A/N: Alright, what is going on, guys? Gussygus28 here, back after a long hiatus from this site. I do apologize for going dark for so long, it's just that I've been kinda on a writer's block and school has kept me really busy. But now that I've graduated, I'm back writing stories on here. And to celebrate my epic comeback, I'm here to bring you all a What If Scenario based on one of my favorite stories on here, and that is Andy and Nica: Dark Legends, written by the very talented PotCFan101. It's basically a massive crossover between the Child's Play franchise and the CW's Arrowverse, with some other horror franchises sprinkled in, I highly recommend that you guys read it and the rest of Potsey's work. Now for this What If, I'm gonna be inserting another horror onto the team and their name is: Gibb Smith from Freddy vs Jason. Now those of you who watched the movie may wondering: "The smoker chick with the red cap? Wasn't she killed by Jason?" Yes, but Potsey wrote a little story called Freddy vs Jason: Jason's Redemption, where he rewrote the film to where Gibb survived the events and forms a connection with Jason. Then he wrote a follow up to that, Constantine vs Freddy, where John Constantine helps her out fighting Freddy. This will pick up two years after that story. And with that recap out the way...

DISCLAIMER: I do not own Andy and Nica: Dark Legends. The original story belongs to PotCFan101. And now... (In Constantine's voice) On with the show...

Waverider, 2017

Andy Barclay, Nica Pierce, and John Constantine have gathered most of the their new team after the Legends Massacre that left the likes of Sara Lance, Mick Rory, Ray Palmer, Nate Heywood, Amaya Jiwe, and Zari Tomaz dead. The members include: Lucifer Morningstar, the Devil himself, Marcus Pierce, or rather his real identity, Cain, the world's first murder, and Chas Chandler, Constantine's longtime friend. But they still need one more member to complete the team.

"Okay, we've got most of our team." Andy said. "We just need to get one person."

"Well Andy, why not just get someone from our other team?" Nica asked her husband. "Someone like Jesse, Kristen, Glen, or even your Mom could be a good help."

"No, they wouldn't." Andy told her. "This is way bigger than a typical supernatural threat. We've already lost Tyler to this, I don't want to lose the others."

"You know what." Constantine said, getting the attention of the others. "I've got an idea: Gibb Smith."

"Who's Gibb Smith?" Nica asked.

"She's an old friend of mine." Constantine informed. "Two years ago, I had to help her take down this bastard named Freddy Krueger, a Dream Demon who kills children in their dreams."

"Hmm, sounds a lot like what Mom and Glen fought the other week." Andy said.

"What do you mean?" Constantine asked him.

"Back when me and Nica fought Anuboll, Mom and Glen travelled to Springwood, Ohio to stop what was mysteriously murdering people in their dreams." Andy told him. "All the while, the Kincaids fought a serial killer in Haddonfield, and Tyler and De Silva went to a camp in New Jersey and fought some zombie in a fucking hockey mask."

"Shit. So the wanker must've come back anyway." Constantine muttered. "I think I should look into that once this is all over."

"Anyways, I guess that's our last member. I take it she lives in Springwood?" Andy asked. Constantine nodded. "Gideon, take us to Springwood."

"With pleasure, Mr. Barclay." The AI Gideon said. And with that, The Waverider takes off to Springwood.

Springwood

Gibb Smith is seen reading a "Magic for Dummies" book. Ever since defeating Freddy Krueger for good, she has been dabbling in the realms of magic for the past two years, much like an old friend of hers, in order to better protect herself. However, due to her still being a beginner, she is nowhere near the level where she should be. The page she reads has instructions on a teleportation spell.

"Sume Nome, Altar A La... Gabrielle's Bedroom!" Gibb chanted, albeit butchering the pronunciation. She closes her eyes in hopes that the spell will work. And then she opens them... and remains at the exact same spot. She sighs in disappointment. A knock is then heard on her doorstep. She walks up to the door and opens it to reveal a man with blonde hair wearing a trench coat. She smiles as she recognized this man anywhere.

"John."

"Hello, Gibb." Constantine said, also smiling. "It's been a long while."

"Yeah, too long of a while." Gibb said. They then hug it out for a good 10 seconds, before Gibb notices a couple people behind John. "I see you've brought a couple friends with you."

"Yes, I have." Constantine said. "We need to talk to you about something."

"Well, make everyone at home." Gibb said, as Constantine and his friends enter the Smith residence. The friends include a man with a beard, a woman with curly brown hair, a man with dark hair wearing a black suit and white shirt, a man with dark hair and a red shirt, and a man with grey and brown beard wearing a green leather jacket. Gibb guesses the taller man was Constantine's friend Chas he once told her about, but it's the shorter man and the woman that really catches her attention.

"You two are..."

"Andy Barclay and Nica Pierce." The shorter man answered. "I take it you've heard of us from the... 'Doll-pocalypse'?"

"Yeah, although trust me, after all the shit I've been through, I would've believe you before then." Gibb said, as she sat on her coach.

"Well thank God it's public." Chas said.

"No, let's not thank Him for anything." the dark haired man said in a British accent. "He wasn't there when we defeated Chucky."

"I'm sorry, who are you?" Gibb asked the man.

"Oh right, where are my manners? My name is Lucifer Morningstar, and this fellow right here is Cain." He said pointing to the other dark haired man.

"Lucifer Morningstar..." Gibb said, getting an idea about the name. "As in..."

"The Devil, yes, exactly, love." Lucifer said, smiling.

"Right..." Gibb said before turning to John. "So, what's up?"

"We need your help." Constantine informed. "We're currently in a fierce battle with a man named Damien Darhk."

"The asshole who threatened the world with missiles last year?" Gibb asked, and John nodded. "Isn't he dead?"

"He was." Cain said. "But he's recently come back to life."

"And he's teaming up with his daughter and a demon known as Mallus." Nica added.

"Okay, so what's this gotta do with me?" Gibb inquired.

"Gibb." Constantine started. "I helped you defeat Krueger two years ago. Because of that, I'd say it's about time you returned the favor by helping me with Darhk. So, what do you say?" There's a long period of silence before Gibb finally answered.

"Ah, fuck it. I ain't got nothin' better to do anyway." Gibb said. "Besides, it could be a way of maybe putting my magical skills to the test."

"You've been practicing magic?" Constantine asked. "That's impressive, love."

"Needed a way to protect myself in case someone like Freddy or worse were to show up." Gibb shrugged, as she grabbed and put on her red cap.

"Alright. Welcome to the Dark Legends, Gibb Smith." Andy said.

"Dark Legends. Smashing name there, Andy." Constantine commented.

"I mean, we've all have had our dark pasts."

"That's debatable for me." Lucifer interrupted.

"And we are pretty much replacing the Legends, so I thought the name made a lot of sense."

"The Legends? Who are they?" Gibb asked.

"They... were a group of friends who ride around a spaceship known as the Waverider and protect the timeline." Andy answered. "You ever seen Timecop? It's kind of like that."

With that, the newly formed Dark Legends leave the house and board the Waverider. Gibb is in awe at the surroundings.

"Wow." she said. "I've seen Dream Demons but this is still a new one even for me."

"That's what I said." Lucifer commented.

"Hello, Gideon." Andy said. "We have our team."

"Hello, Mr. Barclay." Gideon said, once again shocking Gibb. "Do you have a new destination in mind?"

"Yeah, search for anything regarding the Earth totem." Andy requested. "The Anansi, water, and air totems might have been destroyed, but we might be able to find the other three to use against Darhk and Mallus."

"I believe I have found something." Gideon informed. "Apparently, Edward Teach hid some type of treasure in the year 1717 matches the description of the Earth totem."

"Pirate times. Neat." Gibb noted.

"Great. Then that's where we're going." Andy said, sitting down in the captain's chair. "Everyone, strap in." Everyone grabbed a seat, and Andy hits the lever. And with that, The Dark Legends make a time jump exactly three centuries in the past.