So... I decided to make this kind of What If where the villain wins. or the hero turns in a bad guy, this the thing. We always saw how the good bois win and how the villain loses, at least most fics makes the villain lose on the final placements lol.
Now I come here and fuck shit up, making scenarios where the good guy won't win, the bad guy wins and even some good guys, even the most innocent ones turn out to be villains
Before we start, gonna add a difference.
Normal text means that the author (Me :D) will explain things to make sure the villain doesn't fuck up.
Itallic text means how the story is going.
Now without further ado, let's start.
Well, well well, during your life, there are many decisions you can make, and today we will make the correct decisions to get a villain win and give the good guys a bad ending, and to start with this… My favorite girl, Amy. So yep, we start.
Amy, Amy, Amy. What was your mistake? Well…. Your mistake was your laziness, you lost because you didn't want to go with Jasmine, if you did that, you would have got the intel about the apple and you would have avoided a friendship between Sammy and Jasmine, making her more miserable. Now, we will change that. Ok? Now. What's Amy's main goal.
Her main goal is to make Sammy's life a hell and get her out
And trust me guys.
Sammy will not get a happy ending. This is Bad Ending
During the moment Jasmine asked Amy to go. In the original timeline. Amy refused and sent Sammy to do her job because that was the dynamic. But instead, Sammy somehow wasn't there. Maybe, she had to use the confessional as a bathroom, maybe she was exploring the island. But she wasn't there
-Ugh, whatever.- Amy followed Jasmine.
And with this, Amy's victory was assured because of this.
After they went, Amy and Jasmine went for food and instead of having a talk of other stuff, Jasmine noticed all the stuff that Amy did on the first chapter.
-Bitch, what the hell? You wanted to drop your sister from a plane and Bad still considers you as a best girl?-Jasmine said
-Sorry for being based!-Amy replied.- And besides, didn't Izzy and Owen survived after a plane literally crashed on them? I'm sure that bitch would've been fine. Ugh, you are annoying me.- After this, Amy was about to grab an apple, the Apple of Death. Jasmine knew about that, but she just legit let Amy try to eat the apple. Shawn appeared, piercing the apple and explained the whole thing and how to heal from the contact with it, letting the tall girl be disappointed. Accidentally making Shawn some points with Jas.
-Shit.- Jasmine said before leaving disappointed.
-Thanks Shawn, wait a second.-Amy stopped for a few seconds before chasing Jasmine.- Jasmine, you fucking bitch.- Amy followed her.
Amy now has the intel about the apple, and even if Jas tells Sammy, Amy knows, it would be impossible for Sammy to make people get on her side, the rest of the episode would go like normal, nothing important happens, Jasmine wouldn't screw the challenge because let's be honest. Leonard, lol. Look guys, Leonard is one of my favorites but I can't make miracles to save him in this case lol.
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
Now, the next episode.
Twinning is Everything.
This whole challenge would be normal, every single thing would happen like in canon until the challenge ends. Sammy and Jasmine screwed the challenge along with Amy and normally, Amy would go for Sammy, but she had a better idea.
-Ugh, Sparemy will be out tonight…- Amy would see Sammy eating the apple and after she saw it, she had a devilish thought on her mind.- Or maybe not. It's funny to see her suffer after all.- She said, and with this, she had an idea.- If I get Jasmine out, Sammy will have no friends because nobody on my team likes her, except Topher, but he thinks she's fat. So, eh. Wait a second.- She thought.- Rodney was acting weird, maybe I should talk with him.
Amy would go with Rodney, and will convince him to vote for Jasmine, she would ask Rodney about what the hell happened this afternoon, but once she knows. She was convinced.
-(Oh god, I'm so going to be a Heather for this, right?)-She complained while thinking about faking a relationship with Rodney, after all, he is apparently in a conflict with a crush on her.
Next thing she will do, she will go with Topher, she will try to use that little gap of him saying that Sammy is fat to give some dirt about her, he will question, but it's Topher, dude is not the smartest tool in the crayon box. He will go along with it.
-Should I ask for Scarlett's vote?-Amy asked to Topher.
-Eh, letting you pick. She is kinda reserved.- The Chris wannabe said before leaving. Amy thought about this, but she would probably vote for Sammy, Scarlett is an idiot, she is already 4 parallel dimensions above her.
Let her believe that.
-SHUT UP BAD!-Amy complained towards me, Topher just looked at her a little bit weirded and the night happened. She was kinda nervous though. She maybe could have gone to convince Scarlett, but she wouldn't bother her, she is bad, but Scarlett already has to deal with Max, so she will not intervene.
Chris would do the ceremony, everyone except for Sammy, Jasmine and Amy would get the marshmallow
-Alright campers, those of you holding a marshmallow are safe, for now.- Chris looked at Topher, Rodney, Max and Scarlett. Amy, Samey, Jasmine. One of you is going now, all of you 3, you were in trouble for losing the challenge.
Amy was ignoring what Chris said, because she just had a smug look at Sammy who had her face being swollen since she ate the apple, Jasmine told Sammy about the apple, but never specified which one, Amy saw her sister eat the apple and let it happen.
-Stop being such a drama queen.- Amy glared at Sammy while Jas glared at Amy
-The girl is going home is…Jasmine.- Sammy and Jasmine were shocked, why her? Why not Amy or Sammy?- Meet me at the cannon.-Those were the last words that Jasmine heard because Chris didn't let Sammy tell Jasmine goodbye, she was already sick and Chef took her to get treated.
And with this. Amy got a huge point for her victory, she got out of the biggest competition, let Sammy alone. And if you ask for the votes, Scarlett and Max voted for Sammy since Amy told them that she screwed the challenge. Sammy and Jasmine voted for Amy since they knew Amy was evil and Amy, Topher and Rodney voted for Jasmine. And with this, this is also a big screw up for Shawn since with no Jasmine, there's no Jashawn so his relevance is smaller
-Amy-zing.-Amy said before ending the episode laughing at her sister once she and Sammy stayed alone
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
I Love You, I Love You Knots
Sammy would still be in shock, Amy took the only person that was nice to her away from her, she just wanted to stay away from her sister and as the person with low self-esteem that she is. She lost the motivation to continue. This challenge would be good to show more about the twins. Amy would now go foraging, using Shawn as a support to get her good food. She will get normal apples for the team, and the apple of death to Sammy again. Just to torture her.
I mean, is not hard to break a teenager with self-esteem issues… Wait, this doesn't sound right. Anyways. Since she is the one foraging, she would probably take Rodney since he is the closest ally he had, she only sees Topher as an occasional ally for now. But Rodney, he is her Kronk.
-Give me the apple Rodney.-Amy said before Rodney passed her the apple of death.- Ow, wrong apple asshole.- She said, making Shawn giggle a little from that.
-Sorry.-Rodney said before passing her the good one.
And just to show that she is a huge bitch with Amy like everyone demonize on other fics lol, she will serve everyone. Sammy will distrust but has to eat though. She could trust in Rodney. Nothing happens for now, that apple has a delayed effect from what we saw those episode.
During the challenge, everything seems normal, except for Sammy's truth, since she can't speak because her throat got swollen. This was weird for Shawn, but he thought Sammy was allergic or that her throat was swollen by the shock that Max provoked earlier. Finally, during Amy's turn. She will let go all out if there's a truth that she has to say about her family.
Remember when in canon Sammy said that Amy's mother hated her? Well. Considering the situation, it might be a dysfunctional family the ones they have, she might actually expose her mother from whatever stuff she's did, probably being truth considering Sammy admitted her mom hated Amy and Sammy doesn't look like the people who lied. When everyone realizes that she is not lying, she will concern Topher and Shawn.
Under Amy's wing, Rodney may actually not fucked everything up like he did on his challenge and actually win the challenge, which is a shame for Amy, Sammy's boot might be for later. However, the one that will not be safe is Ella, who will be out after this. Amy doesn't like to keep Sammy, but hey, at least the torture treatment with apples will work for now to bully her.
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
A Blast from the Past
This challenge is interesting since this is where both twins got out. However, this might be a big issue for the bears to win, since Rodney and Amy are still in the run and Shawn will be late. There will be the same number of rounds. Dave and Topher will fail in getting each other out the first time. Amy and Sugar will be the second ones, and before the Scuba bear would appear, Sugar would lose against Amy. Max will compete against Sky since Shawn is not here.
LMAO, do I really have to detail why Max will instantly lose against Sky? Bitch is legit Yellow Zoey, no way Max can clutch this, I checked like 14 million of alternate timelines where this happens and he gets fuck in all of them
-GO BACK TO MY STORY.- Amy shouted, making her teammate just back away a little, like if they didn't know about me.
Ok, ok, chill girl
Sammy will go against Dave, but she is just done with the competition, she has no motivation and she has everyone against her, so she just quit, leaving Dave an easy win.
And just because I'm a dickhead, Max goes against Sky again lol
-EJEM!
Ok, ok, Rodney, got it
Sky will face Rodney this time, and due to his infatuation towards Sky, he ended losing, making Amy facepalm herself and after that, Amy says "fuck it" and goes against Shawn, taking Scarlett's turn, they are losing 3-1. She doesn't fuck around and before Shawn does something, Amy gets him out ASAP. 3-2
Chris will say just to give drama that since Amy took Scarlett's turn, Scarlett has to compete, and if she wins, her team gets two points. She will face Sugar, and considering that smarts beat strength. Scarlett would aim for Sugar's legs, getting her out and giving her team a W.
Due to this challenge having Shawn arriving late, Sugar wouldn't doubt in trying to get him out, she knows what is he capable to do and she prefer to have the control in the Dave and Sky situation. So she would aim for Shawn, convincing Sky to help her vote Shawn and since Dave in this moment is a simp, he will betray Shawn.
-YOU DID WHA.-Those would be Shawn's last words before he was shot by the canon.
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
10th: Shawn
And with this, we took any kind of hope for Sammy to get help, now she is the weakest member of her team, she is refusing to cooperate, everyone except for Scarlett who knows what's going on, sympathizes with Amy, but she prefers to be on the best twin side, because, if she helps Amy getting Sammy out, she will end getting Max out.
Mo Monkey Mo Problems
Ok, this challenge is probably a victory for Amy and her homies, just because of not having Ella. The funny thing.
Both teams will get in trouble not because of the monkeys, but because they are idiots. Well, by they I meant Sky and Max. Sky will accidentally get Dave hugged by the bear and the Salmon will get caught by Max' net. However, due to they being 6 instead of 4 and one of said 6 is either the heaviest or the second heaviest contestant, depending on Beardo's weight. They'll break the net easier
-Max, I swear to God, I'm going to kill you fucking di-.- Amy would be interrupted by the net breaking, and trust me. They will have more time to do that rather than Sky and Sugar to get Dave out, until Sugar tries to sing and gets the Bear out because her singing is pretty bad to the point the monkey will just give them the coin to make her shut the fuck up.
However, they would be too slow. Despite of Sammy not even trying to compete, Amy or Topher would be the ones with the coin and win. Now, this is probably the most interesting part.
Who will Sky vote? Dave Or Sugar?. This is the hardest decision for Sky, and well, Sky is not getting a Bad Ending chapter for her, she already is a villain who won.
-I won? Yeah!-Sky said.- Wait, why did you say before that?
But during the ceremony. She took a decision.
She decided to keep Sugar.
-You did what?!- Dave asked to Sky
-Sorry, but I have a boyfriend. And I really miss my boyfriend Keith.
-YOU HAD A BOYFRIEND?!- Dave asked angrier before getting out by the canon
Bye bye Dave, I hate Skave and you are not needed for this anyways. Anyways. Why Sky betrayed Dave? Well…Sky is used to commit bad decisions, we saw it with how she handled the whole My Boyfriend Keith situation. So doing a bad decision like this by keeping Sugar instead of a secured vote with Dave… Will not end well for her. And besides, trust me, we need to get a bitch away to not give the best girl too many troubles and Sky's poor life decisions will help us
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
10th: Shawn
9th: Dave
This is The Pits
The only thing I can do here for this one is to develop Amy's character, specially towards her friendship with Rodney who will slowly stop seeing him as an ally and more like a friend.
Amy already has Sammy on her claws, has Max on her side, Topher is not going to help Sammy, Scarlett doesn't care about here and Rodney is her main ally on this. Sammy is alone on this. Meanwhile, Sky and Sugar really have to work together, they are just 2. And I'm not going into details. Sky and Sugar will do the whole challenge well while The Salmon get lost because they are too busy finding Sammy.
Eventually they will find Sammy, and the only worried person about her is Rodney since he is a good boi, the rest will either blame her or not care in Topher and Scarlett's case. But that was Sammy's last mistake.
Since Sky and Sugar completed the challenge like they should've instead of the rest who tried to leave by other means while finding Sammy. There will be an elimination challenge and a huge dinner for Sky and Sugar.
Sammy's defeat was inevitable. Since Sky and Sugar won, there's no Team Switch. Scarlett will not help her, she would get herself out by doing that. Topher is too busy with the phone. Nobody will help her, nobody will tell her goodbye. She is alone, like she always has. She was alone, she is alone and she will be alone.
And this was Amy's absolute victory, she not only beat Sammy, she broke her, she got her only hope on Jasmine out as soon as she had, she got everyone against her, she got her poisoned each day with the apple.
-Sayonara Sparemy, say hi to that bitch that we have for mother.-She had a smug smile, she won.
So now I can say that I wrote Amy like your average Amy portrayal lol. Anyways, now that Amy won, I mean, her whole thing was getting Sammy out. Could she be stopped from winning?
The answer?: Yes, there are 3 people that can stop Amy from her victory. Scarlett, Sky and Sugar. Scarlett would kill her during Scarlett Fever and Sky and Sugar if they play their cards, but trust me, with 2 allies on her side and on a massive 5 vs 2 disadvantage with the best player for the next challenge who is Max on the other team, it'll be impossible for them to make it together to the merge
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
10th: Shawn
9th: Dave
8th: Samey
Three Zones and a Baby
If Sky and Sugar thought they could clutch this one… They are just wrong. For 1 reason
During this episode, you could see how Max started to use his babysitting skills to calm the babies while Sugar and Sky would probably be too noisy. Topher would probably ask Rodney to carry his baby so he is busy with the whole thing about getting Chris out of the biz. Considering they will be faster, they will arrive on time and have enough time for Topher to fuck everything up to accidentally screw Sky and Sugar instead of them. Chris is annoyed by this, but he has a better idea to humilliate best boy Topher.
After this challenge, Sky and Sugar lost again, but Chris needed to get rid of 1 of them, what would he do? Easy make the others get rid of the loser. They'll get rid of Sky, it was many time mentioned that Sky is an Olympic athlete, it would be better for them to eliminate Sky. And this happens, but hey, now Sky can have time to talk with Keith to break up with him, talk with Dave and see how to fix everything. So well… Not a bad ending for Sky even if she lost.
If Sky doesn't fuck everyhting up lol
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
10th: Shawn
9th: Dave
8th: Samey
7th: Sky
Merge: Amy, Rodney, Scarlett, Max, Topher, Sugar
Hurl and Go Seek
With only 6 contestants left, the merge would start. By the time we are at this point of the competition where Amy started to see Topher and Rodney as friends, sure, she is really bossy, but outside of this, she is not THAT bad with anyone that is not Sammy. She will lose the first challenge though. Sugar will win that, and mainly a reason of why they should've gone for Sky but hey, better being chased by a overweight girl than a olympic athlete
The rest of the challenge will go however you want, whether you give Amy the immunity or not, Scarlett and Max will be caught by Sugar and considering that Topher was the only one that was playing on his own…
And actually being a loner kind of works on this season considering that the main reasons of someone's boot was either being annoying to the rest (Beardo, Sugar) fucking up the challenge (Leonard, Rodney, Sammy) or getting unfairly out. (Amy, Ella, Topher, Max, an yes, having the host planning your elimination is unfair as hell). The only 3 exceptions were Scarlett, Dave and Jasmine since Dave was eliminated by votes, Jasmine by losing the challenge and Scarlett… She tried to do a fucking terrorist attack come on.
-Who's talking?-Topher asked.
My bad, explaining stuff.
-Oh, ok, wait what?-He was shocked because someone answered
The rest of the challenge will go on like normal, no matter if Amy is safe or not, Sugar will find Scarlett and Max, and once Sugar and somebody else, probably Amy because of Rodney sacrificing herself to help her, making her realize that Rodney may not be a love interest for her, but definitely he would be a loyal friend.
Max would be the next boot simply because they like Topher better… And they can't touch Sugar. Leading this to our final 5 and to Scarlett Fever.
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
10th: Shawn
9th: Dave
8th: Samey
7th: Sky
6th: Max
Merge: Amy, Rodney, Scarlett, Topher, Sugar
Scarlett fever
This is the reason of why Scarlett could stop Amy's Amy-zing victory, by killing her, Rodney, Topher and Sugar. However, there's a reason of why Topher is still in the run. He could stop Scarlett. And I'm going to change a little how the final 4 will stop her since Scarlett's original method was pretty dumb, even for a Pahkitew enjoyer like me.
Chris never took the phone, Topher could have checked up all of his stuff and find whoever he bought Pahkitew Island and well, find out the correct code. Chris is not going to help them. So now, they will have to stop Scarlett. With some minutes left. Topher had the plan. Trick Scarlett. Amy asks him how he would do that.
-Just let me do that.- Topher said before knocking the door.- Hey Scarlett, Chris here, I give up, open the door so I can give you up the money.
-Aren't you in the plane?-Scarlett asked, Topher had to show what his 60 bucks spent in online acting classes did for him.
-Yeah.- He continued naturally.- But I'm entering through a secret entrance I have, no the one you or the guys found it, actually I'm arriving, hi Amy, nice haircut there.- Topher would start walking in circles, making Amy and Rodney look at each other confused. Sugar was going to say something, but she was stopped by Amy.-Ok, I'm in front of the door, open now.- When Topher said that, he passed Amy a destroyed drama bot she or Rodney destroyed. And he continued acting. Scarlett was believing the whole thing because when she showed the camera, she saw how Rodney was using one of the drama bots like if he was a ventriloquist and once she opened the door, Sugar and Rodney jumped on the girl. Topher and Amy followed them.
Amy had no idea of what to do, but Topher pressed the buttons he thought were the key.
-"222447774447777"-It was the correct password, the island detonation was stopped, Amy just by the pure excitement and adrenaline for this kissed the guy, catching Rodney out of guard.
-How did you know about that?-Amy said, without realizing what she did for a few seconds before she realized what she did.
-Check what the numbers mean on a classic phone.- Topher said. Amy thought for a few seconds, but before the show gets censored since she would insult Chris, a cut shows now Scarlett getting thrown to the cannon
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
10th: Shawn
9th: Dave
8th: Samey
7th: Sky
6th: Max
5th: Scarlett
Final 4: Amy, Rodney, Topher, Sugar
Sky-Fall and Pahkltew has talent
Now we have Amy solving her feelings with Topher with Rodney trying to understand this, he was always the one falling in love with others, but now he has to help with this case. But there's no time and it'll probably stay just as a future plot for a second season with them because it's already too late for it, it'll be just a crush for the rest of season. They had to race.
On this chapter, the best way Amy has to get rid of Sugar is this. Nobody teams with her, Amy allied quickly with Topher and Rodney so they can be on the final 3, they are friends after all, or well, she is crushing on Topher and without the help. Sugar would be eliminated.
And this… this is the moment when Amy got her absolute victory. Because, Chris didn't forget. Topher took his phone, he thought it would be a good idea to get him out on the final 3 challenge to make him feel the defeat when he was so close, and while not being able to have too much interaction, they agreed on a date after the season. Amy will end going to the finale with Rodney, yes, he is pretty strong but here's the thing.
Amy and Rodney are close friends now and they agreed that whoever wins, they'll give the loser part of the money. No matter what happens now, Amy got an absolute victory in both this and the alternative ending.
"But what about Jasmine and Sammy appearing on the-"
Shut, the fuck up, and listen for a moment.
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
10th: Shawn
9th: Dave
8th: Samey
7th: Sky
6th: Max
5th: Scarlett
4th: Sugar
3rd: Topher
Lies, Cries and One Big Prize
During the finale, Chris gives Amy and Rodney both Jasmine and Samey, they 2 are furious with Amy, during the time Sammy was out along with Jasmine, they 2 became good friends and they will not forget what she did to him. Because of that squirrel, Sammy will lose her hair with Amy making fun of her because it's Amy's Bad Ending, the more Sammy suffers the better.
-WHY DO YOU HATE ME?!-Sammy shouted.
-Wait, you hear that too?-Amy asked.
Both of you shuddup, I'm trying to make this dramatic, geez..
After they arrive, the confessionals of Amy doing all the bad stuff are shown, Rodney would realize that Amy was tricked, then again. Amy was there for him. Unlike other villains, Amy didn't throw Rodney under the bus as long as she lost, she only wanted Sammy out and considering what she said about her family, maybe, Amy just has family issues, maybe she is not bad, after this, he will forgive her, Rodney is a cinnamon roll.
Jasmine and Sammy will try to get the win, but it wouldn't matter if they get them on the mountain, Amy and Rodney are 2 physical power houses and if Sky could break down a mountain with a tantrum, Amy and Rodney could too.
-I WON?! I WON! YEAH! SUCK IT SAMEY, THIS QUEEN GOT AN AMY-ZING WIN.- Amy said before getting the brief case and then looking at Rodney.- Don't worry big guy, you'll get your part
Amy will win the season, spitting on the face of all the haters, they'll cope, seethe and mald, Rodney will just take this as Amy getting cocky and let her have her 15 minutes of fame. After this, Jasmine, Rodney and Amy will leave, Sammy stayed there, just freaking done. What did she do wrong to deserve all of this, she was crying about all of this, the scuba bear was behind her, but since this is a show for kids, instead of attacking her, he will just pass her a tissue while patting her back.
Unfortunately for Sammy, not everyone gets a happy ending. Some of them will get a bad ending, maybe in another story… she would get her happy ending. And this was the Bad Ending where Amy won. Whatever happens after this, if her relationship with Topher works or not, if she can still be friends with Rodney or not, how the public will react, it's now up to her, but for now, she is rich, she got all that she wanted and the best part is.
That Sammy had the worst time of her life, this was an Amy-zing ending
Final Elimination Order
14th: Beardo
13th: Leonard
12th: Jasmine
11th: Ella
10th: Shawn
9th: Dave
8th: Samey
7th: Sky
6th: Max
5th: Scarlett
4th: Sugar
3rd: Topher
2nd: Rodney (First on the Alternative ending)
1st: Amy (Second on the Alternative ending)
Next chapter.
Bad Ending: What if Dawn turned a villain? (Revenge of the island)