Disclaimer: I own nothing of the properties within this story and all right rights go to the creators and companies of said properties

Chapter 2: Santa and her present

"CHEERS!" all of us well as we hit our glasses, with some of the drinks being on the harder side based on the flashes on Vali, Arthur, and Bikou's faces. Tonight is Christmas day with Team Vali and all of us are partying a bit. Mittelt, Le Fay, and I did the cooking for the party, but since everyone outside us can't cook worth a damn, they did the decorating but Le Fay still had to make some minor adjustments. The only one not with us for the party is Kuroka as she wanted to spend Christmas with her sister for the first time in years.

I feel someone wrap an arm around me from behind, I turn towards my left to see a quite drunk Vali with a deep red blush and a large smile. "REN! Did you know when Azazel first put you into our group I thought you were going to be nothing but dead weight? But look at us now! You're like the brother I never knew that I wanted!" Vali told me as he took another big gulp of his spike eggnog that probably has more booze than eggnog. Yes Vali, you told me… five times already.

Weird to think that the battle-hungry Vali was also the type of drunk that goes around telling people how much he loves them. Then again here I am, celebrating the birth of Jesus Christ with the Great Grandson of Lucifer, the descendent of Sun Wukong, the descendants of King Arthur, and a fallen angel. But I really enjoy spending time with them so everything is alright. I'm spending time with some great friends and my two girlfriends. Of course, I would be happy.

After Bikou finished eating his ninth plate of huoshao and spring rolls, we finally reached the gift opening part of the party. We all store Kuroka's gifts in her room to open once she gets back so we just exchange ours for each other. I give Mittelt a copy of the newest pokemon, Heart Gold. For Le Fay, a magical tome from Egypt. For Arthur, a couple of boxes of that black tea that he loves. For Bikou, some plum wine. And for Vali, a few sets of training weights with runes to increase the gravity around him. I did get Kuroka a new kimono but she will find out later.

Mittelt gave me Soul Silver to go with her gold. Le Fay, a new set of inscribing tools for my rune and enchanting projects. Arthur, a pair of glasses that were enchanted by Le Fay to make them both indestructible and not to fall off my face. Bikou, which seems like notes from Lao Tzu, without some recipes like the one for pills of immortality. And from Vali, a book on some simple self-defense which is probably useless against anyone above human level, but it's still nice. I didn't open Kuroka's gift as I wanted her to see my reaction.

As I look over the game case that Mittelt give me I realize a small detail, it wasn't shrinkwrapped. Maybe she got it secondhand? I opened the case to see the game in question, the manual, and some ads. But there's something odd here, a small slip of paper that's folded. I take out the slip of paper and unfold it to see it's a note.

Keep your door unlock tonight~ Santa is coming with a very special gift for you tonight~

I smile at the note. Mittelt loves to do stuff like this after we reach that stage of our relationship. We did a bunch of well-known sexual acts. Anal, cosplay, roleplay, and some other minor stuff, all of which are fun because Mittelt is a fun one in the sack. But I only have done it with her and only recently Le Fay so the competition wasn't hard.

So I decided to get ready for tonight with a quick shower, making sure all the silence runes are in place and working, and checking if I have some lube in case Mittelt is feeling up for some anal play. I even made sure to have some contraceptive pills because even though supernatural women have a harder time getting pregnant it doesn't mean it's impossible and I don't want to be a dad yet.

As I waited for Mittelt until close to midnight, probably waiting until everyone was asleep before we started doing the deed. I almost fall asleep myself a couple of times as I wait, but the promise of sex helps me will my need for sleep away.

Knock. Knock. Knock.

Look like it's time for Santa to visit me~

I get out of my bed and make my way to my door, opening it to see not only Mittelt but also Le Fay. Mittelt is wearing a sexy Santa costume, a tight red band that covers her chest with small tufts of white fur and the band is tight enough to show her hardened nipples poking out, stating that she wasn't wearing a bra underneath it. A pair of red stockings with the same white fur around her thighs. A tiny skirt that's like the other pieces of clothing, red with white fur, and was short enough that I can see her red panties, with the back of it disappearing into the flesh of that tight ass I love. And to finish the look, she's wearing a small Santa hat on top of her head. Her face had that cute smug look that I came to love with a slight blush.

Le Fay is very different from Mittelt, she's only standing there with a massive blush wearing only a large coat that reaches her knees. I let both of my lovers into my room and quickly closed the door.

"I know Santa is coming, but why is Le Fay here Mittelt?" I ask. I don't have an issue with her being here normally but if Mittelt was planning for sex tonight then this might be an issue because I doubt Mittelt planned for a threesome.

Is she?

"Well~ What is Santa without any presents? So I thought of getting you a very special present for being such a good boy this year~" Mittelt said as she turned to Le Fay, who was just standing there with her face getting even redder. Which I thought was impossible.

…

I guess Le Fay was getting the old case of stage fright here, despite it being only us three. "Le Fay, are you ok? You said you wanted to do this." Mittelt said to Le Fay.

"I know, but saying it and actually doing it are two very different things!" Le Fay whine as the blush reaches atomic levels of red. What were they planning outside of the potential threesome?

"Do you want to leave? I rather you feel comfortable when doing this stuff, Fay. Your feelings matter so much in this because it only truly feels good if we both feel good." I said, using her nickname to help calm her down. Which looks to work somewhat judging by the small smile and the calming down of her blush, it was still there but looks more natural.

"Thank you, but Mittelt is right. I wanted to do this, I overheard Mittelt planning on her own but I wanted to join in because I wanted to show you how much I love you. And to show Mittelt how much I love her." Le Fay says, sliding the coat off to show why she was so embarrassed.

And I can now understand why she was so embarrassed. If Mittelt's outfit was sexy then Le Fay's was downright sinful. Her outfit is literally only ribbons wrapped around her body, barely covering her nipples as hints of her candy pink nipples present and the ribbon wedge deeply into her pussy giving it the perfect outline. The finishing touch is a small ribbon wrapped around Le Fay's neck with a little tag saying 'To Ren'. And I thought I was erect before that.

Standing before me are my two lovers, wearing possibly the sexiest outfits I've ever seen, so I did what any man would do in my situation.

{Warning! This part is the smut! The following will happen: Anal and lesbian play}

"EEP!" "WOAH!"

I pull my lovers close to me, making sure to grab a nice handful of their cute asses. Enjoying the feel of Mittelt's tight ass that's a perfect handful and Le Fay's plump cheeks that cause my fingers to sink into the soft flesh.

"I love you two so much." I said, squeezing their buttocks which caused them to softly moan.

"Mmm~ You know Santa only gives presents right?~" Mittelt teases as grinds her small breasts into me.

"Yes, but you said I was a good boy so I thought maybe I could be a bit selfish this year. Wanting my present and Santa~" I said as I looked down at my fallen lover.

I slowly lean down until our lips meet, tasting the cherry lip balm from her lips, before slipping my tongue into her waiting mouth. I deepen the kiss, savoring the taste of my lover's saliva, before ending the kiss despite wanting more. But that wouldn't be fair to ignore my other lover, slowly turning to Le Fay. I quickly capture her lips, tasting her strawberry lip gloss, as I deepen that kiss as well. Running my tongue around with her own, tasting more of my magical lover's mouth. I remove my tongue from her mouth to see the heavily blushing Le Fay before Le Fay turns to Mittelt and steals her lips.

Damn, that hot…

I watch my lovers share probably their first lesbian kiss, their tongues feverishly wrapping around each other, softly moaning as the kiss continues. The two end the kiss, heavily breathing as they stare at each other. Before looking back at me with a look full of love and lust. They both grab a hand, Mittelt my left and Le Fay taking the right, and lead me to my bed. I can feel my heart racing with each step towards the bed and my cock hardening even more, preparing for the actions for tonight.

Once we reached the bed, Mittelt went in for another kiss which I accepted. As we kiss, I feel her hands unbuttoning my button-up shirt as Le Fay unbuckles my pants. Soon enough I stood before my lovers free to the elements with them guiding me to lay on the bed, which I followed. Mittelt and Le Fay climb into the bed, giving me one quick kiss, before turning towards my manhood, which is standing at its full eight-inch height. I feel Mittelt giving the head a small kiss before sticking the tip into her mouth, slowly swirling her tongue around it, as Le Fay gives my shaft a series of kisses and licks.

Seeing the two pleasuring me is nice and all, but I believe in fair play. I slip a finger into Mittelt's panties and Le Fay's ribbon to move them aside to reveal their dripping wet slits. I move my head towards Le Fay's waiting pussy, giving it a long lick, and slowly working my fingers into Mittelt's tight cunt. The girls give a small moan from my actions but I'm not satisfied with such small reactions. Time to break out the eromancy skills.

I cast the [Vibration] spell on both my fingers and tongue, causing the moans to grow in volume. I drink Le Fay's juices, loving the sweet taste, before swiping to Mittelt's insanely tight pussy, tasting the slight tang of her pussy. I repeat the actions of my fingering and eating out as the girls got more extreme with the team blowjob with Mittelt taking more and more of my cock into her tight throat while Le Fay sucks my testicles. I even see the two of them sharing another lesbian kiss with my cock being the middle of it, feeling their duo tongues wrapping around the head.

"I'm about to cum!" I told the girls, which increases their licking and sucking.

"CUM! Cum all over us! Cake our faces with your semen! Show everyone that we belong to you!" Mittelt screams, stopping her sucking on my balls. Le Fay speeding up on her deep throat, sucking even harder!

"HUM! HUM! HUM!" Le Fay screams despite her mouth being filled with my cock.

Le Fay stops her deep throat so she and Mittelt can assault the head, tipping me over the limit!

"CUMMING!" I yell at the top of my lungs, thank you divines for the silencing runes. Arthur would break the door down if he heard us.

My dick explodes its first load, shooting a massive load of semen. My cum lands on the girls' heads, faces, tongues, and on my shaft.

"Mmm~ I love the taste~" Mittelt moans as she swallows the load that landed on her tongue.

"So~ hot~" Le Fay says between her heavy breathing, and she too swallowed the cum that landed on her tongue.

Both girls look at each other, seeing the amount of cum covering their bodies. Both of them leaned into each other and started to lick the cum off each other. Mittelt immediately went for the cum that's resting on Le Fay's breasts and Le Fay licking Mittelt's cheeks and neck. Both of them lapped up as much cum from each other as they could before moving towards the cum that landed on my stomach and covering my shaft. Le Fay is licking my abs while Mittelt gives my cock a quick deep throat to suck the cum. Once both of them finished cleaning me up, they shared another steamy kiss. Their swirling tongues, sharing my semen between them, before both girls swallow the last bit of my first load.

I watch Mittelt pull off her tube top shirt while Le Fay uses magic to cut her ribbons, freeing their breasts from confinement. Both of their breasts have a slight jiggle to them from the motion, their candy pink nipples harden. Le Fay cuts the last bit of ribbons, leaving her only with her ribbon collar with the name tag, straddling over my cock before slowly hilting herself onto it. I grab her by the waist to help her guide down, enjoying the hot, soft feeling of vaginal walls. Once Le Fay fully hilts herself, Mittelt pulls down her skirt and panties before straddling over my face before slowly moving down until she's sitting on my face, her pussy right over my mouth. I started eating out Mittelt again as Le Fay starts moving on my cock.

"Mmm~ So full~" I hear Le Fay say before picking speed, with me starting to hump to meet with her thrusts.

"Oh~? Someone seems to be enjoying themself like a naughty girl~" Mittelt said as she increased the speed of grinding on my face.

"EEP!? Mittelt that's my-! AH!~" Le Fay try saying something but was cut off by her own moan.

"Your cute nipples? Yes~, yes they are. You know I've always been a little jealous about how big you are, but now? I love it when I feel them up~" Mittelt said.

"AAHH!~ DON'T SUCK SO HARD!~" Le Fay yells when a slurping noise started. She has gotten way tighter as Mittelt started her assault on her breasts.

"Ok then~ Then stick out your tongue~" Mittelt demands, hearing an intense slurping and moaning coming from between them.

Well~ Guess it's time to pick up my game. I cast [Vibration] on both my cock and tongue, [Increase Pleasure] on them, and even increase the speed of my thrusts to an even higher level.

"AAAHHH!" I hear both of them scream as Le Fay and Mittelt's pussies tightened even more around my cock and tongue. I give Le Fay's ass a nice slap as she bounces on my hip and I start my full-frontal assault on Mittelt's clit. I can sense I'm getting close to my second climax. I thrust as hard as I can until, with the tightening to show that they too were reaching their limits, before I can't back any longer!

"CUMMING!~"

"SO HOT!~"

I came inside Le Fay as they cummed on my face and dick. Le Fay slowly removes herself from my dick, semen flowing out of the freshly fucked pussy. For most normal people, twice would be their limit but thanks to the system I still have plenty of energy based on how my dick is still rock hard.

We reposition ourselves until Mittelt is lying on the bed, her legs spread wide open to show off her tight cunt, Le Fay on her hands and knees above Mittelt to form the classic sixty-nine position with me aiming my dick at Mittelt's waiting entrance. I slowly push myself into the familiar tight depths.

"MMM!~ I never thought Santa would be getting presents this year. Speaking of presents~" Mittlet swoons as she pulls Le Fay down by grabbing two handfuls of her ass, ramming her tongue into her pussy to enjoy the mixture of Le Fay's juices and my cum.

"AH!~" Le Fay moans before attacking Mittelt's clit as I start moving in and out. I play with Le Fay's nipples as I thrust. I pinch, roll, flick, and even give a light tug at the hardened pink tips. Le Fay would stop attacking Mittelt's clit to lick my cock as I moved back and forth.

"EEEKK!?" Le Fay squeals, I looked towards Mittelt to see what she had done to her and saw her sticking a finger into Le Fay and it wasn't her pussy. Mittelt is fingering Le Fay's ass.

I would be lying if I say the action wasn't hot to me. I speed up my thrust as I feel another climax approaching.

"I'm about to cum." I told the girls, feeling Mittelt wrapping her legs around my waist to tell me to cum inside. Which I have no problem with. I busted my third nut into Mittelt's depth as Le Fay moans at the top of her lungs, perhaps the pleasure for both her pussy and ass was too much for the least experience one out of us three as she collapses with her eyes gaze over.

Mittelt and I move Le Fay around so she can rest for a moment. She might be able to get in one more after resting for a minute or two, but not now.

"Sorry… I guess I bit off a bit too much huh?" Le Fay said through her heavy breathing.

"Don't be silly. You're amazing. Just rest a little bit and you will be jumping right back in. Plus look at it this way, you're going to get your own show like how you and Mittelt give to me one." I said.

"Yeah, I'm certain you'll be right back in too." Mittelt said, giving the tired Le Fay a kiss to which I followed. "But for right now, enjoy your private show from both your lovers."

Mittelt makes her way towards my dresser, swaying her hips to make her heart-shaped ass jiggle with each. She bends over to the second bottom drawer, shaking her ass looking for a certain item I keep for times like these.

"There you are~" Mittelt says in a songful tone as she pulls out a bottle full of clear liquid, that being lube. "Now come over here baby~ I know how much you love playing with my ass~" she says as she bounces on the balls of her feet to make one big jiggle.

She isn't wrong. I'm very much an ass man. Large breasts are nice but there is something to a nice ass, be it the small and tight heart-shaped ass of Mittelt or Le Fay's big and plump bubble butt.

I take the bottle, which I set on the dresser for now, and got onto my knees to play with Mittelt's ass. I spread her cheeks, giving them a nice little squeeze, to reveal the pink little rosebud. I stick out my tongue to give the tight hole a few licks, running the tip of my tongue around the ring, and once Mittelt loosens up I ram it in.

"MMM~ That's it~ Eat my fucking ass~" Mittelt moans, grabbing me by my hair and pulling me to go deeper into her ass. Which I have no problem with as I use my left hand to flick her clit and my right to play with her nipples. Soon enough I remove my head from her cheeks to stand back. I grab the bottle of lube and squirt some into my hand, coating some of my fingers, as Mittelt grabs the bottle and squirts a tad larger amount to cover her hand. After making sure my fingers are properly lubed up, I slip a finger into Mittelt's tight little ass as she wraps her lube-covered hand around my shaft to give me a lubed handjob.

"Damn… this feels so good." I said with a moaning growl. Mittelt truly knows how to make a guy happy in times like these.

"I'm glad you feel that way. Now get to work~ I want to feel your cock breaking my ass~" Mittelt said. "AH!~" and I caused that by shoving in a second finger. I slowly twirl my fingers around her insides, spreading my fingers like a pair of scissors, and once I feel her entrance soften enough I remove my finger to start lining up my cock with her asshole. I slowly push in, savoring the tight pressure caused by her ass. If Mittelt's pussy was tight then her ass threatens to rip my dick off with its level of tightens.

"AAAHHH! I fucking love the feeling when you stretch me out~ Now hurry!~ Ruin my fucking ass!~" Mittelt begs. I answer her wish by wrapping my arms under her arms and lifting her up to go wild on her ass! I thrust with reckless abandonment!

"AH!~ AH!~ AAAHHH!~ YES!~ JUST LIKE THAT! ~ BREAK ME!~ RUIN ME!~ DESTROY ME!~ MAKE IT IMPOSSIBLE FOR ANY MAN TO PLEASE ME!~" Mittelt squeals as manages to change the hold from under her arms to holding her knees, making her ass clear to my plunging.

"No man will ever have you Mittelt. You are mine. No man in the world will ever take you from me! I WILL MAKE SURE THE IDEA OF BEING WITH ANY OTHER MAN WOULD BE IMPOSSIBLE BY FUCKING THE IDEA OUT YOUR HEAD!" I roar, I'm a bit possessive in time like these.

"AH!?~" I hear Mittelt moan in surprise, and I think I know why judging by the mop of blonde attacking her pussy. Sucking out the lacking cum for Mittelt's previous fucking. Looks like Le Fay truly wasn't out for the count.

With Le Fay's pussy raid and my violent assault on her ass, Mittelt was about to cum. Tightening her ass even further than before to bring me over the edge as well! I hilted myself into the deepest parts of Mittelt's ass that I can reach, firing out probably my biggest load yet!

"AAAAAHHHHH!~" Mittelt screams as cums.

This is an amazing Christmas…

"Ren… I see still hard…" I hear Le Fay say and look down to see she's right, I'm still hard. I probably have one more shot left in me. "Ren… here, use this…" Le Fay says, handing me a familiar bottle of lube before getting on all fours at the bed. She shakes her ass, looking back at me with her cute, heavily blushing face, and I don't need to be a genius to understand what she's implying.

"Fay, are you sure? We haven't done anal before." I said, while I do love anal I don't want her to feel like she is forced to do the same thing as Mittelt.

"Ren, I love you and I want you to take my everything. Everything…" Le Fay says, shaking her bubble butt. "I have given you my first kiss, my virginity, my heart, my body, and my soul. I want to give you my last virginity. So please Ren, fuck my ass~" Le Fay says with a voice filled with love and lust. I sigh and turn to Mittelt, silently asking her to at least help me make this pleasurable as possible for Le Fay.

Mittelt slides underneath Le Fay and the two start making out as I go to work my magic, both figuratively and literally. I quickly use a couple of eromancy spells, [Reduce Pain], [Increase Pleasure], and [Stretch]. I'm going to do everything in my power to make sure Le Fay feels nothing but pleasure, I grab her plump cheeks and spread them. I see the tiny pink star and give it a couple of long slow licks, causing Le Fay to jolt a bit at the foreign feeling. I waited for her to settle down before continuing with Mittelt helping me by groping Le Fay's breasts, pinching and flicking her nipples. I also decided to finger her pussy before going in for a second round at the rimjob. I slip two fingers into her wet slit before using my other hand to spread her ass to gain access to her rosebud. Le Fay still jumped when my tongue touched her anus but it wasn't as much as before. I slowly move my tongue up and down, making circles around the ring of her anus, and even give it a couple of light sucks. Soon enough Le Fay's anus relaxed enough for me to try poking it for entrance, which slowly opened up, allowing me to stick my tongue inside. I move my tongue around the insides of Le Fay's ass, enjoying the soft pressure it was giving. I keep the rimjob going, even to the point Le Fay cum a little bit, before moving on to the next step.

I poured a good amount of lube into my hand and made sure that my fingers were extra lubed up for this task. While people say there are cases of too much lube, I rather put too much and keep slipping out than cause Le Fay any pain. I slowly slide in the first finger.

"Mmm!~" I hear Le Fay moan in pleasure, thank goodness.

I slowly work my way, twirling around the inside, making small rubs in areas that Le Fay reacts with the amount of pleasure that I can reach, and repeatedly sinking my finger in and out. Once Le Fay seemed to get used to the first finger, I added the second. I repeated the same things I've done with Mittelt, slowly extending my fingers in a scissoring motion. Slowly but surely, Le Fay's anus relaxed to the point where I'm certain she should be able to take my penis. I thoroughly rub my dick with lube before lining up with her asshole, with the head touching the ring.

"Le Fay, are you sure about this?" I asked, giving one last chance to back out. She responded by pushing her ass towards my dick, signaling that she still wants to do it. "Alright, I'm going to start then." I warn her before slowly moving the head into her tight asshole. Mittelt increases the intensity of her kiss and groping while I speed up my fingering and kiss Le Fay's neck. I keep moving, inch by inch, until my dick was fully sheath inside her ass with my hip meeting her plump cheeks.

"Are you ok Le Fay?" I ask my lover. I look at Le Fay's face, seeing her face blushed and her eyes gaze over.

"Yeah… It's just a bit intense. It's so different from normal sex." Le Fay told me. "Mittelt, can you move a bit back? I want another go down below~" Le Fay asked, to which Mittelt moved back to give her full access to her pussy.

But it seems Le Fay was aiming for something else. Le Fay spread Mittelt's legs farther to reach her cum filled asshole, diving in face first, and started to eat Mittelt's ass like a wild animal!

Seeing one of my girlfriends eating the ass of the other while I'm in her ass is something of a dream. I start thrusting into Le Fay, loving the tight entrance which leads to her soft, hot walls, and watching her plump bubble butt jiggling like mad whenever my hips slams into her ass. Mittelt is playing with her nipple in one hand and pushing Le Fay's head deeper into her ass, Le Fay rapidly fingering herself and roughly grabbing one of her tits, pinching and rolling her nipple, and I'm thrusting into Le Fay's ass like a madman, leaning over to grab Le Fay's free breast, giving it a tight squeeze, and lightly sucking her neck to the point I was sure a hickey will form. I can feel my final climax coming, so I thrust as fast and hard as I can before hilting myself as deep as I can before cumming!

"AAAHHH!~"

"MMM!~"

I slowly remove myself from Le Fay's ass, watching the torrent of cum flowing out of her ass. Just then the waves of exhaustion just hit me, willing myself from falling over as my lover slowly separated themselves, both as tired as I am but I can they're glowing from the happiness and love from our lovemaking.

{End of Smut!}

I slide in between my lovers, feeling them pushing their hot, sweating, naked bodies into my own naked body. Le Fay uses the last bits of her energy to magically move a blanket from my closet and cover all of us. I look at my two incredible lovers. Le Fay, the person who helped teach me the basics of magic and helps me whenever I work on a new project. Mittelt, the person who always stands by my side no matter how much danger we're in and always saves me whenever my life is at risk.

"Thank you, both of you. Not for this, but for everything. I'm truly the happiest man in the world." I said to them, pulling them closer and laying a hand on their asses. I feel the need for sleep coming to me, Arthur will probably try to stab me tomorrow when he sees us like this but fuck it. I'm slowly closing my eyes. But I realized something before sleeping had a full grip on me.

Despite all the action we've done tonight, Mittelt is still wearing that Santa hat…

Author's note

Merry Christmas everyone! This might come in late depending on where you are from but I wish all a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year! Look forward to the Valentine's Day specials!