A/N: See I'm trying to keep up the updating! And remember...the pregnancy from season 2 finale did not happen. And I promise, its not because I''m in denial. I just think that would screw up a lot of stuff for this fic. Lia06: Sorry about the Ephram/Madison. I hate them too don't worry! I wouldn't do anything evil.

Enjoy!

Ephram walked outside the men's dream house in a white and blue baseball tee and a pair of jeans. He wasn't ready for this day. Too bad he couldn't call in sick. He was supposed to want this. When he saw the limo pull into the huge driveway his stomach did a huge flip. Not because he was excited, but because he was dreading it.

Madison popped her head out of the car and once again, Ephram came face to face with his first love, and second choice.

"Ephram!" She said, with a surprised look on her face. She wasn't expecting him and she didn't know if she was upset or excited. No matter how she felt she had to act excited. For the cameras. She ran up to him and gave him a hug and together scooted into the limo, followed by the cameramen. They were in for drama fit for Hollywood.

An hour or so later the rest of the men came out the house and were greeted by another limo. Amy's limo. The limo was soon filled by Aaron, Nathan, Shane, Ethan, and Josh. She was surprised when she saw Aaron come into the limo. She pretended not to notice. And when the rest of them came in, she had no idea what the hell was going on. She acted as normal as she could but the whole time she was wondering where Ephram was.

"Amy?" Shane asked Amy.

"Yeah." Amy replied.

"You seem kinda distant. You ok. I mean you didn't even laugh at Josh's Dropping the Soap joke."

Amy hadn't heard the joke. But from the title, she was sure she wouldn't have laughed anyway.

"So, Ephram what do you do for a living?" Madison politely asked. They had been doing all day, for two hours. For the helicopter ride they looked outside the windows looked excited and pretended to be excited to be with each other. But now that they were about to go to the movies they actually had to talk.

They had the theater all to themselves. Except of course for the massive amounts of cameracrews. They had promised that they would leave during the movie. The owners of the theater were stretching the rules by letting the cameras in at all and when they asked to film during the movie the idea was immediately nixed.

"I play piano. Some say I'm on the way to being an international star!" Ephram said with the same sarcasm he had kept for all those years.

Madison couldn't help but grin. Grin like she used to. Back when they were dating and he would say something funny like that. In a way she still missed him after all these years.

Thinking of years made her laugh to herself. Years. She had been so uptight back then. She knew she had given up something great for a stupid reason. That's why she never forgave herself. He was the perfect guy. She hadn't dated anyone better before or after. Amy was a lucky girl.

The lights began to get dark and the cameramen left as the commercials began to play.

"Ephram, we need to talk." Madison said as soon as the cameramen were definitely gone.

"You're telling me. What the hell am I doing here?" Ephram replied.

"Look Ephram I had no idea what happened. I would've thought you'd be on a date with Amy. I mean no matter what compatibility test or whatever other crap they throw at you, you guys are gonna end up together."

"What?"

"Look, you and Amy are perfect for each other. I'm not even thinking about us. The truth is I love you too much for you not to live life with the person who you're obviously meant to be with."

"Wait, you love me?" The confused Ephram asked. "I never knew you even loved me back then. But now? I haven't even seen you for 10 years."

"I always loved you Ephram. I just didn't know it." Madison replied, saying the last part softly. She looked down, even though the movie had just begun.

"Madison," Ephram said, pulling her chin up with his hand, "What's done is done. I guess I should have told you that before we started dating. I had already fallen in love with Amy, nothing could have stopped it. Not even a beautiful and great girl like you. Well I guess you were more of a woman. But I fell in love with you. But I just couldn't live life without my first choice. I'm sorry Madison."

"Its fine." Madison said, wiping a tear from her eye. "I knew it back then and I know it now. The only difference is that this time I won't get in the way."