A/N: Yes, it is OT4 time! But, WARNING, this chapter is almost entirely anticipation / teasing / build up with just a taste of the forthcoming smut at the end. In the course of writing this I found it was getting SO long that it couldn't conceivably be limited to one chapter. The anticipation and teasing is pretty fun and sexy though so I hope you still enjoy it. I've already split the chapter into two parts so the next update finishing out the scene entirely with smut (the upcoming chapter 10) will be up later tomorrow.


-Chapter 9-

The next week of Caroline's life went by in a peculiar but wonderful blur. Liz Forbes found herself magically the recipient of an all-expenses paid trip on a cruise through the Caribbean. Getting her out of town for three weeks wasn't a permanent solution
/but, it was a band-aid for the time being. Caroline just wasn't sure what she wanted to do about her mother yet. She had less than a year left before she'd be leaving for college anyway and Elijah and Klaus both seemed hell bent on making sure
/she would be sticking around on a more permanent basis.

And who would have guessed Elijah would be open to a three way and more than once?

Kol would have laughed and told her that when you lived as long as they had, everyone was up for pretty much anything as long as it had some novelty. And that kind of thinking, Caroline suspected, was why Klaus was so much more comfortable sharing
/her with Elijah than Kol. At some level it seemed like Klaus had found someone to commiserate with over how much and how desperately he cared for her. Elijah never made him angry by blatantly saying lewd or provocative things to Caroline in front
/of company because Elijah was always a gentleman. But Kol did and, apparently, Klaus was not cool with it.

Caroline didn't mind how Kol treated her, it turned her on and kept her turned on most of the time. Over her first week staying with them, they'd snuck off together several times to have sex — in Kol's room, in her new room, one time in Rebekah's
/room which enraged the woman, on their backyard patio... She knew Klaus knew because, well, anyone with hearing would know what she and Kol were up to. Klaus was obviously begrudgingly allowing it because: 1) Each time she fed from Kol she
/got stronger and 2) She clearly enjoyed what was happening.

But her intuition told her that even if Klaus could hear her being savagely spanked and moaning in return… some part of him would never be entirely comfortable with someone else hitting her and calling her a dirty bitch, even if it was consensually
/or playfully. It seemed, also, to be the kind of line Elijah knew not to cross. Frequently, when she and Kol would fuck, they could hear Klaus storming around the house and slamming doors. It always made Kol begin to fuck her a little more forcefully,
/demanding that she scream for him.

Not that, overall, the issues between Kol and Klaus weren't really weighing too heavily on her mind. Overall her life was pretty phenomenal right now. Every day after school, Bonnie came over to teach her how to hone her magic skills. She was absolutely
/out of control with her abilities right now but Bonnie was a good teacher and patient. The Salvatores hadn't been invited back yet but Elena had usually joined Bonnie on their trips and kept her bloodlust well in check while she prattled on about
/what Caroline was missing.

They both peppered her with endless questions — some of which she was more than happy to giggle over with Elena and others that she would reply to more evasively when she could still see everything making Bonnie just a touch uncomfortable. Mostly they
/asked her about what was going to happen next and Caroline would have to shrug and reply honestly: She had no clue.


As Caroline's first week after transitioning drew to a close, she found herself in search of Rebekah who, it turned out, really only attended school at her leisure and spent a lot of her time skipping.

Caroline had gone out of her way to engage the other blonde after it had been decided she'd be staying for awhile. Naturally, Rebekah had been guarded at first but ultimately she seemed to put the absurdity of the situation they found themselves in behind
/her and just began to enjoy having another girl around the house. It was Sunday today and they had made some serious plans to binge out to reality tv — knowing full well that Klaus would be stealing her during commercial breaks — but on her way to
/their living room, Caroline ran smack dab into Elijah.

"Oh!" she let out in a breathy noise of surprise, completely startled at the site of him as she always was these days, whether it was when he made an appearance in her trysts with Klaus or when he was looking over grimoires with her and recommending what
/spells to practice. Elijah was such a strong and overwhelming presence.

At the root of her nervousness was the fact that she and Elijah had still never really finished their encounter and Caroline knew it was 100% out of respect for Klaus who was clearly staking his claim on her. She may be a succubus and she may need to feed off of you for strength but she is still mine and you will have her when I say you can, seemed
/to be the prevailing alpha wolf message. Hence his continued distaste for Kol, who blatantly disregarded that message by cuing Caroline to run off with him and play dirty hide and seek with nothing more than an inviting wink.

"I'm sorry, Elijah, I didn't see you," she said, realizing that she was trembling very slightly in his arms just at the site of him. A subtle smirk confirmed that he was well aware of the kind of response his presence was eliciting. In response, his grip
/on her upper arms tightened minutely to help hold her upright.

"It's no problem at all, dear Caroline, there is no one else I'd rather have come running into me out of nowhere," he replied politely but his eyes held a bit of mischief.

She may have been getting stronger each day but the one thing the Originals would always probably have over was the advantage of their age. While Caroline was wont to barrel around the house lost in the whirlwind of her own thoughts, the Originals' senses
/were seemingly constantly on high alert. If she'd been walking distractedly enough to run into Elijah, he certainly would have been able to hear her approach and, by extension, had purposefully allowed her to run into him.

Sure enough, he seemed to glance around them quickly to assess if they were at least relatively alone before surprising her enough to make her gasp by forcefully backing her into the wall. He quickly suppressed her sharp noise of surprise by smothering
/her lips with his own and, even then, he was forced to press into hers even further to quiet her when she let out a wanton moan.

Elijah broke apart just long enough to growl hotly into her ear, "I haven't had you in days."

Caroline's automatic assumption was that he was talking about feeding from her, which he only did when Klaus allowed it during à ménage a trois, the last of which had been over two days , she swept her hair to one side and turned her head away slightly,
/offering for him to drink.

"Please, have a taste," she said to him, not even attempting to hide the pure want in her tone.

Elijah couldn't help himself one long slow inhale of her sweet scent but it quickly dissolved into teasing kisses that worked their way down the side of her neck. When he heard her breathing begin to rapidly hitch he pulled his lips away and looked at
/her straight on.

"You think I wish to feed from you?" Elijah asked, sounding almost confused. "While I admit that your blood is exquisite beyond anything I've ever encountered, I feel no need to indulge in it every day. No, what I wish to do is to have you all to myself
/again… to learn you with the intimacy you deserve."

Caroline shuddered harshly beneath him, still pressed against the wall. He used her distraction as an opportunity to grasp her beneath her thighs, suddenly hoisting her legs up to wrap around his torso as he held her against the wall. Caroline initiated
/the kiss this time, wanting to taste nothing but Elijah and praying that they wouldn't be interrupted. She'd been waiting for this… ever since Klaus's phone call had interrupted their only one on one time thus far.

Oh god, she thought in a haze of want when she felt him harden against her already quivering center. Caroline could have cared less where Klaus was in that moment. She needed Elijah to flash them both up to his bedroom and lick at her folds again
/until she was uncontrollably dripping and begging for him to take her. Almost as if sensing her thoughts, Elijah ground his hips into her core with such delicate finesse that the firmness of his black leather belt was pressing harshly into her clit
/through the flimsy fabric of her panties.

The shockwave of pleasure that coursed through her at the sensation had Caroline biting down on Elijah's lower lip, lapping at the coppery taste of his blood with such abandon she might as well have still been a vampire, and Elijah moaned back into her.

The sound of a soft chuckle broke them apart immediately. Elijah was still holding her up but no longer kissing her. Luckily, grinning at them cheekily from the opposite wall was not Klaus, just Kol.

"Don't stop on my account," Kol began, holding up a fake apologetic hand. "I like to watch."

Elijah rolled his eyes with an annoyed scoff and proceeded to lower Caroline gently back onto her feet, much to her disappointment.

"Now, come on 'Lijah!" Kol started chastising. "It's not like I'm going to go run and tell Nik! I'm on his bad side enough as it is. No need to be shy about indulging in front of me."

Elijah was steadfastly ignoring Kol. Instead he kept looking at Caroline, finally simply pressing a respectful and gentlemanly kiss to her cheek when she wanted so much more from him.

"I'm sorry Caroline," he said to her, "This isn't how I want this to happen."

And on that very serious note, he had turned away from her and promptly walked off in the other direction. Caroline looked helplessly after him and Kol just looked back and forth between the two of them with confusion.

"Sorry, darling," Kol said next, flashing forward to press an agonizingly short but hot kiss to her lips. "But, I think I'd better to go see what's bothering him. You have a movie date with Rebekah, don't you?"

An then he had sped past her faster than she could see, leaving Caroline all alone and extremely hot and bothered in the hallway.


Kol felt distinctly left out of some brotherly bonding. Niklaus and Elijah had seemed to take relatively well — shockingly well, given the Tatia and Katherine fiascoes over the years — to a new polyamorous lifestyle. Perhaps the third time's a charm, Kol
/supposed, guessing that both his brothers were finally content to work out a system where they could both actually find happiness rather than stabbing each other in the back over a woman every few hundred years or so. Caroline was the kind of woman
/who could inspire you to do that, too, no doubt.

However, when it came to his involvement with Caroline, his two elder brothers seemed hell bent on ignoring the situation as much as possible. They weren't actively trying to stop anything — they both knew the benefits of Caroline's involvement
/with as many of the four members of their family that contributed to her bloodline as possible. Niklaus especially wanted that additional power for Caroline, so obsessed was he with protecting her for eternity. It would only be a matter of time before
/he started trying to tag in Bekah, at least once.

Nevertheless, despite the extra strength Caroline got from feeding from Kol as well, neither Niklaus nor Elijah seemed willing to acknowledge he was even with Caroline… up to a certain point anyway. The closest he'd come so far was when Nik had
/initially requested he attempt to "feed" Caroline, even then unwilling to acknowledge what he was truly asking for. Nik had needed him to fuck his girl.

It appeared that the truce between Elijah and Nik over Caroline had, at least in part, come from both of their feelings of guilt in their involvement of creating succubi in the first place… Feeling like, at the root of everything, it was they who
/had changed Caroline's basic nature. And that new basic nature included an attachment to multiple partners as well as a literal need for both of them. Kol didn't really feel guilty, especially not if the whole scheme had ultimately bought him
/the company of a tasty little treat like Caroline for eternity.

But, if Nik and Elijah were going to agree to share Caroline with each other for her sake, it seemed hypocritical to exclude Kol… particularly when Caroline herself was no longer shy about how much she wanted the youngest brother. Kol felt confident that
/he'd firmly embedded himself into her memory and it was probably killing her that he'd still never let himself cum with her. At this point it was becoming a game, a form of devious sexual torture to see how long she'd hold out before
/she outright begged him to cum all over her.

That was what Kol was really holding out for.

Okay, so maybe it was also that kind of attitude that kept Nik and Elijah loath to share with him. He got it. He was intimidating competition.

Nevertheless, Kol knew they'd both had her at the same time on at least two or three occasions. Yet, they still made a point to ignore everything going on when Kol began to initiate things with Caroline in front of them. He was getting fed up with it.

Though, he did have to be honest: Kol's concern over the situation only partially had to do with feeling slighted. Truly, Kol could have cared less how anyone responded to his fucking Caroline as long as they didn't try to stop it from happening. No,
/Kol was pretty much only interested in initiating something with his brothers because he knew Caroline wanted it. And very badly, at that.

One thing Kol felt he had a true knack for — prided himself on really — was getting the most tightly wound woman to admit to the most obscene and sexy things while he was pleasing her. Caroline — everyone knew — was beyond a control freak
/and now Kol had seen flashes of her insecurities as well. But, Caroline had a noticeably profound reaction to his suggestion of a fourway with himself, Nik, and Elijah. The husky moan she'd let out when he'd said that was permanently embedded into
/his memory.

Well, Kol wasn't above trying anything once… or more than once, if the first time was just mediocre. Plus, the scenario seemed truly ripe for role-playing — though he kind of wanted to ease into those games with Caroline himself first. Either
/way, if they all pleasured her he couldn't see how it would be a bad experience. Nik and 'Lijah would forget he was even there, they'd be so focused on their blonde beauty.

Or he could try to talk them into a game they hadn't played together in a very long time. As children, well before their lives had taken a supernatural turn, they used to play together in their village. As young boys were wont to do, they
/often decided to pick on a young girl, chasing her through the forest together, delighting in her shrieks, half in fun and half in real trepidation. That young they never quite knew what to do when they caught the girls so the game always dissolved
/into an endless chase.

When they got a bit older, the game got more serious. Catching a blushing young woman could result in gentle wrestling, teasing and pinching, or holding her down to ruthlessly tickle her. It was all just an excuse to start experimenting with girls: feel
/their soft curves, caress a breast for the first time in innocent passing, learn how to touch girls, understand the changes in a woman's body when she was no longer a girl. It was thrilling and fun and, well, frankly women had always loved them.

Of course, eventually, one of these interactions ended up with Elijah — naturally, as the eldest — making out with a girl for the very first time, well before Tatia even. That had been the abrupt end to their games. Becoming young men of the village,
/they traded their games for work and time actually wooing women.

They hadn't started the games again until they were turned. And by then they weren't playing anymore. Then, they were hunting.

Kol felt confident they could devise something that combined elements of the hunt and the game that Caroline would enjoy very much. That alone should be enough to persuade his brothers into joining, right?

Right then, Elijah looked up from where Kol had followed him after stumbling upon his little interlude with Carolinein the hall. Kol attempted to catch his eye and engage him, wanting to take him outside to talk. Unfortunately, Elijah blankly ignored
/him and turned away.

"Elijah, really, it's one thing from Nik but you too?" Kol asked in frustration.

Elijah spoke to him without turning around. "Niklaus would not want us discussing Caroline's urges without himself present, you know that very well, Kol. How much more do you plan to push him?" he returned calmly.

Kol sneered, "Please, you know damn well the only things Klaus gives a fuck about are keeping Caroline and himself safe and making sure that her pretty little pussy is throbbing in pleasure a minimum of 23 out of the 24 hours in a day."

Elijah did snap around to meet his eye then, his arm stretching out at lightning speed to wrap a tight grip around Kol's neck. Elijah lifted him several feet off the ground and Kol snickered at his reaction. Really, he could be just as bad as Nik sometimes. They were both so easy.

"Come on Elijah, you know Caroline won't be happy with you if you hurt me," Kol goaded and Elijah's grip loosened just enough to drop him back down to the ground.

And that was when Kol figured it out.

Kol wasn't sure what he felt for Caroline beyond raw attraction and a definite slowly burgeoning friendship. She amused him. He liked her. But Niklaus and Elijah? They adored Caroline, would do anything for her. Sure, they would obviously expect
/him to behave the same as long as Caroline was a part of the family but, Kol suspected it just sort of bothered both of them that he wasn't quite as unstoppably and painfully devoted to Caroline as they were.

It almost made him want to laugh. Couldn't they just be thankful that he made Caroline happier and stronger without being any sort of threat to their 'epic' love triangle? He was tired of being excluded by everyone except Carolineand Rebekah.
/Kol just had to get them to understand how much she wanted them all to have her.

And when Kol had stumbled upon Elijah going at Caroline in the hall he knew he'd found his opportunity. Elijah had always been the most reasonable of his siblings, after all. Perhaps he was the best person to start with anyway.

"Caroline may not want either Niklaus or myself to hurt you but you should be far more well aware than she what our limits are," Elijah told him calmly as Kol rubbed at his neck in exaggerated annoyance. "I don't know how many more times I can
/warn you to stop pushing your luck."

"Look, Elijah, hear me out okay?" Kol said, finally growing serious and demonstrating so by holding up his hands in concession, "I have something to discuss concerning Caroline that I think you'll want to give sufficient consideration..."

Well, Elijah was nothing if not pragmatic.

When they'd finished talking, they went to find Niklaus.


The next morning, Klaus found Caroline sitting in the backyard having breakfast with Kol and Elijah when he walked out onto the patio and greeted her warmly. The trio was sitting together in quiet but comfortable stillness — a rare state to catch Kol
/in. Klaus leaned down to kiss her, liking an errant drop of jelly off the corner of her lip as he did so, making her blush. He stood back up.

"Good morning, my love," he said pleasantly.

"It would have been a better morning if I'd woken up with you," she replied in that sensual succubus tone she was learning to master and he was coming to love and crave more and more each day.

"I thought you might want to sleep in this morning," Klaus lied, knowing very well that he'd been busy orchestrating other final plans with her two dining companions.

"I can't sleep in when I'm alone anymore," she replied with a nonplussed shrug. "Sit with us!"

"Actually, love, I have a surprise for you."

"A surprise?" Caroline brightened, looking a little confused, "What for?"

"Does there need to be a reason for surprises?" he asked, cocking his head at her with a devious grin. She couldn't help but beam back at him when she shook her head.

"Exactly," Klaus replied easily before offering one hand to help her stand from her chair and the other to gesture out onto the forest that lay a few dozen meters beyond their backyard patio. "Now, would you kindly accompany me to where your surprise
/awaits?"

Caroline took his hand but not before quizzically raising an eyebrow at the direction he was leading her. Into the woods? She looked back to Kol and Elijah first.

"Do either of you know anything about this?" she asked.

Elijah, his face a portrait of stoicism, betrayed nothing as he looked back up towards her from his newspaper and said, "I'm afraid not."

"Even if he did, he wouldn't tell you," Kol replied with a laugh. "I know Elijah seems like no fun but even he has the sense not to ruin a good surprise."

Caroline cocked her head suspiciously at Kol, about to ask — So does that mean you know something? But Kol was already waving her off with a look that suggested he wouldn't be telling her anything.

Klaus shook his head in amusement when Caroline finally began to follow him away from the patio, her eyes still focused on his two brothers dubiously. He lifted her hand to kiss her skin softly, causing her to redirect her attention back onto him as they
/strolled through the backyard of the estate.

"Why so nervous, love?" Klaus asked her. "Do you really think I'd plan any sort of surprise for you that you wouldn't like?"

"Of course not," she replied, her features softening instantly, "I'm just a control freak, you know that…"

"One of my favorite qualities about you, actually," he answered, his tone teasing. When she scoffed in slight disbelief at that he pulled her into his side while they walked to press a kiss to her temple. "It's true, sweetheart. Because I love everything
/about you."

"You're such a sap…" Caroline laughed in response, jokingly slapping him on the chest while her heart swelled to the point of bursting with happiness. She'd never had a boyfriend who was so constantly communicative with her about his feelings but she
/really liked it. After a few more moments though, she looked up to him to say, "Why are we going into the woods, though?"

He smiled back down at her mysteriously and silently in response, as if to say, You'll see.


Truth be told, when Elijah and Kol had come to find Klaus the day before with this scheme he was simultaneously intrigued and immediately closed off to the idea. Irritating him additionally was the fact that, apparently, Kol an Elijah had spoken
/with each other already without him. Shouldn't he have been the first person consulted over ideas concerning any and all of Caroline's fantasies, desires, dreams and, really, anything else?

At first, it seemed like Kol was spouting utter nonsense — going on and on about 'Remember when we were children?" and "All those pretty girls we used to play with in the village." Klaus was not easily sold on Kol's idea.

Finally, though, Elijah had said something to seal the deal.

"Caroline wants to, Niklaus," he had said earlier. "Kol tells me that she fantasizes about it regularly."

It didn't take any further convincing.

And now, here they were, less than a day later, walking in comfortable silence through the woods surrounding Mystic Falls. Caroline had finally relaxed, enjoying the feel of Klaus's arm around her and basking in the feel of the sun on her skin when it
/peeked through the canopy of trees. Klaus couldn't help but smirk knowing that, by this point, Kol an Elijah would both be well on their way behind them and Caroline was none the wiser about what was in store for her.

Finally they began to approach a pretty clearing and Caroline could hear the sound of rushing water. She knew where they were, out by one of the waterfalls in the woods. She swam here every summer with Bonnie and Elena.

"This is one of my favorite places," she told Klaus as they stepped up to the water cascading down from a rocky ledge dozens of feet above them.

"I had a feeling it might be," Klaus replied, releasing her from the hold while she gazed at the water. "Now wait right here, I'll be right back. I'll only be a few minutes."

"Okay," she answered with more enthusiasm now that he'd brought her here though she still had no clue what he could possibly have planned.

He stepped away from her and made his way further back into the woods and Caroline took a seat on the grass to admire the falls as she waited for him.

...and waited for him.

Then waited some more for him.

Caroline couldn't help that she was starting to get impatient. She reached to her pocket but cursed when she realized she left her phone. There was nothing than worse than being impatient and having to estimate how much time had passed. She guessed
/it was a little over ten minutes.

She waited about five more before finally standing to stalk around the perimeter of the water, craning her neck to peek through the trees to try and catch a glimpse of Klaus. Then she tried standing completely still, straining her ears to be in tune with
/the sounds of the forest around her but she couldn't hear him either. Succubi had heightened senses just like vampires so she should have been able to pick up the sound of him, right?

"Klaus?" Caroline called out with trepidation. She tried several more spots out around the falls, pacing further and further into the forest each time she called for him. But she continued to get no response.

Okay, this is getting a little irritating, Caroline thought, smothering the real fears plaguing her mind — This is getting a little creepy.

Just as she had the thought, Caroline realized how far off she'd wandered from the falls. If Klaus was still coming back, she needed to wait for him. Either that or go back home. She decided to give him another ten minutes and began to walk back in the
/direction of the water.

As she turned around, she finally heard something and it made her stop dead in her tracks to be silent and listen. It had been the faintest of rustlings and, though Caroline logically knew she had very little to be afraid of in this world anymore but,
/she couldn't help the innate rush of adrenaline that hit her in a wave of paranoia. Her eyes darted around, searching for the source of the sound.

"Klaus?" she finally called out again, much more hesitantly this time.

When a pair of strong arms suddenly locked around her to pin her arms to her sides from behind, Caroline couldn't help the short surprised shriek that left her lips. Her initial instinct was to smash her heel into the foot of the person behind her but
/the sound of her surprise attacker's voice stopped her. It wasn't Klaus.

"Run…" Kol whispered and released Caroline from his hold.

She didn't need to be told twice. The moment she was free of his arms she sped off at twice the speed she'd been able to achieve as a vampire. What the fuck kind of game was this? And where the hell had Kol even come from? Where was
/Klaus?

The surprise of the situation she found herself in was ruling Caroline's logic in the moment. The more pragmatic half of her instinct knew she wasn't in any danger. That didn't change the fact that the Originals would probably always scare her
/a little bit... particularly when she didn't know what they were up to.

A little scared or not, either way, Caroline became distinctly aware as she ran that she was becoming aroused. And the scent of that would do nothing to aid in her sprint away from Kol. Not that you don't want to be caught.

That thought sent a thrum of hot desire pulsing through her pussy so intense that she had to pause in her sprint and lean against a tree with a breathless gasp, eyes closed to calm herself. The urge to just stop running and slip her fingers down beneath
/the waist of her jeans was very tempting.

And, of course, her brief fantasy of indulging herself was cut short by the sound of determined footsteps slowly approaching her. Caroline's eyes flashed open to find none other than Elijah approaching her. He'd taken off the suit jacket and tie he'd
/been wearing at breakfast and was now just in his black dress pants and his crisp white shirt, buttons undone enough to reveal the top of his chest with the sleeves rolled up to his elbows, showing off his sculpted forearms. When she shuddered at
/the sight of him, she was almost positive that it was visibly so.

Sure enough, she caught the trace of one of his rare smirks before it disappeared and his eyes hardened on her as he stalked forward.

"Now, now Miss. Forbes," he began, making Caroline squirm again. He hadn't called her Miss Forbes since her first day there and she'd forgotten how sexy he could make it sound. "Didn't my brother tell you to run? What are you doing just standing
/here? Shaking with arousal, I might add..."

With that, she could see the veins begin to darken beneath Elijah's eyes and his long fangs begin to descend. Caroline felt herself become wet at the sight. But, she'd never seen Elijah's eyes filled with such dark promise before, flashing with
/what she knew was just a taste of the danger he was capable of against the right people. She was beginning to figure out what was going on now. They were playing with her. And if she wanted to have any fun too, they were going to make her
/follow their rules.

She flashed off again, away from both Elijah and where she thought Kol was behind her. Caroline was running faster than she ever had but, now, a laugh was threatening to burst from her throat too. Alright, if they wanted to chase her, she could make that happen.

But as quickly as Caroline had worked out their game, Caroline remembered — Klaus. Was he in on this too? He had to be. Why else take her out to the woods only to abruptly…

"Oof!" Caroline let out a shocked little groan when someone tackled her to the ground out of nowhere.

Their gazes locked and Caroline was assaulted by the beautiful and now easily familiar sparkle of Klaus's golden hybrid eyes. He was pinning her to the ground with his full weight, his core grinding purposefully into hers so she could feel how hard he
/was. Her back arched upwards in response an Caroline heard herself release an unbidden moan.

"Really, love, you're making it much too easy for us to find you," Klaus's honeyed voice purred out as he dipped his head down so he could press his lips to her jaw as he spoke. "Not only can we hear you from a mile away, the scent of your arousal is all over this
/forest."

"Klaus, what's going on?" she asked, panting hard at the feel of him on top of her, his hips still steadily working against her own.

He chuckled darkly. "Sweetheart, you know what's going on," he purred back, "Do you like your surprise?"

Caroline's breath caught in her throat when she gasped this time, Klaus confirming her suspicions about the game they'd started... something she'd only thought about in her fantasies and only ever admitted to Kol. Was she sure she could handle this in
/real life, though? Feeding from two people at once was intense enough as it was; it left her feeling high and almost bursting with energy. And, as a new witch still very much not in control of her powers, having so much energy and emotion
/flooding her at once usually had… unexpected results, to put it lightly.

Not to mention… how could she even… with all three of them?

Despite her reservations, Klaus could see the lust in her gaze as Caroline bit her lip in a fruitless attempt to keep another strangle moan at bay. Oh, Kol had been right. Caroline had thought about this before.

"I suppose that's a yes then," he said, slyly. "Although I must say I'm a little disappointed in how little of a chase you gave us. I think I hear the others approaching now…"

"Cut me some slack, I'd say I'm just a little outnumbered," she growled back, feeling a little more confident as she began to devise a plan. "Besides, you all have the added benefit that I want to be caught."

An on that note, she pushed herself forward just enough to kiss him harshly, taking his lower lip between her teeth and nipping at him hard enough to make him bleed. This time Klaus was the one to lose his composure when he snarled in response to her
/cheeky action before melting into her kiss. Once Caroline was sure he was distracted, feeling his body relax slightly in how harshly he was pinning her, she began to feed.

She pulled only a little of his energy and very slowly, so that he wouldn't notice what she was doing. When she'd had enough to give herself a bit of a boost, Caroline focused on her energy and pushed Klaus off of her — half with the full force of her
/heightened succubus strength and half with a powerful jolt of magic that sent Klaus flying backwards off of her.

As she flashed off again, speeding away, sure heard the distinct delighted laughter of Kol as he arrived to the scene and stopped to help Klaus.

"Well, I suppose that's why you never tell your succubus lover you're disappointed in her," he goaded.

Klaus merely growled in response, dusting himself off a bit before speeding after her with Kol taking his lead and circling around to find Caroline from the opposite side. If Klaus had thought he was aroused before, even he was stunned by the intensity
/of his need to have Caroline now. Something about the magic she had just used on him… the powerful spell that had hit him like a stun beam had sent a wave of pleasure coursing through him, one that felt distinctly like it was being projected directly
/from Caroline herself.

Just as Caroline thought she had given herself a fair amount of space further into the forest, something caught her attention in her peripheral vision as she ran. Less than a hundred yards away, running parallel to her and matching her speed beat for
/beat, was Elijah. However, while she was running so hard and fast it felt like her legs might give out any second — even with the energy from her quick feeding — Elijah looked like he might as well have been casually jogging. And fuck if he
/didn't look sexy doing it.

Catching his eyes through the trees, she could see his vampire features were still prominent as he helped hunt for her. The raw power he exuded, as well as how in control of it he was, almost was enough to send her running straight to him. God, yes, their game was fun but she did just want to be caught. Caroline
/fought that instinct though and instead, she banked off sharply to her left when she saw a gap in the trees.

But with each passing second, she could hear them all around her. They were being louder now, perhaps either for her benefit to keep the chase going or to work up the nervousness and excitement dancing inside of her. Or maybe they were just become more
/frenzied in their pursuit. Either way, each snap of a twig or rustling of branches she heard had her darting in a new direction.

It was the rushing of water that cued Caroline into the fact that they'd come full circle and she was approaching the same waterfall and shallow pond that Klaus had brought her two less than an hour ago. She stopped running abruptly when she got to the
/water, her eyes flashing in every direction looking for her next escape route.

Her heart thudded in her chest wildly when she saw Kol, as casual as could be, leaning against a tree not too far off to her left. She whipped her head around to her right only to visibly jump backwards a foot or so when she found Klaus stalking up to
/her slowly on that side, his eyes still golden and his double fangs out. Making a 180 from the waterfall, she tried to dash off behind her into the woods but, of course, that was exactly where Elijah was waiting for her. The moment she started her
/sprint, he had her trapped in his arms.

"You performed admirably Caroline but, in the end, you still lost," Elijah whispered lowly into her ear before allowing his lips to ghost over her skin just enough to make her break out into goosebumps. "Now it's time to face your… hmm, punishment or
/reward? We'll have to consult the others. If you're very lucky, you'll get both."

"I didn't even know what the rules to this game were," Caroline argued back an making Elijah chuckle almost patronizingly.

"Sweet girl, there were never any rules," he said, placing a gentle but extremely chaste kiss on her lips.

Elijah spun her around so her back was briefly pressed into his chest before he grabbed her arms and locked them behind her back with one hand. The move forced her shoulders to strain together, making her arch her back enough that her heaving breasts
/were prominently pushing forwards beneath her top as Elijah led her back towards the water where Klaus and Kol were waiting. Kol's vampire features were out now as well but his eyes displayed nothing more than amusement and lust.

"Oh darling, you were so much fun," Kol drawled first, his eyes tracing over her form in a blatant eyefuck that only served to make her wetter. Klaus was just approaching her slowly, taking in her every reaction to what was happening.

"Well, Niklaus? Kol? What do you think? How did Miss Forbes perform?" Elijah asked.

"It was a fair chase," Kol said first. "She held out longer than I would have expected but… I did tell you she loves to be chased."

Oh fucking hell, Kol was going to dirty talk her right here in front of other people — in front of Klaus and Elijah no less. Kol's teasing, obscenities, and demands had her a blushing and embarrassed mess even when they were in private. Sure,
/she secretly loved it, craved the dominance that came from a partner who didn't honestly give a damn how comfortable you were as long as you were cumming like a freight train. And, if anything, Kol would likely be more ruthless in his taunting
/now, if only for the sake of outdoing his brothers.

"I don't know," Klaus chimed in next, both of them less than a foot from her now, arms still tightly pinned behind her back by Elijah's strong grip while she tried to ignore his intoxicating musk and focus on what was happening. "I rather thought that
/was what made it too easy. Her scent was so easy to follow… so sweet and inviting."

"I do agree with you there, Niklaus," Elijah's deep voice rang out behind her, his breath still teasing the skin of her neck. "I don't even have the same tracking abilities you do as a wolf but it was entirely too simple to follow her trail."

Klaus approached her first, reaching out to trail his fingers softly along her cheek and jaw, then down her neck to her clavicle, before gently skimming across the top of her cleavage.

"I guess your reward will just have to wait for later then," Klaus purred out and, in one decisive motion, ripped Caroline's shirt open from the neck to the waist. As it split uselessly down the middle, it hung limp from her shoulders, unable to fall
/to the ground while Elijah still held her arms. She resisted the urge to gasp at the suddenness of the move, unwilling to give them any further reason to look more smug over the situation than they already did.

But then Kol came as close to her as Klaus and suddenly her entire personal space was being utterly dominated by the three of them, all staring down at her hungrily.

"Are you going to unwrap our pretty little present all by yourself, Niklaus?" Kol asked, his tone scolding.

Klaus made eye contact only with Caroline as he smiled easily and gestured towards her, "Be my guest."

Kol didn't need to be invited twice. Just as roughly he split open the thin band of fabric, looping together the cups of her bra, allowing her breasts to pop out and bare her already fully peaked rosy nipples.

"Mmm, so flushed already?" Elijah asked, murmuring almost reverently into her ear while his free hand came around to her front to push the straps of her now broken bra further down her shoulders with her shirt so that the torn clothing was now
/hanging loosely off of the wrists that he still kept bound.

They started so slowly it was torture — the three of them leaning into her so their lips were only centimeters from her skin as they just breathed her in. Occasionally she'd feel the calloused pads of someone's — she couldn't tell who, really — fingers
/trace over the sensitive skin of her torso, teasing ever closer to her breasts but never giving in to what she needed.

"Please…" she finally pleaded, turned on by her own whimpered tone. They all kept telling her that as she became more in tune with her succubus nature, she'd find herself becoming more confident and dominant about what she wanted sexually. But,
/so far, all Caroline found was that she was becoming more and more aroused by be dominated each time they fucked her that way.

"Please what?" Klaus and Elijah both asked in exact synchronization, very familiar with how this routine started by now. It made Kol burst out laughing heartily.

"Are you two fucking serious?" he asked them, still laughing. "She doesn't want you to care what she wants. She wants you to figure it out and then make her say it."

That wasn't always true. Sometimes she wanted Klaus to sweetly make love to her or for both Elijah and Klaus to worship her however she pleased… but, right now, Kol was right. With the three of them surrounding her after chasing her through the
/woods, she wanted to be dominated.

She couldn't see Elijah while he was still holding her from behind but she saw a brief flash of annoyance cross Klaus's face, probably exchanging the glance with Elijah. He masked it quickly, though, obviously not wanting to ruin whatever mood they were
/cultivating here.

Kol must have seen it too, though because, after huffing in annoyance, he redirected his glare harshly onto her, "Caroline, tell them."

Caroline bit her lip in response, distractedly looking back and forth between Klaus and Kol, wondering what she should say. Kol didn't give her much time to decide, though, when he reached out to harshly pinch one of her aching nipples. She had been so desperate
/for someone to touch them — and Kol obviously knew it — that the sting of his rough touch barely even registered. Instead, her hips inadvertently jerked forward with a violence so severe that Elijah almost lost his hold on her. Elijah quickly locked
/onto her tighter and she released a long moan at the feeling of being further restricted.

When her eyes opened after her drawn out sound of agonized want, she found Klaus starring daggers at Kol. She decided to save Kol the trouble and at least display that she was totally fine with how Kol chose to tease her.

"Kol, again, please do that again!" Caroline hissed out, her hips still bucking forward uncontrollably, trying to make contact with something. Kol just laughed at her.

But her pained plea obviously elicited some reaction within Klaus because he was no longer focused angrily on Kol. Instead he lowered his head to her opposite breast and bit her her nipple without any further warming up. She couldn't help it; Caroline
/let out an identical moan and jerked her hips forward again.

This time, instead of exchanging any uncomfortable glances, they were all just smirking at one another. It simultaneously made Caroline's core start to clench in anticipation and also worry. Exactly how much were they planning to tease her? She
/didn't have to wait long to find out.

Klaus and Kol both took up space on opposite sides of her before leaning down to each capture one of her nipples in their mouths. The sensation of both of them made Caroline cry out more sharply than she thought she ever had before. Where Kol was harsh;
/bruising; and unforgiving, Klaus was soft; barely there; and tantalizing. Caroline's subsequent series of pants in response were interlaced with short cries of pleasure.

And then she felt one of Elijah's hands slip around to her front. First, he undid the clasp of her jeans. Then he slid his long an tapered fingers beneath both the fabric of her jeans and her panties. But instead of touching her, Elijah merely
/cupped her gently, barely pressing into her skin at all.

Caroline violently shuddered in response, desperately attempting to grind herself more forcefully into his hand. But, between the three of them holding her, she was completely immobile. She couldn't do a damn thing to relieve herself.

How long, exactly, did they plan to torment her without relief?


Guys, I'm sorry I've been AWOL for awhile now but, I've been having some bad personal problems and have really been focusing on getting my shit together. But, I think I'm in the process of accomplishing that so hopefully this won't happen again. Fingers crossed!

So, why does Klaus have more of an issue sharing with Kol than Elijah? I dunno, essentially just cause Elijah is noble and polite as hell and learned from their mistakes with Tatia. And Kol, you know, has always basically been kind of a little shit. I realize this chapter was a lot of buildup without any conclusion but, as I mentioned, the next chapter will be almost entirely straight up smut. I really thought this fourway deserved some sufficient buildup.

Second half of this coming out soon, particularly if I get some motivating reviews! ;)