Welcome! I'm a new writer, and this is a smut fic I wrote on my free time :)

It was inspired by a certain r/CultOfCapella roleplay, as well as Flexdrop441 fics (when are you rewriting Subaru's revenge? That shit was so good but then you deleted it :c) as well as my favorite fic, Karma's Revenge!

I had to wait until I could make an account, so you might get the next chapter today or tomorrow :)

It has tons of smut in the later chapters, so get ready for that!

Around a month ago, Subaru mysteriously disappeared. The Emilia camp quickly started looking for him, but it was no easy task. Something was blocking his connection with Beatrice, making the entire process harder.

Eventually, he was found to be in Gusteko, deep inside a rift of mountains. Emilia, Beatrice and Garfiel took upon themselves the task of rescuing him, and so they rushed to his location.

Arriving at the cold mountains of Gusteko, they managed to find a small cave thanks to the putrid scent of some Witch Cultists. Of course they would be the ones behind his kidnapping. After disposing of them, they entered the cave. After some minutes of walking, they arrived at a closed iron door.

Garfiel beastified his arm and struck the door, his claw burrowing on the steel. He yanked his arm backwards and tore it apart. Inside was a sleeping Subaru on top of a comfortable bed, along with a few plushies looking like mabeasts. He was using a rabbit plushie as a pillow.

"Subaru!" Emilia said, rushing to his side. She poked his cheek and breathed a sigh of relief, he was okay. His Subaru was safe.

Beatrice put her short arm on his stomach, checking his gate in case he had been cursed. Nothing looked out of the usual, it was the exact same as the night he had disappeared.

"We need ta get out o' here." Emilia and Beatrice nodded, picking Subaru up like a potato sack and leaving. By the time they left the mountain and climbed onto the carriage Subaru was still asleep, though they didn't pay attention to it.

The next morning, he finally woke up. Stretching his arms, he took notice of his surroundings and companions.

"E-Emilia…?" he said, his eyes wide in shock. He shook his head around, as if looking for someone.

"Yes Subaru, it's me. We rescued you from the Witch Cult."

"No! You couldn't have!" Subaru took his hands to his head and curled his body into a ball.

"Let me go back. Or she will come." Beatrice and Emilia looked at each other. What was Subaru talking about? Garfiel was busy riding the carriage along Patrasche so he didn't hear what was going on inside.

"Bad Subaru! We can't let you with the witch cult, you nincompoop!"

"Who is she, Subaru?"

"Mama."

That word sent chills down their back. Mama? The same Meili talked about? But Subaru looked okay… He hadn't been tortured, had he? Meili had told them everything about how Mama treated her children.

Before they could ask, Subaru followed.

"Mama is always nice to me. But when other children make mistakes she makes me see it. I don't want to end like them."

Emilia and Batrice were shocked. Mama? Nice to him? He… couldn't. Subaru couldn't think that the sin archbishop of lust was, in any way, nice. Had he been brainwashed? He had to be.

Emilia rushed forward and tightly hugged Subaru. "Don't worry Subaru! We'll protect you, I promise!"

"You will?" Subaru said, a few tears ruling down her cheeks.

"We will." answered Beatrice, and Subaru bursted into tears.

After he recovered, Emilia asked what he had been doing for the past month. She needed to know what the archbishop had done to her so she could freeze her in the most painful way possible.

"She patted my head." That's not what they were expecting.

"Scratched my chin. Gave me lap pillows. Told me I'm a good boy."

That didn't sound very human. More like… if Subaru was a pet. A simple dog she took a liking to.

"We also played games. Tons of games."

"What kind of games Subaru?" asked Beatrice.

"At times we played chess. Or tag. Other times…" he drifted off, blushing. Emilia caught up on the meaning, Frederica had told her how babies were made after all. And that ugly whore had dared to do it with her Subaru.

"Subaru…" she started speaking, clenching her fists. "Did she…"

"I didn't want to, but… At times she even transformed onto you…" Subaru sobbed.

"Half-elf, come. Leave Betty's Subaru alone." Beatrice ordered. Emilia turned to her with a rageful expression. The temperature dropped by a few grades.

"Beatrice." she spelled, slowly. "What do you want?"

"It's important, I suppose." She picked up her hand and dragged her outside, where Garfiel was preparing breakfast. They walked away so no one could hear them.

"Give me your mana, I suppose." Emilia reluctantly agreed, extending her arm. Beatrice touched it and a light purple light came from it, along with Emilia feeling more tired.

"I'm going to Al Shamak her to the rabbits, I suppose."

"She's mine, Beatrice." Emilia refuted.

"She tainted Betty's Subaru, I suppose. I won't forgive her, in fact."

"She used me! She used me to force herself into my Subaru! I'll be the one to kill her!"

"Betty doesn't care, I suppose. Betty only cares about Subaru." Beatrice left and entered the carriage again. Draining Subaru's mana, he fell asleep for the rest of the journey back home.

Meanwhile, back at the frozen wasteland of Gusteko, Capella was welcomed by two dead guards. Rushing to Subaru's room, he found it empty.

Someone had taken away her pet. And she wouldn't let that pass by. It had to be that dumb half-elf her pet used to follow instead of her, the great Capella-sama. Turning into a white dove, she left the cave and set fly towards Roswaal's mansion.

She would take revenge, no matter the means.