Rachel's College Boyfriend?
By CollegeStar21
Summary
What if Rachel never got back together with Finn before Senior year and she met a guy name Brody Weston over the summer and they instantly hit off making it offical after she lost Nationals. She finds out that he goes to college at NYADA majoring in Musical theater How will their relationship work when her ex boyfriend Finn Hudson tries to win her back? And what happens when the Glee club members find out that she has a new boyfriend? Will they believe her or not?
Find out what happens.
I will be adding a few characters in this story aswell so Rachel will be making new friends but could make friends with the Glee club members.
The Next Day With Finn.
Finn sat on his bed looking at pictures of him and Rachel together the summer before their Junior year. He picked up a picture of him and Rachel and she's kissing his cheek. He starts singing looking at more pictures of them together and a few of just her.
It never crossed my mind at all
That's what I tell myself
What we had has come and gone
You're better off with someone else
It's for the best, I know it is
But I see you
Sometimes I try to hide
What I feel inside
He looked at Rachel's facebook page and looks at pictures of her with Brody looking alot more in love with him and keeps on singing.
And I turn around
You're with him now
I just can't figure it out
Tell me why
You're so hard to forget
Don't remind me
I'm not over it
Tell me why
I can't seem to face the truth
I'm just a little too not over you
(eh eh eh oh eh eh eh)
Not over you
(eh eh eh oh eh eh eh)
Finn looks back at more pictures of just Rachel and tried to smile at the goofy pictures of her that he took and he frowns still singing.
Memories
Supposed to fade
What's wrong with my heart?
Shake it off, let it go
Didn't think it be this hard
Should be strong
Moving on
But I see you
Sometimes I try to hide
What I feel inside
He felt tears clouding his eyes looking at the pictures of her and Brody together and saw some of her on his back looking like she's laughing then some of her looking so in love with the guy and it's like he was never part of her life.
And I turn around
You're with him now
I just can't figure it out
Tell me why
You're so hard to forget
Don't remind me
I'm not over it
Tell me why
I can't seem to face the truth
I'm just a little too not over you
He looks back at pictures of him and Rachel together at the lake and he missed those days and wish he never broke up with her then started dating Quinn Fabray again because he could have been with Rachel during prom but no he had to take Quinn wishing it was his ex girlfriend he was dancing with.
Maybe I regret
Everything I said
No way to take it all back, yeah
Now I'm on my own
How I let you go
I'll never understand
I'll never understand
Yeah, oooh, oooh, oooh
Oooooooh
Oh
Ooooh, oh
He throws the pictures of him and Rachel together on the ground with tears falling down his face wishing the pain would go away.
Tell me why
You're so hard to forget
Don't remind me
I'm not over it
Tell me why
I can't seem to face the truth
I'm just a little too not over you
Finn looks one more time at Rachel's pictures of her with Brody and felt sick to his stomach seeing about 4 pictures of Rachel kissing her new college boyfriend on the lips and on the cheek. He logs off after that no longer in the mood to see her with another guy.
Tell me why
You're so hard to forget
Don't remind me
I'm not over it
Tell me why
I can't seem to face the truth
And I really don't know what to do
I'm just a little too not over you
(eh eh eh oh eh eh eh)
Not over you
(eh eh eh oh eh eh eh)
He turned off his laptop and lays back down crying for an hour then sleeps for the rest of the day wishing his life was better then it was.
At The Berry House.
Rachel and Brody walked downstairs together with loving smiles on their faces as they held onto each other. They sat on the couch just so in touch with each other. Rachel was laying in his lap with her face buried in the crook of his neck.
"You look beautiful in the morning." He murmurs running his hands through her hair. It was Saturday and next Sunday Brody had to be back in New York.
"No I don't." She murmurs snuggling more into him.
"Yes you do baby, you look gorgeous every time I see you and I'm not just saying that because I'm your boyfriend." Rachel blushed and looked at him yawning a little.
"Are you tired still babe?" She nodded a little pouting and he kisses her temple.
"How about you get comfortable on the couch and I'll go make breakfast for us, does that sound good?" She nods climbing off him and he gets up but not before pecking his girlfriend's lips.
She smiles kissing him a few more times before he goes into the kitchen and starts making them a nice breakfast. Rachel thought about last night and the moment she shared with Brody and knew she was ready to make love to him but she wanted to be aleast 18 when they take that next step in their relationship.
Rachel heard the door bell ring and groaned standing up and walked to the door and opened it to see Brittany Pierce standing there.
"Is Santana still asleep?" Rachel just shrugged not letting her in the house.
"Can I go see her?" She shrugged pointing inside the house and Brittany frowns.
"Why are you being so mean to me?" She asked closed to tears.
"Just come in and wait by the door and call your girlfriend because I'm not speaking to her." Brittany walks in and calls Santana while Rachel sits on the couch.
Santana comes down a few seconds later holding Brittany in her arms asking what's wrong and she told her about Rachel being mean to her.
She walks over to Rachel and slaps her in the face hard. "How could you be mean to my girlfriend Man hands?" Santana spats. Rachel stood up.
"Don't ever slap me again, I wasn't being mean to your girlfriend." Santana slaps her again not believing her.
"STOP FUCKING SLAPPING ME. SHE ASKED IF YOU WERE AWAKE AND I SHRUGGED THEN SHE ASKED IF SHE COULD SEE YOU AND I POINTED INSIDE THE HOUSE SO SHE COULD COME FUCKING SEE YOUR BACKSTABBING ASS AND THEN SHE ASKED WHY I WAS BEING MEAN TO HER." She screams.
Brody walked the room asking what's going on and Santana glared at Rachel not believing a word she said.
"Your girlfriend here is a lier, she's being mean to my girlfriend and I don't like it." Santana said glaring at Brody then pushed Rachel slapping her again.
"Knock it off Santana." Brody demanded but she wasn't going to listen to him and pushed Rachel again but this time Rachel pushed her and Santana pushed her back then they start fighting grabbing each others hair and screaming at each other. Santana kicked Rachel in the stomach and she screams feeling the pain but held her ground fighting back.
"KNOCK IT OFF RIGHT NOW." Both girls stopped moving and looked to see Shelby glaring at both girls firmly.
Find out what happens next and the song was A Little Too Not Over You by David Archuleta.