"This is going to be the most exhilarating year yet."
"And why is that, Prongs?" Sirius asked as he leaned back against the headboard of his bed.
"Because, Pads, this is the year." James, who had been digging out his pajamas from his trunk, stood tall and glanced at his friends, "This is the year that Evans finally says yes!"
"I thought the last five years were the years she would," Remus grinned as James sent a quick glare his way before he proceeded to change for the night.
The infamous Marauders found themselves in their dorm room after the new year's grand ceremony. It had been bittersweet to say the least as it was their last time witnessing the sorting, the last time they would say 'Merlin, it feels good to be back,' and the last year they had to see James make a fool of himself before they were to face the looming war. Granted, James had changed a lot over the summer, he had gone through some experiences that allowed him to grow into a man he liked, and hopefully so would Lily Evans.
But Lily Evans had also changed during the summer.
Just like the Marauders talked and laugh about what's to come this last year at Hogwarts, Marlene McKinnon, Alice Fortescue, Mary McDonald, Lily Evans, and you laughed and talked about the new year.
"I'm so ready to see Potter's newest attempts to get little miss Evans' attention this year," Marlene said as she laid on her bed, legs crossing as her feet touched the bed.
"Oh, I don't think anything can top last year's grand departure," you said as you glanced at the red-headed girl who only rolled her eyes at the laughs your comment had brought.
"Please, don't remind me," she groaned as she threw her head on your lap. "I will never be able to touch glitter without remembering that stupid howler."
"Oh, come on, it was cute," you looked down at her as she glared up at you. "You looked so cute with your embarrassed face, the way you were trying so hard not to cuss half of the English dictionary his way, and let's not forget how the glitter made you look like Thinker Bell."
Mary laughed at your last comment, as she—like you and Lily—was a muggleborn.
Lily only glared all the more as her roommates broke into laughter when Mary explained to them what a 'thinker bell' was, but she soon blushed when your eyes caught her green ones.
This past summer, you and Lily had spent it together since the minute it started as Lily had asked her parents if she could do so, with the promise of spending her last week before the last year with them. And in that time, things had changed with her best friend. There had been so much laughter, so many memories to cherish as you two spent the summer mostly out of the house, and when you were in the house, the memories were ones that brought Lily a massive blush on her pale cheeks and a feeling of need between her long legs.
"I'm tired, so I'm off to bed. Do not make much ruckus, will ya?" Dorcas said as she changed into her loose pajama pants and top. Everyone seemed to agree as they yawned and nodded along with words of agreement.
Soon enough, the Gryffindors' had all fallen into a deep slumber as the prospects of the new year was only hours away.
The Great Hall was lively as students eat and converse during their first morning together. It seemed everyone was in high spirits as even those students that were chewing their food trying not to fall asleep seemed to be happy.
By the time the students had received their timetables, all students were awake and ready to start their day. Which included James Potter's need to impress Lily Evans.
Marlene, while she had been complaining how her Divination lessons were going to be the death of her, she took noticed how the loud voices of the four infamous Gryffindors were carrying over. She rolled her eyes as Sirius barked a laugh at something one of his mates had said.
"Oi, Black! Quiet down will ya? I cannot even hear my own thoughts," she said as she gave him a fake smile.
Sirius, who had stopped his laughter, gave the woman a sly smirk.
"My apologies, Marlene, I know it's hard for you to think, so I'll keep my volume to the minimum," replied the man. James let out a snort as Marlene's mouth dropped at the insult.
"Real mature," quipped Lily with her usual condescending tone, "both of you are children."
"Oh, come on, Evans. It's all in good fun," defended Sirius as he gave a dashing smile that he knew never worked on Evans or you for that matter.
But before Lily could explain to Sirius and James—who had laughed—the latter man interrupted the bickering that could have happened.
"You're right, Lily. I'm sorry Marlene that Sirius here still has the humor of a second year."
Everyone was looking at James as if the man had sprouted a second head without his knowledge. Sirius looked scandalized, Remus had stopped his spoon mid-way toward his mouth, Peter looked confused, while you and the rest of the girls looked at James with incredulity.
"Umm, uh, it's alright, Potter. I know Sirius can be a git, so it's all good," said Marlene. She gave a small smile.
You broke from your confusion before everyone else, and you were about to question Potter for his unusual defense of Marlene when you noticed how James' eyes kept shifting to Lily's. It took you a second to catch on, but soon you realized that he had agreed with Lily in hopes to impress her with his attempt to show some maturity. You almost laughed at the realization but the students getting up from their seats announced that it was time to head to lessons.
And so, quietly, you all did.
And James Potter's attempts did not end with that first morning.
As the term went by, everyone in the unconventional friend group noticed that James' usual grand attempts to impress Lily had dwindled down to agreeing with her, trying to not disrupt lessons as much as he used to along Sirius, walking next to her and talking about things they had in common, and the occasional romantic gesture of transfiguring things into flowers—and he was cliché enough to give her lilies. Everyone was impressed with how James had gone from a first-class jerk to a complete gentleman. His friends mocked his behavior at first, but soon they were more than willing to help him set up meetings so that Lily and he could talk without ears near them. The whole seventh-year class was betting on when they were going to go on their first date. People were loving it. But not you.
You were livid. Lily was your girlfriend, but no one knew about it. Neither of you was ashamed of being who you were. Both of you were into men and women alike, but you both understood that not everyone was open-minded. Thus, your relationship was a secret. This is why no one knew that whenever you dragged Lily to the restrooms was not to fix hairdos or makeup, but to push her against the wall and steal her breath away. It was that or making her gasp and moan your name while your fingers fucked her cunt until she could barely stand straight.
Something told you that Lily was loving your inability to keep your jealousy at bay, but at the same time there was something in the back of your head that told you that Lily was looking at James with eyes she had never done before. And the thought alone led you to make Lily squirm and quiver under you when no one was in the dorm.
It wasn't until mid-November that things took a sharp turn.
"Hey, Evans!"
You and Lily had been walking to the library when Potter came out of nowhere. You both stopped to look at the man jog closer, and you swore Lily's smile was the brightest she had ever given him. Which he took notice of as he suddenly seemed flustered.
"Umm, uh, can I talk to you for a second? In private?" he asked as he gave you both a smile.
You were about to tell him off with an excuse that you needed to study when Lily spoke first.
"Sure!" said Lily as she turned to you, "I'll meet you at the library, Y/n. I'll just be a minute."
Your eye twitched as you glared at your girlfriend. She gave you one pleading smile before you opted to give her a fake smile to then walk toward the library. On your way there, you had come up with about twenty ways to murder James and how to hide his body.
"So, what did you want to talk about?" asked Lily after she was sure you had gone. She didn't want you hearing whatever corny thing Potter wanted to tell her. Not like she opposed much these days.
"Well, as you know, our last Hogsmeade trip is in about two weeks and I was wondering if you would like to go out with me?" asked James with a charming smile, hopeful eyes, and an erratic beating heart.
And Lily's heart was in the same state as James awaited a response from the redhead. Lily let out a shaky breath before she grabbed his hand and pulled him aside where she was sure no one could see them or hear them.
James looked confused as Lily seemed to have lost some color on her face, leading him to do just about the same.
"Look, I'm sorry for asking," started James as he looked at his feet.
"No, don't worry about that, it's uh, it's complicated." Lily bit her lip trying to let down the boy who she had learned to like, which she hated to admit. But he needed the truth, he didn't deserve to be led on by her like she had been doing. Granted, she had liked the new James, but she was dating you, and she wouldn't do anything to actually hurt you.
"Look, James. This term you've proven to me that you have changed into a person I can say that I like—" James smiled, but soon it dropped, "—but I also changed. I learned things about myself that I was too afraid to let out, but I've never felt so like myself until I decided to be me."
"I don't, umm, you lost me," said James as he tried to see how her changing did anything to affect the ability to properly let him down or go out with him.
Lily rolled her eyes and bit her bottom lip.
"I'm dating somebody," she whispered to him. James swore his mouth went dry. He shook his head as if his brain couldn't grasp her words.
"Wait, so you've been dating some guy and you haven't said a word? Gee, Evans. A little heads up would have been nice." James couldn't help to be a little annoyed at the situation at hand, Lily had never acted as if she was taken, yet she had limited her interactions whenever he pulled a romantic gesture.
"It's not like I have to tell you about my personal life, Potter," said Lily hotly.
"You do when you have a boyfriend and lead me on as if you are interested in me!"
Lily glared at him for what felt like minutes when in reality both of them glared at each other for about ten seconds before Lily broke away first.
"I'm sorry, okay? You just finally started acting like a decent person, so I liked getting to know this renewed James Potter," she said.
After a moment of silence, James broke the awkward air.
"So…is it anyone I know?"
Lily looked at him questionably. He rolled his eyes.
"Your boyfriend?" he said with a teasing grin.
Lily felt her face redden at the gaze of the man. James kept on assuming she was dating a boy when in reality she was dating you, a girl. But she was not about to tell him that.
"Shut up, I have to go. Y/n is waiting for me." With that, she left.
But those two weeks that followed after her talk with James had been hard for Lily. After Lily had gone to the library in search of you, you were long gone. You hadn't even gone to the library as it seemed your jealousy had raised to a level that only anger seemed to be found. After Lily had found you in your dorm, alone, she had guiltily fessed up to what James had wanted to talk about, which led to you stonily asking for what she had said to Potter. Lily explained everything, including how James had taken the news that she was dating somebody. You had somewhat calmed down when Lily had turned him down, but little did you know that the night was far from over as Lily had decided to have a heart-to-heart talk with you not even five minutes later.
What you hadn't expected was Lily's confession that she had wanted to say yes to Potter's invitation. The talk had been one that took over a whole week to process on your part. Lily had admitted to you, her girlfriend, that she had wanted to go out with someone else. At first, you had taken that as Lily's way of saying she wanted to break things off, but to your surprise, she had assured you that she loved you and that you were always going to be hers and the other way around. She just also happened to feel strong feelings toward James. The first week had been you wrapping your head around the idea of Lily being infatuated with James, and Lily spent that whole week reassuring you that she loved you whenever you were willing to actually listen to her without you replying with snarky comments.
The week after that had been about you finally coming to terms that maybe Lily was still understanding things about her, and maybe you were coming to terms with your own personal wants.
There were things that sometimes you needed to try to see if you were okay with that, and Remus Lupin had told you that when you explained to him what was bothering you during one of your many study sessions that week. He was clueless about what it all was, but he understood enough to manage to give you good enough advice.
And so, the day before the last trip to Hogsmeade, Lily approached James Potter with high spirits.
"Hey Potter!" shouted Lily as she jogged toward him. He was sitting with Sirius and Remus underneath a big tree.
Sirius, who had been talking with James, smirked toward James. He pushed Sirius away as he smiled up at Lily as she approached him.
"Evans," James smiled brighter, "nice seeing you."
"Yeah, umm, can I talk to you for a second?" she asked, a sudden batch of nervousness overcoming her.
"Sure," replied James. But seeing that she was smiling at him and not saying anything, he understood that she had meant in private.
"Oh," he looked back at his friends, "I'll be right back."
After they walked a little further away, Lily turned to face him.
"I'll make this quick, Potter. Tomorrow, after everyone's gone to Hogsmeade, go to my dorm room. The stairs won't be a problem, so just go straight for my dorm room," said Lily in a hushed rapid whisper. James looked at her with wide eyes, but before he could ask for some explanation, she spoke again.
"No, don't ask questions. Just show up, and then decide whatever you want," she turned to leave, but then she turned back around, "and don't tell a soul about this, Potter, or I will hex you."
She left, and James was left to wonder what in the hell Lily had prepared for him.
The next day, everyone awoke with high spirits as the day ahead of them promised a fun time. In the dorm where the Marauders were getting ready to leave, Sirius noticed that his best mate seemed to be awfully distracted.
"You alright, Prongs?" he asked with a teasing grin, one that rarely left his face. James looked at his friend and smiled.
"Of course I'm alright, why wouldn't I be?" he said with a dismissive wave.
"Since your talk with Evans yesterday, you've been acting a little weird," added Remus as he grabbed his house scarf. He was excited to finally get some more chocolate as his current stash was getting smaller.
"No, I haven't," James exclaimed.
"Yes, you have," shot back all the other three marauders in unison. James only rolled his eyes. He hadn't come up with an excuse to not go to Hogsmeade with his mate, and he could only hope that if he dared disappeared, they wouldn't go looking for him.
At las, he managed to do just that. Right before he was out of the gates, he told them that his stomach had started to feel funny which had earned him confused looks because he had been completely fine minutes before. Nonetheless, he told them to head to Hogsmeade while he went to the restroom with the promise to meet them at the Three Broomsticks if he felt any better. Peter had shrugged and taken the excuse without any doubt to James' words, but Remus and Sirius had an inkling that his sudden stomachache had to do with his talk with Lily.
After James had rid of his friends, he rushed back to Gryffindor Tower where he almost tripped when his feet caught on the stairs up to the girls' dormitories. Once he was in front of Lily's door, he inhaled deeply and exhaled as he knocked.
He was met with silence. James' hands started to sweat, thinking that Lily had pulled a mean joke on him when her voice called him to come in.
With sweaty palms, he did. He opened the door to see Lily sitting on her bed, and right next to her was you.
"Umm, hi," he said with an unsure smile.
"Close the door, Potter," you said as you glared at him. It wasn't a death glare, but it wasn't one that could assure James that you wouldn't curse him.
James closed the door, but he was too nervous to even ask if he could sit somewhere.
"You don't have to stand there. Go ahead, you can take a sit on my chair," you said while pointing at the black velvety chair you had next to your bed which was across Lily's. He sat with cautious steps. He was more nervous than before, after all, he hadn't expected to see you. But in all honestly, he wasn't sure what to expect after Lily's vague directions.
James sat, he swore his heart was beating faster than usual, his palms were shaking, and there was a voice in his head telling him to get out, yet his legs were going numb.
You noticed how nervous he looked which made you grin a little while you turned to look at Lily. She had a stoic face, but her body gave away how nervous she was too. It seemed that you were the only one who was feeling relax, which was odd as Lily had been the one to plan this; she had been the one to ask you to let this happen.
"James," the man flinched as you called his name. Your voice, although relatively soft, was loud in the quiet room, "did Lily tell you why you're here?"
He only shook his head. You rolled your eyes and looked at your girlfriend.
"You didn't even give him a hint to what you planned for today?" you asked. She shrugged her shoulders.
"I told him to come to my room after everyone was gone, I was sure I was being obvious, Y/n." She rolled her eyes. You huffed at her and turned back to see James, who still looked nervous.
"Do you have an inkling as to why you were invited here today?" you asked him. James shifted on his spot and nodded his head. Like for the umpteenth time, you rolled your eyes. "Use your words, Potter."
"Um—" he swallowed hard, "—at first I didn't think much of it, but then, last night, it kinda hit me that Lily had meant, umm, sex. But then I remembered that she has a boyfriend and decided that it was not that."
He felt his face redden after his words came out, it seemed that saying them aloud had him feeling stupid. You only nodded your head.
"Well, she did mean sex. And she does not have a boyfriend, Potter," you said the last part almost with a hint of annoyance which Lily picked up. She stifled a giggle at seeing how the word alone made your right eye twitch.
"But she—" started James practically glaring at Lily. You raised your hand to stop him.
"She doesn't have a boyfriend, but she is taken, Potter." You knew you were being unnecessarily mysterious, but how many times can one person get to have a quiet and flushed Potter in front of them?
"You see Lily and I are together, as in we're girlfriends," you said slowly. You saw how James' eyes practically bulged at the news; his mouth went dry and partly agape.
"I know, shocking," you said while making jazz hands, "I know Lily failed to mention that detail in your many chats this term, which is why this situation is a rather complex one."
"How so?" James struggled to say.
"Well, for one, Lily asked you to join her tonight for a chance to sleep with her. Honestly, it's beyond me why she couldn't think of any other activity that might require intimacy other than sex," you said as you gave your girlfriend a look of annoyance, yet it was endearing, "I suggested a romantic picnic to let you know her little secret and all, but she changed subjects and convinced me that I should open my mind to the idea of a threesome."
If James were to have been drinking anything, he was sure he would have spit it out, which is why he only managed to choke on his own spit.
"Breathe, James," you said as you stood from your spot and walked toward him, "look, I know it is a rather complicated offer as we are just throwing you all of this information in hopes that you will come up with an answer soon."
"It's not that, I just, why, umm why?" James couldn't understand why he had been asked to come here in the first place if you two were a thing. Which you understood as his eyes kept looking back and forth, especially as Lily seemed to be just as nervous as him.
"Well, isn't it obvious, Potter? Lily finally fancies you the way you fancy her," you said with a devilish grin, "I thought it obvious by now. After all, I would have assumed that my distaste for you this term was clear and that maybe you figured out that I was jealous that she was actually enjoying your company and actually sought it out."
James looked back at Lily who only gave him a sweet smile, he turned back to look at you as you showed a surprising new dominance. He knew you to be like Remus, quiet, studious, nice, but capable of being quick-witted and with a sharp tongue. But this was new, even Remus who fancied you, would be surprised to see you now.
"Trust me, It wasn't easy to digest hearing my girlfriend confess that she likes a boy she swore she hated," you said as you stood next to James, giving Lily a smile, "after that, she reassured me that she loved me, nonetheless. Granted, I didn't believe a word from her after that, you know being jealous and angry doesn't let you think straight. But I came around, after all, we are new to this dating thing, sure I've had partners before but not an actual relationship, especially since it's not common for two witches to date, let alone be attracted to both men and women alike."
James looked at you with a raised eyebrow. You rolled your eyes and gave him a wolfish smile.
"If you think I like you as Lily does, you are so mistaken, love," you said while you grabbed his chin. Both your faces were so close that if Lily leaned to the left she could pretend you two had just kissed.
"I don't fancy you, James, but I must admit that you are quite handsome."
You let go of his chin and walked toward the middle of the room.
"So, given that Lily is shaking as much a Pettigrew when you catch him sneaking around, I'll tell you what we have in mind, and you can decide whatever you want after," you started. You waited until James nodded his head in understanding before giving him a somewhat soft smile.
"As you now know, Lily and I are together, and we've gotten the chance to explore ourselves a lot," you held back a grin when James fixed his crotch, "that being said, we know what we want. You are here because Lily wants you, James. This means, there is no obligation to interact with me sexually, this is about Lily. But you need to be vocal throughout the whole thing, communication is a must. We don't normally use a safe word, but for this occasion 'cucumber' is the safe word. You can use it too if you think is too much. Are you with me so far?"
"Umm, so Lily and I would be doing stuff while you do what exactly?" asked James.
"You'll be pleasuring Lily just like I will, if you two want to start it off you can, or I can go first that way Lily is a little more relaxed, and I can join in, or you can after a while. We are experimenting here. This is not my first rodeo, but last time I was the only girl in the room," you said. James looked at you as if he was seeing you in a new light.
"Alright, go on," he said to you. You nodded.
"Well, that's about it. But like I said, communication is key, so you want to do something? ask, and we'll consider it, and sometimes we might get caught up in the moment, so we can let things happen but any of us can stop it whenever. Now, if you don't want part of this at all, that's okay too. But whether you walk out that door after doing it or not doing it, word of this doesn't get out to anyone. This is between the three of us, and we can discuss it anytime because I'm sure Lily would love nothing more than to do it again if she likes it," you said with a smile. If James or Lily were to describe the tone you were explaining everything, they would think they were in a lesson learning about charms and whatnot. You were weirdly comfortable with the situation.
"Alright, I'm in," said James after a minute of silence. He still looked a little nervous which is why he still remained seated. "Umm, you two, umm, can start. I don't think my body comprehends the situation yet."
You huffed a laugh before looking back at Lily who nodded at you. With one last glance at James, you walked toward the bed and sat next to her.
You took Lily's hands and your thumbs rubbed soothing circles on them. Lily let out a shaky breath which you reacted with a smile. Your right hand grabbed a hold of her usually pale cheeks and leaned in for a soft kiss. You could feel the slight hesitation at the small action, but soon, she relaxed into the kiss and didn't lose time in kissing you back with ardor. Her soft lips were bruising yours the more she sought of you, and you could only grin into the kiss because this was her showing her appreciation for everything you were doing for her.
As the kiss increased in heat, Lily became restless on her spot on the bed, so you grabbed her waist pulled her to your lap. You maneuvered both of you in a position that allowed James a clear view of both of you. Smartly, Lily had chosen to wear a skirt with stockings, and as she sat straddling your lap, you could feel the heat from between her legs. Lily tangled her fingers in your hair, practically pulling your hair as she softly ground into you. You were enjoying the feeling of Lily letting her desire overcome her body as she seemed to be feeling the neediest. Your hands traveled to grab her full butt cheeks, and you received a moan and a slight bite from Lily.
You opened your right eye and from your position, you could see James. His mouth was slightly open, his elbows rested on his knees, and his breathing was hard. You weren't sure if the man was losing his shit because this was the most cliché thing for a man to get turned on to, or because he was seeing Lily in such sexual state of mind that his brain couldn't understand that it wasn't a dream.
You grinned wider and this time your hands went up Lily's body, and under her shirt. You groaned into the kiss as you realized that Lily had decided to not wear a bra. It's beyond you how you didn't notice she had gone braless. You moaned into the kiss as you palmed her small full breasts, feeling the heat her body was radiating.
Finally, Lily pulled back from the kiss after she had decided that air was needed. You took the opportunity to take off her shirt, revealing her breasts to you, and for the most part to James. This time the groan came from the man himself, Lily smiled at the somewhat nice reaction she got and moaned when your mouth started to leave a trail of kisses and bites from her jaw to her neck, to then leave red marks on her chest. Your hands meanwhile palmed her breasts and/or played with her pink-ish nipples. You loved to kiss and bite the spots where her freckles were darker. You loved her freckled body, as it allowed you to explore her body and leave her in a state of pure need for you.
Lily threw her head back when your lips wrapped around one of her hard nipples. Her hands tangled with your hair once again, and this time she opened her eyes to look at James, and this time the man was fully gaping and shifting on his spot a lot more than before. She gave him a naughty grin.
"You can touch yourself, James," she said, her voice dripping with need as she rocked her hips on your lap and pushed her chest closer to your mouth. You opened your eyes to see Lily looking at James, and you turned your sight to him. James looked back at you as if seeking reassurance, and with a nipple between your lips, you nodded at him.
He let out a shaky sigh, similar to the one Lily had let out earlier, and hesitantly pulled his sweats down to his thighs. His dick sprung out, semi-hard, and Lily's eyes practically bulged at the sight. You only hummed as the man was already to a good size and he was only semi-hard. Lily knew how to pick them. James grabbed his dick, and with tentative strokes, he pleasured himself to the sight of the girl he's been pinning for years and her girlfriend. He was sure he was dreaming, and Sirius was about to wake him up and tell him off for making sex noises in his sleep.
Lily was enjoying herself, but she needed more, and you knew that. But you loved it when she begged for more, to be touched in places that on a normal day she would blush before the words could leave her. So, you waited until Lily's needy moans turned into frustrated noises, to finally become hushed whimpers that swallowed her cute little pleas.
"You have to talk to me, love, otherwise I won't know what you want," you whispered on her neck as you bit on the sweet spot she had there. She quivered under your touch.
"I want more, Y/n, please, I want more," she pleaded as she pulled your hair, thus your head moved back. You looked at her.
"What, Lily? Say it," you demanded.
"I want—" she bit her lips and looked at you with her lust-filled eyes, "—I want James to be here with us too."
You grinned at how everything about her screamed lust and need, while her voice still held certain innocence.
"You heard that James?" you looked at him and he nodded his head, a soft reply left his lips before you signal for him, "well, then come here, and take those pants off already."
James quickly took off his shoes and his pants followed and seeing that wearing a shirt was pointless, he took it off too, leaving him to be the only one naked in the room. He was naked and outnumbered. You removed Lily from your lap and moved her next to you.
"On your knees, Lily," you said as you stood up from the bed. You stood next to James, who looked almost out of place, and waited for Lily to face you both. Once she did, you took off your long-sleeve dress and threw it behind you, knowing that it piled with James discarded clothes. James glanced at you just like Lily, their eyes on your every move. You did not remove your underwear which caused Lily to pout. You gave her a kiss on the lips before you backed away and looked at James.
"Go ahead, kiss her," you said to him. He gave you one look and then to Lily who was biting her lip expectingly. James approached her and Lily sat on her knees so he wouldn't have to bend down so low. Their kiss was hesitant at first, and tentative touches on their faces and arms were just as soft as the kiss. You looked at them and you couldn't help but feel like they belonged. There was a small pang of jealousy, but you shook it off, after all, you were dating Lily, she loved you and you loved her. So, for Lily, you took a deep breath before you walked around behind her. Their kiss started to increase in heat, but you told Lily to be on her fours before they could continue. She quickly did, her ass to your face and her face was in front of James' dick. You heard a hiss and looked up to see James looking at Lily; she had grabbed his cock and was stroking him experimentally.
You pushed back Lily's skirt. You could see the damp spot on her underwear, so you touched it with two of your fingers. Lily let out a whimper at the sensation.
"You're so wet, love, and all we've done kiss," you said while grabbing a handful of her left asscheek. She shook her ass a bit, and you smirked before landing a swift smack on the free cheek. She let out a yelp, while James let out a gasp. She had gripped him tighter. You massaged her asscheek for a minute before you landed another smack. This time James looked at you while you redden Lily's ass, his eyes practically were dark behind his glasses.
"Tell me what you're doing, sweetheart," you said while toying with Lily's covered sex. She moaned.
"I'm stroking James' cock, he is so big. I can't wrap my hand around him," she said, her eyes never leaving the cock in front of her. It was totally different from those dildos she had bought to try out. He was warm on her hand, and pulsing, and leaking pre-cum. She was obsessed with it, and she hadn't even tasted it. She knew you liked sucking dick every once in a while, and she had practiced with the dildos, but she didn't know where to start now that she had one in front of her.
"How about you suck him off, sweets? But don't let him cum, work him up nicely, I'm sure James won't mind if you're a little sloppy, right James?" you asked while your eyes found his.
"No, I don't mind," he replied with a husky tone. He was still nervous, but his own desire was taking over. It was only a matter of minutes before he would find his footing.
Lily nodded her head, reassuring herself that she could do it right, she gave a soft kiss to the tip of James' cock. He hissed loudly at the contact of her cold lips against his hot tip, but then he was groaning when her lips wrapped around his heavy head.
"Fuck," he cursed into his palm as his other hand grabbed the redhead's hair. While Lily sucked and licked James' cock, you pulled Lily's underwear down her thighs, and she moved her legs as she helped you get them off. Once they were off, you laid on your back and position your face right above Lily's dripping cunt. You could smell her strawberry lotion on her legs and her natural musk which made your own clit throb. Knowing what came next, Lily opened her legs wider, letting her cunt get nearer to your mouth. You pulled down the few inches she left, and your mouth was on her cunt in seconds.
Lily moaned around James, and the man had to try to control himself as the feeling of her moans was making his cock feel more feeling than ever before. He's done sex and gotten many blowjobs before, but this was new. For one, it was Lily Evans who was sucking him off, and two, the same girl was getting her cunt eaten out by her secret girlfriend. And that was shocking in itself as James only knew you as Moony 2.0 for so long it was hard to understand this version of you. You were shocking him, and he could only feel the smallest twinge of guilt as he was getting to see a sight that Remus only could dream about. And Sirius, oh boy, if Sirius could see him he would self-combust because his brain would overload trying to understand the picture in front of him.
You were dancing with death as you ate Lily out, your mind having proclaimed breathing as overrated, your mouth and tongue worked nonstop as you sought to have Lily come undone in your mouth, on your face. Your tongue explored what it could of Lily's cunt, taking in her harsh tang, which you were becoming addicted to the more you found yourself between her legs. It was a tiring job, but one you could do all day, to have her quivering above you while your tongue and mouth wrecked her in minutes, and without the need of your fingers which were as slim as hers. You had learned to make her jelly with your tongue, you could have her babbling nonsense in minutes, and you were obsessed with how she would ride your face as she came undone with shaky legs and loud moans.
And lord, she was close. The feeling of your tongue inside her cunt, trying to take in all the evidence of her desire, she was seeing stars with her damn shut eyes. Her clit was stiff, and every time it bumped on your nose, her legs would give out just a bit more. She was enjoying being eaten out by you, but she was also enjoying the way she was wrecking James with her inexperienced mouth. The man had stopped making sense a little ago, the usual coherent curse would leave his lips, and Lily was feeling more secure of her actions which had led her to try and have him deeper inside her mouth. She was gagging on his thick cock, practically bruising the roof of her mouth and her throat.
Lily started to lose control of her body, and her hips only knew to rock as your lips sucked on her clit while your tongue would lick whenever it could. Lily was so close to coming and it took one slap on her ass for her to grip James' cock, pull back, and shriek your name as your mouth worked her through it while your arms held her still. James could only curse and thank Lily for her tight grip on him because he would have cum all over her face if she hadn't. He was in paradise and so was Lily and you were the goddess who had allowed them in.
You pushed Lily aside, making her land on her back. You smiled at the sight of Lily breathing hard, while her spread legs allowed anyone to see the beautiful view of her pink cunt completely covered in saliva and her own slick and cum. She shivered at the cold air that was attempting to dry her bliss.
"You did so well, love," you said while you gave a swift kiss to her belly while James' hand removed the hairs that were sticking to her face because of her sweat.
"James, would you like to try something?" you asked him while you removed your bra and your soaked underwear. Lily perked up to that.
"Umm, I think we could all be benefited if Lily laid on her back like she is while I, umm—" "fuck her" "—yeah, fuck her while she returns you the favor?"
You looked back at Lily, and unsurprisingly, she was nodding in agreement to James' proposition. You climbed up the bed while Lily turned to present her wet sex to James while she waited for you to sit on her face just like she had.
"Before we start," you stopped your movements, "I feel like I should have asked this before, but you do take the cleansing pills right?"
The cleansing pills were the newer version of the cleansing/protection potion to prevent any type of sexually transmitted infections and prevented males from impregnating women while they took it daily. It was a fairly new product, but James was a man known to be somewhat sexually active, so you just needed to be sure. Besides, Lily would get to experience the feeling of someone ejaculating inside of her without fearing getting pregnant.
"Yes, I do. Even if I don't do anything, it's easier if I don't stop taking it," he said while positing himself between Lily's legs. He was finally feeling comfortable, but it didn't stop him from seeking reassurance. You smiled at him.
"Smart lad," you said as you situated yourself above Lily's face. She pulled you down to her mouth and you practically rolled your eyes back as she had decided to try and make you feel as wrecked as she did which you knew would be impossible as she was about to experience a very thick cock used her cunt. You knew the feeling, and after getting your cunt wrecked by Lily after a few times, you had decided that getting fucked thoroughly by a cock was the second best feeling in the world.
James teased Lily's lips which had the girl twitching while she moaned around your clit. You played with your breasts while you looked down to see James push in the head of his cock. You felt Lily gasp as her tongue went inside your dripping hole. And she practically whined when two of your fingers started to rub on her stiff clit.
"You're doing so good, sweetheart," you said as you rubbed circles on her clit, making sure she was feeling good while James pushed the rest of his cock inside of her tight walls.
"Fuck, Lily, you feel so good," groaned James as his dick was finally fully inside of her, spreading her walls around his thick cock. He could feel Lily's cunt trying to swallow him whole, milk him for all his worth. Lily was whimpering underneath you and you could feel the breath of each silent plead hit your cunt.
"Talk a bit louder, baby, we can't hear you," you said soothingly as you kept rubbing her.
"You're going to make me cum again," she moaned as your fingers wouldn't stop making her sensitive cunt feel the thick cock even more whenever she clenched trying to not cum too soon. But now that you knew what she had been whispering against you, you rubbed a little faster. And Lily bit your thigh as you managed to make her cum a second time, but the only difference was that she had James inside her, so deep, and all she could do was moan as she came around him. James grabbed your shoulder as he lost some of his balance at the feeling of Lily's orgasm. He was trying so hard not to cum too soon, he feared that he might wake up before he got to truly fuck Lily Evans.
You pulled back as Lily regained her breath, and started to move her mouth again. You were dripping on her lips and all due to seeing her cum twice. James started to thrust slowly, allowing Lily to feel every inch of him before he lost his composure and fucked her into the bed before he could cum. You were enjoying Lily's eager mouth and fingers that had joined in as she tried to make you cum for her, but you were also enjoying the sight of James' cock progressively fucking Lily open. You looked up to see that James had been doing the same, and when he looked up, you both grinned like idiots because it was all too hot. You were about to say something when James came closer to your face, which allowed him to spear his cock deeper inside of Lily and allowed him to steal a kiss from your slightly parted mouth. It was a quick peck, but when he pulled back, he was only an inch away from your lips. You licked your lips before you grabbed the back of his neck and pulled him in for a deeper kiss.
If anyone dared walk in, they would see you making out with James Potter while the man had Lily Evans shrieking her moans while he fucked her open as she ate your cunt with fervor. It was a pornographic image, really. Lily's black stockings were miraculously still intact, her skirt flipped over, while you and James were bare ass naked. You had to admit that you hadn't thought of having a threesome with James Potter of all people, if anyone had to make you choose it would be Remus. The man radiated switch which would allowed you to be both your dom and sub persona. Atlas, Potter had been the one that had managed to get a front seat to your and Lily's experimental relationship. You knew that after this, you and Lily would love each other still no matter what, but you had never been the one to see yourself as a one-person partner, and Lily hadn't either but she had been the one to realize it before you. You would have to thank her for showing yet another new thing. And James was going to be a possible new presence, and what could stop you from convincing Lily to let Remus join in?
When you and James pulled back, you grinned like a maniac as an idea came to your mind. You pushed James back a bit so you could see how his dick fucked your girlfriend. You leaned down, your cunt still being abused by Lily's teeth and tongue, and out of nowhere, your tongue started to give licks whenever at a spot where both Lily and James could feel your tongue. Both of them let out loud grunts as your tongue added to the delicious feelings they were already feeling. You felt James' free hand grabbed your hair, which allowed you to better see what you were doing. You three kept that up until your legs started to quiver when Lily had managed to rapidly hit a certain spot, and before you knew it, you screamed a curse as you squirted all over Lily's face. She didn't stop fingering you which only made the mess greater, and not soon after you came violently all over, Lily kept shoving her fingers inside of you as she bit on your thigh again as she came around James again. And James couldn't help but roar as he finally got to cum. Thick ropes of cum filling Lily, but she was soaking that mid-ejaculation, his dick was pushed out and the last spurts of cum landed on your tired face. Not that your half-aware mind cared.
James collapsed on the empty spot next to Lily while you threw yourself on the other side of her. The heavy sounds of breathing filled the room, the sounds of wet skin and moans were long gone but they still ringed in your ears.
You giggled as you realized that Lily was probably soaking wet all over her face and her hair probably had collected your first squirt.
"I'm sorry, Lils, I probably showered you," you said as you felt your body heat up in embarrassment. She giggled too.
"It's okay," she said, "that was the hottest thing ever. I finally made you squirt."
"The bed is soaked," added James as he touched a pillow that had been victim to the event. You all laughed before the room fell into a comfortable silence. It didn't last long, though.
"Remus would kill me if he found out what just happened here," said James to himself, but the room was too quiet to go unheard.
"Why?" you asked curiously. Lily sat up to look at you.
"Well, he likes you, Y/n," she said as if it was the most obvious thing in the world, then she looked at James, "he would kill you because it wasn't him who got to be part of this."
"It would be the end of me," said James dramatically. You laughed at the irony of it all, but then your smile turned salacious.
"You know, after we are out of here, I wouldn't oppose offering the same deal to Remus," you said. Half joking. After all, Remus had been your first choice.