Set during iThink They Kissed when Carly tells Freddie that at the dentist Sam said that they had kissed. Also sorry if Carly sounds a little crazy in the first paragraph she gets better by the end.
Freddie's POV
"Why didn't you tell me?" Carly says angry at her friends but still confused. "We swore we would never tell anyone!" I said frantically. "Aww man I've been speaking of it!" "You and Sam are my best friends, I need to know these kinds of things! But this is just crazy!" Carly says, still freaking out. "Carly, why? Why is this crazy?" I say calming down. "I mean I thought, you two hated each other and well I don't know You are supposed to love me! Not her, you love me! Right, you want me to be your girlfriend! So why are you going around kissing other girls, that is not me! Also you two hate each other if I haven't said that already." Carly says, sounding insane.
"Okay, okay. You sound absolutely insane." I say walking away from her towards the door. "Wait! Tell me why I sound insane." Carly says, grabbing me and pulling me back into the room. "Fine." I say. "First off Sam and I don't hate each other. It's just a game we play, It's how we show our feelings towards each other. I know it sounds weird but it's like our own kind of communication." I say trying to explain this to Carly without her totally freaking out again. "um, okay." Carly says sitting down in a beanbag chair. "But! You love me! Right?" Carly says. "Um yeah-...
-as a friend, Carly." I am waiting for her response. "Freddie!" Carly gets up off her chair. "You used to say you loved me like every chance you could!" "Used to." I say. "Those are two very important words. Carly you are an awesome friend and I know I used to have a huge crush on you but when I think about it now it was just a stupid childhood crush." I say trying to reason with her. "And it's not like we dated or anything, I can kiss girls that aren't you if I want. Even if it's Sam." I say trying to answer her questions and reason with her.
"I'm sorry Freddie. I really am, I just feel a little... I don't know..." Carly says, trying to think of the right word. "Are you jealous?" I say. "Maybe. I guess I kind of liked having someone always nagging me to be their girlfriend. I liked to attention you gave me." Carly says, sitting back down in her bean bag chair. "I'm really sorry Freddie." she says and I can tell she meant it. "It's okay Carly and even though I don't have a crush on you anymore doesn't mean you can't be one of my best friends right?" I ask her sitting down on the beanbag chair next to her. "Yeah and what do you mean when you say one of my best friends?" Carly asks me. "Um, Sam! She's my best friend too!" I say. "I should have known that. I just thought you would never even consider her as a friend!" Carly says.
"Real funny Carls." I say thinking about Sam. Wait! I shouldn't be thinking about her, why would I think about that blonde haired demon. "Freddie? Freddie?" Carly says waving her hand in front of my face. "What?" I say. "You zoned out." "Sorry I was just thinking." I say. "About what? Sam?!" Carly says. "Why would I be thinking about Sam?" I say blushing. "I don't know, I mean you were talking about her before you zoned out and when I say her name you keep on blushing..." Carly says, staring at me oddly. "WAIT! You like Sam!" Carly says. She figured me out. "Um no." I say quietly. "Yes you do, Freddie! I know you too well!" Carly says standing up. "Okay, fine! I may like Sam." "I knew it!" Carly says. "But that doesn't mean she'll like me back." I say staring at the ground. Right as I say that we hear the door slam downstairs and Sam's voice go "Carly? Where are you, I'm eating your bacon!" Carly smirks at me. "Well then let's go find out." She grabs me and pulls me out the door of the iCarly studio.
"Carly, no! I don't want to do this!" I say as we get down to the first floor of her apartment. Sam is staring at us from the kitchen eating bacon. "What do you not want to do, nub?" Sam says. "You look upset, did Carl decline your request to be her boyfriend, again. She'll never love you." Sam says to me, making me more upset. Carly nudges me to make a move. "But will you?" I ask her. "I'm going to go upstairs now." Carly says rushing out of the room. "What did you just say nub?" Sam asks me to walk closer to me. "I said but will you? `` Will you love me or at least like me?" I say speaking fast. I know she could hear the nervousness in my voice. "What do you think?" She asks me. "Um, no. I don't think you would." I say and turn around to walk into the living room disappointed.
"Wait! You answered that question, I never did." Sam says running into the living room to stop me from leaving. "Just tell me already so I can go sit in my room in the dark." I say not facing her. "Freddie, there's no need for that. I think that I may just like you too." Sam says. I turn around to look at her, her bright blue eyes are sparkling and I know she was telling the truth. "Really, you like me?" "Does this answer your question?" Sam says. She walks even closer to me and kisses me. It doesn't last long but it answers my question. I smile at her. "I think it does!" I say and she walks back into the kitchen to get some more bacon.
As Sam turns around Carly and Spencer appear from behind the pillar in the kitchen. "I told you Spencer, I knew Sam and Freddie would get together! You owe me ten." Carly says to her brother. "Okay, sure! And hey you're not the only Seddie shipper!" Spencer says as he hands Carly a ten dollar bill. "And hey I got that all on video. The iCarly viewers are going crazy!" Carly says pulling up on the monitor in the kitchen. "You streamed this online!" Sam says pulling away from her bacon to go over to Carly. "Yeah and It was so worth it." Spencer said. I walk over to the others. "I think it was." I say and kiss Sam on her cheek. I know it was.