I Dare You To Love Me, a glee fanfic

I Dare You To Love Me

Disclaimer: I never owned Glee or the songs in this story, and I know how to forgive the dead.

Mark is not and will never be Freddy Krueger. He is dead

He stopped being a pedophile at that point.

Chapter 1: The Dare

Noah Puckerman was at a party at Rachel St. James's house, slow dancing with Kurt Anderson while only wearing his boxers. Kurt could feel Puckzilla getting harder as they continued to dance to "I honestly love you" by Olivia Newton-John. Noah kisses Kurt at the end before grabbing his things and storming out.

Kurt followed Noah to his truck, then turned around and Noah screamed, "Six months! I was tortured and raped for six goddamn months! I came back thinking I was fine! I find myself jerking off as I watch you dancing at Scandals to J-Lo's song on your Facebook page. I only told Santana because I thought she was my best friend! God, Kurt, I never wanted to come here! I planned to do the world a favor!"

Noah was about to get into his truck when Kurt said, "I left Blaine after Tracy died. I dare you to love me, Puck."

Noah soon took off his boxers and threw his clothes in the back of his truck. Then he strutted up to Kurt and kissed him full on the lips as he picked Kurt up. As Noah breaks from the kiss, he says, "No problem, my prince." He then takes Kurt back inside after getting his clothes.

Soon they are in a guest room with Blaine and Quinn. While Noah was sucking on Blaine's penis, Kurt was pounding his penis into his ass as Quinn rode Puckzilla. For the next four hours, Quinn moans in pleasure while she rides Puckzilla. When it was quiet, Santana and Rachel peaked in to see that the men were wearing silk PJ bottoms while Quinn was naked, and Noah was lying between her legs as he was holding Kurt's penis.

In the morning, Quinn and Blaine were the first to wake up. Then, Quinn says, "You better be glad I never told Kurt about you venting to me about Tracy. Or that you dared me to have a foursome with them when Puck stormed out. Now, where are my clothes, Blaine? I am not walking around the house naked for a week."

Blaine chuckles and says, "Rachel hid them, not me, and you will get them back before we all leave." Then he takes Kurt's old football jersey out of his suitcase as he says, "Rachel had me bring this to mess with Puck and Kurt. Rachel told me about Puck after Santana told her about him. I still can't believe Santana dared Puck to slow dance with Kurt while he was in his boxers."

Quinn looks at the men sleeping as she says, "I can't believe that we both rebounded with Sam, or that we are about to again. I mean, come on, Blaine, we both saw how Sam kept looking at us when Kurt was dancing with Puck." Soon, Sam was walking in as Noah and Kurt woke up.

Then Noah says, "Blaine, man, Sam told me about you guys last night before I danced with Kurt. Quinn, if you get pregnant, you better have a paternity test done this time on that baby. After finding out from Rachel that Beth was Finn's daughter, there is no way I am going through that again."

Kurt then chuckles as he says, "Quinn, I guess this makes us even. You got mine, and I finally got one of yours. I mean, I know Blaine is with Sam, but so are you, and that means you're with Blaine now, too." Quinn says nothing as she helps Blaine get Sam undressed as Kurt and Noah get dressed. Soon, Quinn is heard moaning again as Mercedes asks Noah if they could talk alone.

As soon as they were alone, she says, "I was the one that knew about Sam and Blaine first. I was also the one that told Kurt to go after you. I never told him about your gun closet or about Mr. H buying you new clothes after you came out to him. Now, will you tell Quinn her suitcase is under my bed? I don't want to see her ass again, and I had a hard time keeping Azimio from staring at Quinn all night last night."

Noah chuckles as he whispers, "Okay, and I told Quinn that Rachel told me about Beth. So, you might want to give Rachel a heads-up, and you could have told me when I vented to you about Beth back in high school."

Mercedes looks around, then whispers, "Sue was there when Quinn told me the truth and Quinn got you drunk on wine coolers hoping you wouldn't remember being with her." That way, she wouldn't have to tell Finn anything. You know, Kurt might be Rachel's bestie now, but he was mine when we were in high school. If you hurt him, I will hurt you. Got it?"

Noah chuckles and says, "Chill, Aretha, and despite what you heard. I just wanted to be with Kurt last night. If Z hurts you, I'll hurt him and tell Jazz if anyone bullies him. Uncle Nono's got his back. How did my dad take it when he heard that Jake was with Unique now?"

Mercedes chuckles as she says, "About as well as he took finding out you're gay too." Then she shows him Nick's text message he sent her after she sent Nick a picture of Noah and Kurt dancing.

Then Noah texts Burt what Nick told Mercedes, before saying to her, "Tell Nick that Mr. H is my dad now, and tell Unique I'll have your back if Jake hurts her. I know he might not think he is gay since Unique had her bottom surgery before they started dating, but come on. Ha, you might get a call if Blaine or Sam is the one that got Quinn pregnant. " Then he shows her a picture on his phone.

Mercedes whispers, "I saw that picture right after you came out to Mr. H. I didn't know it was your gun closet until you came out to the rest of us. I think you should keep a Super Soaker in there too. You better hope Rachel doesn't tell Kurt about your bladder or that all those pee-filled balloons came from you."

Noah chuckles and says, "Finn ratted me out when Kurt was on my side during Babygate. Man, if Mrs. H had her get a paternity test, my friendship with Finn wouldn't have been strained. I doubt he would be able to accept me being gay or with Kurt." After looking around, he asks, "Was Finn Kurt's first crush?"

Mercedes chuckles and whispers, "Yes, but I'm starting to wonder if you were his second. Do you know how many times I've read, "No, not Puck!" in his journal back in high school before he met Blaine?" Then she hands Noah a picture and says, "I found this in Finn's room after the funeral. I doubt Mr. H knows it's missing, and I think it belonged to Kurt's mom. Read what's on the back first."

After reading the back, Noah laughs as he takes a picture with his phone. Then he asks Mercedes, "Was it after he started playing football when he started writing?" "No, not Puck!" Mercedes nods her head yes as she giggles, but says nothing.

They then go into the living room after Noah gets Quinn's suitcase, then Kurt screams, "Rachel, where the heck is Quinn's suitcase? I am tired of seeing her naked or watching Sam, Santana, and Brittany drool at her!"

Soon, Noah picks Kurt up and puts him over his shoulder. He then pulls Kurt's jeans and underwear off as he says, "Chill, my prince, or I'll spank that sweet ass of yours. Right here, right now. " Then Blaine and Quinn put their hands down Sam's jeans as they dragged him to the guest room where Quinn was staying.

Santana and Brittany peeked into Quinn's room as Sam moans, "Oh, God, harder!" repeatedly as he fucks Quinn as Blaine fucks Sam for the next four hours. While Sam moans in pleasure while Noah was in a guest room with Kurt, kissing him all over his body.

As Quinn starts moaning in pleasure, Kurt whispers, "Thank God Blaine is quiet during sex. I know Quinn used to be quiet with Finn. Rachel and Mercedes just texted me that it does not matter if Quinn has your baby or not, they will both be okay with being the third surrogate for me. Um, you will have to be the sperm donor. Tracy was Blaine's daughter, not mine."

Noah kisses Kurt's tears away and says, "My sweet prince, do you remember what you would always tell your dad?" Kurt chuckles as he cuddles with Noah in bed.

Then Burt texts Noah, asking, "Puck, are you going to visit your mom before you go home or are you coming back to Washington?"

Noah replies, "I'm never going back to Lima, Mr. H. After I came out to my mom, she and Sarah disowned me. My mom told my dad after Jake started dating Unique. I haven't asked Kurt to move in with me yet. Plus, he'll have to stay with you anyway. You know, he can't stay on the base with me until after I come out there."

Burt replies, "Puck, do you want me to say it? Take Kurt to the base and leave the rest to me, okay? Just to let you know, I know about Beth being Finn's daughter, but Carole doesn't. Well, I've got to go. See you in a week."

Noah sends Burt the picture of the picture Mercedes gave Noah with the message, "I'm so glad you are not with my mom right now! I wonder if Kurt or Mrs. H know you are on Viagra? I mean, come on, Mr. H. I am guessing that's what Tracy told me about, Burtzilla. Elizabeth mentioned that nickname a lot in her diary, and Tracy told me about Burtzilla pills the last time she was at the base. Blaine and Quinn are rebounding with the same guy."

Burt replies, "I know, someone keeps talking about a Trouty Mouth on Facebook and called you Mr. P. I know Santana is pregnant with Artie's baby, but I couldn't help but laugh. Well, I've got to go; time for my pills." Noah didn't reply and snuggled with Kurt as Sam's moans subsided.

Soon, Noah takes a picture of himself and Kurt kissing and announces their relationship on Facebook. One of his superiors, Mike Young, comments, "Finally! Tell Kurt that I am friends with his father, Burt and I know that what happened to you changed you. Don't worry; he has already spoken with the guys."

Noah soon notices Kurt's crying, then Kurt whispers, "I made your heart skip a beat."

Noah hugs Kurt as he says, "You had my heart from the day I watched that video of you shaking your sweet ass at Scandals. I love you, Kurt." They soon drifted off to sleep.

When Noah woke up, he heard Sam moaning in pleasure. Then Santana yells, "That's it! I can't take it anymore! " Then Kurt woke up as they heard Santana slam a door. Before she screams, "Guys, we get it! You are showing Puck and Kurt that you are over them! But did you both have to do it with Trouty Mouth? I would rather hear Puck moaning in pleasure all week than hear Sam's noises!"

Then Rachel says something before Sam yells, "They faked it! I never did anything with Blaine or Quinn! They spiked my drinks with your sleeping pills to make me seem like a willing participant! Santana is right! I've had enough! Puck might love Kurt, but I don't like Blaine or Quinn that way!"

As Noah and Kurt get dressed, Santana asks Sam, "Do you remember when we fought over Brittany back in high school?"

Then Kurt went up to Quinn and said, "I'm sorry, Quinn. Okay? This is between us, no one else. I know my leaving Blaine after Tracy died hurt him, and Puck hurt you when he came out. Quinn, you have not been able to look me in the eye since Tracy's funeral. I also know about Blaine's dare and that you two thought that we'd go back to you. Puck is with me, and I love him! Now you two are going to have to deal with it. We are done with both of you!"

Quinn watches as Noah wraps his arms around Kurt before calmly saying, "Fuck you, Kurt! You don't think I knew you wanted Finn? Hell, that was why I went to Puck. I was only with Finn because he was popular, and I was only nice to you because of Sue."

Then she looks at Santana and says, "Some friends you and Brittany were. You have your wedding on a day I can't come, then you force Blaine to marry Kurt when he wasn't ready. He tried to be whatever Kurt wanted, but never felt good enough. Then Tracy dies, and he learns how Kurt truly felt about him. " Soon Blaine and Quinn get their things and then leave without saying a word to anyone.

Blaine came back an hour later and asked to talk to Noah alone. He looks at a picture of Rachel as he says, "Quinn was wrong. I wanted to marry Kurt. Tracy's death broke both of us, and I'm not going to lie. I still love Kurt, but since you came home, he hasn't been the same and has been pulling away from me for a while before we filed for a divorce. I might be his soulmate, but you are everything he ever wanted in a partner. All I ask is that you treat Kurt like gold."

Noah chuckles as he says, "You got it, man, and I'm sorry about all this. You know, if Tracy had lived. I might be worse than Mr. H was by the time she was thirteen."

Blaine chuckles as he says, "Come on, Puck, you fell for Tracy first, and you know it. She would have had you wrapped around her finger; Puck. " Noah rolls his eyes, but says nothing as Blaine goes to the guest room where his things were.

Then Noah watches Sam go into the room Blaine was in, only wearing his boxers. Soon, Sam is heard moaning quietly as Kurt pulls Noah into the room they were staying in and whispers, "Denial much? What do you want to bet: that Sam asked Blaine to come back? At least you owned up to your feelings."

Noah kisses Kurt's neck as he whispers, "I bet I can make Santana want to kick down the door four hours from now. Now I want to hear my prince sing." Before long, Kurt was moaning, "Noah!" repeatedly for the next four hours. Santana laughed when Sam went to his room, glaring at Kurt's room two hours into Kurt and Noah's lovemaking. Noah and Kurt only stop long enough to get a bite to eat while in their boxers by the four-hour mark. Then Noah is heard moaning, "Oh, Kurt!" for four more hours. Mercedes, Rachel, and Santana each peeked in to see Noah bouncing up and down on Kurt's penis.

Mercedes was the only one that recorded it on her cell and sent the video to Quinn with the message, "This is not Kurt's fault, Quinn. Kurt didn't rape Puck, and I believe Kurt saved Puck. You tried to destroy Puck when you were with Finn. You might have loved Puck after Finn died, but you didn't love yourself. I kept quiet about you trying to kill yourself when you moved in with me. I am not doing it anymore." Quinn never responded, and Mercedes prayed Quinn would see the light soon.

After Noah and Kurt got dressed this time, they heard Sam yell, "Blaine, you are my best friend! Of course, I love you!" Then Noah watches Blaine pull Sam into his room as Kurt and Noah walk out of theirs. When Kurt and Noah hear Sam moaning, they peek in to see him bouncing up and down on Blaine's penis.

Then Noah whispers to Kurt, "I think Sam swings both ways now. Quinn might not come back, and I saw Blaine with Sam at Scandals a couple of times last week. I think he is still new to this, like me, but I know I'm not attracted to chicks anymore. I still love Quinn, but you are the one I love and want more. I'm calling you Prince now because you saved me, Kurt. Plus, I know how much you would cringe when I call you Princess, and I wasn't going to let my prince hate my pet name for him." Then Noah picks Kurt up and blows raspberries on his belly as Kurt laughs.

Quinn comes back at noon and asks to talk to Kurt alone. But he refuses and says, "Quinn, you can apologize all you want!" Then Noah pulls Kurt close as he says, "You know what, Quinn," before he sings Sorry, Not Sorry by Demi Lovato.

(Puck)

Payback is a bad bitch

And baby, I'm the baddest

(I'm the baddest, I'm the baddest...)

Now, I'm out here lookin' like revenge

Feelin' like a ten, the best I've ever been

And, yeah, I know how bad it must hurt to see me like this

But it gets worse (Wait a minute)

Now, you're out here lookin' like regret, ain't too proud to beg

Second chance, you'll never get

And, yeah, I know how bad it must hurt to see me like this

But it gets worse (Wait a minute)

Now, payback is a bad bitch

And baby, I'm the baddest

You fuckin' with a savage

Can't have this, can't have this (Ah)

And it'd be nice of me to take it easy on ya, but nah

Baby, I'm sorry (I'm not sorry)

Bein' so bad got me feelin' so good

Showin' you up like I knew that I would

Baby, I'm sorry (I'm not sorry)

Feelin' inspired 'cause the tables have turned

Yeah, I'm on fire and I know that it burns

Baby, fineness is the way to kill

Tell me how it feel, bet it's such a bitter pill

And yeah I know, you thought you had bigger, better things

Bet right now this stings (Wait a minute)

'Cause the grass is greener under me

Bright as Technicolor, I can tell that you can see

And yeah, I know how bad it must hurt to see me like this

But it gets worse (Wait a minute)

Now, payback is a bad bitch

And baby, I'm the baddest

You fuckin' with a savage

Can't have this, can't have this (Ah)

And it'd be nice of me to take it easy on ya, but nah

Baby, I'm sorry (I'm not sorry)

Bein' so bad got me feelin' so good

Showin' you up like I knew that I would

Baby, I'm sorry (I'm not sorry)

Feelin' inspired 'cause the tables have turned

Yeah, I'm on fire and I know that it burns

Talk that talk, baby

Better walk, better walk that walk, baby

If you talk, if you talk that talk, baby

Better walk, better walk that walk, baby

Oh, yeah, talk that talk, baby

Better walk, better walk, that walk, baby

If you talk, if you talk that talk, baby

Better walk, better walk that walk, baby (Oh, yeah)

Baby, I'm sorry (I'm not sorry)

Bein' so bad got me feelin' so good

Showin' you up like I knew that I would

Baby, I'm sorry (I'm not sorry)

Feelin' inspired 'cause the tables have turned (Have turned)

Yeah, I'm on fire and I know that it burns

(Sorry, sorry, not sorry, not sorry)

Payback is a bad bitch

And baby, I'm the baddest

I'm the baddest, I'm the baddest

Noah did feel sorry for Quinn, but her actions with Blaine and Sam after their breakup. Not to mention her and Blaine's treatment of Kurt behind their backs for the last two days made it impossible to forgive her. But he wasn't the one that said anything about it. Santana, who was six months pregnant, gets in Quinn's face and yells, "You have really outdone yourself, Quinn. I know what happened to Puck hurt you and that him being with Kurt is like a knife to your precious little heart. But you can't put all the blame on Kurt."

Then Quinn screams, "Two of my ex-boyfriends are gay, Santana! How is that not Kurt's fault? He tried to take Finn from me! Now, Puck is his new partner! While Sam is with Blaine! Puck and Sam claimed for years that they weren't into gay sex! Hell, correct me if I'm wrong, Santana! Didn't you try to get Puck to fuck Matt back in high school before you and Brittany started having threesomes with him?"

Quinn soon storms off to the guest room, she was staying in and comes out with her things again. Then she glares at Kurt, saying, "I knew coming back here was a mistake. I came here to remember Finn, not how Kurt has been stabbing me in the back for years! I was supposed to be the surrogate, not Rachel! Puck promised me he wasn't like his dad! Then he leads me to think we would get back together before telling Kurt he is gay and loves him! It was not my fault! I'm the victim here! I did nothing wrong!"

Kurt got in Quinn's face and yelled, "How can you say that, Quinn? You had me believing you were okay with me being with Puck when we were in that foursome yesterday!"

Quinn pushes Kurt away as she yells, "I thought it would help me get Puck back! I didn't think he would enjoy two dicks inside him after being gang raped by over a thousand men for a year!" Then she knocks Kurt down as she storms out yet again.

Chapter 2 will be up soon.