AUTHOR NOTE: This was originally requested by kellymarxdolls.
It had been about four months since that day at Bobby's and Sam still texted you every day. Multiple times. You read his texts but never replied. You thought by now the pain would be gone, but it wasn't. You just got used to ignoring it. You were picking up your room when you heard a commotion downstairs. When you ran downstairs your eyes widened at what you saw. There standing in the kitchen was Dean. Bobby had him embraced in a hug. Dean smiled when he saw you. "Heya kiddo," he greeted.
"Is it really him?" you asked Bobby and he nodded. You sprung at Dean wrapping him in a hug. He chuckled and hugged back, "how?".
"I don't know," Dean said, "where's Sammy?". You looked away, but not before he noticed the sadness in your eyes, "what happened?". You sat and explained everything to Dean only leaving out the girl Sam cheated with was Ruby.
"We haven't seen him since," Bobby said.
'But he texts me every day," you said, "I haven't replied,".
Dean got to work on tracking his baby brother down. Once he found out his location you all headed there. You didn't wanna go, but you knew Dean wouldn't let you stay at Bobby's alone. You entered the hotel Sam was staying in and headed for his room. Dean knocked. When the door opened your heart sunk. Bobby and Dean didn't know it, but it was Ruby who answered the door. When Sam walked by he paused in shock as he saw his brother.
As you watched Sam almost attack Dean and Bobby telling him it was really him Ruby smirked at you as she left. Feeling tears well up you stormed off.
"Y/N!" Sam called wanting to chase after you, but Dean stopped him.
"Why would you hurt her Sam?" Dean asked.
"She told you?" Sam asked wondering what Dean knew.
"Said she walked in on you banging some girl," Dean said then remembered the girl who answered the door, "wait was that her who answered the door?"
"Dean," Sam started, "I hate that I hurt Y/N and I tried to make it up to her, but she's shut me completely out,".
"Can you blame her Sammy?" he asked, "that girl adores you, and you go and sleep with someone else,".
"What am I suppose to do Dean?" Sam asked, "I have tried everything to get her to talk to me,". Dean sighed.
"I'll go talk to her and see if I can get her to talk to you and then we can find out what yanked me from the pit,". Dean said walking out to find you. He found you sitting on a rock by the hotel's parking lot entrance. "Hey," he greeted sitting next to you.
"Hey," you said.
"I know your hurting Y/N," Dean said, "and I know he doesn't deserve it, but you two should at least talk,". Tears rimmed your eyes.
"I love him, Dean," you said as the tears fell, "why wasn't I enough?". Dean pulled you into a brotherly hug and let you cry it out as he softly rubbed your back.
"I don't know what got into Sammy," Dean said, "but you need to talk about it and maybe figure it out,".
"What if we can't fix it?" you asked, "will I lose you and Bobby as family?".
"What?" Dean asked surprised, "of course not kiddo. You're stuck with us,". You smiled a little.
"OK," you said, "I'll try talking to him,".