Rachel's College Boyfriend?
By CollegeStar21
Summary
What if Rachel never got back together with Finn before Senior year and she met a guy name Brody Weston over the summer and they instantly hit off making it offical after she lost Nationals. She finds out that he goes to college at NYADA majoring in Musical theater How will their relationship work when her ex boyfriend Finn Hudson tries to win her back? And what happens when the Glee club members find out that she has a new boyfriend? Will they believe her or not?
Find out what happens.
I will be adding a few characters in this story aswell so Rachel will be making new friends but could make friends with the Glee club members.
Okay I know your all wondering if Ava Channing is pulling a game on Rachel but the answer is no at all. She is the one of the Characters that I'm adding and she will become Rachel's new friends.
On Tuesday.
Rachel Berry strode towards the choir room for morning Glee practice with her boyfriend Brody next to her, holding her hand. They walked into the room and took their seats in the back row and talk to each other quietly before the others get there.
Finn walked in with Rory and sighs taking his seat and hated seeing his ex girlfriend get kissed on her nose by her college boyfriend who he doesn't trust one bit. He use to be able to kiss her nose or cheek and he loved seeing her nose crinkle while blushing or whenever she laughed.
Brody Weston just screamed bad news to him and he was going to make Rachel see that Brody belonged back in New York away from his Rachel Berry. Rachel didn't even glance at him in the hallway or in class. Glee practice was very awkward because he always wanted to sing with her but she would turn him down everytime.
"Dude stop staring at them like that, it's creepy looking." Puck says in his ear and Finn snaps out his thoughts and ignores him before facing the front.
Rachel glanced over at Finn as he looks at the front of the room and sighs softly wishing he would give up. She was madly in love with Brody and she wore the necklace to prove it.
"Just ignore him babe, you don't need to deal with high school boys like Finn Hudson." Finn heard Brody say the pet name that he always called her and that pissed him off.
"She doesn't have to ignore me if she doesn't want to Brody, there is nothing wrong with high school guys." He says glaring at him.
"Your right there is nothing wrong with high school guys but there is something wrong with jealous ex boyfriends that can't take a damn hint." Brody spoke.
"Fine sing off to see who can sing better with Rachel and she will decided who she wants to be with." The group stared at them.
"Fine by me Hudson because your going to lose. You can sing with Rachel first because you always safe the best for last." Brody said confidently.
Rachel looked at Vanna and she nods saying it's a good idea and the others agree. Rachel sighs before standing up going to the middle of the room with Finn.
"What song are we singing together Finn?" He smiles at her lovingly.
"I think we should do pretending, do you still remember it Rach?" She sighs nodding.
"Just as long as you don't kiss me when it's over." Finn frowns slightly but nods saying okay and Brad starts playing and they start singing.
Rachel with Finn.
Face to face and heart to heart
We're so close, yet so far apart
I close my eyes I look away
That's just because I'm not okay
Rachel.
But I hold on
Finn and Rachel.
I stay strong Wondering if we still belong
Will we ever say the words we're feeling
Reach down underneath and tear down all the walls
Will we ever have a happy ending
Or will we forever only be pretending
will we a-a-a-always a-a-a-always a-a-a-always be pretending.
Brody stared at them as they sang a song that he had to admit was really good and Rachel sounded good with Finn's voice but he was going to win this.
Finn with Rachel.
How long do I fantasize
Make believe that it's still alive
Imagine that I am good enough
And we can choose the ones we love
Finn stared at Rachel seeing how gorgeous she looked close to him and hoped that she would pick him after this contest.
Finn.
But I hold on
Finn and Rachel.
I stay strong Wondering if we still belong
Will we ever say the words we're feeling
Reach down underneath and tear down all the walls
Will we ever have a happy ending
Or will we forever only be pretending
will we a-a-a-always a-a-a-always a-a-a-always be
Mr. Shue walking into the room and took a seat asking Kurt what was going on and he tells him and he nods wondering what Brody's voice sounded like.
Finn and Rachel.
Keeping secrets safe
Every move we make
Seems like no one's letting go
And it's such a shame
Cause if you feel the same
How am I supposed to know...
Quinn stared at Brody to see him not looking nervous or scared at all. She liked that he didn't show jealousy towards the two exes singing now.
Will we ever say the words we're feeling
Reach down underneath and tear down all the walls
Will we ever have a happy ending
Or will we forever only be pretending
will we a-a-a-always a-a-a-always a-a-a-always be (Finn.pretending)
will we a-a-a-always a-a-a-always a-a-a-always be (Rachel...pretending, Finn...pretending)
will we a-a-a-always a-a-a-always a-a-a-always be pretending.
They finished and everybody clapped for them then Finn sits down and Brody stands up and they talk to the band and Rachel stands on the other side of the room and the music starts and Brody stares into Rachel's eyes singing right to her.
I know everyone on
This planet wished that they had you
I feel so blessed baby
Listen now that I got you
I know every man
Probably told you that he loved you
This ain't ordinary love song
No this ain't no ordinary love song
So I'mma say it in the stadium scream
It like an anthem
Say it from the mountain top
Sing it like a favourite song
I'mma put my cards on the table for you
Rachel joins in grabbing ahold of his hands and Finn glared at their hands.
Cause I love you eh
And Baby there's nothing in the world
That I won't do for you
Oh I love you oh
I gotta tell you about a million, trillion times
Baby you're the best thing in my life
Brody watched Rachel grab his hand and place on her heart as she sings her solo.
Put your hand on my heart
Can't you feel that boom boom boom
Only one reason that it beats is for you
In this love game baby I play the fool
This is no ordinary love song
No this ain't no ordinary love song
So I'mma say it in the stadium
Scream it like a anthem
Say it from the mountain top
Sing it like a favourite song
I'mma put my cards on the table for you
They sing together never taking their eyes off each other.
Cause I love you eh
And Baby there's nothing in the world
That I won't do for you
Oh I love you oh
I gotta tell you about a million, trillion times
Baby you're the best thing in my life
Quinn glanced at Finn to see the scolded look on his face.
For once in my life
Once in my life
I can see it clearly
Cause you open my eyes
For once in my life
Once in my life
I'm that in my mind
You're the only one for me
Baby can't you see? oh oh, oh oh
I'm so oh, oh, oh
Brody wraps his arms around Rachel's waist from behind and she sways her hips as they finish up the song.
Cause I love you eh
And Baby there's nothing in the world
That I won't do for you
Oh I love you oh
I gotta tell you about a million, trillion times
Baby you're the best thing in my life
They stop singing and just stare into each others eyes. Finn didn't like how they kept on staring so he clears his throat.
"So Rachel who is it going to be me or Brody?" The others rolled their eyes. Seriously was he that stupid? Some thought.
Rachel answered him by wrapping her arms around Brody's neck and kissed him passionatly. Brody held her by the hips deeping the kiss. They stayed like that for awhile before Finn clears his throat loudly trying to get them to stop.
Rachel pulls back resting against her boyfriend's chest and stared at Finn. "If you haven't figured it out yet, I picked Brody." He sighs.
"He's just going to go back to new york next week and cheat on you because that's what guys like him do." Finn yelled.
"Dude you better shut your mouth because you don't know me. I haven't cheated on her since we've been together and I've never cheated on my past girlfriends so little do you know Finn. Your pissed off because I got the girl that you treated like crap to be mine. Move on because she has." Brody points out.
"Just answer this question Rachel and I'll accept that were over for good. When your future of being on the Broadway stage, who is the guy you see in the front row cheering you on?" Everybody was impressed with that question and looked at Rachel waiting for her to speak.
"I see Brody Weston sitting in front row cheering me on because for once in all my relationships that I've had, Brody makes me feel loved, he treats me like a queen and he's being the boyfriend that I've always wanted in you Finn but you didn't give me what this guy right here holding me in his arms gives me." Rachel tells him.
Brody looks at his girlfriend with a huge smile on his face before glancing at Finn to see him glaring at him hard.
"Were over Finn for good and you need to accept it because I don't plan on ever getting back together with you, sorry to say it in front of Glee club but you hurt me and were bad together. I'm happy with Brody and I wouldn't change it for the world." Finn grabs his bag and kicks a chair before walking out.
Rachel looks up at Brody and sighs. He whispers in her ear that he loves her and she whispers back that she knows. They sit back down and Mr. Shue goes on with practice.
Find out what happens next and the songs were Pretending from Glee and I Love You by Chris Brown.