moment.
"Hmm?" the blonde continued doing her mascara.
"I'm whipped. But only you can know, okay?" Santana admitted nervously.
"Of course my love. Now why don't you get our friends so I can see my masterful plan come together." She put down the mascara and Santana quickly went to get the other two.
When Brittany finally saw it all put together, she let out a joyous cackle. This was gonna be the best Halloween yet.