This is the first time I post something and I am eager to learn more and evolve. I hope you enjoy and like the story, I love any type of feedback, good or bad. It is a reader insert story about a night between two hot pirates. It's NSFW with some funny phrases.
""- for talking
``- for thinking
Enjoy! ^-^
Reader's POV
It was late into the evening and I was still occupied in the kitchen cleaning the mountain of dishes that were left after dinner. Even though there aren't many members in this crew they sure eat a lot, just the empty plates were enough for half an hour of work let alone all the pots from cooking. Just then I hear swift but heavy footsteps getting closer to the kitchen. Knowing that everybody is either playing cards or sleeping in their cabins makes me shut off the faucet and focus on them.
` Who could it be, and at this hour?` glancing at the clock I see it's a quarter pass eleven. Usually, at this hour there was a party going on but lately we've had a party almost every day, so the captain decided a break is in order.
The door opens slowly, Benn walks in carrying mugs on his arms. I look at him from the corner of my eyes... this is great at this rate I'll be here until midnight. He places the mugs next to the sink where I'm slaving away and looks at me. He keeps on looking at me so I take my chance to strike up a conversation." Sooo, thirsty much ?" He just looks at me, his gaze burning into me going from my face to my shoulders and lower, repeat.
Minutes pass by with him looking at me, smoking and I continue washing the pots. " If I didn't know better I would think you're trying to catch somebody's attention..." Blows out smoke from his cigarette then smirks at me.
"What do you mean? " I ask glancing at him then back to the pots. By now I had one more pot and the dishes from dinners. And the mugs...
"Dressed like that" he looks me in the eyes, something predatory underneath his gaze.
"I took of my shirt after splashing it with water, this is easier and I don't end up with more laundry afterwards" I look back at him as I water some plates under the faucet jet. `Is he trying to intimidate me? He should know this doesn't work with me...`
"Is that so... or were you hoping somebody else walked in?" Still with a smirk on his face
"Who else would be up at this hour and willing to help me clean these?" I gesture at the plates, but I don't get an answer to that. He seems to be pondering his next move or maybe he's run out of what to say.
More time passes by, him looking at me while I wash...When I get to the mugs I have an idea. Smirking I turn to him "Hypothetically, If I was trying to catch somebody's attention, who do you think it's?" I look at him as I later up the mugs with soap.
He's averting his eyes now, focuses on the match he light's up for the next cigarette.
He mumbles, looks back at me "Isn't always the captain?"
"I wouldn't know. It's the first time I'm on a pirate ship, remember?"
"Or the first-mate, somebody high up ?" He looks at my hands now, rising up the soap from the mugs.
"Or maybe both" I smirk, wiping up my hands on the apron which is already wet from all the splashing and looking straight at him.
He looks at my hands then at my eyes like he's searching for something.
"Both? at the same time" murmurs, and lights up another cigar
"Why not, after all If I were to catch both of their attention it would be unfair to choose on, being impartial to them an' all that" I answer his murmur flirtatiously while struggling with the knot on the apron.
"Need help with that?"
"Wouldn't you like to ?" I grin as I turn around.
He takes his time with the knot, his breath on my neck as he bends to take a closer look. `I know he's playing with me, a fucking sailor should know how to un-knot a simple string`
Once he's finished, he whispers in my ear "Come to captain's quarter If you feel brave enough" then takes his leave.
`Is this a challenge? I can't say no to such a thing after all` I look at the closing door.
After a couple of minutes of me putting all the plates back in their designated spots and putting on my t-shirt I make my way to captain's quarters well, it's right next to my shared room and Benn's room is on the other side of mine. It was chosen in the idea that anyone with improper thoughts will be discouraged by their presence to take any action.
I stop in front of his door, which is slightly ajar, glancing in I see them both playing cards at the tables on top of some maps. `No point staying outside, after all I do wonder what they're planning`
Opening the door, I murmur a greeting to them.
As usual the captain's smile is plastered on his face but there seems to be something amiss in it. Benn looks at me and smirks turning back to the cards on his hands.
"Well, well, I didn't think you would come" Shanks looks at me from top to bottom with curiosity more than anything in his eyes.
"I knew she would " Benn grins at him.
"I am really curious as to what I just stepped into " I look at both quizzically.
"Do shut the door, we wouldn't want to wake up the rest of the crew with our talking and take a chair."
"Aye Aye Captain" I sit down at the chair in between them before I can say anything Benn gets a glass and places it in the middle and Shanks pours some alcohol from the bottle.
"It's whiskey, I heard from Benn something very interesting" He starts, smiling at me "But first I need to know something. Are you interested in anyone? On the sea or land?"
"No... Why does it matter?"
"So, no crush, no feelings of love/like to anyone?" He pushes back.
"No...there is no one I like right now..." He looks at me somehow amused but with serious eyes.
"Then I, we, have a proposition for you. The voyage is rather long and time spent at sea is sometimes boring and rather unfulfilling, if you would like to partake in some extra fun..?" He says, smiling gently at me . "If you were to say no we won't ever bring it up again and we'll forget everything that was said here" he offers
"You can accept at first and if things are too much we'll back down and break up any agreement" Benn talks while taking a sip of the whiskey.
"And if you refuse this will not be propositioned to you roommate. This proposition is purely for you and based on you behavior we noticed. But if we were to misunderstand your intentions and feelings do correct us" Shanks adds smiling gently at me. Benn looks at me calmly.
"Just to be sure, this is not going to have any strings attached, Right? " I ask, looking at both of them.
"Yes, if either one of us, or you, has a change of heart afterwards we will cease the agreement" Benn speaks while Shanks just nods.
I ponder what they said while they closely observe me.
"Very well, I could do with some pure unadulterated fun" I smirk while grabbing my glass and taking a sip.
Shanks jaw hits the floor while Benn just smirks back lighting his cigar "We could start tonight, have a go and see if it would work.."
"Have you guys done this before? Sharing partners", I sip some more whiskey as it warms me up
"No... but there is a first time for everything no?" Benn smiles at me.
Shanks, getting past his initial surprise, leans in towards me. "Are you sure about this?" He looks at me as he touches my left-hand with his. His palm is hot and sweaty against my slightly cool one.
I smirk moving my eyes from one to the other, `Am I sure that I want to get fucked by two good looking pirates? Fuck yeah ` "I am, don't you want to rob my chest, Captain?" I lean towards him grinning.
He pulls back laughing."Mbhahahaha". Ben chuckles on my right, cigar smoke dancing in the air. He grabs my hand that is holding my drink "Shall we move somewhere more spacious". Looking towards the bed in the corner of the cabin.
"Why not?" I look at Shanks as he still giggles in his spot before getting up slowly, Benn gets up with me, still holding onto my wrist gently.
Shanks gives a small smile before getting up and going towards the bed. `Do they think I'll run? is that why Benn is still holding my wrist?`
We follow him, the 3-4 steps it takes to reach the bed before he plops down on it, towards the bottom edge of the bed. I take a spot in front on him and Benn gets behind me, next to the headboard.
I glance at both of them before I go to take my boots off, Benn's hand still on my wrist stops me. "You know I don't really want to mess up the bed with boot footprints." Benn let's go of my wrist almost as an afterthought, looking at me calmly.
Shanks smiles at me as he leans back on his hand...except there is no space for it and he ends up falling backwards on the floor."Bhahahaha sorry sorry, I am a bit nervous" I look at him quizzically as he gets up and retakes his spot. `Is he drunk? This can't be the first time he has sex is it ?I should be nervous. But I'm not gonna let them feel that`
"So nervous for me ? It really makes me feel special" I grin at him. "How about I help you" I move to sit on my knees while leaning towards him and grabbing his shirt, starting to unbutton him.
"My my, Benn would you look at that? Somebody's eager" He smirks at me before making eye contact with him as if he was trying to convey a message to him.
Finishing with his buttons I push the shirt off his shoulders, but it stops at his hand. He's staring at me I stare back. "I 'm sure. I want this" I tell them and it seems to be enough for the men to make their moves.
Shanks grabs my right hand and starts kissing up my arm, from my wrist. I feel Benn move his left hand around my waist and softly bring me closer to him. `When did he move his leg up the bed`. I end up in between Benn's legs, ass pushed up against him, my legs in front of me and Shanks leaning over them while kissing my hand. Benn's hand sneaks underneath my t-shirt, grazing my abdomen above my pants.
Turning my head to get a better look at him Benn captures my lips in a kiss. Lips lock up, eyes close and teeth lightly grazing my bottom lip for entry. I part my lips slightly letting his tongue enter my mouth, his right hand reaches up and grabs my boobs underneath my t-shirt. Shanks moves my legs so that he's in between them while looking at us.
We part away, I'm a bit breathless while his hand cups my boob gently, smirking at me.
"I think you're a bit overdressed like this" Benn smirks and grabs the bottom of my t-shirt lifting it over my head.
"A bit too dressed down here too" Shanks grabs the edge of my pants and pulls them, or at least tries to...I raise my hips to help him but he's having difficulties pulling them with one hand.
"HaHaHA, Why wear so skin tight clothing ?" Shanks laughs
"Should I give you a hand, Shanks?" Benn gloats behind me, one hand reaching towards my other pant leg to pull them off.
"Mbhahahaha, I could certainly use one" Shanks laughs back making me chuckle on this simple banter they both had.
Once my pants are finally off, I look at Shanks from underneath my eyelashes, trying to strike a sexy pose "Do you like what you see Captain?" moving my right leg towards his leg I try to gently rub it.
Benn chuckles behind me while Shanks just smirks at me "My my, I wouldn't have guessed that red would look this good on you". My red panties were quite striking against my milky white skin. Benn starts fumbling with my bra, trying to get it to open. He softly pushes me towards Shanks, trying to see better behind me.
" no matching set?" Shanks smirks staring at my white bra.
"What can I say ,Your offer did take me by surprise. Next time I'll make sure to match up" I grin at him while Benn still fumbles with my bra.
"Do you need a hand Benn" He gloats towards him, getting closer to me. I smirk "Maybe I can show you how to do it ?" I propose, hearing him hum behind me.
"I just can't find it" Benn growls, hands pulling harder against the material. "It's been a long time since you unbuckled a bra, Benn"' Shanks just chuckles at him and his problem.
"Easy, easy, let me show you" I tell him pulling myself away so that he doesn't rip the material. When I feel his hands leave my back I lay back against his chest and look up at him while with my right hand I unbuckle the bra from the front. Gloating at him through my lashes "See? EASY"
Shanks laughs quietly at Benn's face, a slight blush on his cheeks. I push down my arms the bra straps while and throw the garment off the bed. Benn grabs my face in a kiss and one of his hands come to massage my breast slowly. Shanks grabs my right ankle and rises it slightly to start peppering me with kisses, his lips were slowly making their way further up the leg.
Being stuck between two hot bodies that were pushing against mine, lips locked in a fervent kiss and another pair that were making their way towards my core, was making me wetter.
Benn's both hands cup my breasts and start tweaking my hardened nipples the action make me sight in his mouth, breathless as I was due to the kiss, there was no stopping.
Shanks mouth starts to greedily kiss and nip at my thigh leaving imprints on them and edging closer to my core.
Shanks looks up at Benn and makes a small nod. Benn releases my lips but I keep my eyes closed while lightly panting. "If it gets too much or you want to stop. Just say so, ok?" Benn's deep voice booms close to my ear.
I nod but there is no more movement. Opening my eyes I see him staring at me, hunger in his gaze as he looks from me to my breasts then back at me.
I clear my voice slightly just to say two letters " ok" . That seems to be all the needed encouragement from me as Benn starts to kiss my jaw slowly, his hands massaging and tweaking my nipples making me arch my back. Shanks slips closer to my core, breath hovering over and looking at me. Locking eyes, Shanks smiles before he slips a hand underneath my panties massaging me slowly. A small sigh gets out of my lips at the fervent gaze. Feeling my wetness he says: "Well well, our little girl is certainly excited to play with us".
I was closed in between the two, legs spread apart Shanks' hand underneath my panties massaging my core while Benn's hands playing with my nipples suddenly I hear a tearing and see shanks throw my panties somewhere behind him."Ooopsie, didn't know it was going to break so fast"
"You better buy me a matching pair" I manage to say before Benn kisses me again, his tongue enters my mouth to push against mine playfully.
"Yes yes" He laughs at me before going south. His breath tickles my core, his sole hand resting on my thigh gently massaging it.
I moan in the kiss as Shanks tongue gives an experimental lick on my core before his mouth consumes me. My mind stops thinking for a minute, lost in the feeling of being eaten out by a Yonko and kissed by his first mate. Benn breaks the kiss leaving me panting heavily and whimpering as Shanks tongue uncovers more secrets from within me. Benn starts sucking on my neck trying to find that spot that gives me pleasure.
I'm getting more and more turned on when Shanks finger enters me alongside his tongue making me gasp. One of Benn's hand leaves my breast and goes south, close to his Captain's face, which is now pressed against my core. His hand grazes over my nub softly before starting to rub circles with a light touch.
"Oh fuck, fuck fuck " I chant as I near my orgasm.
Shanks increases his movements with his tongue, adding another finger and scissoring them all the while Benn stimulates my bundle of nerves with his fingers. One of my hands grab his head lightly pushing his face closer while the other grabs Benn face, I want to kiss him, I have to kiss him I can't keep my moans low enough. Benn kisses me deeply, sucking each moan in his mouth I tether on the edge of orgasm not yet feeling the necessary push to make me crumble forward.
I push Shanks face forcefully against my core as he adds another finger in, scissoring and pushing in and out of me. Finally, I reach my height crumbling with a loud moan against Benn's mouth, my thighs twitching, Shanks doesn't stop licking and pushing his fingers in me, Benn still rubs me, helping me ride the last waves of my orgasm. I break the kiss, panting heavily, slumping against Benn's strong chest. Shanks rises his wet face from between my legs, giving me a victorious smile 'who knew you taste so good? Benn, you should taste her too' he grins at his crewmate.
I blush at this or maybe it's the height I'm just coming down from, the whole room is too hot for my liking. After no movement for some minutes and just heavy breathing Benn breaks the silence 'Did we tire you out already?' I breath in, trying to calm down my heart. "I'm just realizing now the unfair situation I'm in?"
They both look questioning at me."'I'm naked over here and both of you are still fully clothed, very unfair" I pout at them. "Mbahahaha, would you like to undress us ? "
" 'I'd like to repay your actions of tearing my panties back " I smirk at him before reaching for his waist. My hands land on his toned stomach before going south towards his pant line. Adjusting my position so that I could lean in more comfortably I unbuckle his pants and pull the zipper down expecting to see another layer of clothing underneath...except
"Really?" I look up in surprise at him.
"Easier access"
"It looks like you planned this for a while captain?" I smirk at him, he stands up from the bed and his pants fall down on the floor.
"Does it? Do you like what you see?" He smirks at me, taunting with my own words.
I look at him in the eyes before licking my lips "If I say I do, what would you do?"
"Nothing" He laughs at me "I think you forget we have one more person being unfairly treated" He looks to my left, winking at his crewmate.
I turn in bed to face Benn "I think the Captain just ordered me to undress you". Benn smirks, raising his hands as if to say you're welcome to and lays back against the headboard. I start taking off his shirt before starting to kiss along his neck and making my way down, following my hands with my mouth. Taking a peak at Shanks he's still on his feet, hand on a bottle looking at me as I make my way down. My hands start working on his pants and my mouth kisses above them drawing a low grumble from him. Once I unbuckle his pants he pushes my head away and gets off the bed letting them pool at his feet standing there in just a pair of boxers. "My my, did the Captain's offer took you by surprise too Benn?" I grin at him, getting off the bed kneeling in front of him and hooking my hands at the edge of the boxers, slowly pulling them down. I could see Shanks behind him smirking and taking a drink from the bottle in his hand. Benn just looks at me, impatience in his voice: "I could do that faster."
I smirk at him, looking up from my place below him, before grabbing his dick with one hand and pushing the boxers on the floor with the other. He gasps as I rub my fingers on him and grunts his teeth. "Get back on the bed"
"I only take orders from the Captain, darling" I grin at him before putting most of his dick in my mouth and rubbing my hands over what I couldn't fit, starting to suck him off. He swears loudly and grabs my head with his hand, just holding it there while I play with his dick in my mouth getting used to the taste.
"Mbahahaha, she sure knows who is the boss here" Shanks laughs behind him, I move my head slightly to the right to make eye contact with him. Benn just grinds his teeth head slightly bend backwards while I work my magic on him.
After a couple of minutes of me sucking and bobbing my head up and down on him I feel him grab my head and pull me off him." Enough" he pants "That's enough" he seems to be uneasy on his legs. Shanks chuckles behind him 'Is she that good?' while Benn just growls at him.
"Maybe you should give it a try Captain?" I smirk getting up from my kneeling position, intended to go towards him before I feel a hand grab me from my middle and push me on the bed. Benn hovers over me "Not so fast, I should get to return the favor, no ?" He smirks at me before he kneels at the edge of the bed, head between my legs. Shanks gets up from his spot and walks towards me "MMM you should Benn, but the again I should get a favor too, no ?"
"Why not do both?" I say as I angle myself to let my head fall off the bottom edge of the bed, Benn moving with me. "Well come on darling, what are you waiting for?" I call back to Shanks as he makes his way towards my head.
"You really are too eager" He says to me making eye contact with me. When he is in my reach I move my hands closer to his erection, softly grazing the tip with my fingers making him groan. "Hmmm, sensitive much ?" I smirk at him before licking over his head. "Jju-Just a biiiit" he draws out. Benn starts nipping at my thighs sucking and biting them matching the marking his captain left on them minutes before.
I draw a loud gasp from Shanks as I engulf his head in my mouth completely sucking lightly before moving my tongue along his head. "Oh oh oh "He groans moving his hips slightly to my rhythm. I take more of him in my mouth before moving my hands up and down his remaining length.
I keep going for a while completely forgetting about Benn, focusing only on pleasuring Shanks with my mouth. Suddenly, I moan around my length in my mouth as Benn spread my folds with his hands and started tongue fucking me in rhythm with my bobbing of head. "Oh fuuuucck fuccckk " Shanks panths lowly.
The only thing in the room was the sound of panting and wet bodies mixing together.
As I climb again to my orgasm I start moving my hips more forcefully against Benn's face, Shanks seems to be approaching his orgasm as he snaps his hips against my mouth before pulling out completely and stopping : "Fuck fuuck hold on" he says. Without a dick up my throat my moans are loud. Benn stops his ministrations on me making me whimper "No no, c'mon I was so close" I pout while looking at him.
"In a second, I almost thought you were going to suffocate me " Benn smirks rubbing his wet face against my thigh. "Wo-u-l-dn't, huh, wouldn't you die a happy man?" I huff at him, he just chuckles at me before looking at Shanks. "I didn't want to ruin your fun this fast but I'm thinking we need to get to the main course" Shanks smiles at me before bending down to kiss my mouth.
"If you feel up to" Benn nips at my thigh again.
"Fuck yeah, let's go" I say needy.
To be continued!
Please rate and if you have time leave leave a comment.
Thanks!