It's been four years later and Christian is starting to move on with his life. He will never forget Satine though, and he will never marry or have children, but he's ok with that. All he cares about is that he had fallen in love and was loved in return.

But at the same time trouble comes back to town, Alfred. This time Christian is ready for him.

"Well Alfred, long time no see."

"Don't even start with your shit Christian, if it wasn't for you I wouldn't have accidentally murdered Satine."

"Well if it wasn't for you, Satine would still be alive and we would have had our family."

"Fine you want Satine back that bad, then consider this a gift from me to you!"

Then Alfred pulled out a gun and pointed it right at Christian and shot him.