A/N: This story starts after the culture festival. Senpai is in 2nd year and Nishikata, Nagatoro, & Takagi

are in 1st year. Each section will largely be following one of the characters. This is my first story so

constructive feedback is appreciated but also please be kind!

Also, check it out on Wattpad at 1108920119-don-toy-with-me-miss-takagi-san-nagatoro-takagi and check it out on archive of our own at /works/33026986/chapters/81978022

Naoto Hachioji is Senpai's name but I will mainly refer to him as "Senpai"

Chapter 1: I'm going to hug you now, Senpai.

Senpai: "A-alright everyone, settle down!"

Interest in the art club had peaked in Kaze High after some drama surrounding the president's art piece along with Senpai's excellent turnout for his exhibit, largely thanks to the help of the Toro-cats & the president's painting. Unfortunately, this led to many people joining the art club for less than virtuous reasons.

Many expectant boys left the club after they looked and saw no sign of the president. This left just one other boy with Senpai in a room full of fangirls. Most of the people ignored his request as many girls were talking amongst themselves about Senpai's looks and his artwork while giggling and blushing. In fact, the only people who really quieted down were a short, fairly muscular boy and a girl of similar height and a large forehead.

Senpai: Well, at least this gives me time to wait for Nagatoro to arrive-

As soon as Senpai finished that thought, the door to the art room slammed open as Nagatoro burst through the doors.

Nagatoro: "Su~p Senpa-"

A dark look went over Nagatoro's face as she saw the massive crowd of girls in the room.

Nagatoro: "Senpai? Who are these people?"

Senpai: "Oh, uh, you see, the culture festival got a lot of people interested in the art club and these are all people considering joining."

Nagatoro: "What are you squirming about for? you're so gross Senpai!" *noodle slap*

Senpai was blushing profusely as Nagatoro was inching closer and closer to him. Nagatoro suddenly realized what she could do to keep this horde of girls away from her Senpai.

Nagatoro: *with an evil smirk* "I'm going to hug you now, Senpai."

Senpai: "Wha- Nagatoro, everyone will see us!"

Nagatoro quickly jumped into Senpai's lap and threw her arms around him. Trapped on his stool and unable to think of anything else, he wrapped his arms around her in turn.

Senpai: "What was that for?!"

Nagatoro: "Look up, gross-Senpai!"

Nagatoro's plan seemed to work as the room was now empty except for the fairly muscular boy and a girl with a big forehead.

Senpai: *still blushing profusely* "Well now t-that's over with, w-why don't we do some introductions?"

The 2 in front of Senpai and Nagatoro nodded their heads in agreement.

Senpai: "So, uh, I'm Naoto Hachioji and I'm acting president of the art club. I draw and... yeah."

Nagatoro quickly elbowed Senpai.

Senpai: "Ow! Alright, alright. This is Nagatoro. She's a first year student..."

Nagatoro waited in anticipation. When he didn't say anything she became a little agitated.

Nagatoro: "That's it?! You're not going to tell them about your kohai? Going to make me do all the work? Gross!"

Senpai: "Uh, as you can see, she can be a little bit harsh but she doesn't mean it. She, uh, also m-models here from time to time and she, uh, hangs out here a lot since we don't have many members..."

Nagatoro still looked slightly annoyed, but also slightly satisfied.

Senpai: *looking at Takagi* "Well, how about you?"

Takagi: "Hello! I'm Rie Takagi. I've mainly been focusing on my grades but I draw from time to time and I was looking forward to joining a club with Nishikata."

Nishikata: "I can introduce myself Takagi-san! I'm Yuki Nishikata and I draw as a hobby in my free time if I have nothing else to do.

After Senpai gave Takagi and Nishikata a basic rundown on different ways to make art, Takagi asked a question.

Takagi: "Hachioji-senpai, is Nagatoro in the art club? You haven't seemed to really be directing anything towards her."

Everyone in the room gave Takagi a weird look as Senpai responded

Senpai: *While blushing* "W-well, uh, Nagatoro just models here from time to time and hangs out here so I guess not?"

Senpai then noticed Nagatoro glaring at Takagi.

Senpai: "Also, uh, this might be weird but could you not, uh, r-refer to me as Senpai? Just Hachioji is fine."

Nagatoro gave Senpai a surprised look which turned into a smiling blush. She then remembered to tease him.

Nagatoro: "Geez Senpai! Can't handle someone else calling you by your honorific? Geez, you're so gross!"

Nagatoro gave him another playful noodle slap.

Nishikata almost wasn't listening during this exchange as he was deep in thought.

Nishikata: "Takagi-san! How about a competition?"

Takagi: "What do you have in mind?"

Nishikata: "A drawing competition! We each do a drawing and Hachioji-san can decide which one is better!"

Senpai: "W-well..."

Takagi: "Sure! Loser has to buy juice on the way home!"

Nishikata: What Takagi doesn't know is that I've been practicing drawing ever since she asked me to join the art club! My skill in drawing still lifes is unmatchable!

Takagi: "Since Nagatoro-san isn't going to be drawing and Hachioji-san will be judging, why don't we draw Nagatoro-san?"

Nagatoro scratched her cheek while slightly blushing at Takagi's words as she had never modelled for anyone other than her Senpai.

Nishikata: Crap! Now I can't use my skill in drawing still lifes! Still, I should be better at drawing than her. This should still be easy! "Sure, Takagi-san! I'm finally going to beat you now!"

Senpai: Oh. I was going to ask them to draw still lifes but this sounds like it's important to them. Besides, I can sketch Nagatoro anyways while they're drawing. "Sure, as long as that's okay with you, Nagatoro?"

Nagatoro: "Well, I'm not so sure..."

Senpai: "I can also s-sketch you while they're sketching."

Nagatoro: "Bu-t, if you're going to force me, I guess I have no choice!"

Senpai: "So, uh, I'll get the canvases…"

Senpai went into the prep room. After about a minute, he came out with 2 canvases.

Senpai: "Uh, could one of you bring the last one?"

Nishikata: "Sure."

Nishikata went to get the last canvas. As they set up their canvases, Nagatoro sat down on a stool, sitting down with a casual smile. Senpai was surprised that Nagatoro neglected to tease him at all or try to strongarm him into drawing her with her swimsuit.

Nagatoro: "And let the sketching begin!"

Takagi and Senpai started sketching casually, taking quick glances and making a few strokes with their pencils accordingly. Nishikata, however, was growing redder and redder by the second.

Nishikata: Dammit! I can't just stare at a girl head-on! That makes me look like a pervert! Damn you Takagi-san!

Nagatoro noticed Nishikata looking at her and looking away embarrassed. Rather than smirking and teasing him, she scowled slightly and went back to her original stance. Senpai noticed this but said nothing and went back to sketching.

Nishikata: Okay, calm down Nishikata. You're just doing a drawing. You're just doing a drawing. You can do this.

Nishikata picked up his pencil and started sketching.