"How do we get out of this place?" asked Phoebe

"I don't know it seems like we're going round in circles" said Cole shaking his head

"Do you think maybe there are enchantment down here"?

"I don't know, the demon we vanquished was able to shimmer, so maybe the enchantments only work on us"

"So someone wants to keep us down here"

"Maybe, I just wish whoever it is will just reveal themselves to us".

"I know, but we better keep moving". Replied Phoebe

A few minutes later

"This wasn't here before was it" asked Phoebe pointing to a door

"I don't think so, but it seem like the person has finally chosen to reveal themselves"

"You think it's a trap"

"Of course but we don't really have a choice"

"Cole if I die, I just want you to know that I don't hate you"

"You're not going to die Phoebe," said Cole waving his hand and freezing Phoebe (Not so much freezing but sort of sunning her) "I sorry Phoebe but you'll be safe out here" he whispered before walking through the door.

"You are so predictable," said a voice to Cole as soon as he entered "Freezing Phoebe to protect her, how noble"

"Who are you?" asked Cole

"You mean you don't know, and here I thought you were suppose to be smart"

"I am"

"Really, well then how come you do know who I am.... Especially since I have the same powers as you, well with better upgrades"

"Look I don't know what your plan is but these games have got to stop"

"Games, I'm not playing any games, I'm trying to save my family the one that you're going to ruin"

"What" said a shocked Cole "Does that mean I'm going to turn evil again"

"No" said the voice "No, you don't but your love for Phoebe destroys my family". The voice suddenly became quite, and in front of Cole shimmered Crystal "Why, do you love her more than my mother more than me"? She whispered

"Are you my..." "Daughter... yeah". Cole was so shocked that he didn't even realise that Phoebe had come in the room having fought the stun he put on her.

"Cole you in here" shouted Phoebe walking in there family reunion

"Why can't you leave him alone?" shouted Crystal to a shocked Phoebe who had just seen both Cole and Crystal in the cave crying

"Was it you who brought us here" said Phoebe positing herself in a fighting stance

"I don't want to fight you anymore" said Crystal in a defeated Voice "I don't know why I thought I could change the future... goodbye Cole"

"Wait what is you name" asked Cole

"Crystal" said Crystal smiling "You gave it to me, it was you father sisters name" she said before shimming out

"Cole" said Phoebe running to him "are you ok?" she said with concern in her voice

"Yeah"

"So I was right she is you daughter," said Phoebe with evident pain in her voice

"Yes" he said noticing the note of pain in her voice "But it seems like I gave up on her and her mother for you".

"Cole I'm sorry"