Thank you so much carmengmtr, Nicole Miklos, Blondie 20000, Leann Nickerson and Angels-heart1 for all your wonderful feedback!

Leann, Dean and Cas aren't fight like there were in the show in this story but there are still some hurt feelings that will be addressed soon.

Blondie, oh man Lorna came out of left field...I think she's my 'Gemma' of this story. Don't want to give too much away but I really like the character so she will be around again.

Okay so this is my take on episode 15x8 "Our Father, Who Aren't in Heaven". I'm going to apologize to any Eileen fans out there up front. She's not a hero in my story...sorry. I'm definitely putting a different spin on her back story here.

Anywho...thank you again for your feedback! I hope you enjoy this next part! Author's Note at bottom (of this pretty long part)

Thanks

Val

Chapter 29

Jo stretched as she opened her eyes as Dean climbed back into the Impala. "Where are we?" She asked as she looked out the window at the gas station sign, 'Beemer Gas-N-Go'.

"I was just getting ready to wake you to see if you needed the toilet." He told her.

Jo squirmed slightly, she did need to pee but instead she turned to Dean and asked, "Beemer?"

"Nebraska."

Jo blinked at Dean, "Nebraska …we're in Nebraska. Why didn't you wake me?" Jo asked before she put her hand up to stop Dean from talking. "Never mind…the real question is why are we in Nebraska? I thought we were going to the bunker."

"I was going to grab a couple of coffees and some stale donuts but we past a diner about a mile back. Why don't go and get some decent grub and we can talk."

Jo sighed, "fine…I'll wait to go the bathroom then. We go…sit down and you tell me what you're doing."

SPNSPNSPN

"So you just made the unilateral decision that we're going to get Ami now and that I'm taking her to Rufus's cabin instead of going with you to the bunker. You're just sidelining me without speaking to me first." She said as she shook her head angrily.

"Look, you planted the seed and the more time I've had to sit on it the more I think you may be right."

"Okay but why take me out of the action?"

Dean looked down at his hands, "you've known me a long time Jo. You know better than anyone that my reputation is jump in head first and fly by the seat of my pants and you've seen what that gotten me on more than one occasion. So I decided to do things different…instead of swinging for the fences we're gonna play small ball."

"What are you thinking?" Jo asked, trying to push her anger down.

Dean shoved the empty plate aside as he leaned across the table. "If you're right and if Eileen made a deal and that's why she really ended up in Hell then it wouldn't be too far fetch that she may have made a new deal."

"A new deal," Jo repeated as she gave herself a few seconds to connect the dots. "Sam's connection to Chuck…the flashes he's seen. You think Chuck is probable having the same flashes."

"Yeah but the thing is…flashes would never satisfy him."

"You think Eileen's a plant?"

Dean sighed, "I hate to think that because I know Sam cares about her but the more I think about what he told me about what went on in Rowena's the more I think she is. She walks through a damn wall Jo and shows Sammy a hidden room where he just happened to find the spell that he believe Rowena had been working on for our Mom to make a spirit flesh…a spell he used to make her flesh instead."

All of Jo's anger disappeared at what Dean was suggesting. "Oh Dean…you really believe that?"

"Believe it enough that I reached out to Gabriel and asked him to be on call."

"You think that's necessary?" she asked.

"I don't know… I'm pissed that Chuck probably knows about you and Ami now."

"Yeah but we still don't know for sure if she ever made a deal originally with a crossroad demon."

"I texted Ash while you were asleep and he's been researching her past. Seems nobody heard much about her before 2007 other than her being Lilian's student. Then in 2008 suddenly she began amassing a lot of impressive kills."

Jo swallowed as she shook her head, "you think she made a deal to be a better hunter. What kinda of demon would agree to that? Don't they have some kind of code of honor or something?"

"Never hunted demons…mostly banshees and other monsters…never demons though. What Ash has been able to piece together she gave demons a wide berth."

"I've never met a hunter who hasn't taken out at least one or two demons. Heck I took out two with Rufus before I started hunting with my Mom."

"Exactly." He told her.

"Wait you said 2008, didn't she get killed in 2017? That's not ten years." Jo said, she wanted to come at this from all angles just to make sure they had covered all possibilities.

"I don't know…maybe because a human was controlling the hound that took her down the detail of the deal flew out the window."

"Dean…if we're right we need to tell Sam,"

"I know and I will once we get you and Ami on your way."

Jo sighed, "to Rufus cabin."

"Nope. I told Ash to get a car ready for you. I also told him to tell Ellen and Bill to pack up and be ready to leave after you pick up Ami. I want all of you out the houses that Chuck knows about. Random is going to be our friend."

"You're not telling me something. You have a plan."

Dean nodded his head. "If Chuck is connected to Sam and he's using Eileen too then I think it's because he's got a weak spot."

"A weak spot…is that possible?"

"You know about the tablets…the prophecy about Ami and Jack. Well we know that will never happen but I've been thinking instead of the angel tablet maybe the answer is in the demon tablet."

"Demon…there's a demon tablet?"

Dean smirked as he nodded his head, "God dictated the tablet for a way to seal the angel and demons back into Heaven and Hell if something happens to him. If God's untouchable then why did he did have a plan in case he wasn't around?"

"But wouldn't that tie back to the prophecy about Jack and Ami?"

"Maybe but maybe there's something else."

"Like what?" Jo asked.

"Chuck's sister…Amara…The Darkness. He locked her up when he began the Creation. If The Darkness could be locked up…" he said with a grin.

Jo returned his grin, "then maybe Chuck can be locked up too."

"That's what I thinking Sweetheart. So I get you and Ami settle. Go check on Sammy…tell him what I'm thinking and then go pick up Donatello."

"And Eileen?"

"Leave her in play instead of outing her and showing our hand. Let him think she's part of the team."

"But if she's letting Chuck know what's going on somehow. How are you going to do that?"

Dean smirked at Jo. "Gabriel might have used some his archangel mojo so that what she hears and sees will be slightly altered to what really happening so that whatever Chuck is seeing will be believable but it won't be everything that we're doing."

"Dean, I don't know…sounds risky to try and play Chuck."

Dean reached across the table and took Jo's hand in his. "We're playing the cards we've been dealt. I'm not happy about this either but I think it's the best chance we've got."

Jo swallowed as she squeezed Dean's hand. "Then let's pay our check and go get our daughter."

SPNSPNSPN

Dean walked into the bunker and saw Sam sitting at the map table. "How you feeling?"

"Okay, tired but okay." His brother told him as he looked down at his hands. "Dean, I was in Chuck's head. I was in his head…and he's weak…Dean I could see it…he is weak and afraid. I think we can beat him. I really think we can beat him." He said as he looked back up at the older Winchester with tears of hope in his eyes.

"I know Little Brother, I know. Cas filled me in," Dean told him as he clapped his hand on Sam's shoulder. "He told me everything when I spoke to him while I was driving Jo to drop her off with Ami."

"Drop off? Jo and Ami aren't with you?"

"Nah, Jo decided she wanted to spend some time with Ellen and Bill."

"Oh." Sam murmured sadly, he was missing Jo and Ami.

Dean looked over his shoulder, "so where's Eileen?"

"Took off on a hunt. Got pissed that I went and backed her up without her asking for back up. She's in her room now catching up on sleep."

"I see," Dean said, he knew he needed to tell Sam his suspicious about Eileen but he could see his brother really wasn't up to the idea that Eileen might be a spy. He decided he would watch her first and then get Sam away and talk to him. "Well I think I have an idea if you're interested."

Sam studied his brother and saw it…saw that he was completely in the game. "This little trip you and Jo took seemed to have helped get you back in the game."

Dean snorted, "yeah…it put a lot of things into perspectives. So you want to hear my idea on how we can take advantage of Chuck's weakness?"

Sam grinned as took in his brother's smirk. "Let's hear it."

SPNSPNSPN

Donatello stared at the hunters as Castiel finished explaining that Michael possesses Dean and Sam's half-brother Adam. "What is it with you people?! Can anything you do be easy?! I mean…"

Dean looked up just in time to see the way Eileen's eyes glazed over before Donatello was suddenly possessed by Chuck and began threatening the people Sam and Dean loved. Any lingering doubt that Eileen wasn't betraying them was gone.

He wasn't sure how much Chuck knew but obviously he saw they were working with Donny. The only good thing was that Chuck wasn't going to reveal his ace in the hole so Dean didn't think they had to worry just yet about Eileen doing something to cause them harm.

So he agreed with Sam that Eileen would stay in the bunker and make sure the spell stayed open while him, Sam and Cas headed to Hell to find Michael. Of course he didn't tell Sam or Cas that he had called for Gabriel while he went to his room to grab his back up weapons.

SPNSPNSPN

"So I'm here to spy on her?" The archangel asked.

"Don't let her see you…don't pull any tricks on her. I think he can see through her eyes somehow and Chuck will know your pranks. Just make sure she holds up her end of the job and keep the spell going while we're gone."

"Why do you take all the fun out of everything," Gabriel whined.

"We don't have time for you to be cute," Dean snapped as he grabbed a couple of clips of ammo.

"Can't help it, just comes naturally," he taunted before looking at the door. "Do you really think going to have a chit chat with Michael is going to help?"

"He knows something that worries Chuck, something besides the prophecy about my daughter and Jack." Dean reasoned before he added, "he may be pissed enough that Chuck screwed him over not for any noble cause but that it was just for his entertained."

Gabriel shook his head, "you don't get do you? There's a reason you're his sword. Would you ever betray John…even knowing what a lousy father he was to you and Sam?"

Dean ducked his head, "probable not but we have to try Gabriel. It's all we have right now."

"I'll lay low," Gabriel reassured him. "but I'll keep my eyes on her in my own way."

"Thanks," Dean said as he slipped his knife into its sheath. He looked up when he heard Sam knock on the door. He nodded towards the nursery and Gabriel slipped inside before Dean called out. "Yeah."

Sam walked in, "you ready?"

Dean nodded his head as he pulled out his cell phone, "yeah but I need to call Jo. I need to see her and Ami before we do this."

"Of course," Sam said. "We'll be waiting for you. Give Jo and Ami my love."

"Will do," Dean told his brother as he watched him turn around and head down the corridor.

"I can do one better," Gabriel said as he came out from the nursery.

"What?" Dean asked in confusion.

Gabriel walked over and placed his hand on his shoulder, "shut up, you can thank me later." He told him before Dean was suddenly standing in front of a startled Jo.

"Dean…Gabriel?"

"I'll let Dean tell you what's happening. I'll be in the other room so you can have your family time." Gabriel said before he quickly pulled Jo in for a hug.

They both watched as Gabriel stepped out of the room that Jo and Ami were in. "Dean, what's going on?" Jo asked as she looked up at Dean.

"You're not going to be happy," Dean told her as he quickly filled her in on what had happened since he went back to the bunker.

Jo gaped at Dean as she sank down in the chair behind her. "Hell…you're going to Hell to get Michael back."

"Jo I know this isn't easy…"

"Easy…Dean you're bringing that bastard back into our lives."

Dean knelt down on one knee in front of Jo. "I get where you're coming from but Jo this isn't the same Michael. This Michael has been using my brother Adam as his meat suit for 10 years in the cage."

"I know…I know," Jo said as reached out and took Dean's hands in hers. "It's just Hell…isn't there another way?"

"No…Sweetheart we have to do this." He told her.

"I hate this plan," she whispered.

Dean stood and gently pulled Jo up and wrapped his arms around her. "I promise, we'll be together soon."

"Dean, we should get back." Gabriel said as he poked his head into the room.

"Right," the hunter sighed as he looked over at his daughter napping in her bassinet. Stepping over he reached down and lifted the sleeping child into his arms. "I love you Sweetpea," he murmured before he kissed Ami's forehead and laid her back into her bassinet.

Dean turned and looked at Jo, "you have everything you need? Gun…ammunition…your knives…angel blade…holy water?"

"I do. Don't worry about us Dean. You can't afford to be distracted."

"I know," he told her as he pulled Jo in for a hug before lowering his face and kissing her.

Jo sighed as Dean kissed her forehead, "I love you." She murmured.

"I love you too," Dean told her. "No matter what…this…us…"

"Don't you dare," Jo said as she interrupted Dean. "Don't you dare think you're giving me the 'you're the best thing to happen to me' speech. That's a goodbye speech and this isn't goodbye Dean Winchester. So once you get the info we need from Michael then Ami and I are coming home."

"Yes Ma'am," Dean said with a grin before he leaned down for another kiss.

"Go," she whispered as she stroked his cheek.

"See you when we get back," he told her as he stole another kiss before he felt Gabriel's hand on her shoulder and when he opened his eyes he was in their room in the bunker.

"I hope you know what you're doing," Gabriel told the other man.

"Me too…me too." Dean said as he grabbed his gear and joined the others.

SPNSPNSPN

"Rowena's the Queen of Hell!" Dean whispered to his brother as they sat in her throne room.

"I know Dean…I can see her." Sam said as he watched Cas leave with two demons to look for Michael to make sure they didn't double cross them.

"Samuel be a dear and make me a drink. It's just down the hall." Rowena asked as she nodded towards the door. Once he was gone she looked at Dean. "You're keeping secrets from your brother again I see."

Dean sighed as he quickly filled her in on everything. "So," he said. "Can one of your bitches drag a soul to the pit if somebody didn't make a deal?"

It was Rowena's turned to sigh, "no they cannot. They'll kill innocent people but you only end up down here on a rack if you make a deal."

"Dammit, so she did make a deal," Dean said angrily.

"And she escaped when Chuck opened the pit," Rowena confirmed.

"And let me guess, you never created that spell to turn a spirit to flesh."

"I'm so sorry Dean," she told him. Rowena cared for the younger Winchester and hated that Samuel was being played by Chuck and this Eileen.

"Can they drag you to the pit before your deal is up?" he asked.

"That was the hound my Fergus loaned to the British Men of Letters. All bets were off once a human had control of the hound."

"That's what I thought, I just needed to know for sure," Dean said as stood up. "Where did Sam have to go for that damn drink?"

"Well I may have slowed time down just a wee bit to give us a chance to chat," Rowena said with a smile as she looked towards the door suddenly Sam walked through carrying a glass of scotch. "Thank you Samuel," she cooed as Sam handed her the drink.

Sam gave her a tentative smile as he looked over at Dean before asking, "so has he be regaling you with stories about Ami?"

"Ami?" Rowena repeated.

"Dean and Jo's daughter," Sam said with a grin.

"Well I never thought as the Queen of Hell I could be surprised but Dean Winchester having a wee one certainly does. Well come on, I know you both must have pictures." She said with a smile.

Dean actually blushed slightly as he pulled his phone out and pulled up the photos of Ami. He couldn't help smiling as he passed the phone to Rowena. "That's my girl."

Rowena gave the elder Winchester a genuine smile, "she's a darling," she gushed as she scrolled through the pictures. She stopped when she saw one of Jo holding the Ami. "Is she the bairn's Mam?"

Dean nodded his head, "yup that's my…"

"Joanna Beth Harvelle," Rowena finished as she passed Dean back his phone.

"You know Jo?" Sam asked slightly surprised.

"She may have thought she killed me once…made me use one of my resurrection charms a few years before we met." The redhead admitted with a huff. "I heard she had died."

"Yeah she and her mother died helping us try and stop Lucifer. That demon bitch Meg had released a pack of Hellhounds on us. Jo died saving me." Dean explained as he grinned at the thought of his woman taking down Rowena…even if it was only temporary.

"Then how?"

Sam explained to the woman who had started out as an enemy but had ended up being one of their greatest allies and someone he had grown to love about Jo being pulled from Heaven to testify against Dean and then Death deciding to deny Jo back into Heaven to punish Dean.

Rowena shook her head in disgust. Her and Jo may have been on opposite sides but she was offended for the other woman and how she was used by first by Osiris and then Death.

"Death is a tacky jackass," Rowena murmured before her minions and Cas came back into the room.

"Michael is not here," Cas said to his friends. "The cage is empty; he must have gotten out when Chuck opened the pit."

"Son of a bitch!" Dean hissed. "So he's topside and we've been wasting time down here looking for him!"

"Wasn't a complete waste of time," Sam said as he smiled at Rowena.

Dean looked over at the former witch and raised his eyebrows, "yeah I guess it wasn't."

"Dean, Sam we need to get back," Cas said seriously.

"Right," Dean agreed. "Rowena…thank you for your help."

The new Queen of Hell smiled at the brothers. "You boys be careful," she said sincerely before she snapped her fingers and the three found themselves back in the bunker.

SPNSPNSPN

Dean sighed as he lifted his bottle of beer and took a swig. He'd tried to pull Sam aside to speak to him about his suspicions and what Rowena had confirmed about Eileen after they had trapped Adam and Michael.

But Jo had called to let him know that they were making good time and would be back at the bunker in a few hours. So by the time he got off the phone with Jo and he came back into the map room it wasn't his brother he found but a note from Sam telling Dean he took off with Eileen to help another hunter with a vampire nest.

He tried to call Sam to tell him to watch his back but decided that wasn't a good idea. They were heading into a vamp nest and he knew Sam didn't need the distraction. No when Sam got back they would sit down and talk.

"Don't know why Jo wouldn't let me just zap her and Ami back here." Gabriel said as he opened up a king size Snickers candy bar.

"Jo wants to be as normal as possible and normal is driving home with our daughter." Dean told him before asking. "Take it you didn't have any luck talking to Michael either?"

"Told you…he wouldn't betray the old man any more than you would betray your father."

"Yeah…yeah I know," Dean said before adding. "What's Cas doing?"

"Still trying to reason with him."

Dean nodded his head as he looked at Sam's note again. "Do you think he's okay?"

"He should be fine while Dear Old Dad has Eileen in play…besides, he wants to watch either Sam killing you or you killing Sam. That's his endgame…he's not going to take one of you out like that. He wants to play with you, like a cat with a mouse."

"Right," Dean said, he turned his head when he heard footsteps and smiled when he saw Jo walk in with Ami. "Why didn't you call to say you were here? I would have met you in the garage." He said as he got up and welcomed his girls home.

"Made really good time," Jo told him. She smiled as she passed Ami to her father before turning and giving Gabriel a hug. "How's everything going? Any luck breaking through to Michael?"

"Cas is talking to him." Dean explained as he bounced Ami in his arms.

Jo looked up at Gabriel, "shouldn't you be in there too?"

"Michael and I didn't exactly part on good terms. If anyone will get through to him it'll be Cas."

"Speak of the angel," Dean quipped as his friend walked into the room.

Cas looked at Jo, Dean and Gabriel and announced, "I broke through to him."

SPNSPNSPN

The other three listened as Castiel explained about forcing Michael to attack him and when he got close enough how he grabbed Michael's head and showed him the images of what Chuck had been up to.

"Maybe you went too far," Dean said.

"Maybe," Cas murmured.

Dean reached over and placed his hand over Jo's before saying, "I mean…he's been in lockdown for quite a while, you know? Maybe you just...uh…went too fast. What's he doing now?"

The angel nodded his head, "no idea. He was very distraught."

Jo snorted as she mumbled, "archangel assholes get distraught."

Dean squeezed her hand. "Yeah but what exactly did he say?"

"'Leave. Get Out. I want you dead.' We didn't bond. Where's Sam?"

"Shit," Dean said. "Things have been so crazy; I haven't been able to fill you in."

"Fill me in? Fill me in on what?"

Dean, Jo and Gabriel told Castiel about first Jo's suspicions about Eileen and what Rowena confirmed while they were in Hell. Cas wasn't sure what was worst…finding out Eileen is a spy or that he hadn't picked up that her soul wasn't pure when he had met her after Sam had completed the spell. "And Sam's with her now?" he asked.

"He's a big boy, he should be fine." Dean said trying to reassure himself as much as everyone else.

They all looked up when the heard rumbling noise coming from deep in the bunker. "What the Hell is that?" Jo asked as her and Dean stood up.

Gabriel and Castiel looked at one another and both said at the same time, "Michael."

Dean handed Ami back to Jo, "you two stay here."

SPNSPNSPN

The three men walked into the room Michael was in. He turned when they walked in and said sadly, "God lied to me. I gave everything for him. I loved him. Why? I'm not even the only Michael."

Dean nodded his head, "Look I'm sorry. You didn't deserve the shit he dumped on you. Nobody does. Help us."

Michael looked up and frowned when he saw the woman standing in the doorway. The look didn't go unnoticed by Dean who quickly turned and saw Jo standing there.

"I'm part of this," she told him firmly. She needed to see this version of the archangel who caused her, Dean and Gabriel so much pain.

Michael stiffened, "he fed his grace to a talking ape!"

"Watch it brother," Gabriel hissed as he invaded the other angel's personal space.

Michael cocked his head slightly as he studied Gabriel before he snorted in disgust, "you actually believe you're in love with that mud-monkey?" He sneered as he glared at Jo.

"Okay you refer to me as a monkey or ape again and I'm going to start slicing and dicing with my blade." Jo snapped as she stormed towards Michael with her blade drawn.

"Jo," Dean said as he stepped between them. "It's not him."

Jo dragged her gaze from the archangel to Dean and took a deep breath. "Right," she said as she slid her blade back into its holder.

Dean gave her a slight nod before turning back to Michael, "all of this is Chuck's fault. Help us make things right."

Michael watched Jo and could feel the anger vibrating off of her towards him…no not him…the other Michael. He needed to know what the other Michael had done and before he could stop himself he reached out and grabbed Jo's hand.

Soon he was hit with a flood of memories of this woman's life from birth to death to being dragged from Heaven and abandoned on Earth to the other Michael tracking her down and basically using Dean who he knew he wasn't going to be able to control forever to rape her to create the perfect vessel.

That he fed her his grace to prep her. That he wanted to turn her into one of those bastardized monsters he had created so that the vessel had even more power to make the vessel stronger so that it could contain him.

Jo gasped as Dean grabbed her and pulled her away from Michael, braking the connection. "Son of a bitch!"

"I'm fine," Jo told him as she looked over at the angel with tears in her eyes.

Michael ducked his head slightly; he was overwhelmed with the emotions he felt from the connection. He was familiar with the emotion of anger the woman felt but it was another emotion that outweighed the anger. It was the utter love she felt towards her daughter, his sword. The love she had for all her family.

He swallowed as he turned towards Dean and said, "Yes, I will help you. What was done to the Darkness can be done to God. If he's as weak as you say then I know how." He reached into his pocket and pulled out a piece of paper and passed it to Dean, "That's the spell."

The others exchanged quick glances before Cas asked, "And the ingredients?"

Michael shrugged his shoulders, "Myrrh, cassia, rockrose…"

Dean nodded his head, "we've got them."

"And, to bind the spell together, the nectar from a Leviathan blossom." Michel told him.

"A Leviathan blossom? What is that, like a flower?" Dean asked.

Michael looked at Dean, "A flower that only grows in one place. Purgatory."

The others watched as Michael snapped his fingers and a portal opened behind him. "That's the door. It'll remain open for 12 hours. Now, if you'll please." He said as he held his hands up and jingled them in a silent request to remove the cuffs.

Dean reached into his pocket and pulled out the keys to the handcuffs, "You coming with us?"

Michael snorted in amusement, "no."

He began to walk out of the room but stopped when Dean grabbed his arm. "Before you go can I talk to him?"

Jo gaped when she saw the way Michael's eyes flashed blue and she was hit with a memory of how the other Michael's eyes would flashed blue when he would take over Dean's body after they had sex and swallowed the bile in her throat at the memory.

Dean looked at his younger brother, "Adam?"

He nodded his head, "Yeah?"

"Adam, I want you to know we are sorry. What happened to you… You're a good man. You didn't deserve that." He finally said out loud what he had felt for the past ten years. He never really met the brother his father had hid from him and Sam before he was killed by a ghoul and took his form but he was still his brother…his family. He was an innocent and didn't deserve to be screwed over like he had.

Adam looked at Dean and gave him a sad smile, "since when do we get what we deserve." He said as took a shallow breath before adding, "good luck."

The all watched as he walked out of the room before turning their attention towards the portal. Dean nodded his head towards Cas before looking at Jo. "Cas and I need to go; we don't have much time."

Jo fought the urge to say she could go with them but stopped knowing realistically she had to stay with Ami and Gabriel. "We'll get everything else ready for when you get back. Go," she urged.

Dean pulled Jo into a hug and kissed her quickly before nodding his head towards Cas. "Meet me back here in ten," Dean told the angel as he rushed towards their room to grab his gear.

SPNSPNSPN

Sam looked around the parking garage. Something felt off but they needed to help Eileen's friend. He saw the pick up truck that Eileen said belonged to Sue and reached down to opened the car door before stepping out as Eileen got out on the driver's side.

He looked over at Eileen and asked "she said she saw vampires here? It looks empty." Sam turned when he heard footsteps and saw the other woman joined them.

The other hunter smile slightly as she said, "look again."

Eileen moved slightly towards the other woman, "Sue. You're okay." She said before grinning slightly and adding knowingly, "thank God."

Sue looked quickly at Eileen before suddenly she was gone and a cloud of black smoke swirled around her and Sam swallowed when Chuck suddenly stood before them. He looked over at Eileen and smirked, "anytime," he said to her before turning towards the younger Winchester and greeting, "hi Sam."

TBC

A/N - Okay so in this story Eileen did make a deal and that's why she ended up in Hell. Sorry don't buy that the hellhounds haven't killed other innocent people before and that Eileen was just 'dragged' for no real reason to hell.

Once I decided she would make a deal with a crossroad demon, why not make a deal with Chuck too. To become human again so that she could continue her 'crusade' (she's actually pretty driven for revenge like John...which is why I never bought Sam and her as a couple) to find the banshee that killed her parents and made her deaf.

Plus when I re-watched scene where Sam and her were in the garage, the way Eileen looks at Sue and gives this creepy smile before saying 'thank God' to 'Sue' who then turns into Chuck just made the idea that she made a deal with Chuck even more plausible to me. Of course that's my interpretation of the scene.

Anyways, again...sorry to any Eileen fans or Saileen shippers out there.