Just wanted to give you all an update since I didn't say anything in the last chapter.

Arc 2 I've got a solid summary In the works and this is were the paths REALLY start to diverge from canon especially Roswall for obvious reasons. I've seen alot of people concerned about Subarus role in the overall story and while I've already gave my 2 cents on him being forced into a support role, this Subaru WILL NOT be overpowered by any means till much later in the story. He simply dosen't have enough time to hone his skills In any meaningful way. But trust and believe once he has time to train and starts to take proper steps to becoming stronger he's gonna be an absolute MONSTER!

Now as for Emilia... OH BOY alot of people are not gonna like this version of her for a short while. Just like Subaru she puts others well being before her own except instead of being alone in her suffering like Subaru, she's actively hated against and that can reeeeally mess with someone's world view especially when the one person that's actually nice to you keeps dying over and over again. This will have the benefit of her being a much more competent leader though. While Subaru will keep the camp mentally sound, Emila would be the actual forefront of her candidacy instead of relying on Subarus accolades to have any real chance in the election. Everything that happens will be due to HER WILL not Subarus weither it be good or bad.

As for RETURN BY DEATH... like I said previously the burden is shared, not completely on Emilia or Subaru. What that means for the duo you'll simply have to wait and see. That's kinda what I want the theme of this what-if to be, sharing the burden.

Another thing I feel the need to comment on before there's any confusion. Subarus interactions with the main cast will be... more natural to put it lightly. Subaru having insight to everyone's personality due to return by death, while useful in a crisis, can make him seem rather unnatural and downright untrustworthy. Since the character dynamics will be built around his intinital conversations and no rbd messing with his psyche, the people in the mansion especially Ram and Beatrice will be alot less hostile as his intentions will be alot easier to read. This will work in Emilias favor for alot of reasons that I don't want to spoil yet.

Again I want to thank you all that have commented on this crazy what-if so far. like I said my writing is mediocre at best so I hope you can all give me some insight to better convey the story. I really like those reaction fics so if someone wants to play around with this concept or even do there own twist with it by all means go for it! I'll be doing a QA midway through arc 2 so get all your questions out of the way. I'll answer any that aren't to spoiler heavy.

Last but not least a couple of lines I can't wait to get to in the story. There random lines completely out of context.

Think of them as teaser trailers.


"Ya see garf? We can do anything by working with eachother!!"

"Just shut da fuck up you idiot.

"hey garfiel. we beat em right?"

"Yeah. He's a puddle of blood now"

"then who's that guy?"

"OH YA GOTTA BE FACKIN' KIDDING ME!!"

"huff huff hehe well Garf... You take the 500 on the right huff huff and ill take the 500 on the left."

"piss off I'll take 500 n 1!"

"THATS THE SPIRIT!!"


hah* *hah* Enough of your dribble half wit! Your constant blabbering is making my brain melt!"

"Jeez Prisca-san *hah* *hah* didnt realize I had that much of an effect on you.~"

"Ugh your jester seems to have rubbed off on you! Your both complete idiots!"

"Sure sure tsundere, you can yell your head off once we kill this son of bitch!"

"Hmph as if mineself needs your help with something as trivial as this!"


"Once this "alliance" is over I will make sure your death is slow and painful"

"dully noted... looking forward to it"


"Your far cry from that simp of a priest, MEATBAG!"

"I've been Itching to try this out without Trixe nagging at me! ORIONS FIST: HUNTER MODE!!"


"On my honur as a knight and for the one I call a friend I WILL STRIKE YOU DOWN!"

"Then lets see you try it "Finest knight"!"

"AL CLAUZERIA!!"


"Not matter what route you take it will end in tragedy. Your conviction means nothing when you come face to face with the devil. My teacher has left me with nothing... and you have left me less than nothing."


"Emilia... who are you talking about?"