WARNING: Rated R for a reason!!! CHAPTER contains 'naughty' things!

SURPRISE by eLLe

Chapter 2- Suspicious Screams

James continued to kiss Lily's neck as his hands wandered her body. Lily threw her head back and she grasped onto his shoulders, she began pushing her hips upwards as he pushed downwards. This closeness and sensation made both of them moan. The temperature in the room was rising dramatically.

James' sweaty hands found Lily's inner thigh. He began running his hands up and down, getting nearer and nearer to her sensitive area, she shivered with pleasure. She didn't know what was going to happen next, whether or not they'd take it a bit further. He had always been James Potter the arrogant bully. She would never admit she found him attractive, but her body and mind told her otherwise. There were times where she'd drift off and accidentally think of him sexually, but the opportunity had never presented itself and in the back of her mind she'd been longing for this. And now that it had, she was sort of freaking out. But one thing was taking over her. Her hormones.

All she knew was that she wanted something to happen, she wanted action, she craved it, she welcomed it, she needed it.


James looked up to see Lily's face demanding more. He smirked.

"May I" he asked, with a cheeky grin. She nodded quickly and closed her eyes.

With Lily's permission he slid his hand up to the garter of her panties. He pulled them off slowly and gently, as if taking care with this fragile and delicate beauty.

Lily giggled "You're taking your time"

James got the hint and threw Lily's panties across the room. Before Lily knew what was happening she felt his fingers between the folds of her vagina and suddenly he pushed them inside her. She bit down on her lip, suppressing the scream that was about to come out. He proceeded in thrusting his fingers deeper and quicker inside of her, while his thumb moved in a circular motion on her clit. Suddenly, she felt something she'd never felt before, an indescribable pleasure that could be felt throughout her body.

"JAMES" she screamed at the top of her lungs, the pleasure was too good to not scream.

He withdrew his fingers from her moist, warm centre and rolled on the floor next to her.

Their friends who had been swimming heard her scream and found it quite suspicious. They swiftly got out of the pool and stealthily made their way to where they thought the scream had come from: Lily's room.

Lily was breathing deeply. James, who was lying next to her on the floor, was looking at how beautiful she was. The moonlight was beaming through the curtains and was lighting up Lily's face.

"God you're beautiful" he whispered.

Lily turned to face him "Thanks"

Caught in the moment she leaned in and kissed him. It wasn't a soft, slow, gentle kiss. It was a fast, passionate, and rough kiss. Lily broke the kiss and climbed onto his stomach, sitting on him. James leaned up and brought Lily's face down to his and started kissing again. Lily's wandering hands found the button for his pants, she unbuttoned the button and unzipped the zip. As she slid his pants and boxers off, her body went further and further down his body. By the time his pants and boxers were around his ankles, her head was hovering above his dick and her hands were sliding down his firm stomach towards his 'family jewels'.

"KNOCK KNOCK" yelled Sirius, as he opened the door of Lily's bedroom.

Nobody could see Lily's room clearly, all they saw was the outline of her stuff and the odd outline of two people on the floor. In a very compromising position. There was the sound of Sirius searching for something and then all was revealed.

"Oh, here's the light gitchimaboobi" exclaimed Sirius as he found the light switch.

"OH MY GOD" yelled their friends.

What they saw frightened and shocked the hell out of everyone! James was on the floor with his legs spread out and Lily was between his legs and on her knees facing his dick. Because Lily was wearing a short skirt with no panties they could see her white bottom, since she was bending forward. Apparently cats had caught all of their tongues. Silence resounded throughout the Evans' residence.

Lily quickly got up, leaving James privates exposed.

"Wow James, you've got a bigger dick than Sirius" exclaimed Annabel, examining James' dick.

Sirius' jaw dropped and he stared at Annabel "You told me ten minutes ago that mine was the biggest you've ever seen"

The girls giggled "Anny says that to all the guys" remarked an amused Emily who was watching Lily looking frantically for her underwear.

Meanwhile, James stood up and was putting on his pants as everyone continued to watch. "Excuse me guys, I think we need some privacy" yelled James in frustration.

Everyone laughed at him.

"Nuh, uh-uh, Prongs" teased Remus "If we leave, you guys might pick up where you left"

"Ha-ha, very funny Moony. But me and Evans here (he pointed to the Lily who was looking under the bed) weren't doing anything" exclaimed James.

Sirius snorted "So you're saying that you're half naked with no boxers on and Evans -" he never got to finish what he was going to say because Lily leant back on the wall and slid down, landing on the ground with a THUMP. She brought her knees up to her chest and wrapped her arms around them.

All of the girls sighed and exchanged sideward glances.

"This is the part where she cries" mumbled Michelle as the girls made their way to Lily.

"Always happens, 'member that time when she was smashed and cried about forgetting to make her bed that morning" whispered Annabel.

"She only cries when she's smashed" muttered Emily "And she cries about the stupidest things. She's an emotional wreck when she's smashed"

The girls had made their way to Lily and were comforting and hugging her. The boys just leant against the wall watching them try and calm down Lily.

"Oh, it's my entire fault" sobbed Lily "I'm sorry for being such a bad friend! I always promise I won't drink this much, but I always do. I'm so sorry guys. I can never keep a promise"

"Oh, Lily" soothed Annabel as she hugged Lily "Don't say that. Hey you even made your bed today"

"OH ANNY" squealed Lily as she continued to cry "I love you, have I ever told you that. Oh I love you too Michelle and Emily. I love you all"

"Group Hug" yelled Michelle as the girls hugged each other.

*******************************KITCHEN**********************************

20 minutes later the group was seated around the kitchen table.

"So if we take this we'll sober up?" asked Emily, referring to the potion David had been given from his dad.

"Yeah, Dad told me to have a sip and you'll be fine" explained David as he passed it around the table.

It had been around the table and now everyone was sober and confused. The things they had done tonight, had been remember and finally sunken in.

"Oh my God" exclaimed Annabel as she put her head in her hands "Did I give you head Sirius?"

"Well, you tried" sighed Sirius nonchalantly "I never came though, you know you should work on your sucking. You really do need to improve"

Annabel turned crimson in embarrassment "Well maybe YOU need to grow a dick"

Annabel was like the baby in their group. She always relied on the others and was afraid of the dark. When they were first years she always had to sleep in the 5th year's dormitory with her elder sister, as the years went on the girls woke up to a sleeping Annabel next to them. That's why she was considered the baby. But she was a beautiful young lady, she was a younger version of Catherine Zeta Jones. She looked so pure and innocent, but her looks deceived her. The same girl who was afraid of the dark had lost her virginity two years ago, and gave pleasure to guys she's just met or didn't even know that well. She wasn't a slut, she was just easy.

"Excuse me Annabel, but I think I have a great dick" exclaimed Sirius "Come upstairs with me and I'll prove it"

Annabel stamped her foot on the ground and yelled "FINE"

The two disappeared upstairs. Then there was six.

"I don't even want to know what they're doing" mumbled Lily as she hit her head on the table.

"Well, Michelle and I are gonna clean outside and try and get Matt and Hilary to wake up" explained David as he stood up "Matt, Michelle, Hilary and I are gonna go home at midnight. We have to be home then"

"Yeah it's only 11ish we'll probably get it done" said Michelle as she smiled and took David's hand.

The two disappeared outside. Then there was four.

Emily sat next to Lily "It's as if everyone's pairing off" she sighed and looked longingly at Remus who was teasing James.

"Em, I can't believe I let him finger me" whispered Lily "I always said I'd have to be in a relationship to do that shit. I promised myself I wouldn't turn into Annabel"

"Lily, come on. You've broken that promise before. Edward Davies. You did 'everything but' with him" whispered back Emily "You didn't complain about him"

"But I actually liked him" moaned Lily.

"So you don't like James?" asked Emily.

"I hate him" mumbled Lily.

Emily chuckled "You guys seemed pretty comfortable when we came in"

Lily's stood up and stormed off into the sitting room. James followed her.

The two disappeared into the sitting room. Then there was two.

"Remus" called Emily "I'm bored"

Remus smiled "So am I"

"Let's snog" suggested Emily. Before they knew it they were snogging on the kitchen table.

**************************SITTING ROOM**********************************

Lily didn't notice that James had followed her. She was sighing and mumbling the entire way to the sitting room. She threw herself on the big couch and buried herself into a pillow. She threw the pillow away and yelled-

"I wish I could take back the things I did with Lucas (first boyfriends), William (fling), Davies (fling) and Potter" she yelled into the room "I want to be the innocent girl I used to be. Not the 'easy slut who you can get pissed and do shit with' girl. I want to be my daddy's Silly Lily and my mommy's Water Lily. I want to be their little innocent girl again"

She fell into the couch and started crying. James scrunched up his face and awkwardly made his way to her and patted her back. Obviously he didn't know how to comfort someone. Lily, desperate for comfort turned around and hugged him. She didn't care that he was Potter, all that mattered was that he was there.

James was taken aback and continued to pat her back, but the awkwardness faded as she hung onto him tighter so he hugged her instead of patting her back.

"Silly Lily" he said quietly "Water Lily"

"Potter" she mumbled into his chest.

"Come on Evans, you didn't go that far with me. I'm not that bad of a mistake am I?" he tried to comfort her.

"Potter, do you know what my mother said to me on this couch today?" asked Lily, she did not wait for an answer "She told me you were my happiness"

"Do I make you happy?" asked James hopefully.

"NO" mumbled Lily "You don't make me happy. You're who you are. I can't change you and I don't want to change you. You are who you are. And I just don't feel it with you. You aren't my happiness"

"Oh, ok" whispered James "You seem tired you should go to bed. We'll fix up the house by tomorrow. Don't worry"

James released Lily from his embrace, but Lily held on. "Evans, I think you should go to bed" Lily slowly released her grip allowing James to get up and walk away.

"G'night Potter" said Lily to James' back.

James didn't turn around, he kept walking to the kitchen. "G'night my happiness" he mumbled so that he could only hear.

Lily made her way up the stairs and was turning the corner when she bumped into Sirius zipping up his fly.

"Hey Evans" screamed Sirius "Where you goin?"

"Sleep" Lily said with a yawn "I'm tired"

"NO you cannot" demanded Sirius "I haven't played my game yet"

"Sirius I'm tired. PLEASE" Lily pleaded.

"No, you're going to play 'SIRIUS SAYS….' with the rest of us" demanded Sirius. He grabbed her around the butt and put her over his shoulders. She giggled as he bounced up and down the stairs. He carried her all the way to the kitchen and dropped her on the table where Remus and Emily where snogging.

"ATTENTION!" Sirius yelled "We're going to play 'SIRIUS SAYS…' gather round, gather round"

The grandfather clock in the dining room struck midnight.

"Sorry Sirius, we have to go home" apologised Matt with disappointed written all over his face.

"Have fun playing Sirius says" said David with a cheeky smile on his face.

"Bye" everyone said as Matt, David, Michelle and Hilary left the house.

"Sirius, what is SIRIUS SAYS…..?" asked Lily.

J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J

DISCLAIMER- nothing you recognise belongs to me

J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J

A/N- So……..what is Sirius Says……? Chapter 3- Sirius Says……

REVIEW review REVIEW review REVIEW review REVIEW review REVIEW review

J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J J

THANKS TO ALL MY REVIEWERS

Meg

J.E.A.R.Potter

Ruth3

lilbird – I'm sure Paolo Santos sang it, but I'm not sure if he wrote it. Sorry! The version I had was by him so that's what I wrote. Thanks for pointing it out.

freakyfroggurl22

B-a-B-i

lilynjamesAAF

Softballgrl89