A/N: In this chapter, Andy's powers are a bit different than what they were in present time. Prudence Warren is also familiar with his past life with Prue.

Princess Pinky: No Cole is not evil in this one. He is trying to find Andy. Sci Fi Fan Gillian and son gomay vidal goku as always thank you for your kind review. Mandebella, yeah, I thought about Cole's clothes too! piperleo4eva: I honestly don't know if Prue/Prudence are of the same soul but it makes sense. Pruedence.Halliwell: I'm glad you liked the idea of Natalie being the evil enchantress...I thought it was fitting!


Salem 1700

Riding on horseback, Cole led Prudence deep into the woods. "My Lord we have traveled for many miles, and you have yet to tell me of your purpose. Is it for personal pleasure?"

"Personal Pleasure?" Cole snickered silently to himself unable to hide a grin, "Definitely not". Prue, even a ancient variation of her would be the last women in hell or on Earth that he would want. Stopping the horse, Cole hopped off and offered Prudence a hand of assistance. Leery of his intentions, Prudence looked about at her surroundings. "Why have you brought me, so deeply into the woods?"

"I want you to show me something," Cole rubbed his chin still grinning. He still couldn't get over how much this women looked like Prue.

Sighing, Prudence reached for the buttons on her vest, and started to untie the lace. "No...No I don't want to see that!" Cole grimaced covering his eyes, as she started to remove the blouse.

"Then what?" Prudence quickly pulled her vest back together.

"Your magic"

Magic? Her mother had told her never to use magic unless it was against the dark forces. Mortals like this Lord would not understand it, just like the mortals who had burned her mother at the stake. Prudence had been only eight, but still the scars of her mother's death remained, making her fearful and untrusting. She couldn't take the risk.

Prudence kept her gaze calm and steady, not letting the man see her fear. "I know not what you speak of. Only witches use magic"

Cole could see that this wasn't going to be easy but he needed to provoke a Tracer attack. Prudence was hesitant and with good reason. "I was so hoping I wouldn't have to do this." In an instant, Cole transformed into Belthazor, gnashing his teeth, and growling, "Now I've showed my magic, I want to see yours!"

A caped figure resembling Robin of the hood, lurked in the shadows watching, his eyes widening at the sight of the red demon.

"Demon of the Dark Lords," Prudence hissed, pointing a finger. Telekinetic blasts flew out of her joints, sending Bethalzor into a tree. Still frightened, Prudence looked about whispering to the wind, "I need your protection"

White swirling lights appeared near the tree, forming into the shape of a man. Andy appeared holding a standard bow and arrow.

"He is a Lord of Darkness!" Prudence shouted as Belthazor reverted back into Cole.

"Not quite but close," Andy grinned offering a Cole a hand up. Prudence stood bewildered, "Andrew you know of this demon?"

"He's my wife's sister's, boyfriend," Andy replied while Cole dusted off his backside.

"Your wife allows her younger sibling to keep company with a demon?"

"Half demon" Cole retorted, "and for the record, Phoebe is your great, great, great granddaughter from the future".

Prudence looked to Andy for confirmation. "And your wife, Prue?"

"Is Prudence Melinda Halliwell," Andy answered just as band of men opened fire upon them.

"WITCHES!"

A flaming arrow struck Cole in the back, before anyone had time to react. Andy pushed Prudence into the brush hoping she wouldn't be seen. "Shimmer back NOW!" he told Cole. Stubbornly, Cole shook his head, latching onto Andy's shirt.

"Oh no...I cannot leave without you. Phoebe will never forgive me, if I don't bring you back to Prue." He tried to shimmer them both but only succeeded in temporarily fading. The Elders were blocking the ability for Andy to pass back through time.

"I can't go back to Prue! They won't let me!" Andy replied pulling the arrow free from Cole's flesh.

"I can send you back," Prudence replied peeking her head from around the bush.

"How?"

Kneeling, Prudence pulled a locket from around her neck. It was a duplicate of the locket her Mother had used to trap, the demon Mathew. Melinda had blessed it and given it to Prudence for good luck. "This locket is a holding chamber for spirits. You can travel safely through time without being detected".

Andy looked at her skeptically, "what about you?"

"I'll be fine" Prudence smiled, "I'm destine to Grandmother the Charmed family line remember?" Slowly she began to chant.

"Return the bond of love which was not to be undone. Know no sorrow, know no pain, return love's gift without personal gain!" White swirling lights formed around Andy pulling him into the locket, making Prudence smile.

"Return him safely, Lord Turner"

Manor Present Time

Prue looked perturbed. "All right you want to tell about that little vision you just had, or do I have to guess?"

"Not really," Phoebe just grinned speaking through clenched teeth, as the rest of the family congratulated Piper and Leo on their anniversary celebration. She didn't want to tell Prue, about the coffin, until she had time to think and digest it a little more.

"Phoebe," Prue said caustically forcing Phoebe's hand. "I'd rather talk about Melinda's story. Don't you find it odd, that a Tracer named Andrew, aided her daughter".

Prue didn't want to admit, but deep down she found it too much of a coincidence to ignore. "That Tracer is Andy, Prue"

"Phoebe we have no way of knowing of that" Prue replied doubtful, "for all we know, that could have been Andy's past life. Melinda is just recalling what she knows from history"

Phoebe shook her head, "No Prue. That Tracer has to be Andy'.

"What makes you so sure?" Prue challenged.

"Because Andy's powers were earned, not inherited. The only Tracer to inherit the power that we know of is Amanda," Phoebe pointed to the child in Prue's arms. "Those powers were given to Andy by the Elders not by his family genes. Think about it Prue. It's him"

Prue closed her eyes and swallowed, "Even if it is, I have no way of bringing him back. For Andy to be in the eighteenth century would mean that the Elders sent him there as a consequence. They don't want me with him Phoebe" Phoebe's dark chestnuts eyes narrowed, "And they don't want me with demon, nor Piper with Leo, but that's not stopping us. It's true love, Prue and you've got to fight for it"

"How?"

"Go to him, Prue. Be a risk taker! Let the Elders see, that not even their harshest, consequence can stop you" Phoebe felt her own security for Cole's love rise as she encouraged her sister, " Please sweetie you've got to do this. Do it for Amanda"

The two sisters were about the head to the attic, when Cole shimmered in, bleeding.

"Cole?" Phoebe questioned worried, letting his slump against her arms. "He's bleeding! LEO!"

Prue quickly set Amanda down and lent an arm of assistance as she and Phoebe helped Cole to the couch. "Why is he dressed like that?" she asked noting his post colonel attire.

"I'll explain later. LEO!" Phoebe shouted again ignoring the intense stare that was occurring between Cole and Prue.

"What happened?" Leo looked worried as he spotted the burnt flesh of Cole's wound. Healing hands worked in no time to heal the demon, making Phoebe sigh in relief.

"Oh Thank God" Tenderly she kissed Cole's head, "What happened?"

"We were attacked by marauders"

"We?" Cole's statement caught Prue's attention, "what do mean we?"

Cole's bottom lip stuck out in playful jest, "Me, a witch, and Andy"

"Andy?" Prue breathed, as Cole reached into his pocket fishing out the locket.

"Here, he sent you an early anniversary present"

Prue's hands shook as she took the locket into her hands. "It's beautiful," she said, admiring the antique markings.

Phoebe smiled at Cole and kissed him.

"Why don't you open it maybe there is something inside" Cole suggested.

"The last time I opened something like this a demon flew out"

"I guarantee it's not a demon," Cole coaxed.

Nervous, Prue picked at the clasp, separating the two halves, releasing a set of white and blue swirling lights. She could hardly believe her eyes, when Andy appeared, still wearing eighteenth century garb.

"Andy!" Prue beamed giggled rushing towards his arms.

Golden Gate Park

Natalie stood anxious waiting for the female Elder, Helena, to appear.

"Why have you summoned me?" Helena materialized in white robes, her hands clasp in front of her.

"I was attacked by a demon today" Natalie answered calmly, "Belthazor"

"Belthazor?" The Elder looked at Natalie curiously.

"He was seeking information. I believe it is his mission to reunite Andy with Prue, as a favor to her sister".

Helena looked displeased as she waved her hand creating a hologram of the scene where Prue released Andy from the locket. "Oh dear, it looks like despite the consequences they have yet to learn their lesson. Thank you for informing me"

Natalie smiled, bowing her head. "It is still my intention to serve nothing but the greater good."