At Victor's house, Piper and Leo gather ingredients to make potions.
"Piper, where are you going?" asked Leo.
"I have to find Shax." said Piper.
Piper walked out the door. Leo walked after her, but then heard a call from someone.
"Who is that? Must be a new charge." said Leo.
Leo orbed out.
At P3, A redhead girl paced the ruins of P3. Leo orbed in.
"Leo? What is going on here? Where's Piper? What happened to P3?" asked Paige.
"Piper's fine and P3 shut down 2 years ago. How do you know Piper?" asked Leo.
"I'm her sister, a witch. A Charmed One." said Paige.
Leo looked at her like she was crazy, and started to orb out.
"Wait. I'm your charge, or else you wouldn't have been able to hear me. Take me to Piper." said Paige.
Leo relents, and orbs out with Paige.
Outside the manor, Cole from the real timeline is in this Cole's body. An avatar pleads with him to reconsider, but fails. Cole walks into the Halliwell manor.
In the Halliwell Manor, Phoebe sat on her bed, relaxed. A demon, named Sonya is helping her get dressed. For some reason, Phoebe felt relaxed with Sonya, and it scared her a little.
"Phoebe, we're alone right? You promise you wouldn't say anything to Cole or anyone else downstairs?" asked Sonya.
"I promise." said Phoebe.
"I'm your half-sister, Paige. The Elders changed my appearance, so I could sneak in, and help you. Piper and Leo are working on other things. The Elders have also lost Prue. She disappeared, and they're afraid she might be the new Source." said Sonya.
"No. Prue's the Source." said Phoebe.
"And Piper's on a demon hunt. If we don't stop her, then she could get hurt." said Sonya.
Someone knocked on the door, startling the 2 women.
"Think about it." said Sonya.
Sonya shimmered out. A demon walked in.
"It's time for the surprise birthday." said demon.
"Right." said Phoebe.
She walked downstairs, with the demon.
In the living room, Cole walked in. He is surprised to see the demons everywhere, who are celebrating his birthday. Cole sees the Seer.
"Seer? You're dead." said Cole.
Seer laughed, and the other demons laugh as well. Phoebe walked down the steps, and past Cole. Phoebe walked up to her demon boyfriend. Cole watched as Phoebe and her demonic boyfriend walking upstairs.
"What is she doing with him?" asked Cole.
"Your affairs are well known. Just like you're here with her." said Seer.
A blonde shape shifter walked up to them.
"No." said Cole.
"And then after she gives birth to your child, I can be the mother that you want." said Seer.
Cole ran up the stairs after Phoebe.
"We better report this." said blond woman.
Seer looked annoyed, and walked away to entertain the other guests. Sonya shimmered in.
"Sonya? What's wrong?" asked Seer.
"That's not Cole. He's from another reality, where he chose Phoebe, instead of the Source. And because of it, the 4th witch, Paige, didn't die. The 3 sisters, killed all of the demons in this room, including the 2 of you, as well as the Source." said Sonya.
"How do you know this?" asked Seer.
"I saw an avatar outside. I decided to talk to him, and he was more than willing to share with me, who Cole really is. We just have to find a way to kill Cole, and keep our Cole. Then this reality will be permanent." said Sonya.
"Let's go." said Seer.
Seer and blond shape shifter shimmered out. Sonya shimmered out.
In Phoebe's room, Cole arrived, and saw Phoebe and the demon. They see Cole enter.
"Belthazor." said the demon, a little scared.
Cole threw an energy ball, and killed the demon.
"Cole. What the hell!" said Phoebe.
"Phoebe, he was..." said Cole.
"Oh, now you play the devoting husband. It's a little too late for that." said Phoebe.
"Phoebe, wait." said Cole.
"No. I'm only staying here for Piper. So she doesn't end up like Prue." said Phoebe, leaving.
At the quarry, Leo and Paige orbed in, and saw Piper freeze the demon, and unfreeze his head.
"Where is Shax?" asked Piper.
"I don't know." said demon.
Piper blew up the demon's left hand. The demon screamed.
"Where is he?" asked Piper.
"I don't know." said demon.
Piper blew up his right hand. The demon screamed again.
"Piper?" asked Paige.
Paige and Leo walked up to Piper. Piper blows up the demon.
"Who are you?" asked Piper.
"I'm Paige, your sister." said Paige.
"If this is some lame attempt by the Elders to bring me back, then forget it. I've turned my back on them. They won't bring back Prue, and they made me lose Phoebe." said Piper.
Paige turned to notice an old man walking towards them.
"Victor?" asked Paige.
Victor hurled an athame at Piper. Paige runs, pushing Piper out of the way, and it stabs the Lazarus demon, which reformed itself, and exploded again.
"You all right?" asked Paige.
"Who did that?" asked Piper.
"Your father's evil." said Paige.
Paige pointed to Victor. Victor's eyes glowed black.
"NO! I don't want to lose my father." said Piper.
The Lazarus demon reformed itself a 3rd time, and fired an energy ball. Leo grabbed the 2 sisters, and orbs out. Then orbed next to the Lazarus demon. The energy ball struck Victor, killing him.
"No!" yelled Piper.
Piper blew the Lazarus demon up. Paige scooped up the remains.
"Do you have a container? It's a Lazarus demon. It'll keep reforming, unless we bury it." said Paige.
Piper brought out a bottle, and Paige put the Lazarus demon remains into it.
"Leo, why are you here?" asked Piper.
"You're married. Aren't you?" asked Paige.
"Divorced." said Piper.
"So then, you're not pregnant." said Paige.
"No." said Piper.
"Fine. Take me to Phoebe. She'll listen." said Paige.
"I can't. I'm forbidden to orb to the manor." said Leo.
"Fine. I'll go there myself." said Paige.
Paige walked towards the manor. Leo and Piper looked at each other. Piper walked away to Victor's house, still holding the bottle containing the Lazarus demon. Leo sighed, and orbed out.
At the manor, Phoebe is in the kitchen, when Sonya shimmered in. Paige walked in, startling Sonya.
"Sonya? What's wrong?" asked Phoebe.
"Cole isn't the only one from another reality." said Sonya.
"What do you mean?" asked Phoebe.
"That's the way I'm supposed to look." said Sonya.
"Cole changed reality, so that Piper, you, and me, never met. He took over the manor, and Piper and Leo left, without you." said Paige.
"How is Piper doing?" asked Phoebe.
"She's fine, except that she and Leo are divorced, and that a Lazarus demon killed you father, who had been turned evil." said Paige.
"So it's true. Prue is the Source, and she's trying to kill us." said Phoebe.
Darryl walked into the kitchen.
"Who are you?" asked Darryl.
"She's one of us." said Sonya.
Phoebe recited a spell, removing the evil from Darryl.
Sonya grabbed Darryl, Phoebe, and Paige's hands, and shimmers out.
In the attic, Darryl, Phoebe, Paige, and Sonya shimmered in. Phoebe and Paige gathered potions. The 4 then shimmered out, before any demons arrived.
In the graveyard, Piper arrived, and talked with Leo. Sonya shimmered in with Phoebe, Darryl, and Paige.
"Phoebe?" asked Piper.
"There isn't much time. They're bound to know eventually that I'm not a demon, and got Phoebe and Darryl away from them." said Sonya.
"Who are you?" asked Leo.
Sonya turned into Paige.
"There's 2 of you?" asked Piper.
W Paige- whitelighter, from this reality. Paige- from real reality.
Piper stepped forward, and Paige and Phoebe grab her hands, reconstituting the Power of 3. Piper buried the Lazarus demon.
"If we vanquish Cole, then time will be restored." said W Paige.
W Paige transformed back into Sonya.
"I can't turn back to Paige very long, or I'd merge with the Paige from the other reality." said Sonya.
"Leo, Piper, Phoebe. Get to the ruins of P3. Sonya and I will get Belthazor's flesh and meet you there." said Paige.
Piper, Phoebe, and Leo nodded, and orbed out to get more potions and the Book from Victor's house.
"All right. Let's get going." said Piper.
Leo, Piper, and Phoebe orbed out with the Book of Shadows, and potions. Sonya and Paige shimmered out.
At the manor, Belthazor ordered everyone to find Phoebe. Paige orbed in.
"Tell me, are you always like this in the morning." said Paige.
Cole whirled around, and fired. Paige ducked. Sonya fired, and knocked Cole into the wall. Paige cut a piece of Cole's flesh from his hand, and ran up to Sonya. Sonya and Paige shimmered out.
"FIND THE WITCHES! SONYA BETRAYED US, AND JOINED THEM!" said Cole.
"On the contrary, she was just getting the witches out of our line of fire." said a familiar female voice.
Cole whirled around to see the Seer. A being flamed in. The flames die down, revealing the robed Source.
"The Source." said Cole.
"You betrayed me in the reality you come from. We want our Belthazor back, not the traitor from another reality." said Prue/Source.
Belthazor shimmered out, before they can harm him.
At P3, Piper, Leo, and Phoebe waited for Paige and Sonya. Paige and Sonya shimmered in, and handed Piper the flesh. Piper and Phoebe made the potion, and soon it's ready.
"We have to find Belthazor." said Piper.
Belthazor shimmered in.
"Looks like he found us." said Paige.
"You have to help me. The Source found out who I really am." said Cole.
"I know. I told the Seer." said Sonya.
"Why?" asked Paige.
"In case Piper and Phoebe didn't unite in time, I could sense the change in you, so I decided to see what the Source would do." said Sonya.
"You've got to help me." said Cole.
"We'll help you." said Paige.
"Potion." said Paige.
A container of potion appeared in Paige's hand. Piper froze Cole.
"Goodbye, Cole." said Paige.
"No." said Phoebe.
Phoebe took it from Paige. Cole unfroze, and saw Phoebe.
"You don't want to do this Phoebe." said Cole.
"I do. You changed reality, which kept Piper away from me, and killed the sister I never knew about until now." said Phoebe.
"Cole? If you were going to change reality, you should have made it so Prue never died." said Paige.
"Yes. Instead you created a reality, where we will never be together. Goodbye, Cole." said Phoebe.
Phoebe threw the potion at Cole, who exploded. Paige vanished in white lights, and Sonya is turned into Paige, and made alive again.
"You're alive, now?" asked Piper.
"Yes. Why didn't reality return to normal?" asked Paige.
"Because Cole created this reality, and unfortunately it remains. The 3 of you are now, the Charmed Ones. Prue is alive, if you strip the powers of the Source from her, then we'll have the Power of 4." said Leo.
"Let's go." said Piper.
Piper, Phoebe, and Paige collected the potions, and Book of Shadows. They orbed out with Leo, leaving nothing important behind.
In the real reality, Paige returns, and tells a pregnant Piper, and Phoebe what happened.
At the penthouse, the 3 sisters arrive to discover an empty penthouse.
"It looks like he's gone." said Phoebe.
"I hope for good this time. For all of our sakes." said Piper.
Piper and Phoebe walked into the elevator.
"Happy Birthday, Cole." said Paige.
The 3 sisters orbed out as the elevator closes.
