Disclaimer: Naturally I don't own Harry Potter, nor do I own the movie "When Harry Met Sally," from whom I *kind of* stole the title. ^^

A/N: I don't know the "official" title for these past-time Hogwarts stories, but to explain, it's when the characters that are adults in the series were students at Hogwarts. =D Enjoy! I've also decided to write a second "chapter," so to speak, so check it out when you finish reading this one! :) (P.S. Reviews are appreciated! ^^)

*NOTE* A reader with a very good eye (and obviously a love for Harry Potter) has pointed out to me that Arthur and Molly Weasley wouldn't have been in school at the same time as the Marauders, but several years before. Oops! So there's a little inconsistency, but it doesn't change the story too much since it's not really about Lily and James anyway. :) (Thanks Madhuri! =D)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"Isn't she wonderful?" sighed Arthur Weasley, gazing longingly across the Gryffindor Common Room.

"Mmhmm," replied his friend James Potter, his face buried in a book.

"No, really look at her," said Arthur dreamily, a smile crossing his face. "She's amazing."

"Yep. Amazing," said James.

Arthur looked over at his friend sitting beside him on the steps. "You're not even looking!" he said, nudging him on the arm.

"Arthur, I know who she is," replied James lazily, looking up from his book and smiling. "She's in practically all of our classes."

Arthur frowned. "Yeah, I know. And still it seems she doesn't know I exist."

James brushed some unruly black hair out of his eyes and grinned. "Sure she does, buddy," he said. "Look, she's staring at you right now."

Arthur's eyes widened behind his round glasses. He spun around and scanned the room. There were thirty or forty other people there, playing Exploding Snap and chess and talking loudly with each other, but he immediately saw who he'd been looking for: Molly Sullivan. She was sitting at a table with three of her friends, including Lily Evans, and they were laughing and talking. Her short red hair was pulled back into pigtails.

Arthur put a hand on his chest and looked at James, who was grinning at him. "She's not staring at me," he whispered anxiously. "Geez, don't scare me like that."

James laughed good naturedly. "It's all in fun, you know that," he said, punching him playfully on the arm. Arthur grabbed his arm on the spot where James hit it when he wasn't looking. "Look, why don't you just go over there and talk to her, if you find her so 'amazing'?"

Arthur looked shocked. "What? No way. I couldn't do that."

"Oh, for Merlin's sake, Arthur, don't be such a baby." James rolled his eyes.

"I'm not a baby!" said Arthur. "I just can't go over there. Besides, what would we talk about? For all I know we haven't got anything in common."

"Well, let's see," James said, putting down his book in his lap. "Do you know anything about Quidditch? Girls like that."

Arthur shook his head no.

"No? Hmm. Well then I guess you're sunk, my friend," said James.

Arthur frowned and put his chin in his hands. "Perfect," he mumbled.

James laughed. "I'm only kidding! Geez, lighten up, Arthur."

"It'd be a lot easier for me to 'lighten up' if you would stop making jokes at my expense," Arthur muttered.

"Alright, well what's your best subject, then?" James asked, moving down a few steps so he was at Arthur's level.

"Oh, that's easy!" cried Arthur, brightening up a good deal, and even managing an excited smile. "Muggle Studies!"

"So go talk to her about that," James suggested.

Arthur turned and looked at James through his round, steel-rimmed glasses. "Talk to her about Muggle Studies?" he asked in disbelief.

"Well, not about the class itself. Go impress her by telling her something you didn't learn in class," said James, smiling slightly.

"Yeah? Like what?" asked Arthur excitedly. His brown eyes glinted brightly, and his red hair hung down over his freckled forehead.

"Oh, you know, you're always lugging around some trinket or another," said James vaguely. "Go show her one of those," he said, then leaned back on the stairs and opened his book again.

"You really think she'll like that?" Arthur asked his friend.

"Yeah, of course," said James, then added, "now let me get back to this book. I'm at a pivotal point."

Arthur grinned and stood up, then turned around and smiled at his friend. "Thanks, James," he said.

James looked up and grinned.