After Dutch asked her and Arthur to look for Hercules missing men, Carly ends up shot with a dart when examining a dead parachuter.

Next thing Carly knew, she awakened tied up to a chair, barely remembering how she got there, it all happened so quickly. Making things worse, a large man punches her as he tries interrogating her. The whole gender thing doesn't really matter as much in my stories.. Plus my stories normally portray her in her early 20's.. It's suggested she already had Sachi, so probably much older here actually.

Carly gives him her fake name, Katy Holmes, but the interrogator doesn't buy it, apparently it's the name of another employee of the corrupt army of the Island. He instead interrogates a friend of Hercule the group met earlier, who was also now captured, both speaking the native language so Carly doesn't understand it, though the interrogator pointed at her and she heard him give a question, she made it out as 'who is that!?'

The two seemed to be going in cycles and that angered the interrogator and he punched Hercule's friend before he went back to Carly, pulling a small gun. Carly gulped, normally guns don't faze her. But this time she was left tied up with no escape.

"You.. Die." He said in broken english, when suddenly a combat knife with thrown into his side head and falls down dead. Arthur Morgan steps out of the forest, grabbing back the knife. It was his only one afterall.

"You good Carly?" Arthur Morgan asked, cutting her loose from the chair.

"Yes thanks." Carly said, hoping off and untying Hercules friend, who ends up leading them to the other prisoners. Once freeing them though, it results in a small gunfight. Carly grabbing a Repeater Carbine, as does Arthur. There's a whole row of them all stacked up.


After winning the gunfight and freeing the hostages, Carly and Arthur find Dutch and Michael inside a cave. Bill and Micah stay behind, watching the camp Hercule gave them.

Dutch and Michael call out a creepy old woman they found, who barely speaks english, and is clearly less than friendly. But hey, desperate times. Enough that Dutch had to give all the bank money he had left just so she'll lead them though the cave. So in the end, the bank job was kinda pointless.. Poor Hosea and Lenny.

"What now Dutch?" Carly asked worriedly.

"We do what our two groups have always done. We survive. Get that boat. Get back to the rest of our family." Dutch explained, leading the others with a torch. He and Michael have the only ones so the other two have to stick close.

"We found the prisoners.. Beaten, tied…"

"Poor bastards." Dutch replied.

"No, that was me." Carly said, deadpan.

"Well.. Least you're alive." Dutch replied, unsure what else to say.

Eventually the creepy old woman shows them a letter to get out. Dutch gives his torch to Carly to go up first. But the woman demands more money.

"You took it all." Dutch said, deadpan.

The woman draws a knife to his throat. "You pay. You pay now!"

Without warning, or much emotion, Dutch shoves her back head onto the latter, and begins strangling her. Which unnerves Arthur, and Dutch throws down the corpse.

"What was that!?" Arthur cried.

"You saw what happened." Dutch replied.

"You keep killing people Dutch.. I don't like it." Arthur said. Dutch stops and faces him.

"I'm just trying to make sure all of us survive.. Now come on." Dutch said, and climbs up the latter.

"Come on." Michael said, going up second. He managed to find a Bolt Action Rifle, probably from the battle from Hercule helping them escape the chain gang.


The team find Javier being literally dragged by a mule as and Fussar his men taunt him.

Dutch orders the others to help him blow up one of the buildings which succeeds as a good distraction, and they save Javier, bringing him back. Though not without several other battles.. In fact the whole sequence is one long battle. Not sure why it's even involved honestly, it's barely brought up afterwards, and adds nothing to the story.. But hey, it's a fun side quest.

When they get back, Micah gives the closest he can to sympathy for Carly over her interrogation. But Carly still ended up just ignoring him.

This is short lived regardless, as more of Fussar's men arrive, even bringing a war ship, and a very large battle endures.

After the group fight past 3 or 4 large waves of enemies, Arthur ends up destroying the boat with a cannon. Winning the day.