Craig's POV:

"Let's begin with a basic explanation of the class trial! So, your votes will determine the results. If you can figure out "whodunnit" then only they will receive punishment. But if you pick the wrong one... then I'll punish everyone besides the blackened, and the one that deceived everyone else will graduate!"

"Oh gee, could the, uh, person who killed poor Heidi just admit it so we don't all die?" Butters rubs his knuckles together looking around nervous at the other campers

"Goddammit Butters, that's not going to work." Kyle pinches the bridge of his nose and sighs "If we wanna find the killer, we'll just have to use the evidence we gathered to find them."

"Khel, this isn't elementary school anymore."

"God fucking dammit Cartman!" Kyle slams his hand on the wooden stadium

"Before we start this trial thing, could I ask a question?" Stan looks at Monokuma waiting for his reply

"Ask away!" Monokuma cheers

"What's going on with...those pictures?"

"I'd feel awful if they got left out just because they died. Okay, that about does it for the preamble. Get ready to get started! First up is the case summary. Now, let the class trial...begin!"

Kyle: "The murder took place in the Gym room."

Butters: "And there was wax scratched off on the gym floor…"

Cartman: "Thanks for stating the obvious, Butters."

Butters: "No problem, Eric!"

Tolkien: "The killer must have taken her by surprise while she was behind the stage."

Butters: "Gosh, I just feel bad. She didn't even have a chance to fight back…"

Something's off about what was just said... Because if Heidi hadn't tried fighting back then, there's no explanation for the scratch marks on the gym floor.

Craig: "No, that's not right."

The debate ends and returns us back to the courtroom chatter, everybodies attention is now on me.

Craig: "Try to remember how the scratch marks looked, and the chipped acrylic nail Stan found behind the back stage. With the scratch marks and chipped nail, Heidi was definitely fighting back"

Butters: "She fought back? With who…and who?"

Kyle: "Between Heidi and her murder, for fucks sake Butters."

Butters: "Alright so you're saying… Heidi wasn't caught by surprise in the gym and she actually fought back?"

Stan: "She must have been attacked backstage first, then she tried to run to the entrance of the gym. Her killer ran after her, and that's where they finished the job…"

Kyle: "That much should have been obvious after taking one look at the scene. It shouldn't even need to be explained."

Kyle pinches the bridge of his nose and sighs

Butters: "Oh hamburgers, sorry uh fellas. I'm just still trying to grasp the- uh the fact that this is real."

Butters was ignored and everybody continued talking

Stan: "Next is the subject of the murder weapon."

Clyde: "So what was used to kill her?"

Tolkien: "It was without a doubt something that's hard that can make a dent into the head when hit with."

Craig: "It was a bat. I could tell by the dent in the head the shape of it was a bat"

Cartman: "But that couldn't have killed her, the hit didn't look hard enough. Something else stabbed her in the stomach."

Kyle: "Cartman, how the hell would you know that? Did you fucking Heidi Turner?!"

Cartman: Fucking hell Khel NO! Just because Heidi fucking Turner broke up with me in like 4th grade doesn't mean i'll still have something for or against her!"

Kyle: "Then how the hell would you know!?"

Cartman: "Simple, I took a sneak peek once Craig and Stan left!"

Cartman shrugged

Jimmy: "So her killer used some st-..stup…stuu-…Random knife they had on them?"

It wasn't just any random knife, there was a specific one missing…

Craig: "No, that's not right."

Craig: "No. I don't think it was a knife. I'm almost positive it was the bottom half of a bat."

Bebe scoffs

Bebe: "The bottom half of a bat? You're joking."

Craig: "No, I'm obviously not."

Stan: "After the murder, we discovered that the bat was broken in half and the bottom half and top half were tried be hidden."

Wendy: "Which means that the bottom half of the bat must be the murder weapon."

Nichole: "Okay, so the murder weapon was a bottom half of a broken bat. But where does that get us?"

Bebe: "I mean, we all know Scott Malkinson killed her, right!?"

Tricia: "That's right...Scott Malkinson was the one who saw it first. What more proof do you need?"

Scott: "Hold on a second! I'm--!"

Stan: "Let's draw our conclusions after we've presented our arguments Or else, what's the point of the trial?"

Bebe: "Well we can talk all we want, it's not gonna change that conclusion."

Butters: "I don't think that's true at all! I'm sure if we keep at it, something new will reveal itself." Butters beams

Nichole: "You really believe that?"

Wendy: "So I guess there's no question that the bottom half of the bat was the murder weapon."

Wendy: "But where does that get us?"

Bebe: "Scott must have taken it from the gym closet, right?"

Bebe: "He did it in secret, before anybody got into the gym... And then he hit her head with the bat and then broke it in half and stabbed her with it!"

Tweek: "SO HE REALLY DID DO IT! ACK!!!" Tweek tugs at his shirt and starts to breathe heavily

Craig: "Calm down honey, It's not Scott Malkinson."

Tweek: "HOW DO YOU KNOW THAT!!!?"

Kenny told me and Stan that he was in the gym when an old taped up bat was taken from the gym but didn't see who it was

Craig: "No, that's not right."

Craig: "Scott Malkinson didn't take the bat from the gym closet."

Bebe: "Next you're gonna say he's not the killer, right? Go ahead and say it all you want that won't change the fact he did!"

Craig: "Well, what if I have a witness? What do you think, Kenny?"

Kenny: "Mphm??"

Craig: "Remember what you were telling me and Stan earlier?"

Kenny: "Mpmm mphm phm pmhmp mphm pmhm mphm" (Translation: Well, I went to go get the soccer ball from the gym closet, and all the bats were still there. But when I found the soccer balls and turned around to leave...one of the old taped up bats was gone.)

Craig: "So you're saying the bat disappeared while you were looking for your soccer ball in the gym closet?"

Kenny nodded

Craig: "Just to be perfectly clear, the bat disappeared while you were in the gym closet, correct?"

Kenny nodded once more

Craig: "And at any point while you were there, did you ever see Scott come into the gym closet?"

Kenny shakes his head

Craig: "The bat disappeared while Kenny was in the gym closet. But Scott wasn't there the entire time."

Craig: "In other words, there's no way Scott could have taken the bat."

Bebe: "Okay, then what about this? What if Kenny and Scott are in on it together, and lying to protect each other?"

Kenny: "Mpmhm mphm mphh mhpmmm mhphm phmmm!" (Translation:Why would I get involved in something like that!? I have a little sister to take care of, I have no time for things like that!!)

Craig: "Scott didn't go to the gym closet, and he didn't take the bat."

Butters: "So then who did take the bat?"

Wendy: "Kenny seems like the obvious person in the room. After all, he did say he was in the gym closet."

Butters: "What!?"

Kenny: "Mphm!?"

Butters: "Nonono! Kenny would never, he's too kind for something so mean!"

Kenny nods at Butters words, seeming confident and kinda smug-ish

Wendy: "How do you know that Butters? Kenny could be lying to you, he could be just manipulating you into covering for him."

Butter rubs his knuckles together looking down at at his hands

Butters: "Because Kenny wouldn't risk his life over something like this, he wants to live and keep his sister alive and give her the best life possible. He wouldn't kill someone just to ruin all his progress."

Wendy: "How do you know he isn't just lying to you though Butters?"

Stan and Kenny look at Butters with worry, like he's a piece of glass that's about to break. While Tweek and Cartman look at him with anticipation, like Butters is gonna do something mind blowing. Which i doubt that Butters would do something mind blowing.

Wendy: "And how can you prove that Kenny didn't kill anybody when you weren't even with him?"

Kenny: "Mh mphmh mh!!" (Translation: It wasn't me!!)

Wendy: "And is there anyone to prove that?"

Bradley: "I can."

Kenny: "Mpm, mphmpmhm mphmm mphm!" (Translation: That's right! Bradley was standing inside the gym watching and waiting for me the entire time I was getting the soccer ball.)

Nichole: "But then...couldn't either one of them have grabbed the bat?"

Bradley: "Actually, no. Because...um...well…"

We looked at Bradley with curiosity and he just looked more nervous as we did

Bradley: "We were also reading porno magazines…"

Kenny nodded confidently, and the courtroom went silent for a few minutes…

Tolkien finally spoke up

Tolkien: "But if it wasn't either of you, then what other possibility is there?"

Bradley: "Actually, there is one other possibility."

Scott: "Oh yeah, that's true! One other person did come to the gym closet while we were there."

Stan: "Why didn't you say so in the first place?"

Bradley: "Well, because...Heidi said not to say a word or else she would hit us with it…"

Craig: "So… Heidi is the one who took the bat?"

Kenny nodded

Bebe:"I'm sure she just took it for self-defense…"

Stan: "So you're saying the bat she took...was then taken from her, and she was killed with it?"

Bebe: "Yep!"

Scott: "I mean she was kinda crazy…"

Bebe: "See!? He did do it!"

Scott: "No you're wrong! I didn't!!!"

Stan: "Hold on. It's still too early to decide conclusively that Scott is the killer, wouldn't you say?"

Stan: "Because you see, there's no way Scott could've done it when he was with Kenny and Bradley. And until we unravel that little mystery, you simply can't declare that he's the killer."

Craig: "That's right, There was hair that wasn't even the murders, it was hair that belonged to people who had alibis."

Butters: "So, the culprit tried to throw us off?"

Stan: "Yes. And if I were the culprit, why would I need to get rid of all my hair in the gym and replace it with someone else's?"

Clyde: "The reason all the hair was replaced...was to remove any trace that the killer had never done it."

Craig: "No. If that were the case, they would have had to do something about the body itself, not just replace hair."

Tolkien: "That's true."

Bebe: "Okay, then why wasn't the killer's hair on the ground?"

Stan: "The killer got rid of it all and replaced it with others, of course. To remove any trace that they had ever been there and to make it seem like someone else was."

Nichole: "Wait, then that means...!"

Wendy: "Scott isn't the culprit?"

Kyle: "But are you sure we can decide something so important based solely on the replacement of some hair!?"

Craig: "No. There are other reasons that prove Scott couldn't have done it."

Bebe: "I would like to hear these reasons, Craig!"

Craig: "Do you remember anything remarkable about the gym at the scene? Heidi was attacked on the back stage first, then fled to the middle of the gym, right?"

Butters: "Yeah, then they ran after her, caught up to her, and stabbed her."

Craig: "And how did the killer get to her in time? Did they have any trouble with it?"

Bradley: "What do you mean...?"

Craig: "Evidence that the killer had trouble getting to Heidi… I'm talking about the acrylic nail."