AUTHOR NOTE: This picked as part of my prompt event by peytonmorrison455.

PROMPT #5: "You're too good for them,".

CHARACTER: Sam

You were walking back to the hotel you and the boys were staying at. You had joined the Winchester clan a few years ago after they rescued you from your mother who had been turned into a werewolf. You had been in the town your boyfriend lived in and decided to visit him. You expected a nice maybe even romantic evening with him, not to have your heart broken over cheap pizza and flat soda. He said you were a great girl, but the chemistry just wasn't there. Even gave you the whole it's not you it was him act. You saw Sam standing outside his and Dean's room on his phone and prayed he didn't notice you or your eye liner stained face as you headed to your room. Just as you unlocked your door you heard Sam calling for you.

"Y/N, are you ok?" he asked. You couldn't look at him.

"I'm fine Sam," you said trying to stop your shaky voice as you rushed inside. You were so worried about getting the makeup off your face as you rushed to the bathroom you forgot to lock your room door. You splashed cold water on your face and luckily got the make-up to come off. Just as you finished you looked up in the mirror and saw Sam sitting on your bed. You jumped a little.

"Sorry, didn't mean to scare you Y/N," he said as you walked out of the bathroom, "you've been crying? Y/N what's wrong?". You tried to stop the tears that were building up, but you couldn't. The minute you started to break down again Sam's arms were around you. You told him everything. Sam held you close the entire time. His own heartbreaking at the sight of you dealing with a broken heart. When you finally calmed down Sam guided you over to your bed and sat down with you in his lap. You didn't mind. Sam was sweet and loving. Just being in his hug made you feel safe and secure. You were both silent for a while. "You're too good for them,". Sam finally said.

"What?" you asked him.

"You're too good for them," he repeated, "Y/N, you're sweet, kind, loving, you have the biggest heart of anyone I know, you're never afraid to stand up for those in need which makes you an amazing hunter, and Y/N, not only all of that but your beautiful inside and out. You deserve someone who treats you with respect. Someone who treats you like you're their world. Someone who will truly love you,". You chuckled.

"Where am I gonna find him?" you asked sarcastically.

"Right here," Sam said and you looked at him with shock, "Y/N I've always been right here. I was drawn to you the day we met and I swear each day I just fell more in love with you. Your perfect Y/N, in so many ways,".

"Sam I," you started to say, but you couldn't find the right words. What the hunter just confessed to you was huge and the shock rendered you a little speechless.

"Y/N," he said caressing your cheek. You couldn't help but lean into hunter's warm touch, "let me show how special you are. Let me show you the love you deserve to have. Give me a chance and I promise you, you will never suffer a broken heart again,". At first, you didn't know what to say. Sam was in so many ways a dream guy. Caring, sweet, strong, brave, funny, smart, and definitely handsome. What girl would be foolish enough to pass him up? True the hunter doesn't have the best record of living girlfriends, but you do not believe every girl he ends up will perish. Just when Sam was starting to worry you didn't feel the same you softly grabbed his face and pulled him down into a soft kiss. You felt him smile against it.