Will Carrie be able to stand up to Michael Myers? What about Allyson and Sue? Contains sexual content!
"She'll never want to have anything to do with you after all of this!" Sue threatened.
"Oh? What you think you and her are forever or something?"
"Wait," Sue said, noticing Carrie had been gone an awful long time, it was eerily quiet with not a single sign of her, "Where did she go?"
Allyson looked all around, "Shit! Why weren't you watching her?!"
"ME?! WHAT ABOUT YOU, BITCH?!"
The two shoved each other and took off running to where they thought they had witnessed Carrie run off to.
"CARRIE!"
"CARRIEE!"
They found Carrie limp on the ground; they feared the worst. They got down on their knees and looked the poor girl over, no cuts on her just some scrapes, her face was red but otherwise no blood on her. Sitting up on the grass now, Allyson picked Carrie up into her arms and rocked her as she hugged her, "Oh, Carrie! I'm so sorry! I should've been watching you!"
Carrie let out a groan, Sue slapped at Allyson and took Carrie away, "You're hurting her!"
Allyson backed off, she felt awful for screwing up, letting her petty jealousy get the better of her, no doubt Laurie would be angry their secret weapon was left on her own and couldn't take on the lumbering monster by herself.
"I'm taking you home," Sue whispered to her.
Allyson didn't want to just abandon Carrie, she felt so responsible for her that she had to make sure that she was safe. When she was able to talk she told Allyson Michael was close to killing her but she managed to get him to backoff, she was able to use some of her power on him before she blacked out. She said she remembered seeing blood coming out of one of the eye holes of the mask. Allyson was glad to hear that she hurt him, maybe he would be a lot weaker, easier for them to defeat before Halloween.
Carrie was still shaken, she didn't leave the kitchen table after Sue sat her down, she drank a pitcher's worth of water. Sue's mother watched this with concern, bad enough she hadn't seen her in the past two days and having to deal with Sue bouncing off the walls worrying, "Carrie, how are you? We missed you around here."
Carrie was still dry and needed to finish another glass before she could answer, "Fine, Mrs Snell. I...I've been busy."
Sue and Allyson stood in the hallway arguing about what to do, "This is stupid."
"No it isn't," Allyson insisted, "We'll prove once and for all who's the better woman."
"Carrie obviously," Sue said, rolling her eyes.
Allyson sighed, "I know that, Sue! I meant who is the best woman for Carrie! God! Do you ever let people finish?"
Sue regretted this already, "You and I both already know deep down who it is. She obviously prefers blondes anyway," she said, flipping her long hair back for the brunette to get a good look.
Allyson snickered, "Yeah, but I'm sure personality is more important to her."
Sue scoffed, "Oh, like you have one!"
Allyson turned away from Sue and went into the kitchen.
Carrie was still talking to Sue's mother when Allyson swooped in and kissed Carrie on the cheek; Carrie and Sue's mother were a little surprised, if only they looked over in the hallway they might not see Sue in the darkness but they could maybe see her eyes lit up with jealousy.
"Are you ok, Carrie? Do you need anything?"
Carrie was a bit off guard, she was going to say something but Sue walked in and kissed Carrie on the other cheek, "Do you want to sleep in my room tonight? You know like old times?" She looked up at Allyson after saying this, sneering.
It was all like Sue's mother wasn't even there, she decided to make herself scarce and go into the living room to occupy herself.
Carrie eventually decided to stay at Sue's for the night, she would see Allyson soon. Word that the Halloween dance had been moved to the night before Halloween had spread with no explanation but Allyson knew the truth just that no one wanted to confess being scared.
Sue knew Carrie was hesitant about going to the Halloween dance but chances were they would still have time to kill the boogeyman, plus she had already found the perfect costume to wear.
"I just know you're gonna love it."
"Well I mean you should only wear it if you want to," Carrie told her, she sat on Sue's bed watching her move things around her closet.
"Oh I want to wear it but it'll be all worth it when I see the look on your face."
Carrie was still trying to understand Sue and Allyson's feelings for her they admitted before she was almost killed.
"Sue...I..."
Sue stopped destroying her closet for a minute, "You don't care what that skank wears do you?"
Carrie never got used to the insults Sue and Allyson threw at each other, "Sue, please stop saying things like that about Allyson."
Sue didn't want to face Carrie, the more worked up she got the more she wanted to angry cry, "Do you...love her?" Sue finally put her clothes aside to face her.
Carrie couldn't remember ever seeing Sue this upset before, "I love both of you."
Not the answer Sue wanted, it wasn't even evident if Carrie knew about the kind of love she was talking about. Sue sat down on the bed next to her and took her hand, "Carrie, " she spoke softly, "You want know why Tommy and I broke up?" Carrie didn't say anything, she let Sue talk, "That night...," Sue wiped away a tear and laughed, "That night I was with Tommy we were in his car, we were well supposed to do it that night. It was both our first time so we wanted it to be special. We were kissing, our clothes weren't even off yet, my eyes were closed and as things go more intense I...I...," it was too painful to say, too scarring to repeat her own words. Sue remembered she had her head against the window as Tommy kissed her neck, "Carrie!" she called out, she never forgot the look on his face when he stopped a moment to look at her, figure out if what he just heard really came out of his long term girlfriend's mouth. She let it all out for Carrie, no going back.
Sue could tell Carrie was confused, "I-I didn't know what came over me at the time but I know now...," she trailed off, "I know now that I didn't want to be with Tommy...I wanted to be with you."
Carrie allowed this to sink in, she could feel it in the pit of her stomach, these feelings she didn't fully understand, "I really like you, Sue...I really like Allyson too...I just don't know...," she lowered her head, the last thing she wanted to do was disappoint Sue.
Sue assured she hadn't with a peck on the lips, when Carrie opened her eyes, Sue was the one turning red, "Sorry," she said, turning away but Carrie wanted her to stay right there, she held onto Sue and took some charge in kissing her. The tall blonde sat in Carrie's lap, her hands all over her, maybe a bit too grabby but she had been holding back for so long. Carrie got the shock of her life when Sue took her top off, Carrie covered her eyes, "Dirty pillows!"
Sue gigged, she was still wearing a bra, "Come on, it's ok, promise."
She let Carrie feel them, her hands were so big, strong Sue had dreamed of them touching her, she knew how Carrie would love feeling how soft she was.
"GIRLS! DINNER!"
Carrie jumped, knocking Sue on the floor, rather than be upset, Sue laughed, giving permission for Carrie to laugh too, they would need to pick this up later.
Allyson spilled everything to her grandmother, how she really messed up and could have gotten Carrie killed but she wouldn't let her beat herself up over it, she told her about what she heard from an officer earlier, a body matching the description of Michael was found in a ditch just a half a mile out of town but she didn't want to get her hopes up.
"We still have to be vigilant this Halloween."
Allyson bit her lip, she wasn't sure she'd go for this, "So I was thinking of going to the dance, it's the night before Halloween and well..."
"Good."
She was not expecting that, "Good?"
"Michael could still be around, he could target any one of those kids. Having Carrie there will be like sneaking in a weapon of mass destruction. If he shows it'll be game over," she said this, checking her bullets.
"I'm just worried that..."
"What? She's tough, right? She wants to stop him before he does this again."
"Yeah..."
"Look, Ally, I know you love her but this is huge."
Allyson didn't tell her about how childish she acted, how she showed her ass at the Spirit Halloween just to compete against that impossible girl. Before Allyson left to head back home, Laurie whispered, "Wear a sexy cat costume. I think she'd like that," Laurie took a peek at her granddaughter's backside, "And don't be afraid to show off. Really stick it to that prissy bitch."
Allyson's jaw stayed open.
Carrie came down the stairs wearing a bunny costume, one not made for children but not as a sexy costume either, she mainly just kept the white ears and the bottom half of the bunny getup, fluffy pants and the big feet with the suspenders, the rest was just a jean jacket. When Sue finally came out of the bathroom and stepped downstairs she could tell Carrie was floored, she wasn't the only one, Sue's mother thought her tits were going to pop out of that purple corset.
"What are you even supposed to be?"
Sue lifted her skirt and did a curtsey, those knee high boots and period piece clothes, she did look very witch like, "I'm one of the Sanderson Sisters."
Her mother frowned and looked her over, "The Sarah Jessica Parker one?"
Sue struck a pose, making sure to stick out her thigh enough so Carrie got a good look. Carrie and Sue posed together for pictures before heading out to the dance, Sue's mother
Sue and Carrie couldn't tell anyone apart at the dance, Sue could only just hope that Allyson and Michael Myers stayed far away tonight, Allyson especially.
'Maybe I can convince Carrie that Allyson is on that creep's side,' Sue thought, 'I mean I don't care if she dies or whatever but maybe she could rough her up a bit.'
"Hi, Carrie!"
Carrie was startled by the girl dressed all in black with this cat mask on; though her mouth was exposed, even Sue had trouble placing her, it defiantly wasn't Chris.
"Ally...," Carrie couldn't even finish, Allyson grabbed her face and pulled her in for the deepest kiss she ever had.
Sue stood there like she was stuck in time, Allyson might as well have slapped her across the face, it was that big of an impact. Allyson put Carrie's arm in hers and smiled, "Coming, Sue?" Sue took a moment to get moving, when she saw the back of Allyson she saw that her ass was at least covered but she was wearing what looked like some kind of black spandex like Jeggings which was almost like wearing nothing, her ass was perfectly shaped and stuck out for Carrie to see. Sue had a delayed reaction following them inside, she didn't even notice Chris or Billy by the door. The two were dressed like a biker gang, they saw everything, Billy commented on it looking like Carrie was about to get very lucky tonight while Chris wanted to barf but also go inside and see where this went.
Carrie was lost in a confusion of people, loud music and strobe lights but kept up with Allyson, though she could hardly make out what she was saying she followed her dance moves; of course it had to be a fast song, it was Halloween, no chance for anything slow.
"Cute costume!" She said loudly, cupping her hands so Carrie could hear.
"Thank you! You're a nice kitty!"
Allyson chuckled because it sounded like something more inappropriate, she meant to say. Sue bumped between them to interrupt what she found to be an unholy union. She rubbed up against Carrie, making sure her breasts were in Carrie's view the whole time, at one point they were almost in her face. Carrie was feeling strange when this sexy witch rubbed her body against hers, gyrating like she was on spring break; this was even out of character for her, this was something Chris would be trying to get her to do with her to attract a guy. Allyson stood back a moment and folded her arms, she thought a teacher or someone might put a stop to this but looked like they were on their own. With that uncomfortable look on Carrie's face, Allyson knew that it was time to cool off.
"Ok, you're a sexy peasant we get it!"
Sue pulled away from Carrie and got in Allyson's face, "I'm Sarah Sanderson, moron!"
Allyson shoved her when she was getting too close, "You're acting like a slut!"
Sue pushed back harder, "I'm acting like a slut?!"
Carrie looked all around them, some people stopped what they were doing and waited for a potential catfight to break out, she stepped between the two feuding girls with her arms out, maybe it was seeing what idiots they were both acting like or the energy Carrie might have been passing through them but they decided to back off and share Carrie. Carrie was caught between the sexy cat and the sexy witch, she was confused by their looks, like they were sleepy, both went in for a kiss, they took turns tasting her lips. Carrie did feel more relaxed, in some ways the more she touched them the more she felt like she was in control for once.
Both girls took turns grinding against and lip locking with Carrie. No one really paid them any attention; Carrie could only see the lights and a window behind the DJ. There he was, it had to be, standing outside the gym. No one else had that mask, she knew she had to say something, but Sue and Allyson were very persuasive with their bodies; seemed like she could get used to this kissing thing.
To be continued!