AUTHOR NOTE: This was a request for wattpad user Magic_and_books
SUMMARY: Gabriel sends you to an alternate reality when Loki threatens to harm you to draw him out. How will you adjust to your new world and will you go back?
Gabriel held onto you tightly and fluttered off. The only thing going through his mind right now was getting you somewhere safe. Loki had threatened you in order to draw Gabriel out and he was not gonna let anything happen to you. Once you landed you looked around. You were in a deeply hidden alley.
"Gabriel what's going on?" you asked a little scared.
"Y/N, don't worry," he said hugging you, "I won't let anyone hurt you,". You watched him draw a weird looking symbol on the wall.
"Who wants to hurt me?" you asked.
"An old enemy of mine," he said. He hugged you again, "I love you Y/N, always,".
"I love you too Gabriel," you said. Before you could think he pushed through the wall.
You opened your eyes and you were in a big king size bed. Covered in a huge, purple, velvet comforter. You looked around. There was a huge dresser with big screen TV mounted on the wall above it. There was a door to the right of the room that was clearly a walk-in closet and another door that lead into a master bathroom on the left. You noticed a framed picture on the dresser. You climbed off the bed and walked over to it. You picked it up and your eyes widened. It was a wedding picture of you and Gabriel. From the looks of it was an outside wedding. There was something off about Gabriel though. You couldn't really put your finger on it. That's when you heard giggling and could smell bacon frying. You decided to follow the sound of laughter. You exited the bedroom and walked down a small hall. You noticed tons of family photos on the wall. One of a little girl with your hair and Gabriel's whiskey-colored eyes. Another one of a boy with your eyes and Gabriel's brown hair. Several other photos were around too. You stopped and stared at one for a moment. It was of you and Gabriel. Gabriel is holding a little girl in his arm and his other arm around your waist. You couldn't tell for sure, but you looked like you were pregnant. You headed down a spiral staircase. As you reached the bottom the laughter got a little louder. To your right was a big, spacious living room and to your left was a kitchen. You walked into the kitchen and spotted Gabriel at the stove and two children sitting at the counter eating. Gabriel spotted you and smiled.
"Morning sugar," he greeted.
"Morning mommy!" the two kids greeted. You froze. "Did they just call me mommy?" You thought to yourself. Gabriel noticed your odd reaction and his face filled with concern.
"Are you ok Y/N?" he asked walking over to you.
"Um, yeah," you said forcing yourself to snap out of it, "I just feel off today,".
"Come sit with us," he said softly placing his hand on your back, "maybe you'll feel better after some breakfast,". You nodded as you took a seat next to the little girl.
"Bacon and waffles ok?" he asked.
"Sounds good," you said giving him a small smile.
"Daddy makes the best waffles," she said. You smiled.
"I bet he does," you say wishing you know the girls name.
"Of course I do," he said handing you a plate, "If Pepper approves than I know it's good,".
"Pepper?" you asked causing him to look more concerned.
"That's my name Mommy," the little girl said with a small frown, "you didn't forget me did you, Mommy?".
"Oh no sweetie," you said cursing yourself for upsetting the little girl, "Mommy just doesn't feel good today,".
"Pepper," Gabriel said picking the little boy up from his high chair and putting him down, "Why don't you take Sage into the living room and watch cartoons for a bit while I talk to mommy,".
"Sage must be the boy's name," you noted to yourself.
"Ok Daddy," Pepper said hopping down from her chair. She grabbed the little boy's hand and headed to the living room. Gabriel walked over to you and hugged you from behind resting his head on top of yours.
"What's wrong cupcake?" he asked, "I'm a little worried,".
"I'm sure I'm fine Gabriel," you said, "I just feel off today,".
"Maybe you'll feel more yourself when we go to your brother's cookout today,". You hadn't even given any thought to Sam or Dean.
"Cookout?" you asked confused. Your brothers weren't really the cookout type.
"Dean's annual 1st day of summer cookout,". He said.
"Sounds fun," you said, "maybe being around more family will get me out of my funk,".
"Great," he said kissing your cheek, "let's get the kids dressed and then ourselves and go,". About an hour later you and Gabriel where fastening Sage and Pepper into their car seats.
"Daddy, can I play on my tablet until we get to Uncle Dean's?" Pepper asked.
"Sure, sweetie," Gabriel said and handed her the tablet and handed Sage his favorite car toy and you headed off toward your brother's house. During the drive, you tried to make more sense of this new life. You and Gabriel were married. Gabriel was definitely human and you had two kids. You couldn't help but wonder what else about your life is different in this new world. You also wondered why your Gabriel sent you here. What was he protecting you from? You soon pulled up to a small two-story brick house. As you pulled into the driveway you noticed another car there. You got out and got Sage out of his car seat as Gabriel helped Pepper out. You all walked to the door and Pepper knocked. You were greeted by a smiling Dean.
"Uncle Dean!" the young girl yelled jumping into your brother's arms.
"There's one of my favorite girls," he said kissing her cheek before putting her down.
"Gab, Y/N, come on in," he said moving aside, "everyone is out back,".
"My brother here yet?" Gabriel asked.
"Not yet," Dean answered as he lead you guys to the backyard.
"Brother?" you asked Gabriel.
"Castiel," he said, "he's going through a rough time remember? The divorce,".
"Oh," was all you could say. You walked out back and Gabriel was swarmed by three little kids.
"UNCLE GABRIEL!" they all called tackle hugging him and he chuckled.
"Hi Y/N," you heard someone say. You looked over to see Cassie.
"Hi Cassie," you greeted back noticing the wedding ring on her finger.
"I started the grill," she said.
"Awesome," Dean said, "Sammie wanna help me carry the burgers to the grill?". Sam came over with a blonde girl right behind him. As they got closer you saw it was Jessica.
"Sure Dean," he said hugging you, "Hi Y/N,".
"Hi Sam," you said.
"Hey girl," Jessica said hugging you when Sam let go. You had never gotten to meet Jessica in your world, but Sam had shown you pictures and talked about her sometimes.
"Hey Jess," you said.
"You can put Sage in the playpen over there by the picnic table with Mary," she said.
"Mary?" you asked.
"You're niece silly," she said with a giggle. As the day went on you took a mental note of everything you learned. Jessica and Sam had three kids two twins who were eight. A boy Luke and a girl Lilly. They also had a toddler about Sage's age. Sam named her Mary after your mother. Sam was a lawyer and Jessica was a fifth-grade teacher. Dean and Cassie had one kid Zoe who was also eight. Cassie was a stay at home mom and Dean was a cop. That part kinda made sense. Dean loves to help and save people. You had learned that in this universe Gabriel was a pretty big movie producer. The information made your head swim.
"Finally made it," you heard Gabriel said. You looked up to see Castiel. He was dressed in black shorts and a white shirt. His hair was messy and he looked tired. Following behind him was a little girl who looked just like him.
"Hey guys," he greeted walking over to the boys, "sorry it took so long I had to pick up Grace from her mother's house,".
"Uncle Gabriel is Pepper here?" Grace asked.
"Sure is sweetie," he said pointing to the big trampoline Dean and Cassie had in their backyard. She hurried over there.
"Poor Cas," Jess said, "he's still adjusting to the single father life,".
"Well Meg did just spring the whole thing on him," Cassie said, "all because she felt too tied down,". You noted in this world Castiel was had been married to Meg and had a daughter named Grace. This world seemed weirder by the minute, but also so normal in a way.
"So how are you guys?" Castiel asked as he watched Dean flip burgers.
"I'm good," Dean said, " finally caught the flasher that kept hitting stores,".
"That's good," Castiel said.
"Maybe that can be my next movie idea," Gabriel joked, "I'm actually kind of worried,".
"About what?" Castiel asked.
"Y/N has been acting weird today," he said, "like she barely knows anyone's names and she keeps saying she's having an off day,".
"Just keep an eye on her Gab," Dean said, "if it gets worse let me know,". Gabriel nodded. Soon you were all sitting at a picnic table chatting and eating. You started to relax and have fun a little. It was odd, but nice to see your family in a normal life. Especially seeing your brothers happy, even Cas despite the whole divorce thing. Soon the night wound down and the kids started to get tired. You all said your goodbyes as you and Gabriel fastened Pepper and Sage into their car seats. You drove in silence thanking that maybe you could get use to this life. You felt Gabriel intertwine his fingers with yours. You looked over at him and smiled. You arrived back at your new home and you gently woke Pepper up as Gabriel got Sage. Soon both kids were tucked in and you watched from the doorway as Gabriel read Pepper a bedtime story. He finished, turn on her nightlight, and left.
"You are such a good dad," you said as you wrapped your arms around his neck. This may have been a human Gabriel, but you could tell by the shine in his honey-colored eyes it was still the Gabriel you loved.
"And you're just so amazing and beautiful," he said resting his forehead on yours, "feelin better?".
"Much," you said as you softly pressed your lips to his. He wrapped his arms around you as he deepened the kiss. It was definitely the way Gabriel would kiss you. You could even taste a hint of candy. He picked you up and you wrapped your legs around his waist not once breaking the kiss as he carried you to the bedroom. Minus the grace and sometimes wings it was even the way Gabriel made love. Over time you got use to the new life you had. You were happy and content. One night you heard a noise in the kitchen and snuck down to check it out. When you walked into the kitchen your eyes widened. Billie was standing there.
"Finally found where he stashed you," she said looking around, "not bad,".
"Why are you here?" you asked, "is it safe to go home now?".
"No safer than before," Billie said, "I've come to see if you wanna go home before the chance is gone forever,".
"Wait," you said, "why didn't Gabriel come and get me?".
"The Gabriel in your world," she said, "died,". The room spun for a minute and you grabbed the kitchen counter for support as you digested the news. You're actual Gabriel was dead.
"How?" you asked.
"He sacrificed his life for your brothers," she said, "and so many others from the alternate world,".
"So what now?" you asked wiping tears away.
"You can come back home," she said, "or stay in this universe,". You thought for a moment. Going back to your world meant living without your archangel, but staying here gave you a normal life with a human Gabriel.
"I wanna stay," you said, "so please wipe Sam and Dean's minds clean of me,". She nodded and vanished. You went back up to bed and laid there. You let some tears fall for the real Gabriel and fell asleep.