Rachel's College Boyfriend?

By WorkingGirl22

Summary

What if Rachel never got back together with Finn before Senior year and she met a guy name Brody Weston over the summer and they instantly hit off making it offical after she lost Nationals. She finds out that he goes to college at NYADA majoring in Musical theater How will their relationship work when her ex boyfriend Finn Hudson tries to win her back? And what happens when the Glee club members find out that she has a new boyfriend? Will they believe her or not?

Find out what happens.

I will be adding a few characters in this story aswell so Rachel will be making new friends but could make friends with the Glee club members.

Merry Christmas. Chapters of Brody and Rachel in New York are coming up soon.

Alright enjoy this chapter.

In New York.

Vanna gasped softly when she saw what was in Brody's hand. Is that what she thinks it is? was her brother really holding this?

"Is that grandma's wedding ring?" He nodded staring at the beautiful ring.

"Okay time for a follow up question, why do you have it?" Brody gave his a sister a knowing look.

"Your going to ask her?" He smiled nodded. He was going to ask Rachel to marry him on New Years. They were going to have a long engagment and get married once college is over for them. He found the girl that was it for him.

"Oh my god this is amazing. I'm finally going to have a sister. Did you ask her dads for permission?" He chuckled.

"Yes Vanna I did and they both say it's okay just as long as it's a long engagement and I agree with them. I know it's only been a few months but I really know that I found the girl I've been waiting for." Vanna grins clapping her hands.

"I'm so happy for you big brother. I knew you and Rachel were perfect for each other. I can't wait to see her face." Brody takes a deep breath.

"Same here sis. I really hope she says yes because it's going to be really awkward when she says no." Vanna rubbed his back saying it's going to work out for him.

"Brody and Vanna it's time to eat come on." They get up and Brody puts the ring back in his pocket before joining his family for dinner.

In Lima.

Rachel, Blaine and Santana finally show up. Santana fixed her makeup and she looked good but she looked like she was crying a little. Rachel turned her car off and took keys out after putting it in park. She reached in the back and grabbed the container of cookies.

They get out of the car feeling the cold air hitting their faces. Blaine wanted to see his boyfriend so badly. He rushes to the door not caring about almost falling.

"Be careful Blaine before you fall." Both girls yelled as they walked slowly together. They were wearing heels so they had to be careful.

Blaine rings the door bell. Both girls finally made it to the door and smiled when Kurt greets them at the door. Blaine walks in first then the girls walk in so glad to be out of the cold.

"Hey guys it's about time you joined us. Was the roads hard to get by?" Carole asked.

"A little but me and Santana were dealing with something. We're good now." Rachel tells them. They all smiled and Rachel put the cookies on the table.

Finn smiled when he saw his ex girlfriend looking so beautiful this Christmas Eve. Rachel gave him a slight smile before hugging Kurt.

Santana walked over to him. "Let's talk in the kitchen Frankenteen." He just followed her.

With Santana and Finn.

"Listen to me real good. Okay? nod your head if your listening?" He nods.

"Good now I know you have this crazy idea that you and Rachel belong together am I right?" He frowns nodding.

"Finn your not the smartest guy in the world. Your barely going to graduate but you will. Finn you date Quinn, cheat on her with Rachel. Break up with Rachel because she cheated with Puckerman. You then steal Quinn away from Trouty Mouth and date her. Am I losing you?" He shook his head.

"Alright where was I? oh you get pissed off when you see Rachel with St. James at prom last year. You break up with Quinn and kiss Rachel on stage costing us Nationals. Now Rachel is with super hot college boyfriend and you do whatever it takes to take her away from said boyfriend? this is where your plan ends." He frowns.

"What do you mean?" She walked closer to him.

"You outed me to JBI and I'm warning now. Your messing with the wrong person here. Fuck with my life again and I'll mess you up. Nod if your listening." He slowly nods.

"Happy Holidays Finn." She said sweetly before leaving the kitchen. Finn stood there for a few minutes. Wishing Santana wasn't invited to this get together.

After two hours of eating, talking, singing. It was to give people gifts. Finn went first and walked over to Rachel handing her the gift. She looked at him for a second before opening it. She stared at the gift and frowns. It was a picture of her and Finn when they were together the summer before their Junior year.

"Um thanks Finn." Santana looked at the gift and rolled her eyes. Really Finn? why the hell would Rachel like a picture of her and Finn? Santana thought.

"Now open this one." She unwrapped the small gift and opened it not believing what it was.

"Are you asking me to marry you Finn?" He nodded.

Everybody stared at them wondering what Rachel was going to do.

"I know your with Brody but we have history together and I love you Rach, please say yes." She sighs.

"Finn you will always be my first love but you need to find somebody that truly gets you and makes you happy but I've moved on." She gets up and closed the box handing it to him.

"I'm sorry but my answer is no." He frowns and walks upstairs.

"Alright who's next?" Burt and Hiram asked trying to lighten the mood.

Rachel sits down feeling bad but he had to understand that she's moved on.

Find out what happens next.