Can't Hide My Feelings Anymore

Disclaimer: Again, I do not know the WWE Superstars, I won all the other characters.

A/N: Thanks you guys so much for the reviews. I am glad you guys really like this story, as much as I do writing it. If you ever have any ideas, please tell me. I might think of using them whenever I have writer's block. Again guys, thanks so much for all the reviews, keep them coming!!!

Chapter 5

Date #1

--While shopping--

"I'm still worried about you going out with John."

"He said, just friends."

"C'mon, Natalie. All the guys know that both John and Randy are vying for you."

"The only one I want is Randy."

"Ok, I got a question, say you have a really awesome date with Randy tonight, which I know you will have, but you go on your date with John and it goes better than Randy's, and John wants a little kiss at the end, what are you going to do?"

"How many freakin times do I have to tell you, I wouldn't kiss John. Jeez, Nickie, I am so not like that. I am not attracted to John whatsoever, he's not my type." Natalie revoked picking up a mini strapless black dress with sparkly belt.

"That's cute." Nickie replied picking up a long, red, silk one.

"Let's try these on."

"They look nice, but Randy said that our date was casual, we're going to the beach or something."

"That's sweet, well Paul and I are going out to La Bistro tonight."

"Wow, that fancy place. Well, it's about 4 o'clock, I want to go back to the hotel, before the big date."

"The big date!"

"Whatever, let's go." Natalie jumped in her car, and Nickie got in the passenger side. They started blaring the Jessica Simpson cd, that Natalie put in there.

"This was the first song me and Randy kissed to." Natalie said while it was on Sweetest Sin.

"Jeez, you really like him! I hope that you don't ruin it with John though."

"Why the hell do you keep saying that?"

"Natalie, compare the two."

"What's there to compare?"

"Randy's so much your type."

"I know that. I am only going out with John as friends."

"Have you told Randy that yet?"

"No. Why should he know?"

"Whatever. You are going to ruin this relationship with Randy."

"There is no relationship yet with Randy."

"What?"

" I guess there is, sort of. He didn't ask me to be his girlfriend though."

"Guys don't do that anymore, Natalie."

"Whatever. We're here at the hotel. Have fun tonight."

"You too."

-- 7 p.m.--

There's a knock at Natalie's hotel room door.

"Hey Shorty, u ready?" Randy said.

"Yeah, honey. Lemme grab a hoodie, just in case."

"Don't worry about it, I got two in the car. I've got this planned."

"You're just too damn cute, Orton."

"Tell me something I don't already know." Randy said laughing.

"Whatever, let's go."

-- At the Beach --

"Awww, Orton. This is really beautiful." Natalie said looking around at the place Randy set up in the rocks, overlooking the sunset.

"I knew you would like it, baby."

" This is really sweet."

They soon finished their dinner, and we're just laying there cuddling.

"I heard you asked my brother for his permission."

"Well I thought that I should."

---Meanwhile--

There was a knock at Paul's door.

"Hey Cena, what's up?"

"Not much, I just wanted to ask you something."

"Sure, what did you want?"

"I want to ask Natalie out after our movie thing tomorrow."

"The only problem I see with that, is that she is actually on a date with Randy right now."

"Oh, but I would still have your permission, then right?"

"I guess so."

"Alright, thanks Paul. It means a lot to me."

-- 8 p.m. Nickie and Paul's Date--

"Hey Paul."

"Wow, Nickie, you look amazing." Paul said admiring the red dress that she had bought at the Mall today.

"Thanks, you ready to go?"

"Yeah."

-In the Car--

"Are you alright, Paul? You seem really nervous."

"I'll be fine. We're here."

--At dinner--

"I'm nervous because I am worried about Natalie."

"She's with Randy, he wouldn't let nothing happen to her."

"I know that, It's not Randy, it's John, after you called me today he came to my room, and asked my permission to date Natalie."

"I warned her about this."

" I don't know why she would even think of dating him, I've never been a big fan of him or his character on the screen."

"I know what you mean, don't worry about her. Whatever is supposed to be will always find a way."

"Good, now let's stop worrying about her."

-- Back with Natalie and Randy (at the hotel)--

"Randy, I had an amazing time tonight."

"Me too, Shorty. You want to be my girlfriend?"

"Aww, Randy that's so sweet, like I would say no." Natalie said making Randy smirk.

"Good, tomorrow night, you want to go out again?"

"John asked me to go to the movies, as friends tomorrow night."

"Oh alright, Shorty. I'll see ya tomorrow though, right?"

"Definitely, sexy. See ya tomorrow."

" You want to come in and watch a movie, it's only 11."

"Sure, why not?"

Randy and Natalie walked into Randy's hotel room.

"Just sit on the couch, what movie you want to watch?"

"How about Love Actually?"

"A chick flick?" Randy said as he was changing into a sleeveless Nike shirt, and boxers.

"Please, sexy!"

"Whatever you want, Shorty." Randy said carrying in two bottles of Pepsi and bowl of popcorn.

"Where did you get this stuff?"

"There's a small kitchenette in here."

"Oh really, I guess since you are the legend killer, they need to have nice rooms."

"Damn right, Shorty."

"Love Actually, here we come."

2 hrs into the movie, Natalie was fast asleep on Randy's chest.

'What am I going to do with her? I'll just put her in my bed.' Randy thought.

He carried her into his bed, and then snuggled up to her. 'Good night, Shorty' was his last thought before he went to bed as well.

--The next morning--

Natalie wakes up and has no idea where she was, or who she was with. She turned over to find Randy.

"Omg! Randy, we didn't have sex, did we?"

"How could we have sex if we're both clothed. If I knew you wanted to, we could have." Randy said smiling.

"Damn you, Randy."

"You fell asleep on my chest last night while watching that damn chick flick, and so, I didn't know your code, so I just decided to put you in my bed, it's not like we didn't fit or anything."

"Well I better get out of here, baby. It's noon." Natalie said kissing Randy.

"See ya later, Shorty. Have fun tonight."

"I'll try. Later baby."

"What the hell is going on here?" Paul said walking into Randy's room which Natalie was still in.

"Paul, nothing happened, I fell asleep while watching a movie and Randy didn't know my code, so I just put her in my bed, alright?"

"Just as long as you two didn't do anything, alright."

"Wonder if we did, Paul? What are you going to do about it?"

"Quit messing with me."

"How was your date, bro?"

"It was really good."

"Ok, I got to let y'all go, see ya later!" Natalie said walking out of the room.

Damn, that was 7 pages, sorry it took so long guys!! Hope y'all had a good 4th of July. Thanks for all the reviews, keep them coming. My AIM sn is littrellsgurl515. Thanks again, guys! PLEASE REVIEW!!