Rachel's College Boyfriend?
By CollegeStar21
Summary
What if Rachel never got back together with Finn before Senior year and she met a guy name Brody Weston over the summer and they instantly hit off making it offical after she lost Nationals. She finds out that he goes to college at NYADA majoring in Musical theater How will their relationship work when her ex boyfriend Finn Hudson tries to win her back? And what happens when the Glee club members find out that she has a new boyfriend? Will they believe her or not?
Find out what happens.
I will be adding a few characters in this story aswell so Rachel will be making new friends but could make friends with the Glee club members.
Enjoy.
At McKinley.
Finn Hudson was trying to get Rachel back and so far he wasn't getting any luck. It was Glee club practice after school and she was looking at him unsure what to say to him. He was wondering if she was regetting not getting back together and now wants to? He would love for them to get back together.
"Hey Rach did you want to tell me something?" She looked at him and nods walking over to him.
"Yes I do and It's not easy to say this." Finn stops her with a smile.
"Rachel relax! I totally understand." She stares at him confused.
"Wait you understand what?" She asked him. He grabs ahold of her hand.
"I understand that you regret us not getting back together and I know Santana is spreading lies about me getting back with Quinn but it's not true because your the only girl I want and now we can finally get it right this time with me being on the football team and you wearing your cute animal sweaters and knee socks following me around like you use to you! I'll even stick up for you this time like a good boyfriend." She stared at him and scuffed.
"Do you hear yourself Finn? you think I'm going to just go back to the old Rachel Berry who let people walk all over her?" He was about answer back when Rachel stops him.
"Mr. Shue I would like to sing a song with our newest member Vanna Weston before we start working on stuff for Sectionals." He nods and Rachel glares at Finn who was staring at her confused. Both girls stood in front of the room and Rachel says her song if for Finn. Santana rolls her eyes knowing that Rachel is going to sing a love song for Finn.
Vanna.
ooo oh oh oh
oh oh oh oh
Rachel.
i thought i'd shiver
i thought i'd weaken
when you asked me to meet up again
i was so sure that
in one second
all my emotions would rush back in
you cut so deep
i couldn't see myself moving on without you
Everybody stared at Rachel surprised that it wasn't a love song she was singing to Finn.
Both Girls.
I never thought i'd break free
i always thought you'd be part of me
and nothing can change that
i didnt dare to believe
that i'd recover you leaving me
and you couldn't change that
over i thought i would cry
i spin over but im more than alright
i never thought
seeing you again would make me feel
nothing, nothing, nothing
it feels so good to feel
nothing, nothing, nothing
Rachel stared at Finn hard as she sang the next part of the song alone then Vanna comes in. Santana had some new respect for Berry.
Rachel.
Did you imagine
i'd be on fire
to feel you touch me and say my name
Vanna.
Ohh say my name.
Rachel.
to hear you say it
you wanna start over i admit
thought i'd feel the same
Vanna.
I'd feel the same.
Rachel.
i hate to break it to you
now i moved on without you
Santana and Puck realized what Rachel was doing. She was telling Finn through song that she met somebody and she was done with him but who was guy?
Both Girls.
I never thought i'd break free
i always thought you'd be part of me
Vanna.
Part of me.
Both Girls.
and nothing can change that
i didn't dare to believe
that i'd recover you leaving me
and you couldn'd change that
over i thought i would cry
i spin over but im more than alright
i never thought
seeing you again would make me feel
nothing, nothing, nothing
it's so good to feel
nothing, nothing, nothing
Rachel looked at the group before looking at Finn and sings.
how can nothing feel so good
how can nothing feel so right
how can something be so completely gone
that was my whole life
Vanna.
i feel nothing at all(3times)
Rachel.
i feel nothing
Both Girls.
i never thought i'd break free
i always thought you'd be part of me
and nothing can change that
i didnt dare to believe
that i'd recover you leaving me
and you couldn't change that
over i thought i would cry
i spin over but im more than alright
i never thought
Rachel.
seeing you again would make me feel
nothing, nothing, nothing
Vanna.
it feels so good to feel
nothhng, nothing, nothing
Both Girls.
nothing, nothing, nothing
it feels so good to feel
nothing, nothing, nothing
Rachel saw the hurt look and angry look on Finn's face but didn't care because he was done trying to control her. She wasn't going to be his type of girlfriend anymore.
"What was that about Rachel? are you trying to tell me something?" Finn asked standing up from his seat pissed off.
"Yes I'm trying to tell you that you can't control me anymore Finn Hudson. you made me feel worthless when were together and I'm done." He walked over to her grabbing her hand but Vanna pushes his hand away.
"Don't put your hand on her Finn, back off my best friend because if you weren't listen she feels nothing for you and has moved on." Vanna pushes him away.
"This is between me and Rachel not you Vanna." She growled ready to slap him when Rachel held her back.
"Don't start something Vanna! as for you Finn what I was trying to tell you is that I've met somebody and were dating." Everybody but Blaine and Kurt gasped.
"Your lying Rachel! I'm the only one that will put up with your ways and tell you to calm down so lets just get back together and be happy." Finn says trying to grab her hand.
"I told you no Finn! I dind't want to do this in front of everybody but I have a feeling you would have got angry and do something you would regret so I'm glad it's in front of everybody because I can't be with somebody who doesn't support me or won't defend me when others try to tear me down and laugh at me." Finn looks down.
"I'm not giving up on us Rachel, we belong together." Santana rolls her eyes at how stupid Finn is acting.
"Oh give it up Finn! She doesn't have a boyfriend but she's making up lies to tell you that it's offically over so just sit down." Santana snaps annoyed.
"Excuse me but I believe I'm very real." A smooth male voice says from the doorway.
"OH MY GOD, YOUR HERE." Rachel and Vanna squeals running over to him and he hugs his sister first saying that he missed her before he wrapped his arm around Rachel and pressed his lips against hers. She wrapped her arms around his neck grinning against his lips.
"Um who is this girls?" Mr. Shue asked at the guest that knows the Captain of New Directions very well.
"Mr. Shue this is my older brother Brody Weston, he goes to NYADA college in New York as Sophomore but he's here for the weekend! He's also Rachel's new boyfriend as you can see, they have been dating all summer." Vanna says grinning.
Finn was pissed off seeing a much better looking guy then him was all over the girl he still loved. Santana, Mercedes, Brittany and Tina were in a daze just staring at the greek god making out with Rachel Berry.
"Alright Berry this is totally not fair that you've gone from Puck, Finn, Jesse, Finn again to a kiss with Blaine now to the hottest I've met."
Santana and Mercedes say at same time in jealousy because they can't believe a girl like Rachel has a guy like Brody.
Brody and Rachel pull alway with a smile on their faces and she rests against his chest.
"She's something that I want girls sorry if your jealous but Rachel Berry is the only girl I want." Rachel smiles up at him lovingly before pecking his lips against.
"Well Brody since it's the end of the day, why don't you join us." Mr. Shue says knowing that everybody wants to get to know him.
"Only if it's okay with everybody?" He says rubbing his hand up and down Rachel's hip.
"Yeah,no." Most of group says but both Puck and Finn say no. Puck didn't like that some guy was much hotter them him. Finn wasn't happy that Rachel was much happier with some random guy that doesn't even to McKinley.
"So Brody come sit next to me and we can talk about where your taking me tonight." Santana says with a flirty smile.
Rachel glared at Santana and tightens her grip on her boyfriend. "Calm down sweetie, I'm all yours." Brody tells her kissing her forehead.
Santana frowns then glares at the hobbit. She was head cheerio and Rachel was nothing.
"You seriously rather date Man Hands then date a cheerleader?" Brody stared at Santana and glared at her.
"Excuse me but my girlfriend isn't named Man Hands, Dwarf, Hobbit, Gayberry, Selfish-Self-centered-Lame-ass Wannabe Diva From Hell,Boy Hips,RuPaul, That Thing, Stubbles, Treasure Trail or Yentl Santana is it?" She stared at him shocked and impressed that he was standing up for her.
"Her name is Her Rachel Barbra Berry short Rae, Chelle or Rach or just Rachel but knock it off." He snaps at all of them.
Rachel stared at him at him rubbing her hand up and down his chest to calm him down. She whispers in his ear telling him it's alright.
"No it's not alright Rachel! they've been bullying you for years and as your boyfriend I don't want it to keep happening." He stares at Mr. Shue.
"Your supposed to help them out as teacher so where have you been when they were tearing down your Glee club Captain?" He asked him firmly.
"Brody I know it hasn't been easy for Rachel but she's got to learn to take Criticism." Brody was now pissed.
"She has to learn how to take Criticism? how is calling somebody Man Hands, Hobbit, Treasure Trail or Yentl nice? Santana is not only talking about her race but she talking about her height and hinting that she's a boy when she's not or that she's gay just because she has two dads as her parents." Will stared at him taking in everything.
"I'm not trying to tell you how to teach but it's clear that yourself needs to be talk to you! I heard about the yelling in her face last year and trust me that will not be happening anymore Will Shuester." He tells him firmly.
"Sweetie calm down alright! it's a thing in the past." He heard Rachel's soft voice and nods pecking her lips.
"It's not in the past because they keep calling you these names baby." He whispers to her and she brings him over to the seat and sits on his lap.
"I know honey." She whispers kissing his forehead before resting against him. Finn stared at them knowing he needs to whatever he can to make sure Rachel falls for him again.
Find out what happens next and the song was Nothing By Charice.