I Slept With My Sister's Boyfriend
Disclaimer: Unfortunately, Joss Whedon, Marti Noxon, Twentieth Century Fox Productions, UPN, Sandollar Television, and Mutant Enemy own BtVS. No copyright infringements were intended. This is my story and not meant to copy the show.
Summary: Buffy is in high school 15 years old. She and her friends decide to go to a frat party. There she meets a guy called Spike who is 19 years old but she doesn't know he is her sister's boyfriend so she sleeps with him at the party!! Read to find out what happens!!
Chapter 5 - Family
Saturday Morning 10:30am – Buffy's Room
Buffy wakes up and finds herself lying on something warm. She opens her eyes.
OH SHIT!!! Why I am in a bed with SPIKE!!!
She looks under the sheets.
AND NAKED!!! I really screwed up!! OH CRAP!! What I am gonna do??? Think brain think!! I could sneak out!! Yeah!! Wuss! I am not I just need some fresh air…that's all…but he spent the night that was really sweet…I know but I just need to get out of here!!!
Buffy starts to climb out
Spike: Going somewhere pet?
Buffy: Oh! Your awake…I was going to get something to…to…..EAT! yeah get something to eat.
Spike: You don't have to lie I understand.
Buffy climbs back in the bed.
Buffy: Okay then I was gonna go out for a while to clear my head…because I'm really confused here and I'm really, really sorry for coming on to you last night. I blame it on me being pregnant because I've been really desperate for sex and you were here so I kinda just jumped at the chance so I completely understand if it was a one off thing. So it would be just great if you left now before I have a breakdown cause I've had enough rejection from you to last me life- time. Trust me and I wont tell your friends or anything I think I've done enough damage to them as it is…and its okay if you don't want to come to the appointment today cause it probably-
Spike: Bloody hell! Women would you be quiet! You're giving me a head- ache! And last night changed things okay! I'm not going to make the same mistake again and use you ! The only reason I dumped you was because of Gwen she was gonna report me and get me arrested or something so I had to break up with you! But I'm really sorry I caused you so much pain lu-Buffy. When I told you I cared about you I meant it, I wasn't using it to get into your pants. And I really wanna be with you and be a family and maybe fall in love…..buy house everything, I'm willing to spend the rest of my life with you.
Buffy: (crying) Oh my gosh! You really mean it…
Spike: Yeah I do.
Buffy: Wow! This…this is very overwhelming and it's a lot to take in…
Spike: So what do you say are you willing to forgive me and we can start over?
Buffy: Oh course! Yes! because its everything I've ever wanted a real family….That's why I left this summer.
They hug.
Spike: Where did you go?
Buffy: New York. It's where my real Mom, my birth mother stayed and I wanted to find out about her and I managed to narrow down where she lived because my Mom had the adoption papers and stuff. And when I got there I found out the original owners had moved out a week ago….and the lady who owned it was called Lillian Summers!! She has my last name and then I asked them if they knew where they moved to and they said somewhere in California but they didn't know where. So I spent the whole summer searching L.A, San Francisco and other places but no one could trace the name. So I gave up and came back home to Sunnydale.
Spike: I'm sorry Buffy, but hasn't your mother pass-
Buffy: No! She hasn't! she – I just know okay! I can feel it, I can feel that's she's out there somewhere.
Spike: But what about what Joyce said
Buffy: Well Lillian's last name is Summers so I figured she must be in some way related to Joyce they could be cousins or even maybe sisters!! I know it sounds a bit crazy Spike but it could explain all the lies. I mean Joyce told Gwen my Mom was an alcoholic and drug user, but in her diary she says that Lillian died giving birth to me.
Spike: did she mention the name Lillian?
Buffy: Well no…but its probably so no one would read it and suss out everything
Spike: So are you going to still look for her then?
Buffy: Yes there are millions of towns I'll have to go to I mean California is big!
Spike: Well have checked here in Sunnydale yet?
Buffy: Funny you should mention that but no
Spike: Well I think you should you never know.
Buffy: I guess so…but I think I should go take a shower and get dressed. You can come too….if you want. I could you use some company. Someone to….to scrub my back.
Spike: Is that supposed to turn me on, or something because you are failing miserably.
Green Avenue
1.30pm
Buffy is walking down the street in a rush to get to the hospital when she stops in front of house. There are men moving in furniture and a sign on the lawn saying SOLD. Just then a girl who looks a few years younger than Buffy comes over and greets her.
: Hey! You lost!
Buffy: No sorry….just….so your new then
: Yep! How'd you guess?
Buffy: I don't know I have these telepathic abilities.
: (laughs) Cool so I'm Dawn. Dawn Summers by the way.
Buffy: Buffy. Buffy Summers…….
Dawn: Cool we have the same-
Buffy: Wait a minute. What's your Mom's name is Lillian
Dawn: You can read minds!
Buffy: No trust me I can't…would it be okay if I spoke to your Mom.
Dawn: Did I do something wrong…Miss-
Buffy: Hey I'm only 15 I'm no 'Miss'
Dawn: Get out! I've just turned 15 and you should look around my age! And not pregnant.
Buffy: Well I'm more mature anyway can I please just talk to her it's urgent.
Dawn: Fine then. Come on.
Dawn then lead her into the house.
Dawn: Mom!!!! Someone's here to see you!!!!
A women around 5'6 with blonde wavy hair and green eyes comes down the stairs. She looks very similar to Buffy.
Buffy: (gasp) Oh my God.
Lillian: Are you okay miss? And what can I help you with?
Buffy: I'm sorry I'm just. (takes a breath) Do you know Joyce? Joyce Summers?
Lillian: Yes she's my older sister I've not seen or spoken to her in about 15 years.
Buffy: Okay. Do you know anyone called Buffy. Buffy Anne Summers.
Lillian: What is this 20 questions I don't know who you are but could you please leave and if you don't I will phone the police! Plus my husband will be here soon!
Buffy: (near tears) Please don't I'm really sorry I just needed to-
Dawn: Oh my God!!! Your Buffy Summers right!! then why are you-
Lillian: (shocked) Your Buffy??
Buffy: Yes I am. And I'm really sorry I bothered you but I just wanted to know if what Joyce told me was true that-
Lillian: Wait a minute I think we should talk in private. Dawn sweetie could you go upstairs for a minute.
Dawn: okay but fill me in later.
She then runs up and quietly sneaks back down and sits on the stairs to listen in.
Buffy: So is she's your daughter then.
Lillian: Yeah
Buffy starts to cry and Lillian moves next to her to comfort her.
Lillian: Are you okay?
Buffy: Not really….it's just so hard. I mean I've messed up badly and I mean I'm only 15 and I'm pregnant and the person who I called Mom isn't my real mother…you are…but I don't understand what happened.
Lillian: I'm sorry Buffy. I'm sorry for leaving you but I had to I had no choice I was onl-
Buffy: (crying) 17. I know but its hurts because I'm only 15 and I'm not giving up my baby I wouldn't even think of it! How could you do that to me and leave me with Joyce! With that monster!!! I didn't do anything to deserve that I was only a baby!!!
Lillian: It wasn't my fault and its not my fault your pregnant either!
Buffy: But it is! I had no one I needed you! I was alone I would get abused by Joyce for being your daughter and I was abandoned numerous times!! I had no one you were the only one who could save me!! But you NEVER!! You left me out on that street to DIE!! I wouldn't have cared if we were poor and struggling as long as you were there with me all I needed was a mother!!
Lillian: I didn't have a choice Buffy I was young stupid and Joyce was the one who talked me into abandoning you she said it was the only way. Then when I left you she must have gone back and taken you back home to my mother and claimed that I had given you to her.
Buffy: She wouldn't do that! Not even Joyce she hates me! And she would have had Gwen by then. So please Lillian tell me what really happened.
Lillian: I..I wasn't ready Buffy I'm sorry. My boyfriend, your father was leaving town to New York and I wanted to go but he didn't want children he wasn't ready like me…I was 17 and Joyce was about 25 so I thought since she was already a mother she would look after you better than I ever could and I trusted her with my life. So I left you on her doorstep with a note, to take care of you. Then I left for New York and started a new life with my husband Dan. Danny Lopez. I decided to keep my maiden name. We married the year I feel pregnant with Dawn which was a year after I left, we were still young but we didn't want to make same mistake like in Sunnydale with you. So we managed to get jobs and to look after Dawn.
Buffy: But then why forget about me…
Lillian: I wanted to but I was ashamed of myself….I couldn't forget you so I came back to Sunnydale many times and I'd see you at school with your friends you were about 5 or 6 and you looked so happy and free. At home. I didn't want to ruin that or confuse things so I left. Plus I wasn't ready to face my family they would be very disappointed in me for leaving you and there was Joyce.
Buffy: I understand…I think but I wish I wasn't the one looking for you I wish you came back for me…..Anyway I've got to go I have an appointment at 2.
Lillian: Buffy is there anything I can do? I mean we could meet-
Buffy: Yeah there is one thing. Could you pretend we never had this conversation. Lets pretend I NEVER existed I mean you've done it for the last 15 years so I guess 15 minutes won't change anything for you. But it sure as HELL has changed things for me. I guess you and Joyce are both a like.
Lillian: You've got it wrong Buffy.
Dan walks in and stops at the scene in front of him.
Dan: Honey-
Buffy: WRONG!!! TELL ME WHAT I GOT WRONG!!! You left me so you could go of to New York with your boyfriend!!! What is it that I got wrong!!! You chose him (points to Dan) over me!!! OVER YOUR OWN CHILD!! YOUR OWN FLESH AND BLOOD!!! Tell me Lillian! Please tell me what I'M SO WRONG ABOUT!!!
A long silence.
Buffy: Well I guess that answers my question. I really hate my self for finding you I wish I never looked. But I guess deep down I knew you were what everyone said you were. Just some dumb slut, who would give up anything for some high school jock!!! But I kept telling myself you must have loved me. But I was wrong I mean isn't that what you said that I'm wrong!
Dan: Who the hell are you? You have no right talking to my wife like that!
Buffy: You don't recognise me Dad? Buffy Summers. The one you left on the doorstep to start a new life in New York.
Dan: That was the past. Our lives have nothing to do with you. I mean you must 25 now and your pregnant so why-
Buffy: Actually I'm 15 it wasn't that long ago!
Lillian: Look Buffy can you please stay calm…..I'm really truly and deeply sorry for everything I have put you through and if I could change things I would but what's done is done and-
Buffy: I know you can't change the past I've heard it before.
Lillian: So I was….I was wanting to know if your willing to give me a second chance. To be your mother- and I'm not asking you to call me Mom or anything. But I just want to be there for you. I want to part of your life again.
Dan: Lily I think this is out order I mean the girls 15 and she's pregnant. She's bad and she'll be a bad influence on Dawn!! I don't want us to have anything to with her!
Lillian: Dan you can't say that she's your daughter as well!!
Dan: She's not my daughter! My daughter wouldn't get herself knocked up!! My only daughter is Dawn!
Buffy starts to cry.
Lillian: Look at what you've done!!
Dan: I don't care! I want her OUT!! Now.
Lillian: Buffy don't-
Buffy: I need to go…and….
She turns and runs out the house. She continues to run ignoring Lillian's cry's for her to stop. Once she is well away from the house she wipes away her tears and walks to the hospital.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sunnydale Hospital
Front Entrance 3.00pm
Spike sees Buffy approaching him.
Spike: Where have you been I've been waiting for an hour!!
Buffy: (crying) I'm sorry.
Spike pulls her in for a hug.
Spike: Sorry luv I-
Buffy: No it's not you…
Spike: What's wrong then?
Buffy then proceeded to tell him everything that happened.
Spike: Wanker! I'm gonna bloody kill 'em!
Buffy: NO! don't Spike It will just make things worse so let's just leave it okay.
Spike: But you can't let him get away with saying that!!
Buffy: I know….but it's too much to handle now...I mean I've just found my birth mother my real Mom.
Spike: I know luv but that Dan guy-
Buffy: It's okay I'll go back tomorrow and you can come with me.
Spike: NO! Buffy we have to go now!
Buffy: But I'll miss my appointment!
Spike: You've already missed it! So we're going NOW!
Buffy: STOP IT! Spike! You can't force me to go I need time to cool off!
Spike: (soft voice) I know pet but leavings things like that with your Mom isn't going to help it could make the matter worse….
Buffy: I know I thought of that…..(sigh) So I guess I have to go back then?
Spike: Yes you do. Come on lets go we can take my car.
Buffy: Okay..
They joined hands and made their way over to Spike's car.
TBC…..
Disclaimer: Unfortunately, Joss Whedon, Marti Noxon, Twentieth Century Fox Productions, UPN, Sandollar Television, and Mutant Enemy own BtVS. No copyright infringements were intended. This is my story and not meant to copy the show.
Summary: Buffy is in high school 15 years old. She and her friends decide to go to a frat party. There she meets a guy called Spike who is 19 years old but she doesn't know he is her sister's boyfriend so she sleeps with him at the party!! Read to find out what happens!!
Chapter 5 - Family
Saturday Morning 10:30am – Buffy's Room
Buffy wakes up and finds herself lying on something warm. She opens her eyes.
OH SHIT!!! Why I am in a bed with SPIKE!!!
She looks under the sheets.
AND NAKED!!! I really screwed up!! OH CRAP!! What I am gonna do??? Think brain think!! I could sneak out!! Yeah!! Wuss! I am not I just need some fresh air…that's all…but he spent the night that was really sweet…I know but I just need to get out of here!!!
Buffy starts to climb out
Spike: Going somewhere pet?
Buffy: Oh! Your awake…I was going to get something to…to…..EAT! yeah get something to eat.
Spike: You don't have to lie I understand.
Buffy climbs back in the bed.
Buffy: Okay then I was gonna go out for a while to clear my head…because I'm really confused here and I'm really, really sorry for coming on to you last night. I blame it on me being pregnant because I've been really desperate for sex and you were here so I kinda just jumped at the chance so I completely understand if it was a one off thing. So it would be just great if you left now before I have a breakdown cause I've had enough rejection from you to last me life- time. Trust me and I wont tell your friends or anything I think I've done enough damage to them as it is…and its okay if you don't want to come to the appointment today cause it probably-
Spike: Bloody hell! Women would you be quiet! You're giving me a head- ache! And last night changed things okay! I'm not going to make the same mistake again and use you ! The only reason I dumped you was because of Gwen she was gonna report me and get me arrested or something so I had to break up with you! But I'm really sorry I caused you so much pain lu-Buffy. When I told you I cared about you I meant it, I wasn't using it to get into your pants. And I really wanna be with you and be a family and maybe fall in love…..buy house everything, I'm willing to spend the rest of my life with you.
Buffy: (crying) Oh my gosh! You really mean it…
Spike: Yeah I do.
Buffy: Wow! This…this is very overwhelming and it's a lot to take in…
Spike: So what do you say are you willing to forgive me and we can start over?
Buffy: Oh course! Yes! because its everything I've ever wanted a real family….That's why I left this summer.
They hug.
Spike: Where did you go?
Buffy: New York. It's where my real Mom, my birth mother stayed and I wanted to find out about her and I managed to narrow down where she lived because my Mom had the adoption papers and stuff. And when I got there I found out the original owners had moved out a week ago….and the lady who owned it was called Lillian Summers!! She has my last name and then I asked them if they knew where they moved to and they said somewhere in California but they didn't know where. So I spent the whole summer searching L.A, San Francisco and other places but no one could trace the name. So I gave up and came back home to Sunnydale.
Spike: I'm sorry Buffy, but hasn't your mother pass-
Buffy: No! She hasn't! she – I just know okay! I can feel it, I can feel that's she's out there somewhere.
Spike: But what about what Joyce said
Buffy: Well Lillian's last name is Summers so I figured she must be in some way related to Joyce they could be cousins or even maybe sisters!! I know it sounds a bit crazy Spike but it could explain all the lies. I mean Joyce told Gwen my Mom was an alcoholic and drug user, but in her diary she says that Lillian died giving birth to me.
Spike: did she mention the name Lillian?
Buffy: Well no…but its probably so no one would read it and suss out everything
Spike: So are you going to still look for her then?
Buffy: Yes there are millions of towns I'll have to go to I mean California is big!
Spike: Well have checked here in Sunnydale yet?
Buffy: Funny you should mention that but no
Spike: Well I think you should you never know.
Buffy: I guess so…but I think I should go take a shower and get dressed. You can come too….if you want. I could you use some company. Someone to….to scrub my back.
Spike: Is that supposed to turn me on, or something because you are failing miserably.
Green Avenue
1.30pm
Buffy is walking down the street in a rush to get to the hospital when she stops in front of house. There are men moving in furniture and a sign on the lawn saying SOLD. Just then a girl who looks a few years younger than Buffy comes over and greets her.
: Hey! You lost!
Buffy: No sorry….just….so your new then
: Yep! How'd you guess?
Buffy: I don't know I have these telepathic abilities.
: (laughs) Cool so I'm Dawn. Dawn Summers by the way.
Buffy: Buffy. Buffy Summers…….
Dawn: Cool we have the same-
Buffy: Wait a minute. What's your Mom's name is Lillian
Dawn: You can read minds!
Buffy: No trust me I can't…would it be okay if I spoke to your Mom.
Dawn: Did I do something wrong…Miss-
Buffy: Hey I'm only 15 I'm no 'Miss'
Dawn: Get out! I've just turned 15 and you should look around my age! And not pregnant.
Buffy: Well I'm more mature anyway can I please just talk to her it's urgent.
Dawn: Fine then. Come on.
Dawn then lead her into the house.
Dawn: Mom!!!! Someone's here to see you!!!!
A women around 5'6 with blonde wavy hair and green eyes comes down the stairs. She looks very similar to Buffy.
Buffy: (gasp) Oh my God.
Lillian: Are you okay miss? And what can I help you with?
Buffy: I'm sorry I'm just. (takes a breath) Do you know Joyce? Joyce Summers?
Lillian: Yes she's my older sister I've not seen or spoken to her in about 15 years.
Buffy: Okay. Do you know anyone called Buffy. Buffy Anne Summers.
Lillian: What is this 20 questions I don't know who you are but could you please leave and if you don't I will phone the police! Plus my husband will be here soon!
Buffy: (near tears) Please don't I'm really sorry I just needed to-
Dawn: Oh my God!!! Your Buffy Summers right!! then why are you-
Lillian: (shocked) Your Buffy??
Buffy: Yes I am. And I'm really sorry I bothered you but I just wanted to know if what Joyce told me was true that-
Lillian: Wait a minute I think we should talk in private. Dawn sweetie could you go upstairs for a minute.
Dawn: okay but fill me in later.
She then runs up and quietly sneaks back down and sits on the stairs to listen in.
Buffy: So is she's your daughter then.
Lillian: Yeah
Buffy starts to cry and Lillian moves next to her to comfort her.
Lillian: Are you okay?
Buffy: Not really….it's just so hard. I mean I've messed up badly and I mean I'm only 15 and I'm pregnant and the person who I called Mom isn't my real mother…you are…but I don't understand what happened.
Lillian: I'm sorry Buffy. I'm sorry for leaving you but I had to I had no choice I was onl-
Buffy: (crying) 17. I know but its hurts because I'm only 15 and I'm not giving up my baby I wouldn't even think of it! How could you do that to me and leave me with Joyce! With that monster!!! I didn't do anything to deserve that I was only a baby!!!
Lillian: It wasn't my fault and its not my fault your pregnant either!
Buffy: But it is! I had no one I needed you! I was alone I would get abused by Joyce for being your daughter and I was abandoned numerous times!! I had no one you were the only one who could save me!! But you NEVER!! You left me out on that street to DIE!! I wouldn't have cared if we were poor and struggling as long as you were there with me all I needed was a mother!!
Lillian: I didn't have a choice Buffy I was young stupid and Joyce was the one who talked me into abandoning you she said it was the only way. Then when I left you she must have gone back and taken you back home to my mother and claimed that I had given you to her.
Buffy: She wouldn't do that! Not even Joyce she hates me! And she would have had Gwen by then. So please Lillian tell me what really happened.
Lillian: I..I wasn't ready Buffy I'm sorry. My boyfriend, your father was leaving town to New York and I wanted to go but he didn't want children he wasn't ready like me…I was 17 and Joyce was about 25 so I thought since she was already a mother she would look after you better than I ever could and I trusted her with my life. So I left you on her doorstep with a note, to take care of you. Then I left for New York and started a new life with my husband Dan. Danny Lopez. I decided to keep my maiden name. We married the year I feel pregnant with Dawn which was a year after I left, we were still young but we didn't want to make same mistake like in Sunnydale with you. So we managed to get jobs and to look after Dawn.
Buffy: But then why forget about me…
Lillian: I wanted to but I was ashamed of myself….I couldn't forget you so I came back to Sunnydale many times and I'd see you at school with your friends you were about 5 or 6 and you looked so happy and free. At home. I didn't want to ruin that or confuse things so I left. Plus I wasn't ready to face my family they would be very disappointed in me for leaving you and there was Joyce.
Buffy: I understand…I think but I wish I wasn't the one looking for you I wish you came back for me…..Anyway I've got to go I have an appointment at 2.
Lillian: Buffy is there anything I can do? I mean we could meet-
Buffy: Yeah there is one thing. Could you pretend we never had this conversation. Lets pretend I NEVER existed I mean you've done it for the last 15 years so I guess 15 minutes won't change anything for you. But it sure as HELL has changed things for me. I guess you and Joyce are both a like.
Lillian: You've got it wrong Buffy.
Dan walks in and stops at the scene in front of him.
Dan: Honey-
Buffy: WRONG!!! TELL ME WHAT I GOT WRONG!!! You left me so you could go of to New York with your boyfriend!!! What is it that I got wrong!!! You chose him (points to Dan) over me!!! OVER YOUR OWN CHILD!! YOUR OWN FLESH AND BLOOD!!! Tell me Lillian! Please tell me what I'M SO WRONG ABOUT!!!
A long silence.
Buffy: Well I guess that answers my question. I really hate my self for finding you I wish I never looked. But I guess deep down I knew you were what everyone said you were. Just some dumb slut, who would give up anything for some high school jock!!! But I kept telling myself you must have loved me. But I was wrong I mean isn't that what you said that I'm wrong!
Dan: Who the hell are you? You have no right talking to my wife like that!
Buffy: You don't recognise me Dad? Buffy Summers. The one you left on the doorstep to start a new life in New York.
Dan: That was the past. Our lives have nothing to do with you. I mean you must 25 now and your pregnant so why-
Buffy: Actually I'm 15 it wasn't that long ago!
Lillian: Look Buffy can you please stay calm…..I'm really truly and deeply sorry for everything I have put you through and if I could change things I would but what's done is done and-
Buffy: I know you can't change the past I've heard it before.
Lillian: So I was….I was wanting to know if your willing to give me a second chance. To be your mother- and I'm not asking you to call me Mom or anything. But I just want to be there for you. I want to part of your life again.
Dan: Lily I think this is out order I mean the girls 15 and she's pregnant. She's bad and she'll be a bad influence on Dawn!! I don't want us to have anything to with her!
Lillian: Dan you can't say that she's your daughter as well!!
Dan: She's not my daughter! My daughter wouldn't get herself knocked up!! My only daughter is Dawn!
Buffy starts to cry.
Lillian: Look at what you've done!!
Dan: I don't care! I want her OUT!! Now.
Lillian: Buffy don't-
Buffy: I need to go…and….
She turns and runs out the house. She continues to run ignoring Lillian's cry's for her to stop. Once she is well away from the house she wipes away her tears and walks to the hospital.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sunnydale Hospital
Front Entrance 3.00pm
Spike sees Buffy approaching him.
Spike: Where have you been I've been waiting for an hour!!
Buffy: (crying) I'm sorry.
Spike pulls her in for a hug.
Spike: Sorry luv I-
Buffy: No it's not you…
Spike: What's wrong then?
Buffy then proceeded to tell him everything that happened.
Spike: Wanker! I'm gonna bloody kill 'em!
Buffy: NO! don't Spike It will just make things worse so let's just leave it okay.
Spike: But you can't let him get away with saying that!!
Buffy: I know….but it's too much to handle now...I mean I've just found my birth mother my real Mom.
Spike: I know luv but that Dan guy-
Buffy: It's okay I'll go back tomorrow and you can come with me.
Spike: NO! Buffy we have to go now!
Buffy: But I'll miss my appointment!
Spike: You've already missed it! So we're going NOW!
Buffy: STOP IT! Spike! You can't force me to go I need time to cool off!
Spike: (soft voice) I know pet but leavings things like that with your Mom isn't going to help it could make the matter worse….
Buffy: I know I thought of that…..(sigh) So I guess I have to go back then?
Spike: Yes you do. Come on lets go we can take my car.
Buffy: Okay..
They joined hands and made their way over to Spike's car.
TBC…..