Timeskip.

Dutch and Hosea plan a big robbery at Saint Denis after Dutch killed Bronte. Carly rides with Hosea up ahead, the two make a distraction explosion.

The others jump into the bank and all goes according to plan. However, before Arthur can crack the safe, suddenly Agent Milton calls out to Dutch from outside, revealing to have captured Carly and Hosea.

Dutch, being Dutch, tries to reason with Milton. "My friend, this is America, there is always a deal to be made!"

"I've given you enough chances. No more." Milton said and pushed Hosea towards the bank. Probably a little confused, Hosea takes a few steps, and turns back to Milton. Who suddenly shoots Hosea in the heart, and he falls down onto the road. Everyone in the bank has horrified and heartbroken reactions. Dutch's reaction in particular is truly heartbreaking, I imagine they were something of childhood friends. And for a moment he becomes uncharacteristically quiet and speechless, and half whispers, "Hosea..."

"Alright, your next." Milton said, motioning to Carly who's held by two corrupt cops. Carly, in response, angrily kicks Milton between the legs knocking him over. Suddenly a rain of bullets emerge from inside the bank. Dutch and the others were enraged, and began a gunfight. Even Michael, who barely knew the guy felt the need to avenge Hosea. The two holding her drop her by instinct, one of them killed in the crossfire.

"DIE, YOU SONS OF BITCHES!" Arthur shouts angrily.

Carly manages to flee into the bank during the chaos, barely noticed by the corrupt cops firing at Dutch's crew. Sarah Amber pulls her inside. Though the 'other Sadie' wasn't there. Was back at the camp. She hands Carly a Repeater Carbine as Sarah was using the AK47 Carly brought with her. Carly runs to a window, joining the gunfight, and manages to get a few of them herself, Sadie going to the opposite of the same window. Michael also uses the AK47 he brought, despite it obviously giving timeline confusions. But hey his modern clothes will do that two. As like the girls.

"Hosea! They killed Hosea!" Carly cried.

"God damn it! I knew this was a bad idea!" John Marston cried, firing a Whinester rifle.

"Shut up Marston!" Micah groaned, reloading his duel revolvers.


Eventually Arthur blows open the back of the bank, and he begins shooting from the roof. By the time the others catchup, Dutch reveals John fell behind and got arrested.

Sarah and Lenny scout ahead, but some lawmen find them and kill Lenny. Which saddens Sarah as Lenny was always like a little brother to her. But Dutch says to leave him there, they have to keep moving.


The next day, Charles and Sarah lead off the remaining lawmen, Dutch, Arthur, Bill, Javier, Michael and Carly sneak onto a boat.

But due to a storm, the boat sinks, and they end up stranded on the Island of Guarma.

Arthur wakes up alone, on a beach. The TB now begins to take effect as he looks a lot worse than he normally does, but he reunites with the others.

But due to the Bad to Worse nature of RDR, the crew get imprisoned by the corrupt local army. Dutch says they were just passing when the boat crashed, and gives everyone fake names as their real ones are too dangerous. Carly gave the name "Katie Rivers", which made her chuckle to herself.

The leader of the team remains unconvinced though, and says they aren't going anywhere till they get his boss. General Alberto Fusar.


Along the way, the team gets caught up in a battle between their new captures and local rebels, Arthur manages to free himself and join in the fight. And the team joins the rebels, though Javier falls behind and is captured by approaching army reinforcements. Dutch promises to return for him.

The leader of the rebel, Hercule Fontaine, leads Dutch's team to a gun stach and the group help fight off the second wave, and drive away the corrupt army.

Dutch and then are taken to a camp to rest up. Dutch said if the rebels help them save Javier and get the hell out of here, he'll try to support them in return. The leader agrees. They also give their real names to Herucle.

"Are you sure we can trust him Dutch?" Carly asked.

"What choice do we have." Dutch replied.


I should ask Balor which characters she'd probably use in a crossover.. By this point these stories are more just made for her and myself..

Micah certanly has the oppunity to one of her darkest and scariest villains, considering all his loyalty, his love for his friends, it's all just attempts to manipulate Dutch, he doesn't actually care about any of them..

Carly herself seemed to hate him in less than a week. Which is kinda impressive..