I don't own Star Trek Enterprise.
Please let me know what you think.
Time Travel is Impossible.
T'Pol often claimed the science directorate ruled out the existence of time travel, and it was true. The Vulcan Science Directorate had been studying physics for decades ever since the first warp flight and from the discovery of interstellar phenomena exploratory expeditions had discovered over the years, but aside from the reality of time dilation the Vulcans had never been able to discover the existence of anything that allowed travel into the future or into the distant past.
But that wasn't the only reason she, like so many Vulcans who attended the Science Academy's hallowed halls, viewed time travel as impossible. Many Vulcan scientists and philosophers had debated on the realities of time travel related paradoxes - many Vulcans had a problem with viewing how anyone could travel back into the past and murder their own relatives before the child who would give birth to the killer in the first place.
How could the grandchild even travel back in the first place to do it?
Wouldn't they not exist?
But philosophies had to give way to science and physics. The Vulcan expeditions had discovered many phenomena during the centuries they had been travelling in this part of the galaxy, and while they had discovered black holes which had a slight temporal distortion they had never discovered any indication the laws of physics actually allowed the existence of a time machine due to the dangers of paradoxes. All the universe seemed to allow was time dilation since it didn't come close to creating any of the dangerous paradoxes which could not be allowed.
When T'Pol had first learnt of the Temporal Cold War she had instantly cast judgement on it, much to the frustrations of her human crew mates, whom she had already begun to respect and admire even though she would never have admitted it at the time.
But over time, despite all the evidence - the further manipulations of the Temporal Cold War from the way the Suliban framed the Enterprise crew by wiping out an innocent colony, the way factions in the war were behind the Xindi attack on Earth, to say nothing of Daniels and how he was able to walk through walls and that database he had left behind, the visit to Detroit where she'd had to deal with the unpleasant sides of human history, the alternate version of the Second World War - T'Pol had always repeated "the Vulcan science directorate claims time travel is impossible."
So why did she stubbornly say that despite the evidence?
Because she just found so many things about the Temporal Cold War impossible to believe, but what T'Pol found difficult to understand was what the war was even about. Why would a number of groups who had the power to visit both the past and the future want to tear it apart by introducing events which weren't even meant to happen?
The Xindi war was one of the biggest examples of factions manipulating events, but T'Pol and her human ship mates had witnessed moments where other factions had pulled the strings and changed history in ways T'Pol could not even begin to think about, never mind comprehend. It had sickened the Vulcan science officer completely that some malevolent race of transdimensional beings would manipulate another race to kill another, just to create a wasteland of terraformed and transformed space for themselves, although T'Pol knew it was expected for worlds to create colonies although some ambitions were much less belligerent.
Trip had lashed out at T'Pol when Enterprise had been thrown back in time to that alternate Second World War where the Nazis had conquered half of the United States of America, she had been ordering a complete systems check to explain what had happened. Trip had believed she was once more denying the existence of time travel, but this time she wasn't. No, T'Pol had come to accept the existence of time travel. She was stubborn, but there was only so much she could take before she accepted the proof with her own eyes She had ordered the scan and checks on the systems to find out what had brought them back into the past and see if there was any sign of finding a way back to their own time. She and Trip had a minute connection, even then. It wasn't hard for her to sense his sheepishness; not only was it written all over his features at the time, but his frustration was identical to her own.
The Temporal Cold War had long since stopped being a Cold War. It was now a Time War. An agent had journeyed back in time to 1916 and assassinated Lenin. The assassin was never caught, eyewitnesses claimed they had vanished. As a result of the assassination, Russia never turned from communism - Stalin may have been a dictator who ruined and was responsible for the loss of millions of lives, but there was no denying without Stalin, Russia would never have grown stronger. The assassination allowed Adolf Hitler to take over Russia and allowed him to focus his attention on the West; without the massive defeat in Russia, the German army achieved victories in places where the war was never supposed to be fought. It was no wonder the Germans were on the way to winning the war.
T'Pol sighed as she thought about the implications; it was so incredible that just one event, one change of history would have so many consequences. She might not know anything about what made a Temporal War so devastating, but after she had just learnt about Lenin and the consequences, she had the feeling that was how a Time War worked; you just sent an agent to an important moment of history, change it, and then created more changes to the timeline along the way.
She wondered if Time Agents were meddling in the histories of other worlds, and it would not surprise her if there were Agents altering time throughout history.
Daniel's return and his disfigurement had surprised and horrified T'Pol and Phlox; portions of his body had aged while others had regressed to different levels, one of which was a foetal stage of his development. T'Pol had some ideas of what had happened, but she had been more interested in getting answers from him. It didn't surprise her in the least Daniels had sent the Enterprise back through time, but it annoyed and angered her the Time Agent had the nerve and the arrogance to use her and her shipmates as pawns as part of his game.
When Vosk's temporal conduit was destroyed after Archer returned and they took the ship into the atmosphere and negated the timeline's changes, T'Pol wondered if they had seen the last of Daniels and time travel. She would like to believe it was never coming back although she would be deeply fascinated to see more moments of history, such as Surak's reformation and the Time of Awakening, and she would really like to imagine the days when she had been so sure time travel was impossible.
But she couldn't.