A/N: It's a Thanksgiving miracle I've finally finished the chapter. I'm sorry this is so late! We're heading into the summer of '85 now, but don't worry! I'll be writing a few chapters of Chasing Yesterday to fill in the spaces between Billy and Teddi moving in together and now. I just didn't want things to feel too clunky. This chapter also ends a tad awkwardly, but I'm breaking it into two parts so the chapters don't get too long. Hope you enjoy!
xxx
The Hawkins public pool was packed to the brim with people. As Teddi hopped out of her van and made her way through the parking lot, the sound of splashing, kids yelling and laughing and the Power of Love playing on someone's boombox nearby grew louder and louder. Today was her day off, but since everyone she knew was working Teddi decided laying out by the pool was probably a better decision than staying home and watching Star Trek reruns all day.
Teddi made her way inside the gates, passing the bulletin board that read "Meet our '85 swim season lifeguards' in large yellow letters. Teddi's photo was between Heather and Billy's. Her hair was longer than it had been when she moved to Hawkins and no longer platinum. Heather had helped her dye it a more natural, golden, honey blonde at the beginning of the summer. The silver ring that had been through her right nostril had been replaced with a thin gold ring that Billy had gotten her simply to match the small gold hoop that was in his ear now (the silver dangly earring Billy had been wearing before was now in Teddi's ear). Teddi was smiling brightly at the camera, which was a stark contrast from the cool, almost bored expression that was on Billy's face in his photo.
"Hey, Katie." she said with a smile as she passed by the front desk. Katie was sitting with her feet up on the counter and a magazine in her lap. Katie threw a wave in Teddi's direction, not bothering to look up. Heather was perched up in the lifeguard's chair, glaring down at a group of kids who were running over to the diving boards. Heather waved at her before blowing her whistle at the kids loudly.
Teddi walked over to the tiny snack bar window, smiling tentatively at the girl on the other side. Cheryl Burns had gotten a job at the pool at the beginning of the summer. Initially she had applied to be a lifeguard, but had quickly changed her mind. "You mean if someone totally disgusting starts drowning or whatever I have to like...give them mouth to mouth? Gross. No thanks." were her exact words. So Freddy had stuck her at the snack bar. She of course hated it.
Cheryl's strawberry blonde hair sat high up on her head in a ponytail. She brushed her feathered bangs out of her eyes, her eyebrows raising expectantly at Teddi. "...Coke, please." Teddi squeaked out. Cheryl was an intimidating girl, and she knew it. Sometimes Teddi was certain that Cheryl enjoyed making her nervous.
Cheryl set down the can of coke in front of Teddi, sneering at it in disgust. "I don't know how you drink that shit," she jabbed one of her long, painted nails at the "New Coke" logo. "They totally ruined it." she held her out towards Teddi.
Teddi dropped her change into Cheryl's hand. "It's not that bad...you get used to it."
Cheryl rolled her eyes. "I'd rather shove old man Myers' speedo in my mouth," she scoffed, tossing her ponytail over her shoulder. Cheryl was also the most dramatic person Teddi had ever met. Cheryl looked back at the red clock on the wall behind her, a smirk forming on her lips as she leaned forward. "Here comes lover boy," she said in a sweet, sing songy tone, nodding her head towards the locker rooms.
Teddi turned just as Billy was walking out. While Teddi enjoyed the summer time, Billy came alive in it. It brought out the Cali boy in him like flowers that bloomed with the warm weather. His sandy blonde hair had turned a few shades lighter in the sun. His skin was a deep, golden bronze. Billy had gotten a new air of confidence about him ever since he'd move out, but now it was something different. Something that Teddi wasn't the only one to notice.
Karen Wheeler and a few of the other moms showed up to the pool every day around mid afternoon for Billy's shift. They weren't very secretive about it either. Heather would climb down from the lifeguard chair and each of them would start adjusting their swimsuits and makeup while they waited for Billy to come out.
"Look at them," Cheryl scoffed. "It's so gross how they're all drooling over him. I mean, Karen has a kid his age. And like he'd want some dried up old hag anyways," she said with an eye roll. "You should go over there and like french him or something and tell that tacky bitch to back off. I mean, who the fuck wears a pearl necklace to a pool?"
Teddi couldn't help but laugh. She pulled her eyes from Billy, turning back to Cheryl. "Cheryl, do you always have to be so...blunt?" she asked, taking a sip of her coke.
Cheryl pursed her glossy lips. "I'm a leo. It's what we do," she said matter of factly. Teddi coughed on her soda, sputtering loudly. "Jesus, Larsson. Say it, don't spray it." Cheryl frowned, leaning away from Teddi.
"Sorry," Teddi cleared her throat. "Sorry...I'm gonna go. Always a pleasure chatting with you, Cheryl." she gave the blonde an awkward salute, wincing at herself as she spun around on her heel and heading over to Billy.
Billy smirked down at Teddi as he watched her approach him, pushing his sunglasses down his nose to look at her. "You stalkin' me, Larsson?" he teased. Teddi stepped up onto a bar at the bottom of the lifeguard chair, balancing carefully as she reached up to kiss Billy. She laughed when she felt his fingers slipping into the back of her cut off shorts, smacking his hand away. No doubt a show for the group of eyes that were glaring a hole into Teddi behind her.
"Aren't you a little over dressed for the pool?" he asked, his hand resting on her lower back.
"Cool your jets. I'm gonna change," she rolled her eyes. "Are you busy tomorrow?"
Billy looked at her cooly. "...Depends."
Teddi let out a huff. "Depends on what?"
"On what you're gonna ask me to do...and which bikini you're wearing under there." he was smirking again.
Teddi pulled a face, popping her hip slightly and raising an eyebrow. "Who says I'm wearing anything under this?"
Billy's smirk twitched just slightly before he looked over the top of his glasses at her again, his eyes trained on the white crop top that was covered in little daisies that Teddi was wearing before looking back at her. "...Where am I going?"
Teddi laughed. Sometimes it was just too easy. "It's El's birthday tomorrow. Hop's having a party for her at the cabin and then she and Max are sleeping over at our place." dinner at Hopper's cabin had become a regular weekly thing for Billy and Teddi. He'd started to invite them over after the fight between Billy and Tommy. Billy had of course been closed off to the idea at first. Teddi had gone to the cabin alone for about the first three weeks before she convinced him to join her.
"You want me to go to some 13 year old's birthday party?" he asked.
"She's 14 now."
"Whatever."
"Oh come on," Teddi huffed. "It'll be fun. There's cake. How can you say no to cake?"
Billy held up his hands. "I'll go. But don't expect me to play pin the tail on the donkey or whatever the hell those little dorks do at parties," he grumbled. Teddi rolled her eyes. "Speaking of birthdays...what do you wanna do for yours?"
Teddi let out a groan. Her 18th birthday was in a week and she'd been trying her damndest not to think about it. "I don't know...do we have to do anything?"
Billy shot her a look. "If I tried that with my birthday would that work?"
Teddi sighed "No…"
"What'd you used to do back home?" he asked.
Teddi thought about it. Birthdays in her family had never really been a very big deal. Her parents hadn't even celebrated their own unless you counted the fancy new purse her dad would buy her mother every year. "...Me and Hannah would drive into the city and we'd ride the Staten Island ferry back and forth for a few hours and smoke weed." she finally said.
Billy laughed. "Jesus, Larsson. As fun as that sounds, you got any other ideas?"
"Well what did you do for your 18th birthday?" she asked with an irritated sigh.
Billy smirked. "Cheryl." he said with a snort.
"Ugh. You're disgusting," she groaned, Billy chuckling at her. "As fun as that sounds, I think I'd rather just go to the movies or something. Maybe we can go to Starcourt and bring Max and El." she suggested.
Billy's smile faltered for just a moment. "Whatever you say, Birthday Girl." he said cooly.
Teddi frowned slightly, pulling away from him. "...I'm gonna go find a lounger and read for awhile. You gonna come see me after you're done up here?" she asked. Billy's smile was back as he nodded and leaned in to kiss her again as if nothing had happened. Teddi hopped down, not looking at Karen and her friends as she passed them and headed for an empty chair by the pool.
She started to wonder almost obsessively about the look on Billy's face when she suggested going to the movies as she peeled her crop top and shorts off. She knew that he was watching her strip down to her bright green bikini, but didn't turn to look at him. Had he maybe planned something different? Was it because she wanted to go with El and Max? When it came to Billy there was really no telling what was going on in his head.
Teddi let out a heavy sigh, plopping down onto the white lounger and pulling her copy of the Fellowship of the Rings out of her bag. With her sunglasses on, she allowed herself to peek back at Billy as she pretended to read. He was watching her with a sort of confused frown before his jaw set tightly and he turned away from her.
He was definitely up to something.
xxx
Teddi was sitting on the floor in front of the couch, chewing on her bottom lip as she carefully folded the bright purple wrapping paper around the stack of books she'd gotten El for her birthday. Teddi had picked them out carefully. There was the Princess Bride, Alice in Wonderland and the Last Unicorn; each bound in intricate covers with a short message that Teddi had written inside each of them.
The phone started ringing as she scrawled From Teddi and Billy on the little tag she'd stuck to the wrapping paper. "I got it," Billy called from his room. Teddi didn't pay much attention to him. She grabbed a smaller present, wrapped in the same purple paper, and set it on top of the other, larger present. "Yeah?...Oh, yeah hi," Billy threw a look over at Teddi before he turned from her, lowering his voice to speak to whoever was on the other end.
Teddi watched him with a frown. She grabbed the TV remote, muting the Starcourt commercial that was playing so she could hear a little better. "Just give me like...an hour. I'll be there. Yeah. Alright, I'll see you then." Billy hung up. He turned, going still when he met Teddi's eyes. She crossed her arms.
"Who was that?" she asked.
Billy shifted awkwardly, rubbing the back of his neck. "Nobody...uh, look Ted, I know I said I'd go to El's party…"
"You're cancelling? Billy, we were supposed to leave like ten minutes ago." she huffed. Teddi stood, scooping the gifts into her arms.
"Something came up is all. I gotta…" he shook his head. "I just gotta be somewhere, okay? El's not gonna give a shit that I'm not there." his tone was starting to get a little colder. Like Teddi was accusing him of something. It only made her more suspicious.
"You know that that's not true," she argued. While Teddi and El had grown significantly closer over the last few months, Billy had also (begrudgingly) bonded with her much to Teddi's surprise. "What's going on here? You're acting really weird. Why can't I know where you're going?"
She was trying to keep her tone light, playful. She even let out a little laugh at the end like she was teasing him. Billy's jaw clenched, and Teddi's stomach dropped. "...I gotta go. I'll see you later. Tell El I said happy birthday." he muttered, grabbing his keys and quickly walking out.
Teddi glared at the door. The Camaro's engine rumbled in the distance, slowly disappearing as Billy drove off. "Of all the nights to pull this shit…" she mumbled to herself, nearly stomping over to the kitchen counter and snatching up her keys. She spent the drive back into Hawkins going over theories to herself. Teddi found herself feeling ashamed when she wondered if maybe there was someone else.
She liked to think that if Billy was cheating on her he'd hide it better. Or maybe that was just her ego. It was Billy after all. Teddi let out a heavy sigh. It had to be something else. She just had absolutely no idea what it could be.
When she arrived at the cabin she pushed Billy from her mind. She wouldn't let this ruin the party. Teddi grabbed the presents, hopping out of the van and heading up the porch, her boots thumping against the old wood. Hopper answered when she knocked.
"Hey, kiddo," he grinned down at her, his eyes immediately looking over to the empty space beside her. "...No Billy?" he asked, his eyebrows raised.
"Something came up last minute," she explained, trying to keep her tone neutral. "It's probably for the best. I'm sure he'd complain about the cake ruining his physique or something."
Hopper chuckled and stepped aside to let Teddi in. He'd traded in his uniform for some jeans an old plaid button up. Teddi always thought he looked less intimidating in his own clothes. More like a dad that liked to tell cheesy jokes...which was exactly what Hopper was.
The kids were all already there aside from Dustin, who was off at summer camp. They were all crowded around the dinner table playing a game of Candyland. The cabin was decorated with colorful streamers, balloons and a big banner that read Happy Birthday! was hanging above the kitchen. There was a small cake sitting out on the counter waiting for it's candles. It was a soft yellow color with bright pink piping and Happy Birthday El scrawled in shaky lettering that Teddi assumed belonged to Hopper.
"Teddi!" El said, smiling brightly at her before pushing her chair back and hurrying over to the blonde. Teddi set her presents aside before wrapping her in a tight hug.
"Jeez, Ellie Bean. When'd you get so tall? I don't have to bend down to hug you anymore." she laughed. All of the kids had hit a growth spurt over the summer. Teddi no longer towered over them. She wasn't really sure when it had happened exactly. It was like one day suddenly Mike was taller than she was and she'd nearly had an existential crisis.
El let out a small laugh. "Hop says I'm not allowed to get any taller."
"He's right." Teddi muttered.
"...Where's Billy?" El asked, peering out one of the front windows as if she expected to see Billy smoking out on the porch.
Teddi winced a little at her disappointed expression. "He's not gonna be able to make it. Something came up, I guess. He told me to tell you happy birthday."
That had gotten Max's attention. The redhead looked away from the board game, looking at Teddi suspiciously. "What do you mean something came up? Did you guys break up?" she asked.
Teddi let out a sigh. "No...it's a long story. I'd rather not talk about it." she mumbled, heading over to the fridge to grab a drink. El and Max shared a knowing look. They'd agree to drop the subject. For now.
"Hey, how come we can't go to the sleepover?" Lucas asked as Teddi pulled a seat up to the game.
Max rolled her eyes. "Because it's a girl's night, genius. None of you are girls."
"That's pretty sexist of you guys." Mike argued.
Hopper scoffed loudly from his spot on the couch. "Quit while you're behind, Wheeler."
"What do you guys even do during a girl's night?" Lucas asked, looking between the three girls.
"Summon demons." Teddi said with a straight face.
Mike, Lucas and Will all shared a look. "...I'm pretty sure she's kidding." Will finally decided.
After the game of Candyland (Mike won, but Lucas had accused him of cheating) they all crowded around El to sing happy birthday and eat cake. After the presents had been opened, Teddi held up the smaller gift she had wrapped earlier, motioning to El to follow her out to the porch.
She handed the small, but long box to the teen with an almost embarrassed look. El smiled at her, making quick work of ripping the paper open. Inside the white box was quite frankly one of the tackiest necklaces Teddi had ever seen. It had a clunky, golden chain and a deep blue stone at the end of it. In the stone there was a constellation that was almost crudely carved into the stone.
"When I was little and my dad started working for the city, he took me and my mom to this state fair so he could make himself look good for his bosses. There were all these game stands, and one of them was this little pool that had these little rubber ducks in it. You got to pick three of them, and if you picked the right one you got a prize. So I begged him over and over to let me play and I ended up winning that horrible necklace," she said, her and El both laughing. "It's how I found out I was a gemini. The girl that worked at the stand was a total hippie and gave it to me when I told her my birthday. The stone is supposed to be our birthstone and then that's the gemini constellation...I don't know. I found it again after I moved in with Billy and I thought you should have it. It's ugly in kind of a cool way."
El held the necklace up, smiling up at Teddi. "I love it."
"Yeah?" Teddi asked, letting out a relieved sigh. "Good! Here," she took the necklace from El, twirling her finger to tell her to turn around and clasped it around her neck. El turned back towards Teddi, taking the small pendant between her fingers. "Perfect. Come on, we should go get Max and head out before Hop tries to kill Mike." Teddi snickered.
The two girls headed inside, El hurrying over to Max and pulling her to her room to grab their things. Hopper looked so relieved Teddi thought he might cry. He stood up from the couch, waving his hands at the door. "Alright, boys, the party's over. You don't have to go home, but you have to get the hell outta my house."
"This is totally unfair!" Mike complained. "I can't spend time with my girlfriend on her birthday because of girl's night?"
"How 'bout you complain to someone who cares, Wheeler. Let's go." Hopper said, herding him towards the door. El and Max came running back out, arms full with their bags and sleeping bags. Lucas and Will wished her happy birthday again before practically dragging Mike out to their bikes.
"Don't worry chief, I'll take good care of them," Teddi said, placing her hands on El and Max's heads. "We're gonna make crank calls and break out the ouija board."
Hopper smiled thinly at her. "Funny. You two be good, alright? No boys or ritual sacrifices," he leaned forward, hugging El and placing a kiss on her head. "Happy birthday, kid." he said, smiling down fondly at his daughter.
Once the three girls were in the van and headed back for the apartment, Max spoke up. "So...what's going on with Billy? Is he being an ass again?"
"What happened to not talking about it?" Teddi asked.
"Why not? The boys aren't here. So, what did he do? What was this thing that suddenly came up?" Max asked, leaning forward excitedly.
Teddi looked at the two girls in the rearview mirror before letting out a sigh. "...I'm not really sure yet. Someone called right before we were supposed to leave for the party and he said he had to go. And when I asked him what was going on he got all...weird."
Max and El looked at each other. "Weird how? Like weird weird, or Billy weird?"
"Billy weird. He's been acting like this all day. Like he's keeping a secret or something."
"We should find him." El said with a firm nod.
Teddi laughed. "Find him and do what? Spy on him?"
Max looked at her as if the answer was obvious. "Duh. If he's with someone else you can catch him in the act and dump his ass."
Teddi actually considered it for a moment before shaking her head. "That's insane. What about the sleepover? And how would we even find him? You want me to drive all around Hawkins all night?"
"We can still have the sleepover later," Max shook her head. El shot her best friend a brief, knowing look. Max looked back at Teddi with an unsure expression. "...El can find him."
"Oh yeah? How?"
El smiled at Teddi sheepishly. "...Long story."