A/N: Here's the next chapter, sorry that its been a while, but I've had a ton of home work. Please review.
Disclaimer: All of that is in the first pat.
Rating: PG-13
"DiNozzo." answered on the other end of the phone.
"Hey, its Kate. We just left Samantha's, where heading over to the Blue Point right now."
"I'm there right now, Carrie and Amanda got into a serious cat fight, they're replacing a window, and they already plastered in a hole in the wall. One of the waiters tried to stop them, ended up with a broken finger."
"Oh, I guess we'll head back to the office then, see what Abby has, talk to you later."
"Ok, see you there."
Abby's Lab
"So Abbs, what do have for us." asked Gibbs as he and Kate walked into the lab.
"Ok, the blood on the first knife you guys found was Carrie's. The second was Lindsay's. But get this, there was an unknown blood on the handle of the second knife." she answered.
"Are you running it through the..."
"Military database. Yes Gibbs, but I doubt that it will show up in there though." she interupted.
"Did you get finger prints on anything yet?" asked Kate.
"Yes, the knife with Carrie's blood on it has a half a finger print, but that's all. The one with Lindsay's blood is covered with to much blood to find anything," she said as she walked over to a table with the evidence all spread out on it. "But I did get Lindsay's prints off this." she said as she held up a bag with a knife in it.
"Where did that come from?" asked Gibbs.
"Tony found it in the living room, the really cool part is that the blood that's on this one is the same blood that's on the handle of the second one."
"So, Lindsay found a knife, cut her attacker, but he turned around and stabbed her in the back." stated Kate.
"That's what it looks like, but that doesn't explain why she was in Carrie's house in the first place." said Abby.
"Well, lets go look at what Tony got," said Gibbs as he started to walk out of the lab. "Tell me if you get anything else Abbs."
"Ok." said Abby as the two of them left.
GARAGE
"Hey boss," said Tony as Gibbs and Kate walked into the garage "What did you get from Abby?" he asked.
"Carrie's blood was on the first knife, and a partial finger print. Lindsay's blood was on the second knife, with someone else's blood on the handle. The third knife had Lindsay's finger prints, and the same blood from the second knife on it." said Gibbs as he sat down at the table.
"Well, Carrie had a thing for knifes, at the bar she picked up a knife from the table and tried to stab Amanda with it, but Amanda moved out of the way, putting a nice hole in the wall."
"Lets look at all the evidence, try to make some connections," said Gibbs as he started to pick through the items and folders on the table.
It had about two hours of looking over evidence, reading folders, and trying to make some connections between the murders when Gibbs started to talk.
"So, Amanda and Carrie get into a fight, Amanda goes missing the next day and Carrie starts to act funny. A week later Carrie goes missing and Lindsay, Amanda's best friend, starts to act funny. A week later Lindsay's, Carrie's, and Amanda's bodies are found in Carrie's and her fiancée house. Carrie's fiancée was out of town for two and a half weeks, and his roommate was at the beach for three weeks. Who could have killed them."
"Wait, we've been looking at this as if the same person killed all three of them." said Kate as she started to look through the stuff on the table. "Carrie and Amanda got into a fight, Carrie starts to act funny at the same time Amanda goes missing. What if Carrie killed Amanda."
Gibbs stopped her their "And Lindsay found out and killed Carrie the same way Carrie killed Amanda."
Then Tony interrupted "But then who killed Lindsay?"
"The roommate was at the beach, Luke Welch was in..., wait he said he got back this morning didn't he?" Kate asked Gibbs as she looked through some things on the table.
"Yeah, he said he got back just in time for work that morning." he answered.
She pulled out a plane ticket "His ticket says he got back late Wednesday night, not Friday morning."
"So what if Luke came home, found Carrie dead, and killed Lindsay for it." Tony put in the last bit of information.
"But how did he know Lindsay did it?" asked Kate.
"Lindsay might have went back to see if Carrie had died, and found a very mad Luke there." said Tony.
"If we can get a blood sample from Luke, then we would know if it was his blood on the knife."
"Good, Kate, we need to pay another visit to Luke Welch." said Gibbs as he stood up and walked to the elevator.