The extended ending was always sometime mentioned but never fully used.. So this is my reason for using it.. Espically now that it's only this and Broken Family now, as the other one is deleted.. realized it was quite useless overall..


The next day John is told by Abigail about a ranch called Beecher's Hope and her hope to buy it, but John angrily points out he has a price on his head, making a bank loan impossible, Abigail angrily says ''I know, anytime we try to settle down, you act like the big gunslinger.

Suddenly one of the rancher's come in and told Joghn to go to Strawberry to get supplies, and Abigail asks him to pick up a parcel for her. John leaves and takes Jack with him, Sarah stays behind with Abigail, sitting on the couch she uses, as all the beds were being used. She pulls out a ciggerate, already being a active smoker before ending up in the wild west.


While Jack stays in the wagon, John goes into the post office at Strawberry to get the parcels and deliveries for Pronghorn Ranch. John tries using his alias Jim Milton, but the parcel isn't in that name, so he uses his real name, and a nearby man notices and quickly leaves. Eventually, he gets the parcel under Abigail's name, and the deliveries.


After everything is loaded into the wagon, Jack starts driving the wagon back to the ranch. John, nervous over stating his real name, tells Jack to speed up as some men begin following them.

Eventually John tells Jack to him to stop, and makes him hide befind a log, as John grabs a Bolt Action rifle hidden on the wagon. Confronting the men

The leading man asks John if he killed a man in Roanoke Ridge some months before. John can either deni or confirm this, and it's revealed that the killed man was his brother. John claims the man's brother had tried to rob them, but the man doesn't believe it and they prepare to fire. John goe into deadeye, killing all three of them, and than goes back to Jack, telling him to not look behind, as he tries to change the subject, saying about Beecher's Hope, and states he thinks it might be a good idea to buy it.


Upon arriving, Abigail notices something wrong, and John reluctantly admits they were shot at. Abigail is horrified, mainly because Jack was endangered. John is less than comforting, still yet to become the true hero of the first game.


Worse yet, the following night a gunshot is heard from the ranch, waking everyone up, including Sarah, who grabs the Heavy Pistol she still had from the present timeline and runs out wordlessly. John grabs his shoes and against Abigail's wishes, he runs outside two. It's revealed certain parts of the ranch had caught fire.

Sure enough, Jeff did in fact return, or least some of his men did. John and Saeah fist fights a few of Jeff's men, Sarah deciding to save her bullets, espically cause the ranchers were scared enough.

Being against a stronger man, she knew couldn't fight fully fairly, so ends slaming him into a nearby pole after kicking him between the legs. John manages to win a 2 on 1 fight.

John convinces the ranchers to finish Jeff off once and for all, telling Sarah to wait for him outside, as he runs back inside the house, and opens a box of guns, grabbing two rifles for Sarah and himself, again ignoring Abigail's pleads, saying the same thing Dutch been saying for years ''I have no choice''.

He also grabs his and Sarah's hats, which were for also kept in the box.