A/N: Takes place the night of the events in "mirror." As always, there be smut ahead, and it's pretty kinky too. Some S&M stuff ahead, I don't like actual non-consensual stuff so I tried to make it clear they're sort of roleplaying the questionably consensual parts. Don't like, don't read.

A/N 2: I've decided instead of doing a traditional, multichapter fic that starts from the beginning and progresses linearly in time from when they meet to the end, I'm just going to do a series of smutty (with some plot) vignettes of this AU at different points in their timeline. It won't go in a linear order, but hopefully by the end, you can piece it all together and if you read it by the correct timeline order then it will be like a traditional, multichapter fic. It's just easier this way since I've already started, and if I can jump around a bit it will help me from getting bored and abandoning this fic. I will always indicate in the Author's Notes what part of the timeline the one-shots are taking place (aka before El's lost her virginity, after she's lost it, when they first meet and start to hook up, etc).

XXXXXX

When she came back to her room that night, he was already there waiting for her.

It wasn't hard, sneaking into her room. He had had plenty of experience doing that with all the girls before El. Sometimes you could sneak in a window, sometimes you sweet talked a dormmate to let you in or look the other way, once he had been caught by the prefect of one of the girls he had been fucking, so he just made her cum, and afterwards the prefect didn't mind him breaking the rules to visit anymore. In fact, she had wanted him to um, come even more after that.

El seemed startled to see him, even though he had told her that morning that he'd be paying her a visit. It seemed that she had just gotten back in from a long school day, still in the Catholic school uniform she had on when she had sucked his dick earlier, which was exactly what Mike wanted.

"Mike! Gosh, you scared me." El huffed, setting her bookbag down on her desk. "Ever heard of knocking?"

Without warning Mike grabbed her, pulling her into his lap on her squeaky single bed. "Why should I knock? It's after visiting hours, El," he hissed into her ear, easily flipping her petite little body over so that she was lying prone across his lap, her cute, juicy ass wriggling up at him. "And even if it wasn't, you're mine. That means I get to have you any time, anywhere. I don't have to knock."

El made a noise that was half a whimper and half a moan, causing Mike's cock to twitch to attention. She squirmed around in his lap some more, causing her ass to jiggle right in front of his face, the pleats of her skirt flipping up gently to flash him peeks of her creamy bare ass underneath.

"Mike…what are you doing?" El's voice sounded unsure, but she made no move to get up off his lap. It was what drove him crazy about her, the way she was so hot and cold, telling him no with her mouth and yes with her pussy. Mike was sure she did it on purpose just to make his cock hard.

"You were a really bad girl this morning, El," Mike said, slowly pushing the fabric of her skirt up to expose her perfect, round bottom. This time it was Mike's turn to let out a strangled moan when he saw that she was still wearing that slutty little thong, the one that had been soaked in her pussy juices from that morning when she had fingerfucked herself into cumming. "Oh fuck, you're still wearing it. You're such a dirty girl, aren't you? Making yourself cum in your thong and then walking around with it on all day, stained with your own pussy juice, rubbing against your little virgin hole…"

Mike pushed her skirt up all the way, not bothering to take it off this time, wanting to keep it on to see it bounce around and frame her plump ass. It made such a pretty picture, El sprawled face down across his lap, her bare ass up in the air, her skirt pushed up her ass, the white thong string disappearing in between her fat mounds, the thigh highs squeezing her parted thighs.

He gave her ass a hard slap, so hard he left a visible red handprint on the creamy flesh, watching her soft ass cheek bounce around from the force of his slap.

"Ah!" El cried out, "M-Mike! What –"

He didn't give her a chance to finish what she was going to say, giving her ass another hard slap. "You put on this thong and these thigh highs to tease me, didn't you?" Slap! "To make my cock hard," Slap! "Didn't you?" Slap! "Admit it!"

"N-no! I ran out of underwear and these were the only clean pair left –"

Slap! "Liar!"

"No!" El mewled, wriggling around in his lap like she was helpless (she wasn't, and it made Mike's dick even harder knowing she was acting like this when there was nothing keeping her from simply getting up and getting away from him). All the wriggling only made her full ass cheeks, now pink because of Mike's merciless slapping, bounce around some more, "It's true! A-and the thigh highs – I can't afford the tights the school wants us to buy. I-I had to make do with these!"

Slap! "I don't believe you," Slap! "You're just a lying, horny, dirty virgin," Slap! "Practically begging me to fuck you, aren't you?" Slap! Slap! Slap! "AREN'T YOU?"

El was making sobbing noises, her head hanging off his lap like she was totally defeated. One look at her pussy though and Mike knew the truth. The white fabric of the thong that covered her petite pussy was soaked through. She had gotten wetter and wetter each time he slapped her ass.

Roughly, he ripped the thong string aside, completely exposing her hairless pussy to him ("I like to wax," she'd told him once, blushing after he had eaten her out for the first time, "It makes me feel lighter down there.") Her pussy was slick and glistening, so ready for him.

Without warning, he pushed two fingers into the swollen little slit, crudely shoving his fingers in and out, viciously finger-fucking her virgin pussy.

"Ah! Ah! Ah!" El keened, crying out but taking it, her tight pussy clenching around his fingers, her juices getting everywhere in the frenzy of his finger-fucking, slipping down the palm of his hand.

All the while, he was staring at her plump, soft ass, squeezed by the thong string which he had violently stretched taut all the way across her left ass cheek. Her fat ass mounds bounced around wildly as he mercilessly fingerfucked her leaking pussy.

Fuck he couldn't take it anymore. He ripped her off his lap and threw her onto the bed, keeping her bent over on all fours while he took his place behind her.

"M-Mike?" El looked back at him, sounding unsure. Unconsciously, her thighs clenched.

She'd told him he could have her anywhere but her pussy. That she wanted to remain a virgin, for God, or marriage, or true love or some shit like that. Well, he wasn't interested in her pussy. At least, not tonight.

Mike spread her ass cheeks apart with his hands, staring down at her puckered pink asshole for the first time. "El, did you do what I told you to today?"

"Yes," she said without hesitation, "Yes, I only hate bananas, broth or rice, Mike. Am I a good girl?"

Mike somehow got even harder hearing her ask if she was a good girl. "No. You've been a very naughty girl. Teasing me with the slutty way you dress. I'm going to have to punish you, El."

As he said that, Mike pushed his cock head up at her soft little asshole.

El looked back at him again, and bit her lip. It was the sexiest thing Mike had ever seen, El sprawled in front of him on all fours, her ass cheeks spread wide, her pussy so wet it was leaking onto the sheets below.

"It's a good thing you did what I told you to do, though. You made your ass nice and ready for me to fuck it, because I'm gonna punish your tight little virgin asshole. You're gonna take all of my cock in it tonight for the first time."

El whined and wriggled her hips around, but didn't try to move away. Mike started to push his cock forward but he realized with sudden dismay that El didn't have any lube in her room. Not that innocent El would know she'd need lube for ass sex, but it wasn't Mike's first time at the rodeo and he knew lube would definitely help, especially for a first-timer like El. They hadn't ever needed it before now; it wasn't hard to get his good girl's virgin pussy soaking and drenched and that was all the lube they had ever needed.

Unless –

Her slick pussy was so wet again, always, always wet for him. He dipped his aching cock down into the soft folds of her pussy, sliding it across her folds, stroking across them once, twice, three times, covering it in her dripping juices. Then he brought it down on her asshole again, smearing his cock all over it, transferring her pussy juices from his cock to her puckering asshole. He repeated the action a few times, enjoying how it felt and wanting to make sure El had all the lubrication she needed to take all of his cock into her ass for the first time.

When Mike was finally satisfied with how slick and slippery El's virgin asshole had gotten, he positioned the tip of his cock at the tight opening, pushing through slowly but firmly, hitching his breath at the feeling of her asshole clenching down hard on his cock, at the visual of his cock disappearing between her fat ass cheeks, bright red from the ruthless spanking he'd given her, her thong string squeezing the side of her fat ass, her white thigh highs and green schoolgirl skirt (the same one she wore to class, to Bible study, to pray during all-school Mass) framing her ass and pussy, the skirt bouncing around as he thrusted lightly into her tight asshole.

"Ah! M-Mike!" El keened, "I-I can't…I don't…. It's big…too big, Mike, I can't take it, ah! Ah! Please!" She cried out as he stroked in shallowly.

"Do you want me to stop?" He knew this was supposed to be her punishment, but he wasn't going to force her. Her pure and innocent act made his cock so hard, but that was only because it was an act. It didn't make Mike feel good knowing he had to make someone do something they didn't want to do. He wanted her to want it, wanted her to want him, to beg and plead for it.

"I…I feel like I can't take it all, your cock is so big…" El paused, panting heavily, and then Mike felt her clench her asshole around him. "B-but…I want to. I want to take it all. I want my punishment. Give it to me Mike….your big cock...ah.." she wriggled around his cock again, trying to adjust, "K-keep going, Mike. Punish me. Fuck my tight asshole…please. Don't stop 'til you cum in my ass…"

Mike was only happy to oblige. He resumed his light thrusting, going deeper and deeper with each stroke of his cock, finally feeling her start to relax around him. Before long, he was hilting himself fully inside her soft pink asshole, his balls smacking crudely on her pussy lips as he sped up, thrusting hard and fast into her warm, tight ass, her red, swollen ass cheeks bouncing up and down with each brutal stroke of his cock.

"Yeah, take it El. Take your fucking punishment. This is what you get for always trying to get me hard. You get your virgin ass fucked. I'm fucking your own pussy juices into your tight ass. Can you feel that? Your ass has a cock in it for the first time and it's mine." He started to fuck her violently, so close to cumming, his balls coming into contact with her slippery cunt every time, hilting fully in every time. He snaked an arm around the front of her and frenziedly stroked her clit, her pussy so drenched that it made a sticky wet Slap! Slap! sound whenever his balls smacked against it. "My cock took your ass virginity and soon, I'm gonna - " Slap! "fuck" Slap! "your" Slap! "virgin" Slap! "pussy" Slap! "too! Unhhhh…" Mike let out a strangled moan as he fell forward and collapsed on El, finally losing control and releasing all of his warm, thick cum inside of her asshole. There was so much, ropes and ropes of it releasing into her freshly fucked ass that Mike thought he might never stop.

"Ah! Mike! Oh fuck! Oh fuck, ohh…." El was cumming too, he could feel her pussy lips twitching against the hand that had been mercilessly rubbing her clit. As she trembled and shuddered underneath him, Mike finally came down from his own mind-blowing orgasm. He had spurted so much cum into her that El's asshole was leaking milky white cum that spilled back onto his own cock as he pulled it out of her.

"Mike?" El asked, panting heavily, collapsing against his side on her narrow single bed. "Will you stay the night with me?"

Mike pulled her further into him and pecked a kiss on her shoulder, "Yeah." It was the nicest either one had been to the other since they'd first met, and Mike wondered at this new tender feeling that was burgeoning in his chest for her.

It was just because she'd just made him cum, hard, that was all. There was no way Mike Wheeler was actually developing feelings that didn't all belong in his cock for this girl.

No way.

Right?

XXXXXX

A/N: So I think one person guessed that it was gonna be anal sex based on his food restrictions for her (I guess we don't have a lot of bottoms in the mileven ship lol I'm kidding I actually had to google for myself to find out what bottoms usually ate before anal sex). Also, just wanted to add that this fic is supposed to be a fantasy of perfect, mindblowing kinky sex but IRL you should definitely use lube if you're gonna have anal sex (and be safe about it obvs)!

If you like and want more, leave a review! I have some free time this week so thats why I'm posting alot, but I expect to be alot busier soon. Reviews help motivate updates! Thanks!