AUTHOR NOTE: This was requested by spn._.addict.
Lucifer secretly snuck around the bunker. He had become intrigued by you. He found himself attracted to you, but envy filled him when he saw how you interacted with the younger of the Winchester brothers. You and Sam would always smile and joke around. Almost always joined at the hip. Lucifer wanted that from you. With you. He wanted the attention from you and even your affections. He wasn't sure why, but he found himself drawn to you. One day not able to handle it anymore he got an idea. It was sneaky, but that's why he liked it.
You were in the kitchen making lunch for the boys. Burgers and fries. It was Dean's day to pick, but you made sure to have a salad made for Sam. You were chopping vegetables when Sam came into the kitchen. "Hello Y/N,' he greeted walking up to you and hugging her from behind. You found it odd but didn't think too much of it. You were best friends.
"Hey Sammy lunch will be done soon," you told him.
"I'm sure anything made by you is beyond delicious," Sam said. You turned to face the hunter.
"Are you flirting with me?" you asked him.
"Would that be such a bad thing?" he asked.
"Hmm," you hummed, "I guess not, but Sam I'm not into you like that remember?". He sighed.
"Can I at least kiss you just once?" he asked. The hope in his voice and eyes were practically pleading with you.
"Well ok, Sam, one kiss," you agreed. He pulled you close to him. It was odd Sam felt cold but comforting. His lips soft, but cool on yours. It was slow at first but soon deepened. You found yourself lost in the kiss until the sound of yelling cut through the room. You broke the kiss and looked to see Sam standing there with a gun pointed at...Sam? You backed away.
"Please don't afraid," the other Sam begged you.
"Stay away from her," Sam ordered.
"I won't hurt her," he said.
"Who are you?" Sam asked. The other Sam looked at you.
"Please, don't be afraid," Lucifer pleaded as he shifted back to himself, "Sammy relax, I actually mean no harm,".
"Why were you kissing her?" Sam asked. You were still a little stunned but couldn't take your eyes off the archangel.
"I find myself attracted to her," he said looking at you, "but I can tell you don't feel the same. I just had to try,".
"You should leave," Sam said. Lucifer nodded looking at you.
"I'm sorry I kissed you," he started to walk off when you grabbed his hand.
"I'm not," you walked up to the archangel, linked your arms around his neck, and pulled him into another deep kiss. Lucifer's eyes went wide for a moment, before joining in. When the kiss ended the angel just stared at you for a moment clearly a little confused.
"So you're really not into Sammy?" he asked.
"Sam is my best friend," you said with a smile, "but I'm attracted more to the rebel angel type,".