Can't Hide My Feelings Anymore

A/N: Thanks for all the reviews! I really want to get over 100 reviews, I was going to do a sequel to this story, but I am really not sure yet. I wanted to mention that this story isn't all about Randy Orton/John Cena/Natalie triangle, all other members of Evolution except for Ric is included in this story, so describes this chapter! Keep the reviews coming!!!

Chapter 18

Falling Apart

Nickie ran out of the Executive Offices as soon as she could. She couldn't believe what she had just seen. She decided to call Natalie and have her meet her someplace, maybe like a Starbucks or something, like that.

"Hey Nick!" Natalie said answering her flip-phone, glad another person called her.

"Hey, we seriously need to talk." Nickie tried choking out the words.

"Are you ok? Are you crying?" Natalie asked caringly.

"Just meet me in Starbucks, the one on 44th Street in ten minutes, alright?"

"Ok, Nick, be right there." Both women hung up the phone as soon as Natalie hung up the phone, John walked into their double-bed hotel room, Natalie did not want to sleep in the same bed as him, let alone same room.

"Hey baby!"

"John, I have to go."

"Why so soon?"

"Nickie's really upset and I am meeting her at Starbucks."

"Oh ok, see ya later baby!"

"Bye John!"

--ten minutes later--

Natalie walked into the Starbucks, and seen a clearly upset Nickie sitting in the corner, with two hot chocolates.

"Nick, what is wrong?"

"Listen, I came back here. I wanted to see Paul, alright?"

"Yeah, I understand."

--meanwhile--

"Hey Stacy." John said admiring her as she walked into his hotel room.

"Hey sweetie, what's up?"

"Plan, baby is in full swing. Steph got Paul in bed last night."

"Get out."

"Yeah, Nickie's upset."

"Why would she be upset?"

"Maybe she caught them." Making them both laugh.

"Well that would be quite funny."

"It would. How are things with you and the legend killer wannabe?"

"Strained, you and the legend killer's Shorty?"

"Same."

"Well I was walking the other night to get Randy, and they were both talking to each other."

"Well then you and I must stop them. I refuse to give everything up to that son-of-a-bitch of a Randy Orton. That creep is an asshole."

"How well I know. So freaking cocky and conceited."

"Then why do you want him?"

"Have you looked at him lately? That guy is hot."

"I only want Natalie for sex, but she isn't giving it up. Yet she gives it up to Randy in like a month, we've been dating for about five. My plan is to tell her I love her tonight."

"Nice one, that will break the two apart. And I'll be sure to tell Randy about it." Stacy said cracking a joke.

"Well, I better get this hotel room into a love shack. That is so not me, but hell, Randy has to pay."

"They both do. See ya baby."

"See ya, Stacy."

-meanwhile-

"What?" You mean to tell me he was fucking the bitch on the table? Did you walk in?"

"No, I seen them through the peephole, Paul kept moaning Stephanie's name."

"I can't believe this. I can't believe he'd go in her trap, AGAIN!"

"Who cares, I am now starting to get over him. How about you and Randy?"

"We kissed the other day, but nothing since, I really want to talk to him."

"Maybe you should, I'll go to the hotel, clean up and you can invite Randy here."

"Ok, thanks a lot."

"Thanks for listening to me, girl."

"No problem."

Randy was sitting in his hotel room, Stacy went off with Torrie and Trish to go shopping, he was just sitting there, wanting someone else to be there. All of a sudden his phone rings and it comes up "Shorty calling" He smiled and answered the phone.

"Hey."

"Randy, we really need to talk, are you doing anything right now?"

"Nope, Do you want to meet somewhere?"

"How about the Starbucks on 44th Street?"

"I'll be there in 10 minutes."

"Alright, Randy. Bye."

"Bye Natalie."

--ten minutes later--

Randy walks into Starbucks and sees Natalie in the corner seat.

"Hey." Randy says as he walks up to her in a Randy Orton shirt and pair of Nike shorts.

"Hey Randy, we really need to talk."

"I know we do."

"I don't want to be with John, and you said yourself that you don't want to be with Stacy."

"I don't."

"Then why are we with them?"

"I really don't know."

"What would happen if we'd get back together?" Natalie said as her phone rang.

"Hi John."

"Hey sweetie, you coming to the hotel soon?"

"Wasn't planning on it, why?"

"I got another surprise for you."

"I'll be there as soon as I can."

"Ok, bye."

"See ya."

"What the hell is the deal with him?"

"I know, he hates you."

"How well I know." Randy showing off a couple black and blue marks that John gave him during their match.

"Why?"

"Well it all started, when I was on Smackdown! And it was him and me, and this one match we had as a tag-team, he really wanted to win, to prove something to Vince, because both of us wanted to go to RAW, for of course, the bigger audience, and we lost the match because we were fighting the Dudley Boys and it was a no-holds-barred match, and they slammed me through about 3 tables, I mean, I was drained, and I didn't want to give up because we were such good friends, and finally they slammed me with a chair, and I was completely unconscious, and they pinned me. After I got back from the hospital, John starts flipping out because Vince called my hotel room, and I called Vince back and said that he was impressed with my match, and offered me a contract to trade to RAW, and John stayed on Smackdown."

"Jeez, it wasn't your fault, baby."

"I know. I've never forgiven myself for that. I didn't want to take the job, but my dad said it would be huge for my career, and now it was the best decision."

"I see. Do you want to go back to the hotel?"

"If you'll stay in my room."

"If you'll have me."

"Definitely."

--thirty minutes later--

-at the hotel-

"Well I will go down to my hotel room, and get my stuff and come up to your room, I don't have that much stuff."

"Alright, see you later baby."

Natalie walks into her hotel room, and sees candles and rose petals everywhere, and there's a song playing in the background.

"John? What's going on?"

"Hey sweetie, you're back."

"John, what is going on?"

"It's been six months baby, happy anniversary!"

"John, we need to talk."

"About what, baby?"

"Randy."

"What do you want with that bastard?"

"Randy told me about the whole match thing, why you're pissed off at him."

"You were with him?"

"Yes, and we're getting back together."

"No, you're not. You're with me now."

"Natalie, what the hell is going on here?" Randy says walking into John's hotel room.

"Why don't you get the fuck out of here, Orton? Don't ruin another thing in my life."

"What are you doing, John?" Natalie said noticing John was on one-knee.

"Natalie, I love you. I know it's only been six months and I don't know how you feel, but I want to be with you forever. I love you, will you marry me?"

"What the hell are you doing proposing to her?" Randy hollers.

"What's your answer, baby?" John says showing Natalie the canary-yellow 6 carat diamond engagement ring.

"No, John. I told you I am getting back together with Randy. This is really nice, but I like you John and I'm in love with Randy."