Day 9 – Never Have I Ever

Rated T, Modern AU, OOC

Oof , for this one ideas just wouldn't come to me, so once again I looked through older stories I never finished and found this one which I thought fit to a certain degree. I didn't really wanna go the normal route of the game itself, so I just interpreted the prompt as a new experience. I hope you enjoy, ~Love, Dia

It wasn't uncommon for people to randomly sit down at his table, especially if those people were girls. They'd stumble onto the seat and act like it was all an accident, like they didn't see him and thought the table was empty, or that they tripped and 'landed' on the seat. Other times they'd ask if they could sit because there were no free tables anymore, granted this last excuse happened to be true once or twice, but usually, it was just a lie and the two would sit in awkward silence for a few moments staring at each other with a number of empty seats all around.

However, the person sitting across from him was a girl he saw around the diner quite often, urgency written all over her face. Sasuke raised an eyebrow at her, but the situation didn't faze him at all, thus he continued eating, putting 2 French fries in his mouth and slowly chewing, waiting for her to state her reason and purpose.

"I need you to pretend we're here together" Sasuke narrowed his eyes at her. "My ex just walked in and I'm not in the mood to deal with him. If I'm here with someone, in this case you, he'll either leave me alone or he'll at least leave sooner." His eyes moved to a guy that was just walking to the counter still obvious to his ex-girlfriend. "Please…" her eyes were begging him to help.

Sasuke sighed and pushed his milkshake her way. "It'd be strange if we were here together and I was the only one that had ordered something" Her pale eyes lit up like Christmas trees.

"Thank you so much. I'm Hinata by the way" She gave him a genuine smile. He nodded her way.

"Sasuke. I'd shake your hand but that would look strange since we're supposed to be here together."

For a second, silence fell over their table but Hinata started giggling at what he just said, her laugh could have also been intertwined with nervous laughter for it was a little too loud for Sasuke's own liking, either way, he couldn't help but smirk her. Naruto would freak if he saw Sasuke talking to a stranger, a girl no less, and not only that, but he was actually putting in the effort to help her and maintain a conversation. He had never willingly had a conversation with a stranger before.

Sadly Hinata' sudden laughing fit turned the attention of a white-haired guy, also known in Sasuke's head as the girl's ex, to them. The said guy looked their way, moment in which Sasuke noticed the myriad of feelings showing onto his expression, he seemed to go from hopeful to confused to slightly irritated and then settle for putting on a fake smile and strolling their way.

"Hinata, long time no see, how are you?" The ex-boyfriend looked at her and gave Sasuke a not-so-subtle glare. He took in their table before raising an eyebrow and immediately asking another question, essentially cutting Hinata off before she could answer his first question. "Matcha milkshake? I thought you hated those"

"Oh, I used to yea, but I think they changed the receipt here. I tasted one sip from when Sasuke ordered one last time and it was pretty good, so today I wanted to see for myself" She said smoothly and took a big sip of her, well…his milkshake. "And I've been pretty good. How about yourself?" She smiled way too sweetly at him.

"Uh…can't complain" He took another second to examine them again. "Well, I was actually thinking maybe we can get together and have dinner sometime next week?"

"Dude, you don't ask out a girl when she's already out with another guy, that's just fucking messed up" Sasuke said, without actually meaning to his voice got deeper and he glared at the 'ex-boyfriend'. He didn't care that he and Hinata weren't there together for real, it's a universal rule you don't ask out a girl if she's there with a date, that's just a douchey move.

Hinata was grinning at him from behind her hand, her eyes glittering with amusement. Sasuke had to admit something to himself, the strange girl was pretty, but she was even more beautiful while she smiled.

"Chill dude. I didn't think this was a date" he said raising his hands as if trying to say he meant no harm. "I mean who the fuck brings a date at this shitty diner" He whispered under his breath, but both Hinata and Sasuke heard him and their moods turned pretty dark. Sasuke's instinct was the punch the guy's lights out, another new feeling he hadn't experienced, at least not because of a girl. He is usually in control of his emotions and rarely loses his cool.

"Sasuke wanted to go have a sweet picnic in the park near my house, which was so thoughtful and sweet, but sadly the weather didn't agree with him because it started raining. That's when I remembered how I wanted to taste the milkshake, so I proposed we came here to wait for the rain to stop." Sasuke had to admit, her lying skills were top-notch, her story had a natural flow to it, she composed a strong and believable narrative with pretty much no holes, her delivery too added to its credibility, fot she spoke with such ease. Hinata reached for his hand that was on the table and squeezed it while spreading her web of lies. Sasuke noticed the ex-boyf rolling his eyes, and a part of him felt utter satisfaction from the jerk's annoyance.

"Whatever. I gotta bounce anyway. See you around" He turned and started walking out the diner without waiting for a reply. Sasuke snorted when he noticed that the ex didn't even purchase anything. He was lost in his own world of trash-talking the guy but was got distracted by the petite girl in front of him that whispered not so quietly "I fucking hope not."

"Well, that was fun." He smirked at her. "Let me guess, bad break-up?" Hinata sighed and ran both hands over her face.

"The worst. It was a set up and we went on a few dates which were fine I guess, but I just didn't really want a relationship at the time, or at least not with him. Either way, the break-up itself took like 3 hours cuz he just wouldn't accept it." She took another sip of his milkshake and gaged. "Oh god, I forgot how awful this tasted." She said more to herself, it didn't take her a full second to turn beet-red.

"Oh my God, I'm so sorry this is yours. I d-didn't mean to drink from it, it just happened. Let me buy you a new one" She got onto her feet but Sasuke grabbed her wrist and forced her to sit back down.

"Don't worry about it. You barely drank any"

Had he been in his right mind he'd tell the girl to buy him extra fries too for the trouble and then he'd tell her to scramble. But for some reason or another, he didn't want her to leave just yet. He pulled the glass back to him and drank from it just to prove to her everything was fine.

"I don't understand how you can drink that. It's not even sweet" Her nose wrinkled in disgust, Sasuke didn't throw the world 'cute' around easily but she looked adorable.

"I hate sweets. So, this is perfect" Her jaw dropped, she looked like he had just said he hated puppies and his mother. Hinata blinked a few times, closed her mouth and opened it to say something, closed it back again. She looked genuinely confused, like someone that hated sweets wasn't meant to exist.

"I-I don't understand. How can you hate sweets? T-They make the world a better place. Don't tell me that after a shitty day you don't go home to eat a gallon of ice cream with a dozen of cookies because I will not believe you"

Now it was his turn to gag just thinking about the amount of sugar in the 'snack' she described. His reaction repulsed her.

"Oh wow. I'm perplexed. I had no idea people like you existed"

The fact that she said it with straight face made him believe she honestly didn't think that what he said could be true, which for some reason he found extremely funny.

"Huh, you learn something every day." She said with a smile, it seemed she had gotten over her confusion and found the whole conversation quite as amusing as he did.

A waitress came over to take Sasuke's now empty milkshake glass.

"Would you like anything else?"

"Could you please bring me a veggie burger and a blueberry lemonade? And some fries too" She ordered and it relieved him that she did, he hadn't had a lunch companion besides Naruto in a while.

"I'd also like some fries and another matcha milkshake"

"I'll be right back," The older woman said and left right away. When he turned back to the girl before him, she was staring at him with a small smile on her lips so he raised an eyebrow at her.

"I was sure you'd tell me to leave, or tell the waiter you'd like the bill and left yourself." She put both of her hands on the table and played with her bracelet. "I've seen you around the diner. You're not the…most welcoming face here and I've also saw you get up and leave on multiple occasions when someone sat at your table"

Her cheeks were a shade or two darker and she didn't look at him but rather looked at her fidgeting hands. She was embarrassed for admitting she noticed him way before this encounter, she was nervous that she had crossed a line. What she said was true, he knew he wasn't the nicest person but he did genuinely enjoy her presence, also he'd been in a number of situations where he would have liked someone to pretend to be there with him so he'd escape an acquaintance or a fangirl. Plus, the very same day Naruto told him he should do an act of 'kindness' a day or his karma would turn bad. He didn't believe in the nonsense his blonde friend talked about, but when she sat down she looked in so much distress even he didn't have the heart to tell her to leave.

"You're right, But, you looked frightened, I'm not heartless," He said in a neutral voice and Hinata blushed even redder. His lips twitched upward. Where did her confidence and acting skills go?

"I-I-I didn't mean you are heartless…just…umm, uh" she was at a loss of words.

"It's fine. You didn't offend me" Hinata looked up at him relived.

"I didn't? Oh, that's really good, because I didn't mean anything rude by what I said" her shoulders relaxed and her blush faded, not completely she was still a bit flushed but not quite as red as before.

"Since you knew there was a chance, I'd leave why did you sit here?"

Her smile softened a little. "Have you ever seen a person and had the urge to talk to them? For them to be your friend? I don't mean to sound creepy, but every time I saw you here, I always wanted to talk to you, I just never had the courage. I guess the situation gave me the opportunity to do so. And I'm quite glad because, I don't know about you, but I'm having a pretty good time talking to you" her cheeks flared even redder with each confession, for some reason admitting her thoughts in front of him was embarrassing. "Oh, just so you know, I've never done this before. I just had a pretty bad day and didn't want it to get worse by having to be in his company for long."

Their talk continued for a while longer until finally, their food arrived. The older waitress placed their orders on the table.

"There you go. Enjoy your food"

"Thank you" Hinata nodded at the waitress with a smile.

"I have one more question." Sasuke said as Hinata took a sip of her lemonade, but gestured with her hand for him to go on. "What happened? When he was here you were a very smooth talker, but when you thought you offended me you seemed to be drowning in your own words"

Her blush came back and Sasuke decided he quite liked how she looked with it. She played with the tips of her hair, rolling it onto her finger. "W-when I was little, I was extremely shy, I couldn't even look at strangers, my parents entered me in acting classes in hopes that I'd get over it. It didn't really go as planned. I'm a lot better now, obviously but I still get anxious easily. Even so the acting classes did help me, when I'm in a crisis I seem to calm down and I'm able to collect my thoughts" She looked a bit over his shoulder in deep thought. "It's like a defence mechanism but it doesn't always work. Case in point when I o-offended you, which I'm sorry about again"

"I see…also you didn't offend me, I told you this before. You only stated your opinion, which was true by the way"

She smiled at him once more and they started eating, it wasn't complete silence, they made small talk asked about normal things, hobbies, friends, school and all that. Once they were finished and Sasuke asked for the bill since it was getting pretty dark and the rain finally stopped, he noticed her playing with the bracelet again.

"Something wrong?"

"Huh?" she looked up at him confused.

"You were fidgeting your hands like you did before when you were nervous. Is something bothering you?"

Hinata opened her mouth. They had spent about 2 or 3 hours together and he was able to pick up some of her habits already. He did seem like the type of person that paid attention, he was quiet but observing. Without meaning to she associated him with one of those old people from the park that sit on a bench and watch everyone pass by, like they don't belong to this world, they just witness it, they are watchers that see the smallest details.

He didn't know what she was thinking about, but her smile was beautifully tragic, she seemed sad, or at least contemplative.

"I was just thinking how much I enjoyed our…lunch? Dinner? And was wondering how awkward it would be to…a-ask for your number m-maybe?"

He also liked when she stuttered a little. "I don't see why not. I enjoyed myself as well"

If only Naruto saw him give his number to a girl, the blonde would never let this slide, which was also why he'd never tell his blonde best friend about the petite blue-haired girl that made his ordinary day a little bit extraordinary, she proved that sometimes doing things you've never done can have a good end result, in this case talking to a stranger and pretending to date led to a pleasant evening and hopefully a friend and maybe more.