Several days after Arthur and the girls rescued John, against Dutch's wishes, Sarah Amber is called to a small town to meet with Micah and Dutch, but Carly tags along. However, as Sarah approaches the house Dutch said to meet at, Micah bursts out of it, tackling her to a wall. ''Was, you, followed!?" Micah shouts. "No!" Sarah cried. "Was you followed!?" Micah repeats.

"Get off!" Carly shouts, before suddenly punching Micah, making him fall a little and Carly helps up Amber. Micah just chuckles, saying "good punch".

"I don't know why Dutch trust you, Micah. You didn't care that Sean died. And you didn't care that Hosea and Lenny died." Sarah said.

"Hosea was weak Amber.. And your friend here, all she does is complain (Carly flips him off).. She can fight, she can't think." Micah said, the third part being. a real in game quote of his.

"Yeah, well you think I forgot about Strawberry.. How you had me shoot up a whole town, just to get back your guns!?.. And back at the swamp, Carly said you shot a child at the stagecoach job you and her did.. You think I don't know what you are?"

"I'm a survivor. That's all there is. Living and dying." Micah replied, moving back some of his long blonde hair.

"You're a pathetic excuse of a human being, you make Trevor better by comparison, and he's probably your ancestor"

Micah prepares to reply when Dutch arrive, telling them to stop fighting.

"Why are we here?" Sarah asked, stepping away from Micah.

"Cornwall is here." Dutch replied.

"Why is Cornwall here?" Carly responded

"Who cares, we need to find him." Dutch said, Micah agreeing.

"Dutch, please, we have enough problems without messing with Cornwall again." Sarah said.

"Oh please, it's just a simple social call." Dutch said, as he and Micah chuckle and move up. Sarah is unconvinced, but Carly motions her to follow anyway.

"This new you Dutch.. I don't like it." Sarah replied nervously.

"We both know Cornwall is gunning for us.. Plus those poor people at Gurma.. That's Cornwall's sugar.. The man is a problem." Dutch replied.

"You're not the same man from Hangover, Dutch." Sarah replied.

"We all change. Miss Caroline did." Dutch responded

"It's because of Micah, Dutch.. I've seen him. Breathing down her neck. Making you crazy" Sarah insisted. "I just followed orders, future lady, now shut your mouth." Micah snapped, Sarah rolled her eyes.

"And Miss Caroline grew up. Can't stop that." Carly responded, referring to her great grandmother.


With the arrival of Cornwall's yacht imminent, the four take cover in the harbour.

When Cornwall arrives, they see Agent Milton and Agent Ross debarking the vessel, with Cornwall scolding them for their lack of progress in finding Dutch and threatening to pull their funding. Micah is sent to follow Cornwall's secretary, who was ordered to send a telegram to New York. Milton and Ross leave, and Cornwall himself talks to a fellow cop, to complain about striking miners.

Against Sarah's wishes, Dutch suddenly reveals his location, scolding Cornwall for his being a dirty coward, where at least Dutch 'admits' to being a thief.

"What the hell do you want?" Cornwall snapped. The girls reluctantly get up from hiding, standing near Dutch.

"Simple.. You give me ten thousand dollars, your ship, and safe passage out of town. And I'll let you live." Dutch said smugly.

Cornwall arrogantly laughs, saying "I'll do no such thing.''

"You sure? Good. I prefer it this way." Dutch said, suddenly shooting Cornwall in the heart killing him. The other cops immediately return fire, beginning a gun battle. Per the normal.

"DUTCH! WHAT THE FUCK!" Sarah cried, jumping into cover to get out her pistol, Carly grabs a revolver she found in an earlier mission. Likely in Guarma.

Dutch just laughs, and says "Problem solved!"

"No! No it's not!" Carly cried, shooting at some of the other cops on the boat, as they all were returning fire.


The three manage to kill all the officers on the boat, but Pinkerton's show up. And the whole thing turns into a bloodbath. Them versus an entire town of cops. Just like in Valentine. Sarah manages to grab a Whinshester off a dead cop, making the battle easier for her. Same with Carly. Milton and Ross are somehow nowhere to be seen. Guess they left pretty fast, because there's no way Milton would miss a chance to try and kill Dutch. Considering his obsession of doing so.


The three fight their way to a building. They see Micah knocking out Jansen, Cornwall's secretary, before continuing their escape. Carly gets mad at Micah, believing he talked Dutch into this, but Micah replies "I just follow orders Carly!"

Micah shoots dual revolvers killing 3 or 4 in a row. Carly, against her better judgement, ends up saving him from an enemy that sneaks behind Micah. Not that he ever noticed, and Carly never tells him for some reason.


After eventually escaping the town and riding into the forest, they finally lose their pursuers. "Some social call." Sarah sassed.

"Don't play dumb, we both knew, Cornwall had to go." Micah said.

"Not in public like that, now we're in more trouble than ever." Carly groaned.

"Relax, I got us the papers we needed.. Now we just need some dynamite. I might know how to get some.. One of you please come meet me in a couple of days." Micah explained.


Turns out to be Carly. And Micah himself ends up the one ride with her to Vanhorn, not Bill Willaimson, and Carly climbs up an abandoned lighthouse with a sniper rifle.

Micah plays drunk, and falls over in front of a stagecoach. The driver orders him to move, but there isn't any response. The driver then sends somebody else to physically move Micah off the road and, as they do, Micah shoots him and gets behind cover, and Carly begins shooting from afar.

Eventually they manage to commandeer the wagon by shooting all the men.

Micah compliments Carly for her shooting who, likewise, compliments him for his "drunk playing", a rare moment of them getting along. But even then, Carly still openly expresses her distrust of him.


''Come on Dutch.. COME ONNN!''

But instead Dutch just wordlessly leaves. Abandoning Micah instead.

Micah suddenly growls in anger. And despite being the good ending, he still grabs his revolver to execute Arthur, but aparn pointing it at Arthur, suddenly a gunshot hits Micah in the hand, knocking away the gun and he swears in agony and looks over to where it came from, only to be struck by a rain of bullets through the chest and stomach area, and he stumbles off the edge. His scream heard as he fell off the long drop, assumably to his death.

Micah's white hat is all that's left of him. But Arthur just throws it off the drop as well.

Carly throws down the AK47 before running over to Arthur.


When the 3 finally return to the 21 centery, Amber is unusually quite, her new friends had fallen apart, and some tried to kill her. She leaves to be alone. Carly not sure if she should follow, but before she can decide suddenly Johnny runs and hugs Carly, saying how worried he was. Even hugging Michael, who awkwardly pats him.

Later Carly sees Trevor, who is actually confused by her saying she missed him and hugging him. He even asks Carly is she's feeling alright.


Meanwhile, Micah reveals to be dead from the fall. His body found by Dutch. This appears to be what made Dutch realize his mistake of trusting him. As once again, he wordlessly leaves, not even closing Micah's eyes.