-Chapter 10-

She quickly found herself on the brink of orgasm but Elijah was steadfastly refusing to do anything but barely touch her beneath her panties. In desperation, Caroline tried to squeeze her legs together to find some relief and effectively trap his hand between her thighs but Elijah stopped her by nudging his knee between her legs to keep them parted. It wasn't a foolproof plan though because it allowed Caroline to grind herself into him, incidentally pressing her ass into his lap where she could feel he was already hard.

The move made him swear under his breath but clearly loud enough for Kol to hear because Caroline felt him smirk against the breast that he was still skillfully taunting with his tongue and teeth. Glancing down to focus in on both Klaus and Kol worshipping her, the sight was so erotic she felt sure she was going to cum just from watching them. When Klaus's eyes flicked upward to meet hers, he looked so goddamn smug that Caroline knew he was well aware what was about to happen.

She came. Her walls spasmed in ecstasy around nothing but still spilled her juices all over Elijah's hand and her panties.

"Oh fuck!" she cried out as she came uncontrollably, her eyes innately squeezing shut as she rode out her pleasure and began to pull energy from someone… she wasn't exactly sure who but it felt like Klaus.

Somewhere in the middle of the ebbing waves of pleasure, she felt both Kol and Klaus stand back up and take a step away from her. Elijah was still holding her captive but he removed his hand from her panties and she heard him lick the taste of her from his hand.

"I don't remember anyone telling her she could do that, do you Niklaus? 'Lijah?" she heard Kol ask. She opened her eyes, now relying on Elijah to hold her upright.

"Which?" Klaus asked in return. "Feed or cum? Ah, well, it doesn't matter. No one gave you permission for either, sweetheart."

"Elijah said there were no rules…" she shot back.

The three of them just laughed at her.

"That was misleading, Elijah," Kol reprimanded.

"Yes, I suppose it was," Elijah chuckled behind her.

"She can make it up to us…" Klaus drawled and suddenly he kneeling in front of her, looking up at her with such lust and adoration that she thought maybe she was about to catch a break and he was going to give her what she needed.

No such luck, though. He simply proceeded to finish undress her. He peeled off one of her boots and then the other before tossing them carelessly away. Her jeans, already undone by Elijah, were slid off along with her panties, and thrown aside as well. Kol caught her panties in the air, though, looking at how wet they'd gotten when she came and quirked an amused eyebrow at her in response before dropping them.

But once she was naked in front of them, Klaus stood back up and began undoing the clasp of his belt.

"Get on your hands and knees, love," he demanded.

Immediately, the hold Elijah had on her released and she didn't even have an option but to drop. Well if this was supposed to be some sort of punishment for cumming, Caroline was on board. She loved sucking Klaus off but it was something he rarely permitted her to do since he was far more concerned with pleasing her.

They were apparently not even allowing her the luxury of seeing any of them unclothed further either, though, because Klaus only opened his pants enough to allow his erect cock to burst forth.

She teased him first, relishing in the power of being able to give him a taste of his own medicine. He growled as she traced her tongue up and down his velvety length before sucking just the tip of his head between her lips.

"No, Caroline," she heard Elijah's voice scold from behind her. She understood what he meant without further clarification. She wasn't allowed to do any teasing of her own.

Not that Klaus had been prepared to let her; without warning he pushed his entire length into her mouth, hitting the back of her throat. Caroline only gagged for a second, the sensation of her throat sliding over him, eliciting a long groan from Klaus. She was eager though and quickly adjusted to begin sucking him.

"Yes," Klaus hissed, guiding her head softly. "God your mouth is divine…"

Behind her, she heard another belt being undone and she quivered, ready to finally be fucked.

Instead, she let out a groan of surprise while she sucked Klaus when she felt the distinct sensation of firm leather teasing over the skin of her ass, making her skin break out into intense goosebumps. The sensation disappeared, just for a moment, only to be replaced by a sudden but brief sharp stinging and the resounding clap of leather on skin. Hell, he was using a belt.

Still in front of her, she heard Kol laugh loudly, pleased with her response.

"Oh, that's going to be difficult for her Elijah," he said. "She loves that."

So, it wasn't Kol spanking her but Elijah? The image of him standing behind her and doing this, something she never would have guessed he would be into, somehow thrilled Caroline even more than when Kol did it to her. Although knowing Kol was overseeing the whole scene and taunting her as usual, brought out an unabashedly exhibitionist side of her she hadn't known she had.

When Elijah slapped her with his belt a second time — only hard enough to send sharp little sparks of pleasure dancing across her skin and make her clit throb, nothing truly painful — she couldn't stop the moan that left her with Klaus still steadily fucking her mouth. Kol would have been rougher with her but Elijah was giving her exactly what she needed in this moment. The feeling of her vibrating moans made him inadvertently jerk his hips harder against her and she faintly heard him curse.

Elijah hit her again, three, four… seven more times, soothing each burning slap by tracing his fingers softly over her now pink skin, making her writhe against him, desperate for him to just reach down and play with her clit. As Caroline continued to buck and moan around him, Klaus finally felt himself begin to reach his release. With a final thrust Klaus felt himself spill inside of her mouth and she eagerly swallowed each drop.

The second he pulled out of her and she could speak, Caroline tried begging again. Elijah ha worked his way up to ten slaps of his belt now, each successive strike making her cunt begin to drip again, more than ready to cum.

"Oh fuck, please, I'm going to cum!" she moaned out. They hadn't told her she could cum but she could feel that she was losing control over her own twitching core.

"Don't, Caroline," Kol ordered sharply.

"Oh, I don't know. I'd say she's earned it," Klaus reasoned, sounding quite pleased with himself.

"Of course you would," Kol answered in an annoyed tone before looking at her again. "By the way, darling, maybe you you need a reminder but 'Oh fuck' isn't your safeword."

"I have a safeword?"

Kol snickered, "No."

But whatever plans Kol had to keep tormenting her were abruptly vetoed by Elijah who she suddenly felt kneeling down behind her on the grass, positioning himself between her legs, his belt already off, now unbuttoning his slacks. He didn't bother with further foreplay, immediately sliding into her to the hilt, knowing full well she was still completely wet and ready.

"Elijah, god!" she called out, the sensation of him finally burying himself her aching core practically enough to make her cum right then. Her muscles were already squeezing around him and she could feel currents of intense pleasure rippling out from her pussy to her clit and up and down her body. She knew she was maybe only a couple of thrusts away from…

But then Kol was stopping in front of her, harshly grabbing her chin between his thumb and finger, forcing her to meet his gaze.

"Don't cum," he ordered simply and forcefully.

Her jaw literally dropped at that request, "Are you fucking kidding me?"

Kol smiled at that, loving it when she lost her composure enough to bring out that spunk they all loved so much.

"Are you pouting now?" Klaus asked her with a laugh. Elijah had, at least, stalled his movements inside her enough to keep her from cumming. Still, it was torture, feeling him stretch her wide like this and desperately needing him to hit all the spots that drove her crazy. She was well aware he knew where they all were.

"You know what that earns you, right princess?" Kol snickered.

"Let me guess, a whole new round of no orgasms?" Caroline snapped right back.

That only made Kol laugh harder, "Actually, normally, that alone would warrant an orgasm in my book. You know I love it when you get bratty during sex. What do you think, brothers?"

Klaus looked like he was considering it but, this time, Elijah really did answer her prayers.

"I'm not playing this game anymore, I want to feel her cum when I fuck her," he snarled at the two of them. "Cum, Caroline."

And then he was fucking her the way she needed to be, hard and viciously, rotating his hips inside of her with each thrust to run his length over her g-spot and then hit deeper, to places other men had always neglected before. When Elijah was inside her, she was always floored by how easy and instinctive it seemed to be for him to bring a woman to orgasm. He was so experienced it was both intimidating and almost overwhelming.

Kol, still in front of her, began gently palming each of her breasts, letting the heat of his palms press into the skin of her nipples which immediately hardened against his touch. That last addition of sensation was the final push. Caroline came with a scream, inadvertently feeding from the two of them without being told to, as she pulsed around Elijah's length, immediately soaking him while he relentlessly fucked her as she came for what felt like forever.

Even after she finally came down from the high, the orgasm had been so intense that even her aftershocks where rendering her a panting and moaning mess. She'd cum so quickly that Elijah was nowhere near close to finishing himself and he was still steadily fucking her and exploiting the responsive nerves along the length of her g-spot.

"Did you enjoy that, love?" Klaus's voice prompted from behind Kol and Caroline looked up to see him slowly unbuttoning and then carelessly shrugging off his own shirt. The sight of his well defined chest had her mewling with desire, honestly unable to answer. His pants were still undone and Caroline could see that he was hard again, just from watching her be fucked.

Kol sighed with exaggerated frustration. "Mmm, you never want to say it yourself, do you?" he asked her. "You want someone to make you say it."

"I'll make you a deal, Caroline," Elijah growled behind her. "Tell us what you wish someone would do to you right now and, if it's dirty enough, we might just let you cum again."

Caroline gasped, biting her lip nervously. She was still so inexperienced compared to them, sharing her fantasies was still outside of her comfort zone. Only Kol had made her do it so far and, although that always turned her on beyond belief, there was something even more nerve wracking about spilling her dirtiest secrets in front of all of them. Elijah pulled out of her, the tip of his penis still teasing up and down her folds, teasing her enough to prompt her enough to give in to Klaus's challenge.

"Play with my pussy until I can't stop myself from cumming," she moaned out, her eyes shutting as she let the fantasy play out in front of her, unaware that her succubus powers were inadvertently projecting the scene out to the minds of each of her companions. "Spread my lips, kiss and lick them, and when you hear me start to whimper, tease my clit with just the tip of your finger. Give me just enough to make me crazy but never enough to let me cum. Then ask me if I like it and make me tell you I do when I can't get the words out because I'm too overwhelmed."

At the end of her prompt, Elijah abruptly pulled out of her completely.

"While that was delicious, it sounds as if you'd prefer that we don't let you come," Elijah considered.

"What? No, I—"

Her plea fell on deaf ears as Elijah stood up, hoisting Caroline up with him, again supporting most of her weight since her limbs were useless.

"Alright, I've been patient enough watching," Klaus growled. "Give her to me."

They weren't far apart so Elijah almost literally just tossed her over to Klaus, giving her a gentle nudge that almost sent her falling but Klaus had her caught and cradled in his arms before she could even lose her equilibrium. She'd forgotten he was shirtless now; the heat of his bare skin pressed into hers had Caroline clinging to Klaus desperately the second he caught her. Klaus would get her off, right? He could never say no to her, not really. Like a woman possessed, she rutted up against him again and again, even going so far as to wrap one of legs around his waist, seeking friction against the bare skin of his hipbone. She ground her clit into his lean muscles, groaning out when she did, knowing full well that her slickness would be coating any inch of his skin that she touched.

Sure enough, her prediction was right and she saw Klaus inhale deeply, closing his eyes as he took in the feel and smell of her against him. Almost unconsciously, but still with practiced determination, Klaus rewarded her with two fingers brought up to softly pinch her clit, rubbing the bundle of nerves back and forth between them.

"Yes, Klaus, don't stop!" Caroline begged. "If you fucking stop…"

"Never," he replied softly, pressing his lips to hers in a searing kiss. He sucked her bottom lip between his replacing the fingers pinching her clit with his thumb so he could begin to finger fuck her too.

"Ah!" Caroline hissed out, needing to break their kiss when she felt him crook in and out of her while rapidly rubbing circles again and again over her clit with his thumb. He was alternately imitating the motions she'd projected in her fantasy and then touching her however he pleased… which was usually much better than what she'd imagined him doing in the first place.

When his thumb began pressing rapidly into her clit in an unpredictable pattern that her body couldn't get used to, Caroline felt herself beginning to feed from Klaus. Through his energy she could feel his own enjoyment of her — and, as always, something much deeper and more intimidating and harder to understand that she blocked out, not ready to acknowledge it quite yet — not to mention his arousal. He smiled down at her, when he felt her legs begin to tremble.

"Do you like this?" Klaus prompted, repeating the words from her fantasy.

She was more than eager to play along and bit her lip in a bratty refusal to answer. It only made Klaus speed up his movements and push a third finger inside of her. Her hips bucked and she cried out.

"Awww was that a sensitive spot, princess?" Kol asked behind them, unwilling to let Caroline forget for a moment that she was being watched. "Do it again, Klaus."

Klaus did and she had an identical reaction — her hips lurched forward and she cried out again, louder the second time. All three of them chuckled at her.

Suddenly Kol was right behind her, pressing into her as firmly as she was wrapped around Klaus from the front.

"Kol!" she squealed, shocked to feel his bare skin against her. Every inch of him was naked — of course she'd been to distracted to notice him stripping while Klaus toyed with her — and a very noticeable hardness pressed into her ass and lower back. Sandwiched between the two of them, she felt completely helpless to do anything but take whatever they chose to give her. This was nothing like when she and Klaus invited Elijah into their bedroom. Today they were all taking from her equally and greedily.

Kol dipped a hand around to where Klaus was still finger fucking her — so that, fuck, both of their hands were playing with her pussy at the same time — and swiped his fingers against her folds for just a few seconds until he was coated with her dampness. Teasing the cleft of her ass, Kol brought her juices up to coat her crack, teasing the extremely sensitive flesh without mercy as he lubricated her.

"Are you ready baby?" he asked, not waiting to hear if she was ready at all. Of course she was though, Klaus and Kol both had taken her this way several times before. She had been shocked at how much she enjoyed it.

Still she uttered out a vague noise of consent and she felt Kol slowly stretch open her ass while Klaus continued to only play with her using his hands. The contrast between being so filled but simultaneously not nearly filled enough by Klaus was enough to drive Caroline insane. A string of obscenities left her mouth, almost incoherently, as Kol began to slowly fuck her from behind.

"I'm sorry darling, I didn't quite get that. Could you try one more time?" Kol asked, laughing and making Klaus and Elijah laugh in response too. In her peripheral vision she saw Elijah approaching their trio to watch the entire scene unfold.

"Watch me while they fuck you, Caroline," Elijah ordered in an almost casual tone. "Don't look away."

He began to fully unbutton his shirt while he watched them both play with Caroline. Klaus removed his hand and stepped away, making Caroline whimper in protest but, he was only parted from her long enough to push off his pants and boxers. Now between two naked men, it was difficult to focus only on Elijah… particularly when Klaus forced one of her legs up to wrap around his waist again, waiting until Kol had pulled out from a thrust before slamming into her pussy.

The three of them fell into an easy rhythm, Klaus thrusting in each time Kol pulled out and vice versa, with Caroline alternately chasing their hips to meet their own each time. She was constantly filled, over and over, the two of them competing to get more and more intense reactions out of her each time. Caroline was overwhelmed with pleasure, incoherently moaning loud enough for any supernaturals in a two mile radius to hear her, she was sure. She bit her lip as she watched Elijah pull out his still erect cock and begin stroking himself while he watched her with intense eyes.

When it appeared that Kol and Klaus had reached a sort of stalemate in who could fuck her better when she was pinned between the two of them like this, they tried a different tactic. Continuing to fuck her, Klaus reached a hand down between them to toy with her clit again.

"Klaus!" she cried out sharply, only to hear Kol growl in annoyance behind her. Suddenly, he was reaching a hand around from behind her to actually slap Klaus's hand away and begin rubbing her clit himself.

Naturally that went over terribly with Klaus who looked about ready to break Kol's hand but Caroline stopped him when she finally snapped her eyes away from Elijah to look at him incredulous. The look was all he needed and Kol seemed to sense what had just passed between them because he laughed.

"Right, like you were seriously going to stop fucking Caroline to beat me up," Kol scoffed. "I'll take my chances, thanks."

Klaus snarled at him in response, glaring at him over her shoulder. Their movements had slightly stalled in the midst of the squabble, which was driving Caroline crazy. But Klaus quickly found another way to occupy himself while Kol tortured entirely too sensitive clit. As Klaus began to fuck her again, his fangs descended again and he slowly bit into the sensitive flesh of her neck and began to drink from her.

She heard Kol grunt in frustration when he smelled her blood and she felt him bend over to the other side of her neck. Sensing what his brother was doing, though, Klaus growled in warning while he drank and Kol backed off with an annoyed sigh. Instead, he thrust into her one final time, knowing that it would be all Caroline needed to fall over the edge yet again while Klaus drank from her.

It was too much, Caroline almost thought when the most intense ripples of pleasure yet overtook her body. Between Klaus pounding into her pussy and biting her neck, Kol completely filling her from behind and absolutely assaulting her desperate clit, and the erotic sight of Elijah standing shirtless in the woods while he jacked off watching her…

Before she realized what she was doing, she was feeding as she came but from all three of them at once — simultaneously experiencing their pleasure and her own. The feel of it threatened to overwhelm her to the point of blacking out, even as she drew energy from them. She felt like a light bulb in the middle of a power surge, on the verge of flickering out.

Vaguely, Caroline became aware of Elijah cumming over his own hand and she watched his seed spill out onto the forest floor where he stood only a few feet away. The site of him pleasuring himself and then losing his composure just from watching her be fucked by other men stirred a new sort of power within Caroline and her witch side began making its presence known.

Without consciously realizing she was doing it, she was conjuring a soft wind to pick up around them. It whisked up the few late summer leaves that had begun to scatter over the floor of the woods in a twister in the air around them that didn't stop until she finished cumming. Right when the spasms dissolved into aftershocks and she was able to slow her feeding, she felt Klaus spill inside of her next, finally releasing his hold on her neck an gently licking away errant drops of her blood as did.

They were all panting hard. Klaus slipped out of her first and Elijah picked up someone's shirt — god knew whose — and cleaned off his hand. Kol was the last to pull out of her and Caroline collapsed backwards against his chest where he wrapped an arm around her and kissed her temple in an uncharacteristically sweet move. Elijah and Klaus were both looking at Kol quizzically and when she felt him still hard against her back, she knew why.

"Seriously, Kol? Again?" she asked. He just snickered at her and pat her head condescendingly.

"Is this some sort of ridiculous attempt to prove that you have more stamina, brother?" Elijah asked, sounding distinctly annoyed and unimpressed.

"That's a contest you'll lose, Kol, and you know it," Klaus added, stepping forward again to kiss Caroline gently and slowly, before handing her his shirt, as hers was torn.

"Pfft, debatable," Kol answered snidely. "And no, not everything I do involves competing with either of you. Caroline and I have an understanding!"

"We most certainly do not," she immediately argued back, pulling the Henley Klaus offered her over her head. "I can't understand for the life of me why you never let yourself cum. It drives me insane."

Kol laughed extremely loudly at that while he stepped back into his own pants, literally wiping stray tears from his eyes.

"Exactly," he replied finally, "Like I said, we have an understanding."

Caroline shook her head, briefly confused, before realization hit and her mouth dropped open in outright insult.

"You mean this whole time you've just been doing this to mess with me? Fuck you, Kol Mikaelson—"

She was cut short by Kol vamp flashing in front of her, stealing her from Klaus to place a bruising kiss to her lips before he broke apart to whisper harshly in her ear, "Don't pretend you don't adore it."

"Now," Elijah's voice broke through, apparently content to interrupt their strange little moment, while they all began to finish collecting their clothes. "I do believe it's quite unfair that Niklaus is the only one who's had a taste of Caroline."

"Mmm, even I haven't tasted her everywhere I've wanted to quite yet," Klaus acknowledged, looking down quite purposefully between her legs which were still bare underneath his long Henley. "Shall we continue this somewhere more comfortable?"

"Bekah's gone for the rest of the day," Kol said.

"Perfect," Klaus replied before sweeping her into his hold and flashing them back towards their home, Elijah and Kol close behind once again.

Caroline's succubus half had come down from the immediate high of her intense orgasm and feeding. Now she was simply charged with energy and eager to work it out. She hoped they'd be able to keep up.


Oh man, sorry I'm a day late but this almost didn't get put up today either! Why? Because I started watching Vanderpump Rules and it's so awful but I can't look away… Also, this was a slightly shorter chapter as it was really just a continuation of the super long one right before it. Not to mention, while I'd love to have them all take her every which way in a single chapter we have to save something for our next fourway, right? There won't be another out and out mini-orgy like this for awhile but it will definitely happen again.

Also again, we'll be jumping a little forward in time. Honestly, this fic doesn't really have a fully rounded plot to begin with so I'm kind of picturing it as an indefinite thing I update going forward with no real 'end.' That will require periodic time jumps over the course of Caroline's life with the Mikaelsons. Now that the conflict of her initial transitioning is resolved this will be a mix of smutty self-contained chapters and, every now and then, longer three to four-shot chapters that work out mini plotlines about Caroline's adventures living as a Mikaelson herself over time. Sound good?

SOME TEASERS: Coming up next it's about that special time! We've reached Rebekoline. No other smut pairings in that chapter though the brothers might make some cute appearances. However, the point of how it'll be laid out is so that people can skip that chapter if they prefer no femslash. But it's a cute premise and you really shouldn't miss it! I also need a Carlijah update. At some point after that… does anyone else feel like Kol would be fantastically good at role playing? Cause I have a feeling he would be simultaneously excellent and a little absurd about it and I'm really excited to write that. And, who knows? Maybe we can get Klaus in on that action too. Anything else?