Later on, back down in the cave, Hiccup was sleeping with Bruni and Toothless waiting for him to wake back up, which he eventually did, and he saw he was surrounded with molted rocks and a river of lava.
Hiccup groaned and felt his head for an injury and felt a pain. "My head. Thanks, Toothless." He then looked up and saw there was now no way out of the cave. "And we're trapped. I can't believe it. And he's probably long gone with that lamp by now."
Bruni then smiled as he reached behind the rocks and pulled on something with his mouth to reveal he had the lamp.
"Bruni." Hiccup said with a laugh as he reached up and picked it up. "How did you even...? You cunning little salamander." He stated as he began to scratch his chin, which he still loved as Hiccup began to inspect the lamp. "I don't get what's so special about this thing. I mean, it looks like the most worthless thing in this cave." He then saw something under the dust that looked like words. "There might be something written here, but it's hard to see."
Hiccup then began to rub the lamp, and just as did something began to come out of the tip that looked like blue smoke, and it began to swirl upwards like a tornado trying to escape from it until forming a gigantic person who hid in the shadows and folded his arms.
"Oh, great one who summons me, terrible one who commands me, I stand by my oath: loyalty to wishes three!" He said in a booming voice while he was looking around as if he was looking for someone. "I said...oh, great..." he then came into the light, revealing his white hair, striking blue eyes, and pale skin. "Excuse me, buddy, hey, where's your boss?" He asked as his voice became more soft and he looked to be Hiccup's age.
Hiccup looked at the giant man who seemed to be just about his age and was at lost for words.
"Help me out here, man. Where's your boss?" He asked Hiccup, waiting for a response. "Come on, if I wanted to talk to myself, I would've just stayed in the lamp."
Hiccup still looked up at the gigantic character, still trying to find his voice.
"Hello?" He asked as he waved his gigantic hand in front of Hiccup. "Use your big boy voice."
"I'm...I'm talking to a giant?" Hiccup asked in shock.
"No!" The figure stated before a puff of smoke appeared again, and he suddenly shrinks. He now has a tall stature, albeit slim. His clothing consist of a blue hooded sweater, frost collecting around the ring of the collar, and wore the same trousers bound with lighter material starting from the knee down to the rather tattered and frayed bottom, and for some reason he was barefoot. "I am not a giant, my friend! I am a genie. There's a difference. Giants aren't real!"
"Okay, sorry." Hiccup apologized as he backed away from the man.
"Names Jack Frost. Where's your boss?" The genie called Jack asked as he looked around the cave.
"My boss?" Hiccup asked.
"Listen, man, I've been doing this a long time. I know there's a guy." Jack stated as he created a staff with a G-shaped arch, resembling a shepherd's crook and then walked behind Hiccup and grabbed his shoulder and leaned over his left shoulder. "He's cheated somebody, hurried somebody, that guy."
"Oh, that guy." Hiccup finally understands. "He's outside." He said as he gestured out of the cave where the exit once stood.
"So..." Jack became confused as he used his staff as a telescope and used it to look around the cave. "So it's just you, me, and Toothless down here?" He asked just as Bruni came up to Hiccup's shoulder. "And a lizard. That's your personal business, but we're gonna have to talk about that later." He then reached down and scratched Bruni's head, which he doesn't like. "It's a pretty lizard." He then got back up to be face to face with Hiccup. "So you rubbed the lamp?"
"I guess?" Hiccup said, not sure what to think or say.
"Hm." Jack shrugged. "Hang on a second, will ya?" He asked and then used his staff to actually hang Hiccup up and began to stretch. "Oh boy, ten thousand years inside the same bottle will give you a crick in the neck." He then turned his head and cracked his neck in both directions and stretched his limbs out. "It feels so good to be out of there!"
Toothless then pulled Hiccup down from the cane and allowed him to fall freely. "I think I hit my head harder than I thought." He commented as he rubbed his head.
"Gotta say, you're not exactly what I was expecting from my next master after all of the others." Jack commented as he stretched his back out.
"Wait, what?" Hiccup asked in shock. "I'm your master?"
Jack then smacked his head, making a graduation hat and diploma appear on his head and hand. "That's right! He can be taught."
"That doesn't sound right." Hiccup commented as the hat and diploma vanishes from his hands. "You look like you should be my master."
"Yeah, well, that's not exactly how it works." Jack commented as he kicked the staff off the ground with his foot before putting it behind his back and placing his hands around it and walking towards Hiccup. "So...do you really not know who I am? I mean, Genie? Three wishes? Rub the lamp? Is none of this ringing a bell for you?"
Hiccup shook his head negatively and surprised Jack.
"Huh...we'll, I'll admit this is the first time this has happened." Jack commented in surprise but knows exactly what to do. Quickly vanishing in a puff of smoke, Jack reappeared in a clear opening and waved his hand at Bruni. "Lizard. Solo!"
Bruni was immediately attacked by musical equipment that attached itself to him after appearing from thin air.
"Uh..." Hiccup was worried for Bruni.
"Don't worry, he's gonna be fine." Jack promised as he began to shake while Bruni began to move against his will and began making small musical notes. "Well, Ali Baba had them 40 thieves, Scheherazade had a thousand tales." Bruni then used the kazoo for a quick note. "But master, you're in lock, because up your sleeve you've got a genie that never fails!" Bruni then freezes mid walk and Toothless waves his wing as if he were clapping. "Whoo!" Jack cheered. "I'm the best."
Hiccup just kept looking very confused, no idea what to say.
"Not enough, Huh?" Jack asked as he leaned on the staff.
"Well..." Hiccup tried to did his voice again.
"I'm kidding." Jack promised with a laugh. "Just watch this." He waved his head and Bruni was suddenly on a drum set and playing using his paws and his head as the sticks. "Here I go!" He cheered as he began to dance around Bruni before looking towards Toothless who has a maraca attached to his back tails. "Let's get the show on the road!"
Jack then slammed his staff down and it released a cloud of mist.
"Well, Ali Baba, he had them 40 thieves. Scheherazade had a thousand tales." Jack sang just as a few dozen thieves came out of the mist and all of their swords were all facing towards Hiccup as they surrounded him. "But, master, you're in luck, because up your sleeves, you've got a brand of magic that never fails!"
Jack then used his staff to yank Hiccup out of the way of the thieves before growing gigantic and sending them flying. "You've got some power in your corner now!" His hands then turned into cannons as he floated above Hiccup. "Heavy ammunition in your camp!" He then shot off the cannons and filled the cave with smoke again.
Hiccup tried to find his way through the smoke but was met with Jack pushing him down as he punched another one of himself. "You've got some punch! Pizzazz!" He then kicked another one of himself before getting roped by a version of himself riding a horse. "Yahoo, and how, all live gotta do is rub that lamp!"
Hiccup then finally caught his bearings and raised the lamp before rubbing it again and Jack comes out of it.
"And then I'll say Mr.- man, what's your name?" Jack asked, just realizing he never got Hiccup's name. "You know what? Forget it. What will your pleasure be?" He asked as he reached behind him and pulled out a silver tray which he opened and turned into a restaurant that Hiccup found himself inside.
"Let me take your order, I'll jot it down. You ain't never had a friend like me!" Jack sang as he suddenly filled the room with multiple versions of himself filling the other tables. Jack then strolled over to Hiccup as he took a seat and handed him a menu. "Life is your restaurant, and I'm your maître d'."
Jack then turned smaller and was on Hiccup's shoulder and leaned close to his ear. "Come whisper to me whatever it is you want."
All of the other versions of Jack in the room jump and looked towards Hiccup and pointed at him. "You ain't never had a friend like me!"
The curtain then closed, and Hiccup pushed through and ended up on a golden couch with Bruni and Toothless fan in him with several versions of Jack doing the same.
"We pride ourselves on service!" Jack sang as he came ahead of the others. "You're the boss! The king! The shah!" Hiccup tried to walk away and almost ran into Jack who was carrying a plate filled of food, when he turned around he was met with more doing the same. "Say what you wish. It's yours, true dish! How about a little more baklava?"
Hiccup then looked and saw that they were all gone except for the original Jack. "Have some of column A." He said as he waved an entire row of clothes, which Hiccup quickly grabbed a bear-like cape and put it on. "Try all of column B!"
Hiccup then picked up a hat from B as Jack split his staff into two and raised them above Hiccup. "I'm in the mood to help you, dude!" He then attached strings to Hiccup's arms, causing him to spin and dance against his will. "You ain't never had a friend like me!"
Hiccup then suddenly ended up on a stage and was dancing with six versions of Jack without his staff.
"Oh! Here's the big part!" Jack cheered as he kept causing Hiccup to dance before breaking it. They all then vanish, and Jack comes up behind Hiccup. "Can your friends do this?!" He then gestured to his left which Hiccup looked and saw Jack hanging upside down while below his torso was spinning in 360 while snowflakes light around him like a disco ball.
"Can your friends do that?!" Jack asked as he gestured to his right where they saw Jack was spinning his staff and drawing in thin air.
"Can your friends pull this..." Jack asked as he used the staff to pull Hiccup to him and took off his hat and then pulled Toothless out of it. "Out of your little hat?!"
"Can your friends go..." Jack then rapped as he then sang as Toothless and Bruni appear and the four danced around, "I'm the Genie of the Lamp, I can sing, rap, dance if you give me a chance!"
A couch then appeared behind them as Hiccup fell down on it and Jack just sat down. "Don't you sit there buggy-eyed." He scoffed at the extremely shocked Hiccup, and he smacked his arm. "I'm here all to answer all your midday prayers!"
Suddenly, Hiccup looked behind the couch as a heavenly glow came in and was followed by several Jack's harmonizing.
Toothless then came over and had a contract in his mouth when Jack took it. "You've got me bona fide certified. Got a genie for your charged d'affaires." He stated as the couch then quickly sped around the cave at lightspeed and suddenly stopped, causing Hiccup to fly off, but was saved by Jack's staff.
"I've got a powerful urge to help you out!" Jack stated as he grabbed a hold of both Hiccup's shoulders before he fell into the lava pit. "So what you wish? I really wanna know." He then created a scroll and sent Hiccup flying on it. "You've got a list that's three miles long, no doubt." He then pulled Hiccup back as he held the lamp close. "All you've gotta do is rub like so!" He said as he then acted like he was rubbing it and Hiccup was, just as Jack then smacked it out of his hands and sent it flying.
As it fell back down, Hiccup caught it as if it was nothing.
"Mister..." Jack waited for Hiccup to tell his name, finally.
"Hiccup." Hiccup introduced himself to the crazy wild guy.
"That's it!" Jack cheered as he smacked his back, causing Hiccup to slip. "One wish or two or three?" Hiccup then climbed back up as Jack helped him. "You ain't never had a friend, never had a friend." He sang as his finger blasted magic that had several dancing elephants appeared.
"You ain't never had a friend, never had a friend." Jack then used his other finger, which caused dancing camels to appear. "You ain't never. EVER!" Jack's voice echoed as he continued to sing. "...had a..." His voice echoed as the light shaped in the form of the Arendelle castle with fireworks going off. "FRIEND LIKE MMMMMM-M-M-M-M-M-M-M-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E-E!"
The two of them then danced back and forth as the cave exploded with life when Jack sent a firework off onto the middle of it all.
"You ain't never had a friend like me!" Jack finished as the firework went off and cleared everything.