Olivia had been curious about the subject for a long time. She'd never had a man not make any sort of hint or joke about it right off the bat and she loved the shock on their faces when she told them yes with no hesitation.
She'd never understood why men were so determined to ask do anal yet could never believe a woman could like it. Did they ever grow out of wanting something just because they thought they couldn't get it?
Her and Elliot were on the sofa watching a movie when she decided to ask the questions. They'd been dating for a few months now and she felt comfortable enough to start opening up to him.
"Can I ask you something?"
"Hmm." He answer curiously turning to face her. She way laying down with her feet in his lap and he rubs them nervously.
"Why have you never asked to fuck me in the ass?"
Elliot almost chokes, throwing his head back until he notices that she's not laughing with him.
"Because I'm not a delusional 18 year old that thinks a woman will say yes. Is that weird?"
"You think all women say no?" Her eyebrow raises and he falters under her gaze.
"Well I mean… yes?"
Olivia sits up and lowers her voice to a seductive level.
"Women can like it as well El."
"Do you?"
"I'm asking for it aren't I?"
His eyes widen and he feels the stirring in his pants. Olivia even after these years was full of surprises, especially in the bedroom.
Liv smirks and pushes herself off the sofa and moves towards her bedroom, starting to unbutton her blouse as she goes.
"Give it to me Detective."
Elliot wastes no time jumping up and following her to the bedroom, kicking the door closed behind him when they're both inside.
He grabs her waist and leans down to kiss her as his mind plays catch up to what she'd just asked. He'd never done it before, he'd tried when he and Karthy were younger but she'd made it very clear that wasn't happening. In fact this wasn't the first thing that Olivia had let him experience and he was pitifully thankful that he didn't have to die having lived a boring sex life.
They both make quick work of undressing each other. She undoes his belt as she always does, the way her eyes darken as she takes his cock out from his work clothes always makes him cocky. He understands, after all the years he'd fantasised about getting her out of her clothes it still blew his mind that he got to do it.
"Lay down." He tells her when she'd dropped her panties to the floor. "And turn over."
She grins excitedly and does as he says, crawling to the pillows on the other side of the bed and grabbing one to place under her hips as she lays down with her legs spread.
Elliot makes her wait before getting in the bed. He strokes his cock In anticipation as the moments go by. He sees her flinch waiting for him and he grins.
"Are you ready for me Captain?"
"Yesss." She moans and he eventually kneels onto the bed. He reaches out to grab her ass and she moans as he spreads her cheeks.
Elliot leans down and licks from her clit to her entrance and pushes his tongue inside her. She bucks her hips back to his face in response and he removes his tongue, full of her arousal, to her asshole and flicks his tongue over her entrance.
Olivia moans again but this time it's lower, more sinful and he feels his dick react to her.
"In the drawer. The lube." She instructs and he grins at how eager she is.
Olivia grips the pillow in anticipation as she listens to him squirt the liquid on his cock. She could hear the squelching as he covered himself and it made her pussy tingle.
Stationed behind her legs ready to go Elliot pushes two fingers inside her pussy and she moans. He thrusts a few times inside her, gathering her cum on his fingers before moving them to massage at her other hole.
He teases a finger inside her and she lets out a gasp below him. When he enters a second he moans into the pillow but lifts her head to speak.
"I'm ready."
Elliot takes his fingers out and lines his cock up, massaging her entrance with the cum and lube covered fingers.
"Are you sure?"
"Yes. Fuck."
He pushes into her slightly and she flinches, making him still until her arm reaches around to his thigh and guides him. She pulls him towards her until she needs a minute and places her hand on the front of his thigh as a stop sign. They go again until his balls press against her.
Her other hand is between her legs rubbing the bundle of nerves throbbing from the feel of Elliot in her ass and she tells him to start to move.
He starts slowly but she's already pushing back against him and he knows she wants more, that her body is ready, so he takes her hips in both hands and starts to move their bodies in sync.
The feeling of how tight she was around his cock makes his balls clench already. Liv buries her head in the pillow and he is worried until he hears a "yes" be muffled into the pillow and he realises she's just trying to not scream out loud.
"You love that don't you? Fuck Liv, such a hot piece of ass like this should be fucked all the time."
Olivia groans and lifts her head to face her. Her mascara was smudged under her eyes and she looked thoroughly fucked as she bit down on her bottom lip trying to silence her moan.
"Oh god. Faster El."
Her fingers on her clit rub furiously as he fucks into her without holding back. She moans loudly into the pillow and he's shocked to find her pulsating around his dick.
Olivia's hand that's not between her legs clamps onto Elliot's thigh, her nails dig in to hold him in place as she starts to cum. Elliot grabs a handful of her hair, pulling her face up from the pillow to hear her sobbing sounds as the intensity of her orgasm makes her lose all self control to hold back.
The sounds coming from below him are enough to send him over the edge. The sound of her orgasm was always a final step for him but this sound was like she was having multiple at once and he came hard inside her as her fingers still worked between her legs.
She bring her hands from between her legs first and Elliot let's go of her hair. He can tell her whole hand is soaked and it makes him thrust inside her again.
"How hard did you cum liv? Fuck."
She lets out a content moan as he slowly fucks into her as he leans down to kiss the back of her next.
"So are you a fan?" She asks, turning her head slightly.
"You fucking bet I am."