Still held by her three attackers, Phoebe appeared in another room somewhere in the underworld. This room was just as dark and gloomy as the one before, but it was a slightly larger. A few seconds after Phoebe arrived in the new room, Dafton and the other two figures popped up inches away from her.

Dafton looked over to Phoebe, "The source will be arriving momentarily." With a wave of his hand, the two figures holding Phoebe let her go and disappeared. The two figures with Dafton did the same.

"Uh, thanks," was all Phoebe was able to say. She was about to ask Dafton why he let her go, when she noticed there was no entrance. Phoebe turned in a complete circle, yet there was not one opening. So that's why he let them go, she thought.

Phoebe was trying to think of a way out of this, but was coming up empty. Lets see, can't call Leo, he won't here me. Can't call Cole, not sure where he is or if he'd even here me.

Phoebe was brought out of her thoughts by a presence entering the room. She turned around and came face to face with the Source.

"Well, well, well, the almighty witch who turned the mighty Belthazor, what an honor it is," the Source spoke, with an air of authority and evil around him.

"I wish I could say the say the same, but then I'd be lying," Phoebe said with a cocky grin flashing across her face only for a brief moment.

The Source let out a chuckle. "I must say," he began, "it is a good thing you kept your word about staying here. Otherwise, I would have had to hunt you down myself. And without any sisters around, you wouldn't have had a chance."

No, Phoebe thought, my sisters aren't dead. Leo orbed up to the Manor in time to save them.

"What's the matter, cat or should I say demon got your tongue?" the Source mocked. Since Phoebe still didn't respond, the Source continued on with what he wanted to say. "Well, Phoebe is it? I have decided that I will be turning you evil, instead of killing you..."

"No need to do many favors," Phoebe spoke out loud and clear.

"Oh, I see you regained you voice. Look guys, we have a little miss. smart alec here. Well, we'll have to fix that now won't me. As I was saying, before I was so rudely interrupted, Dafton here will be guarding your new "quarters", which we will be leaving for in a few moments. You will be put though a series of tests th..."

"Tests, what kind of test?" Phoebe asked nervously.

"Well, if you'd let me finish, I would have told you that you will be put through a series of test to develop your skills enough to become evil and..."

"How many tests, what are they like?" Phoebe asked.

"Gd, it's a wonder the Elders kept you on their side at all. I'm starting to rethink my decision to kill you. Now just follow me and I will take you to your room."

The Source walked over to a torch and placed his hand on the wall right under it. The wall opened and he entered a hall with Phoebe right behind him. They walked for about twenty minutes, until the Source stopped right by another torch. The same thing happened as before.

Once Phoebe was in the middle of the room. The Source said, "Welcome to your new home for a while Phoebe. I wouldn't even consider about thinking of escaping if I were you." The Source walked out, leaving Phoebe staring at his retreating form.

Oh my gd, what am I suppose to do now, Leo thought? "Prue, Piper, why don't you two go wait for the doctor to wake up," Leo suggested of the two remaining sisters. Prue and Piper glanced at each other, then to Leo, to Cole, and bake to Leo again. They held their glares on Leo for a moment before heading downstairs.

"Look Cole," Leo started, "we have to tell them where Phoebe is."

"I know that," Cole told him, "look, I promised Phoebe that I wouldn't tell her sisters what happened and I'm not going to go back on that promise."

"That's why you tell them what happened, just at a different location. Tell them you took her to the beach or something and that it was deserted, then tell them the events of what happened in the under world."

Cole look at Leo, "That's good, yeah, that's really good. Alright, lets go," Cole, stated before turning to walk to the stairs that would lead him the sisters of the woman he loved.

Cole and Leo arrived at the bottom of the stairs. "Where's the doctor?" Leo asked.

"He woke up and asked us where the creature went, we told him that he hit his head and that he must have hit it harder than we thought." Piper explained to Leo.

"Good thinking," Leo told her.

"What happened to my sister? Where the hell is she?" Prue's words were spoken softly, but the concern and angry that was in them did not go unnoticed by anyone in the room.

Cole looked to Leo before speaking. Leo nodded his head, and Cole began what his recount of what happened while he and Phoebe were "out". Just as Cole was starting, the Elder's called Leo, "Uh guys, they're calling. I'll be back soon, I promise." Leo walked over to Piper and kissed her forehead. Before he orbed out he whispered, "We'll get her back."

Unbeknownst to anyone, the Elder's have been watching the whole scene unfold. Three are presently watching at this moment. "That is it! I don't care that she is a Charmed One! She fell in love with a demon; she risked her sisters' lives for him! In her sisters did die, I will not keep on tolerating her reckless behavior! First she let him go, then he turned evil, and now she wants him back again."

"I hear what you are saying Calibhuton, we do, but don't forget that we need her to complete the Charmed Ones.

"No we don't, we have the other one," Calibhuton suggested.

"Yes, but she won't be as close to the other two, nor them to her. Theses three grew up together, they have a special connection," Tobias explained.

"Not at first they didn't. The oldest and the youngest hated each other. Surely if they can come together, so can the she and the oldest, after all, she is not nearly as bad as the youngest," Calibhuton reminded his fellow officials.

"What do you have to say about this, Pention? You've been quiet this whole time," Tobias questioned.

"She has done a lot of good, more good than most, but she is becoming more trouble than I feel she is worth. I mean, because of her, magic was exposed, I know she got it fixed it, but at what cost?" Pention confessed.

"Then it is settled, call Leo and we will inform him that the youngest is dead in the underworld," Calibhuton replied.

Tobias gave him an unsure glance before calling Leo. Seconds later, Leo appeared right in front of them.

"Why Leo, we have a pressing matter that we must discus," Calibhuton began, "it seems that Phoebe is... well she..."

Leo locked eyes with Calibhuton, "No! She can't be...she's not," Leo couldn't get himself to say the words out loud.

Calibhuton just shook his head, "I'm afraid so Leo. I'm sorry," Tobias, thought Calibhuton actually sounded sorrowful, bastard, Tobias thought. "I know how much she meant to you and to her sisters," Calibhuton continued.

Leo was speechless; he couldn't even mouth a word.

"There is some good news," Calibhuton replied as Tobias looked away cause he couldn't contribute in this conversation. Leo looked up, in hope of what Calibhuton just said. "There is another sister, a half sister, find her and you can reestablish the Charmed Ones."

Penny and Patty were watching the scene unfold. "I wonder where Phoebe gets her taste in guy's from?" Patty said with "this is all your fault" look on her face.

"Don't look at me like that. Who do you think Piper took after?" Patty went back to being straight faced.

"Besides, now is not the time to argue about that. We have to find a way to let them know that Phoebe is alive," Penny told her daughter.

"We can't mom. You know what they'll do to us if they find out we told them," Patty argued

"Oh Patty please, what can they really do to us. Besides, you sound just like Phoebe."

"Mother, we have to at least let them attempt this on their own. They will have to learn to do things by themselves sooner or later."

"Fine, but only for a little while. After that, I'm not responsible for my actions or my verbal content."

The next three months pass by very slowly for all involved.

Leo returned to the Manor and told everyone what the Elders had told him. A funeral wasn't held for Phoebe because there was no body and they had nothing to confirm their suspicions of Phoebe being dead.

One day soon, after Phoebe's funeral, Paige confessed to the remaining Halliwell sisters her suspicion. It was confirmed through Patty that Paige was her daughter, however, Patty had to practically tie Penny up so she wouldn't blurt out that Phoebe was alive.

The three sisters, plus Andy and Leo now live less than one roof, are practicing the craft, and get along fabulously. Cole pops in every now and then, Prue and Piper forgave him for his actions before.

Phoebe has been kept in that same room, being put through numerous tests to turn her evil. Though the Source had yet to succeed, Phoebe's spirit is about to be broken.

The Elders are happy with the new arrangement and have no intention of informing the sisters of the truth.

One day, after the Source had come from torturing Phoebe as part of the test to become evil, he went to rest for a little while in his personal chambers. Dalton was left in charge of guarding Phoebe, as usual.

As Phoebe was resting in her room from her usual beating and power beating, the door to her room opened. The person who entered was not the person she expected to ever see. She looked passed him to see Dafton lying on the floor out cold. Phoebe looked up at her rescuer.

"Jamie, what...you're a...I can't believe..." Phoebe was speechless, for she never thought her friend to be a demon. She also just figured he would have never thought her to be a Charmed One.

"Come on Phoebe, we need to get you out of here," Jamie said, walking over next to her, he picked her up in his arms. Peeking out in the hall, Jamie made sure the cost was clear as he made a break for it.

Jamie ran for about fifteen minutes, until he came to the first room that allows you to shimmer, or blink.

By the time Jamie shimmered to the surface, Phoebe was out cold. "Dad," Jamie yelled out.

All of a sudden, Charlie, Jamie's father, ran into the room. "Phoebe! Jamie, what did you do to her?" Charlie accused his son.

"Dad, I didn't do it I swear. Look, if I did why would I bring her to you?" Jamie watched as Charlie's expression changed to one of sorrow instead of angry. "Look, I have to get back, so no one won't expect me."

As Jamie was about to shimmer out, "Wait, I'm sure she would love it if you stopped by sometime," Charlie told his son.

Charlie was taking care of an unconscious Phoebe for a few days. He knew a lot about healing potions that worked on a demon's power from taking care of Jamie.

Charlie walked into Phoebe's room one day to find her awake.

"Phoebe! You're awake," Charlie lightly hugged her.

Jamie walked into the room. "I would have never guessed that you were an evil warlock," Phoebe commented.

"And, we would have never thought that you were a Charmed One," Charlie admitted to Phoebe.

"Clay wasn't a..."

"No Phoebe, he wasn't. Jamie's mom was though," Charlie told Phoebe.

"Phoebe, there is something you need to know. Something about Belthazor," Jamie started to say.

"How do you know about Cole?" Phoebe asked Jamie.

"When I was younger, he was my mentor. I was always told that my family would never be harmed, even though they were human. But, when the Source found out that my brother had married a Charmed One, to be, he gave the order to kill. The Source knew I would never do it, so he gave the job to my mentor, to Belthazor."

Phoebe looked at Jamie shaking her head no.

"Phoebe, he killed my brother," Jamie told her.

"He killed my son," Charlie told her.

"That would mean that he killed my daughters, that he killed my husband." Phoebe began shaking her head no. "Cole...Cole...Cole killed Clay," Phoebe said in disbelief.