Tuesday – 23 July
Tuesday morning arrived with as clear blue a sky as anyone could wish for. Dumbledore arrived at Amelia Bones' office at 9:00 AM.
"Well, Albus, what grand scheme have you got cooked up?"
"A few questions first, if I may, Amelia. Has anyone had the opportunity to depose Mundungus yet?"
"No. Based on the evidence, someone had cast the killing curse at him, and missed, hitting the case of Cognac that he was carrying instead. The blast knocked him down, hitting his head on the cement floor unconscious. Soaking in the cognac for two hours had left him positively pissed. We released him from a holding room late Tuesday morning. Why?"
"There is every possibility that he saw his attacker. We could use a solicitor's pensive, and possibly see who it was. Severus claims that none of the five attacked Kingsley or Mundungus. Severus also claimed that he stunned Auror Jones to prevent any of the others from casting a killing curse on her. You may want to review Auror Jones' memory of the event with her, again to see if someone, possibly Peter Pettigrew was there."
He continued, "It may be worth your consideration to try a pensive memory extraction from Draco, or Thomas Goyle. It is possible that they glanced in Severus' direction, and either may have seen him fall from Harry's stupefaction jinx or have seen who has cast the third curse. It may have been cast from someone on the other side of Goyle." Dumbledore had not yet mentioned examining Harry's memory of the events. He wanted Bones to arrive at conclusions similar to his own without too much prodding on his part.
Amelia Bones had not gotten as far as she had by being a shabby investigator. She realized that Dumbledore was right, even if he did have a personal interest in the case. It didn't matter to her that she hadn't invented the suggestions. They were good ones. If Snape was telling the truth, there had to have been a sixth or seventh person there.
She knew that she could win his freedom, but unless they walked an incredibly thin tightrope, doing so would sign his death warrant with Voldemort. Rita Skeeter could be led to write a story implying that there was a lack of evidence in his specific case.
She asked Dumbledore, "Do you believe that the person who stunned Shacklebolt and tried to kill Mundungus threw the wand at Bellatrix/Snape to get rid of it, or to further implicate Bellatrix?"
"I did get a chance to look at Harry's recollection of the battle. Between the time that Severus was stunned, and the time that Thomas fell, a second throw away wand appeared on the ground about ten feet from Severus. Please examine Auror Jones' report, or question her again. Perhaps Auror Dawlish should revise the wand spell report to indicate that the owner of wand number 3 is listed as unknown. Where was Severus' own wand found?"
"On his leg holster."
"I hadn't considered any intention on the part of the unidentified attacker, other than to get rid of a wand that could be traced back to the attack. I suspect that either Mundungus or Hestia saw Peter, either in his rat form or as himself. That would establish that he was there. Harry's memory, if he chooses to share it with the Wizengamot would establish that Severus did not have the extra wand." Dumbledore chose not to mention his conversation with Draco yet.
She replied, "Okay. I'll see to it. Please keep in mind that keeping Snape out of Azkaban for attempted murder doesn't make him innocent. He would still receive his fines, be convicted of the other charges, most likely found unfit to teach in Briton, and have to face the Grangers. Pray to Merlin that Mrs. Granger doesn't have a wine bottle in her hand at the time. She has every right to charge him in muggle court, and you would do well not to fight it."
"Thank you for looking into this so thoroughly, Amelia. Regarding Dr. Granger, you are of course correct."
Tuesday's Prophet was kinder to Dumbledore than anything that he could have hoped for.
Death Eaters Charged
Story by Rita Skeeter
Four Death Eaters were charged yesterday, each with identical counts including; Attempted Murder, Damage to Property, Possession of Death Eater paraphernalia, and possession of an unauthorized wand.
The suspected Death Eaters were identified as:
Thomas Goyle – age 42
Gregory Goyle – age 16
Vincent Crabbe – age 16
Draco Malfoy – age 16
A fifth person had been arrested at the scene, but has not yet been charged. Speculation exists that there may be a lack of evidence in his case.
A trial date has not been announced, but is expected to begin in the next two weeks. It has not been announced if there will be separate or individual trials. Wizengamot Chief, Albus Dumbledore could not be reached for comment.
If convicted, the four face the following maximum penalties:
Attempted murder – 15 years Azkaban
Damage to property – 10 x the value of the damaged property
Possession of an unauthorized wand – 1,000 Galleons
Possession of Death Eater paraphernalia – 2,000 Galleons
Underage magic - Expulsion
This reporter believes that the sooner these menaces to wizarding society are thrown in prison, the better.
There were no group photographs this time, only the individual photos of the four charged, and one of the hangman's noose. Rita knew that she was sowing IOUs with this, and knew better than to ask why. There obviously were lives on the line. She had previously owled a draft of the story over to Bones under the pretense of verifying that there were no factual errors. Rita knew that asking approval on what was very obviously a sensitive case, would gain her many granted favors down the road. Strangely, the request to keep any references to Snape out of the paper had not come from the usual channels – some junior Auror. Instead it came from the most unlikely source, Harry Potter himself.
On Tuesday for the first time ever Harry awoke in his own bed in his own home. "Thank you, Sirius," he muttered to himself. He would need to do some shopping, and get some things on the walls. He got up, showered, got dressed, and started making breakfast.
Remus was in the pub, reading the Sun when his cellular telephone rang.
"Hi Remus, it's Hermione."
"I would have expected you to simply walk over rather than call."
"I wanted to ask you about having a birthday party of some sort for Harry. Do you think he'd be happier with a larger group, or just a little group?"
"I don't know. To my knowledge he has only ever had one birthday party, and it was quite a large party. What do you think?"
"If we had a big party, I was thinking about the Black Dog. If we had a little party, I was thinking about Harry's space above the Black Dog. My parents aren't really up for too much wizarding company right now."
"I understand. Give me a couple of hours. I'll check with Tim, and see if he's interested in closing the place on the 31st for a private party. I'll call you, if I don't see you first. Also, Harry wanted to do some shopping and go to Diagon Alley this afternoon. I'm certain that he would want you to come."
"Thanks, Remus. I'd love to come along."
"I could owl Ron if you would like. You two haven't had much of a chance to see him this summer."
"If you want." She didn't sound enthused. Perhaps he was best not to interfere. Remus had been on the outside, watching a romance grow years before, and decided that Harry had enough complexity in his life, without "Uncle Remus" stirring the pot. Harry didn't need a parent in his life now, so much as a nonjudgmental mentor. He knew that the time for Harry to begin a more intense level of battle training was rapidly approaching, and if he wanted to have a fun week with his girlfriend, who would deny him?
Remus gave her an out. "Perhaps we could invite Ron another time. We'll be ready to leave about noon. Would you like to come over for lunch, before we leave?"
"Thanks Remus. You're the best." She sounded much happier.
"OK. In the mean time, I'll check with Tim. Bye." He went upstairs, found that Harry had gotten up, and had just finished making breakfast. The pancakes were very good, and the coffee was excellent. He thanked Harry for making breakfast, and told him that Hermione had called about going shopping that afternoon. He volunteered to clean the dishes, realizing that Harry was far and away the better cook of the two. Harry's OWL scores arrived after breakfast. He had passed everything except History of Magic.
Hermione arrived about ten. They made their respective shopping lists for Diagon Alley
Books
Butterbeer
Wizards Wireless
School Robes
Stop at www
Gift for Hermione (on Harry's list)
Gift for Harry (on Hermione's list)
Harry and Hermione showed each other and Remus their OWL scores. Remus was amazed that anybody could be so good at so many subjects. Hermione had even taken the OWL for Muggle studies, even though she had dropped the class. He congratulated them both. They locked the door, and got into the car.
Every trip to Diagon Alley was an adventure for Harry. They drove into London, and found a spot to park near the Leaky Cauldron. They walked into the dingy pub (Harry had developed more of a discriminating eye when it came to pubs, living above one), said 'hello' to Tom, who nodded, but did not say their names, as they passed out the back door to the bricked back alley. Hermione tapped the bricks, which opened into an arch, allowing them to enter. Remus walked back to the pub for a moment, and made arrangements to have six cases of butterbeer ready when they returned in a few hours.
He met up with Harry and Hermione at Madam Malkin's. Hermione loved shopping with Harry. He was willing to try things on, and hold things up. Harry ordered three sets of school robes, a set of dark blue robes for other occasions, and a new set of dress robes that Hermione had picked out. He talked her into a matching set of dark blue robes, an ice blue set of dress robes that looked stunning on her, and a new set of school robes. The both dragged Remus over, and picked out two sets of robes for him. He smiled to himself at the thought of having two people who really cared about him. Madam Malkin said that they would be ready in about two hours.
Next, they went to Gringotts. Harry made a withdrawal of 5,000 Galleons, more than the sum of all his previous withdrawals. Remus was tempted to say something, but remembered that everything that Harry owned to wear had been purchased for him last week by Hermione, including his shorts. Remus had only made 5,000 Galleons in a year one year of his life, and had a hard time viewing that much money as spending cash.
Harry purchased two magical cameras, a wizarding wireless, a magical bracelet for Hermione, owl treats, wrist wand holsters for both of them, gifts for Ron, Neville, Ginny, and Luna. Hermione went off to do some shopping on her own for a few minutes, while Remus and Harry went to Quality Quidditch Supplies. They went back to the car to drop off their packages, and Remus picked up the butterbeer from Tom. They decided that they would stop off at the Weasley store and then have tea.
If the Gringotts building could be described as understated elegance, the front entrance to Weasleys Wizarding Wheezes could only be compared to a carnival. Flashes, buzzes, bangs, and aromas assaulted their senses as the stepped into the store. Trays of stink bombs, canary creams, fireworks, fake wands, and tricks for every occasion were on display. George saw them, and in his best fake oily voice called out, "Mr. Potter, Ms. Granger, Mr. Lupin, how nice, how nice to see you." They all started laughing at George's impression of Mr. Borgin, the shady shopkeeper from Harry's second year. They got the tour and ran into Ron in the back. He looked a little embarrassed at seeing them. "Hi Harry. Hi Hermione. I'm sorry I haven't written yet this summer. I've been working here a lot and spending some time with Luna. How about you?"
Harry replied, "I've been spending quite a bit of time getting to know Susan Bone's Aunt. Remus is staying with me."
"What about your aunt and uncle?" It was obvious that Ron was clueless about what had been going on in Harry's life. Dumbledore had kept things really quiet, and Harry didn't want to go into a lot of details at the moment.
"I'm staying at another place now. How are things going here?" Harry moved the conversation back to Ron's side of the fence.
Ron liked working with his brothers, and felt better about himself with some of his own money. Hermione asked how Luna was, believing that she had heard his original mumbled response. They had been dating, which removed a complication for Harry and Hermione.
George left Lee Jordan in charge at the counter. The Weasleys and Harry's group went upstairs for tea. Ron told his news of working at the store, and mentioned the long hours that he had been putting in. It was obvious that he was very focused on his job and seeing Luna at night. They had grown to really like each other's company. Ron was having a pretty good summer. The logistics just did not make it easy for them to see each other as neither the Granger home nor Harry's place were connected to the floo network.
Hermione told of her summer with Ron half-listening until she came to the attack on he parent's home last Sunday.
"Blimey, that was your house? What happened?"
She told him the basics of the story, leaving out the part about Snape, explaining that they had been sent out of the house while it was being cleaned up, and that the Aurors were gone by the time that they had returned.
"Harry, you really kicked some Death Eater arse! I wish I could have seen it."
Harry shook his head and had a sad look on his face. "No you wouldn't - not really. There was screaming, flying glass, doors being smashed in, blood, and terror in good people's hearts. It was a miracle that no one was killed."
Hermione chirped in, "It was good luck that no one was killed, but Harry had a lot to do with that." He had downed most of the Death Eaters by the time that help had arrived." She beamed at him, and squeezed his hand.
Ron came back, not having listened to a word. "Just think, with Malfoy, Crabbe, and Goyle off the team. Slytherin won't stand a chance this year."
Fred and George who had read the paper congratulated Harry and Hermione. They sent Ron downstairs to get something, and told him that Dumbledore had called a meeting of the Order for that night. Remus mentioned that the topic of the meeting was likely to center on the fifth Death Eater. Harry mentioned that it was time to get going. They left shortly after. On the drive home, Remus asked Harry if there was a reason that he didn'tt want to share his news with Ron.
Harry replied, "Ron was having a great time telling us about his job, and about Luna. I wanted to let him have his moment. Besides the unpublished details of the attack are really Order and Ministry business. Ron is a lot of good things, but he can't keep a secret to save his life."
They carried all of their new things upstairs. Hermione had to get home for dinner.
Harry would be over to the Grangers after dinner, while Remus went to the Order meeting.
After Hermione left, Remus helped Harry put everything away. He asked Harry if Ron had known that Harry and Hermione had started dating. Harry thought for a minute before answering, "We hadn't really talked about telling anyone yet. Something we can do tonight, I suppose. How long do you think you will be tonight?"
"Harry, it could vary. Dumbledore has to tell the Order that one of their own was involved in an attempt to kill you and Hermione. Hear me out. It will be very divisive to the Order. There will be those who will stand and say that Snape was just following the others in his role as spy, and those who will say that he should have stopped it, or never gone along. The evidence is that the attack was directed at Hermione, but there will be those who may believe that it was directed at you. There are many in the Order who place a higher value on your life than another student, simple because they all know you. It doesn't make it right, but their opinions are real. Dumbledore will need to button up the meeting quickly, or things could get out of hand for him. To answer your question, I expect to be at the Grangers by ten."
After dinner Remus walked Harry over to the Grangers, and apparated to Grimmauld Place. They were enjoying the evening out in the back garden.
"Did any of your neighbors say anything about Sunday?" Harry asked Mr. Granger.
"No. The Collins, whose house is behind the back garden weren't home, and no one said a thing. There really wasn't much noise, other than the windows breaking. Your wands don't make a lot of noise, and the whole affair only lasted a few minutes."
"I'm really glad that you and Mr. Granger weren't hurt."
Emma knew that Harry meant what he said, and felt very close to the young man. "Thanks Harry. We're glad that you and Hermione are safe too. Thank you."
Dan inquired, "So Harry, How did you do on your wizarding tests?"
"Pretty good. I received the highest mark awarded in forty years in Defense. I did well in Charms, Transfiguration, Potions, and Care of Magical Creatures too. I'm really happy for Hermione, being named the top student of the year. That's brilliant!"
"Have you heard from your Uncle?"
Harry shook his head sadly. He doubted that he would hear from uncle Vernon again. "No. He probably just wants to be left alone."
"You're right. Speaking of that, we will leave you two alone. Come in later, we will make some lemonade."
Harry looked into Hermione's eyes for a moment. "Hermione, are you Okay with telling people that we are a couple?"
"Of course I am. Why do you ask?"
"You didn't mention anything today to Ron. I didn't know what to think."
"I kind of felt the same way that you did. I wanted to let him have his moment. How about you, are you Okay telling people?"
"What should I say, that you thought enough about me to save my life when I was feeling really crappy, that you are the prettiest and smartest witch in the school, that you see the real me, and you still love me?"
She blushed. "That would be fine with me. Thank you very much, Harry Potter. I do love you. Harry?"
"Huh?"
"When you're done looking at me, would you come over here? There is a spot right next to me, and it would be easier for me to snog you senseless if we weren't sitting across from each other."
Fifteen minutes later a very happy Harry and Hermione went inside. After they came in, Mrs. Granger made a point to lock the door, something that she never would have thought about a week ago.
Harry and Hermione made plans to visit their library on Wednesday morning.
Mrs. Granger commented that it was really nice of Remus to take them everywhere that they needed to go. They both agreed and spent the evening watching a video.
… - …
By eight that evening the entire Order, except Snape were seated in the great room at Grimmauld place. They had all read the Prophet's account of the raid, or had been there, and wanted to hear the story behind the story. Dumbledore knew that this had the potential to be the most divisive issue that the Order had faced in since the attack on Lilly and James. Once again, Pettigrew and Severus were in the thick of it.
He decided that the winning move was to start with the thousand word version, sit back and let them talk it out, then attempt to make any course corrections as needed. Severus had few personal friends in the Order – though most members at least respected his efforts. Few who had school age children, or who had been his student would ever forgive his ruthless teaching style, and many netted the two aspects together against Severus' benefit.
"As most of you know, there was an attack on the Granger home in West Sussex last Sunday, at ten AM. At the property at the time were Doctor and Doctor Granger, Hermione, Harry Potter, and a friend of the family, Dr. Turnbull. Kingsley and Hestia were there patrolling for the Order. Mundungus was also at the house making a delivery."
Dumbledore continued. "An as yet unidentified assailant attempted to kill Mundungus in the garage of the Granger house prior to the main attack. Their killing curse missed him, instead hitting a carton that he was carrying, knocking him to the floor unconscious. Mundungus, we are all relieved that you have recovered. We believe that the same assailant, or a different unidentified assailant stunned Kingsley at about the same time. Kingsley, we are equally relieved that both you and Hestia have also recovered."
"Hestia saw Kingsley fall, and called out a warning before being stunned by one of the five Death Eaters that had portkeyed in to form the main body of the raiding party. Two of the Death Eaters went around the front of the house and stormed the door a minute after the firefight started in the back garden."
"The first Death Eater shattered one of the kitchen windows. Inside, Harry Potter stood up to stun the first attacker, and the attacker was hit. Immediately after, three killing curses were cast at Harry, two came from the other Death Eaters, the third cast from an unknown source. A second window was shattered. Harry and Hermione fired stunners at the same time, hitting another Death Eater. A few seconds later the other two Death Eaters crashed through the front door. Hermione's mother and her friend each threw a bottle of wine at the attackers, with Dr. Granger's bottle hitting one of the Death Eaters in the head. Harry Potter stunned the other."
"At about that time, a team of Aurors arrived, and immediately stunned the fifth Death Eater. They searched the area finding wands, and a hangman's rope to be used with the intention of lynching Miss Granger in front of her parents."
"We have evidence that one of the wands found in the back yard was thrown there by one of the unidentified assailants."
"While waiting processing, the Death Eaters were photographed by Rita Skeeter's photographer. During the photography, the assailant originally thought to be Bellatrix Lestrange turned out to be Severus Snape. He had used Polyjuice potion to impersonate Bellatrix and had been stunned by Harry. The other Death Eaters have been identified as Thomas Goyle, his son Gregory, Vincent Crabbe, and Draco Malfoy. They do not know that Severus had taken the place of Bellatrix."
"All five have been interrogated, and are in individual holding cells. Severus has not been identified in the Prophet. The other four were identified in today's issue."
"The other four have been charged with attempted murder, possession of an unauthorized wand, damage to property and possession of Death Eater paraphernalia. The three students were also charged with unauthorized underage use of magic in a muggle area. A trial date of late next week will be announced tomorrow. I have not yet conferred with the other heads of the Wizengamot to determine if five individual trials will take place, or two trials, one for the four, the other for Severus."
The Order members had sat in rapt silence, hanging on every word. The Grangers were not faceless victims. Some of the members knew the dentists, most knew Hermione, and everyone knew Harry.
Dumbledore concluded. "I would like to open the meeting up first for clarifying questions, then later for statements of viewpoint. Everyone who has a question or viewpoint will be allowed to speak. Can we agree on that? Thank you."
"Had Severus mentioned that he would be going on a raid?" asked Molly Weasley.
"No. He hadn't told anyone."
"When you say anyone, are you referring to our side, or anyone at all?" asked Remus.
"His being there remains unknown to the arrested Death Eaters, who believe that Bellatrix was also captured. Voldemort doubtless knows that someone else took her place."
"What is the significance of the extra wand?" asked Tom the barkeep.
"Each of the wands were tested for the last spell cast. There is every likelihood that the unknown assailant threw the wand in the yard after casting the killing curse with it. The investigative issue for Severus is finding out who cast the third killing curse, or at least proving beyond doubt that the wands that Severus used did not cast a killing curse at Harry Potter."
"What legal issues are Severus facing, and how is he reacting?" asked Tonks.
"In the wizarding world, he could possibly evade the attempted murder charge, if Harry were to testify on his behalf, or the other assailant is captured, and confesses in the next few days. He will be charged, and most likely found guilty of damage to property, possession of an unauthorized wand, and possession of Death Eater paraphernalia. These three charges are punishable by substantial fines and most likely the loss of his teaching position."
"You framed your answer within the contest of the wizarding world. What else is there?" Amos Diggory asked.
"The Grangers have every right to also press charges against any or all of those involved in the attack. It is of no surprise that they are more than a little upset over the attack, the relationship of the participants to Hogwarts, and the fact that Severus has yet to be charged. They believe him at least equally responsible for the attack, and are demanding that he serve time in a prison. It is their right to feel that way."
"Did Snape offer an explanation for joining in the raid as opposed to helping us stop it?" Moody asked.
"He had made a wizard's pledge to Narcissa to do everything that he could to prevent Draco from being killed, or from doing something to earn a death sentence."
Arthur Weasley asked, "Have the prisoners been interrogated to identify operations against any other wizard homes?"
"Draco implied that there are other operations being planned. I intend to see him again tomorrow and learn what he is willing to tell us."
Hestia asked, "Why not use Veritaserum?"
"His outer facade seems to be crumbling. I am curious to see what he will voluntarily tell me."
"Are there other questions? If not, let's move on to viewpoints."
"What is your personal viewpoint on Snape's actions?" Shacklebolt did not look like a happy man.
"I recognize that Severus risked his own safety, his career, and his freedom for what most people would consider an unworthy cause. I recognize that there may have been other ways of stopping Draco that would likely prove less costly to Severus. I recognize that not telling us in advance was a serious mistake. He was caught in the hallway without a pass."
Lupin spoke up. "I agree with all of your viewpoints Albus, but we seem to be forgetting that Snape made decisions that placed the safety of young Malfoy ahead of the safety of the Grangers, Harry, Dr. Turnbull, Hestia, Kingsley, or Mundungus. He made a choice. He got caught, and we seem to be feeling bad for the criminals while ignoring the victims. I'm not trying to turn this into an old family issue, but it has some of the appearances."
"Sirius made a similar pledge to James and Lilly. No one thought ill of him for risking all in keeping that pledge."
Molly stood up. "We all understand the finality of a wizards pledge. What can we do to help Severus?"
Remus came back, "We haven't agreed that his actions warrant rescue, have we? There are no votes on the table."
Dumbledore did not want this to get out of hand. Indeed it had the potential to rapidly splinter the order.
Minerva stood up. "Before we argue about what we are or are not willing to do for Severus, it may be worth asking, what if anything has he asked us to do on his behalf?"
Dumbledore stood up relieved at Minerva's change of direction. "Severus has asked us to do nothing. As always, he has taken full responsibility for his actions. He understood the risks every day that he worked with the order. He understood the risks of getting caught last Sunday. If possible, I would like to see him avoid fifteen years in Azkaban. If possible, I would like to keep him out of muggle prison if it does not mean estranging the other focus of the Order."
He continued, "It is unethical to coach witnesses so that their testimony better aligns with our personal wishes. It is equally unethical to deprive the Grangers of their right to press charges against Severus in the muggle courts. It is doubtless that their lives were in jeopardy, and Severus has yet to convince anyone that he had a plan to stop the other four from achieving their objective. Had Harry, Hestia, and Kingsley not been there, I have every reason to believe that we would have had tragic results. Severus did not have a well thought out plan to stop the attackers. The action that might save Severus time in prison would be for Peter to testify that he cast the curse, or the capture of Bellatrix."
"The Wizengamot has the power to set his trial date, or delay it indefinitely. I believe that it is his best interest that a trial be delayed for a while."
Lupin stood up. "Albus, speaking for myself, I know that you are trying to do what is best for everyone. Everyone here has accepted the risk of consequences as a result of their work with the Order. I don't expect you to make allowances that I am an Order member if I go out and commit a crime, regardless of my reasoning for doing so. In my opinion, Severus was acting completely outside of Order business, and got caught committing a crime. In my opinion, there should be no allowances made, no subtle influence of anyone's testimony in the name of seeking the truth, and no influences against anyone's right to press charges for a crime, or wrongdoing that undisputedly was committed. In my observation, Snape benefited for many years with his close association with the Malfoys, and now is being asked to pick up the tab." Lupin sat down.
Tonks stood up. "I agree with Remus."
Moody, Hestia and Shacklebolt stood up looked at each other, nodded, and said as one, "We do too." Minerva nodded. Tom nodded. Hagrid, Fred and George nodded. Mundungus, Victor, and a dozen of the others look uncomfortable, and fortunately remained silent.
Dumbledore was frustrated. This was exactly what he didn't want to happen. "Our central business is to fight the dark side and protect those that do. There is nothing for us to decide tonight, and no one wants Severus' legal issues to become divisive to the Order. Most of all, Severus does not want that to happen. I am not confusing the silence of some who have chosen not to speak with implied concurrence of another's viewpoint. No one was killed, or severely injured, and four Death Eaters will most likely be going to Azkaban. Thank you all for coming this evening. I wish you a safe journey home. Good night, my friends." He had closed the meeting in such a manor as to discourage hall talk, which in this case would only serve to be divisive.
… - …
When they were going home, Remus told Harry of the evening's events. They both wondered why Dumbledore hadn't been more specific with the details of the story.
… - …
Minerva was at the breakfast table Wednesday morning before Dumbledore, an uncharacteristic event. Flitwick and Sprout joined her. Flitwick commented, "It's good to see you again Minerva, and Pomona. I hope your holidays have been restful. My vacation to Thailand was fascinating. The people are very friendly, and the accommodations were excellent. I rode on the top of an elephant. I haven't done that in fifty years. From the newspaper accounts here, it sounds like young Harry Potter has been dismantling Voldemort's Death Eaters faster than he can replace them. Did I read that another five were captured this week?" Minerva chewed on her bacon strip longer than necessary.
Dumbledore sat down. "You did, Filius, you did, and you are correct. Harry did stop several of them himself, and most certainly saved some lives again. Thank you all for coming today. I know that we had not planned on meeting until the first of August, but changes have come, and I would like your input. As most of you know, Severus has been acting as a spy for the light side against Voldemort, since his return a little more than a year ago. He took part in the raid last Sunday against the Grangers. His participation in the attack was authorized neither by our side, or Voldemort, rather a personal attempt to keep Draco Malfoy from committing a crime that would earn him a life sentence. In doing so, Severus committed enough minor offenses to make it likely that I will accept his resignation that he has given me. It is likely that he will end up serving time in a muggle prison, or some alternate arrangement, if one can be negotiated."
He concluded, "With respect to possible replacements, should the need arise, I am very interested in hearing your suggestions regarding candidates. I am looking for younger people that have good personal skills, and some teaching skills, as much or more than their being world famous experts in their field. Our experience with Mr. Lockhart illustrates that fame may not equate to knowledge, or the ability to transfer knowledge to our students."
"When you say younger, Albus, could you be more specific?" asked Flitwick. "Relative to you and I, younger would include 98 percent of the wizarding population. Also, are you asking for Potions candidates, Defense candidates, or both?"
"The most likely case is that we will need to fill both positions. We will also need a head of house for Slytherin. Someone who will not coddle those students who have already made up their mind to be junior Death Eaters, or see those who have, as possessing some sort of prestige. I was recently reminded that we have no obligation to teach those who are determined to become criminals."
The three heads of houses stole glances at each other and collectively smiled. Christmas had come early.
Professor Flitwick spoke first, "In the event that we may need to fill the Potions position, you may wish to speak to Professor Wo Pei Chang. Chang is Cho Chang's uncle, who has come to live in Briton to spend more time with his brother's family. His English is flawless, and he knows his craft. I believe that the students would find him to be both nurturing and patient."
Professor Sprout spoke next, "I think the answer for the Defense position is obvious, though radical. To my knowledge, there are no formal age limitations, or formal competency certifications required to teach here. A handful or more of our current students owe their very lives to him. Unlike the other candidates that we may also consider, we have first hand proof of his results. The kids who were in that secret club of his that took OWLs or NEWTs in June averaged a half of a grade better on the practical portions than the previous year. Certainly it wasn't attributable to 'hem hem. there's something in my throat' Umbridge. The trick would be to create some type of bridge position, so we could fulfil our obligations to him as well."
Flitwick came back, "We don't even have breathing requirements for a teaching position. Why should we worry and fuss about certifications? Most of us are here, because we love the school, and are good at what we teach. Does anyone have any doubts with respect to his ability? I fancied myself a dueling champion during the Great War. He could kick my arse in a blink. I seriously doubt that I could touch him on my best day, let alone now. We need to look at what we are teaching the kids, and add some topics – conditioning, healing, world politics, and business. These don't have to replace what we are currently offering, or even be full time topics, but could be additions."
Sprout agreed. "Look at the twins, one minute, they're expelled, the next successful business men. I wish I'd had the foresight to partner with them, or invest in their business."
Dumbledore nodded. "I will take both of your recommendations under advisement. Minerva, do you have anything to add?'
"With several recent replacements on the board of governors, all which clearly are in the light side, I see this as an opportunity to position Hogwarts a notch over from center with respect of politics and attitude. Director Bones was able to respond quickly at the Granger raid because she carries a muggle cellular telephone. I not saying that Harry wouldn't have kicked everyone's arse anyway, but it would have taken his owl Hedwig a half-hour to reach the ministry from West Sussex. Teaching our students survival skills should be first among equals in our priorities. I am told that Susan Bones was able to keep her attackers at bay for almost twenty minutes until help arrived. Her mother told me that she said it was solely due to skills that she had learned in the evening defense class. I would be sitting here crowing about my accomplishments as a great teacher, except that I had nothing to do with it."
The others nodded in agreement.
"Thank you all for your input. I will see you all again on the first of August. Please have a wonderful week."
As the heads of houses were leaving, Dumbledore received an owl.
Professor Dumbledore
You asked me if I could remember anything else about the attack on Sunday. When the attackers were searched, all had identical wrist wand holders. Snape only had one – on his left wrist. If he intended to carry a third wand, why wouldn't he have used a double wand holster?
That's all I can think of.
Tonks
As she was getting ready to leave, Dumbledore asked, "Minerva, can you stay for a minute?"
"Of course."
Dumbledore asked, "Did you lead Pomona and Filius to this conclusion, or did they arrive at it on their own?"
"Albus, I never said a word. I think Pomona was deeply affected by the attack on Susan Bones. There's not a doubt in my mind that she owes her life to Potter."
Dumbledore sipped his coffee. "I feel that Harry's needs have strayed from those that can be met by the traditional curriculum. He needs individual tutoring on Auror level fighting skills, conditioning, and healing. He needs to be able to manage a considerable amount of money, and he needs to acquire a workable defense against Tom, including the form of legimancy that Tom has used against Harry. He could be served by traditional classes in Charms, Transfiguration, and Potions."
Minerva asked, "Are you going to let him back on the house Quidditch team?"
"Of course, but I'm not certain that practicing flying maneuvers three evenings a week would be the best use of his time. I think he may rather have some time to spend with Miss Granger outside the company of Mr. Weasley, studying of course. The tone of the Quidditch games may change this year. Slytherin house will have a new team, as well as Gryffindor house. Perhaps we could have a student – staff game this year."
Are you certain that Severus will be unable to teach this year?"
He continued, "I believe that Severus has taught his last class at Hogwarts. I will contact Chang today and make a preliminary inquiry. I am optomistic that Severus will evade serving time in Azkaban. There are several private muggle institutions that could better accommodate his situation. Will you have a preliminary conversation with Harry regarding his career interests?"
"I will arrange it for later this afternoon. I'll send an owl now."
"Thank you, Minerva. I will contact Alastor and the others."
About noon, Dumbledore stopped back to the Ministry to see Severus. The young man seemed to have accepted his fate.
"Hello Headmaster."
"Hello Severus. I've done some investigating. We've found evidence that Peter Pettigrew cursed Mundungus, and by association, Kingsley. The Grangers have stated their intent to file charges against you through the muggle courts. The minor charges will be filed through the Wizengamot. I anticipate that the total fines will not be in excess of four thousand Galleons. Do you have sufficient funds to cover the fines, or could I help you?" Dumbledore knew that Snape was not a wealthy man.
"I'm fine, but thank you for asking."
"Severus, in the event that either the Wizengamot or the muggle court system imposes prison time, how can I best help you?"
"I have my potions equipment, some personal possessions, and a cottage where I spend the summers. I will need to find a secure storage space to store the equipment and safely dispose of the potions that were in the process of being brewed. If there is a small space within the castle that I could use."
"Consider it done, my friend. Should you decide that I could possibly help you with funds, don't hesitate to say something."
"Lupin will need to find another source of Wolfsbane potion. I would recommend contacting Professor Chang. I believe that he is in the country visiting from China. I do not know him personally, but his reputation is excellent."
Dumbledore replied, "I will attend to that as well. The private prisons within the muggle court system have a work release program that may interest you. There is a cost that possibly could be offset in part by the work that is performed."
He continued, "It is my belief that the school board of governors will force a resignation should you be convicted of the fineable offenses. As such, if it is still your intent, I will regretfully accept your resignation as a Hogwarts Professor. I am asking you to please withdraw your resignation from the Order. You have been a valued member of the group, and I hope will continue to be in the future. I have every confidence that you will get past this situation."
"As you wish Headmaster. There is one other thing." Snape hesitated. Dumbledore was his friend, perhaps his only friend. "Please talk with Potter. I honestly didn't know that he was there. I had no intention of causing him harm. I…"
Dumbledore did not need to hear Severus embarrass himself. "I know what you are trying to say Severus. I will make certain that they understand."
"Thank you. I will see you later, Headmaster. Do not worry about me. I will be fine."
Next Dumbledore went to visit Draco. Dumbledore felt certain that young Malfoy would be quite co-operative. A cement floor bed and a coffee tin stool tended to do wonders with young aristocrats who had spent most of their life talking big, and doing little real work.
"Good afternoon, Draco. How are you today?"
"Okay Professor, and you?"
"Splendid thank you. There is nothing like the company of a spirited young lady. I'm sorry, I digress. We were talking about other Death Eater training and upcoming operations last time."
"I told you that I have nothing to tell you."
"Draco, how many nights do you think you will survive in your cell with a dementor floating outside the door? A week, a month, six months? It won't matter what you have to tell me after you have been sentenced, and having seen much of the evidence, I have little doubt that you will be convicted of the crimes that Director Bones has charged you with."
Draco knew that his options for living to be twenty-one were rapidly evaporating. "What do you want to know?"
"Who are the other Death Eaters?
"I have only been to one large group meeting, last December. The people that I saw in the house were Bellatrix, Greg, Vince, Thomas, Severus, Delores, and Rosier."
"Severus Snape?" Dumbledore did his best to sound surprised.
"Yes."
"What operations are being planned?"
"Delores is planning an operation with Bellatrix. I believe that Rosier is also planning an operation with Travis and one of the Borgins. Both would serve as training meetings for new recruits."
"How is Voldemort being financed?"
"I'm not certain. I believe that Father was involved."
"Who is currently living in Riddle Manor?"
"Bellatrix, Peter, and frequently Voldemort."
"What students or recent graduates are being recruited?"
"Warrington, Flint, Bullstrode, Derrick and Marietta."
"Who was doing the recruiting?"
"My father, McNair, and someone who works for Bones. Now I believe Umbridge is working on that."
"Draco, if you believe that Voldemort is really going to win this war, and that he will find out what you have told me, you just signed your own Death Warrant. If you believe otherwise, we should talk again in a few days. Enjoy your day."
Minerva had agreed to meet Harry in the Black Dog pub Wednesday at three. She had rehearsed what she wanted to say for several hours, and hoped to make a sale. Harry invited her up to his flat. She commented on the good taste of the decorating before getting down to business. She had an uncharacteristic smile on her face. "Mr. Potter, I would like to congratulate you on your fine OWL scores. Tell me, are you still interested in becoming an Auror?"
"Director Bones has talked with me about it. She said that she would take me into the program if I got NEWTs in Defense, Transfiguration, Charms, and a class of my choice."
"Does that interest you?"
"I think so."
"Have you ever considered teaching?"
"What do you mean?"
She began her presentation, "Harry, our last career conversation was cut short, and was not held under the best circumstances. Could we start it again? Based in your OWL results, the DA results, yes we know about your group, and what we know about you, I see two career paths that you could easily take – teaching and law enforcement. Wizarding law enforcement has two main branches, investigative and enforcement. There are the Aurors who spend most of their time in investigative work, and the Hit Wizards, who are primarily enforcement and capture. You have a keen eye for detail, think extraordinarily fast on your feet, and possess superb reflexes – leaving both branches of law enforcement open to you, as I suspect Director Bones probably mentioned. As you know, law enforcement is dangerous work. You've seen Moody's battle scars from fifty years of law enforcement. I know that they rarely recruit students from school, but I believe that two people from Hogwarts are currently being recruited for future enrollment into their program. Law enforcement doesn't pay a lot of money, but for those who like the work, it is very satisfying."
Curious about the idea, Harry asked, "What about teaching?"
"Harry, for the right person, teaching is remarkably rewarding, again not in money, rather in job satisfaction. You may have experienced a taste of it last year in your defense group as members learned the spells that you showed them."
She continued, "If you are interested, Professor Dumbledore is prepared to offer you a part-time position to let you see for yourself."
Harry thought for a moment and asked, "Would saying yes to one mean saying no to the other?"
"I don't think so. I believe that he has some ideas regarding classes that you would take to best suit your, shall we say individual needs. Mr. Potter, speaking strictly for myself, I would be honored if you would consider Professor Dumbledore's offer. Shall I call him in? He's waiting downstairs."
"Please." She went to get him. A minute later Dumbledore opened the door.
"Hello Harry. I would like to offer you a part time teaching position at Hogwarts teaching Defense Against the Dark Arts, with Alastor Moody and a guest speaker teaching the theory portion. It would involve substantially expanding the role of practical studies instructor that you so ably organized last year. I will personally arrange your own class schedule so that you could attend the classes that you need along with the topics that I would like you tutored in."
"What classes would I be taking?"
Defense against Tom Riddle
Healing
Charms
Transfiguration
Potions
Business
Human transfiguration
Apparition
"You would teach your classes in the afternoons and the occasional evening."
"I would ask you to consider if you would like to be on the Quidditch team this year. Your ban is, of course, lifted. I am certain that professor McGonagall would be delighted to have you on the team, either as Seeker, or Seeker and Captain. However, your time may be better spent with some of your teaching activities, or activities with the Order, should you accept an invitation to join. Yes, Miss Granger will also be invited to join the Order."
Minerva spoke up, "Harry, I know that you love flying. Winning the Quidditch cup another time won't save lives, and there are lives to be saved this year. I would be honored to have you join us at the staff table on the first of September, but I realize that it is a big commitment."
"I'm very interested. What are the terms?"
Dumbledore smiled at his young friend. "Harry, the terms are as follows:
You need to pass a practical exam given by the Aurors in August.
You may use the staff living quarters if you wish.
You will have unrestricted access to both the school and my personal library.
There is no curfew.
You and a guest may visit Hogsmede every Saturday from 6AM until 9PM.
You will receive ½ of a starting teacher salary.
You may award or subtract points or order detentions subject to school guidelines.
You are expected to act in a professional manner and not abuse your privileges.
You may wear teacher's robes in the afternoons and evenings.
You will still retain membership in Gryffindor house as it suits you.
You may set the curriculum and agenda for the practical aspect of your class.
You will need to coordinate the agenda with the theory instructors.
The overall curriculum needs to be submitted for approval by the twenty second of August.
Except for Saturdays and Order activities, you must remain on the school grounds.
You may wish to purchase an expanded trunk.
You may wish to make use of the excellent reference library that you own.
"If you are interested, here is your contract."
"I accept. Thank you for the offer. I won't disappoint either of you." Harry signed the document, and handed it back to Professor Dumbledore."
"Thank you, Harry. As you need it, please see Professor McGonagall or myself for assistance in your class agendas. Also, I would ask that you meet with Alastor and decide on course books as soon as you can, preferably by the second of August, so we can notify the students what they need to purchase."
"Also aside from Miss Granger, please do not mention your non-traditional classes or topics to the other students."
"I won't Professor."
"Thank you again Harry. It would only be fair to mention that you are the first defense instructor in recent memory that received unanimous endorsement from all of the other Heads of Houses. We really appreciate your decision to share your skills with the other students."
… - …
After seeing Harry, Dumbledore returned to the Ministry to see Amelia Bones.
She greeted him, "Good afternoon Professor. I found Mr. Fletcher and we checked his memory of the attack. A short balding man cursed him, walking away before he hit the ground. The wand could have been the one found in the back garden, we don't know for certain. What was odd was that the man war running from the direction of the back garden and seemed to have stumbled upon Fletcher."
"I have asked Harry to come see me tomorrow morning. If he volunteers to show me his memory, and I see the same things that you described, I may not charge Snape except for the finable charges, though he still may face prison time in muggle prison. Does he possess sufficient funds to pay the fines himself?"
"I believe so. I have accepted his resignation as a Hogwarts Professor."
"What will he do? He is a very unpleasant man." She didn't like the man, and his treatment of her niece was reprehensible.
"Would you rather have him on our side working against Voldemort, or on Tom's side working against us?"
"The former of course. Perhaps I could contact a colleague in potions research at St. Mungos. Perhaps he could participate in a work-release program. That of course is predicated on decisions from Mr. Potter and the Grangers. Do not pressure them Dumbledore. I will visit them after I have spoken with Mr. Potter. Have you set trial arrangements for the four?"
Dumbledore replied, "I have contacted the other Wizengamot heads. We have decided on one trial for the four, and common sentencing, should they be found guilty. I will ask Harry, the Grangers and Dr. Turnbull to be available on Monday 29 July at 8 AM. Should that prove workable for them, I will contact you immediately."
"I will call the Grangers when I have spoken with Harry. I won't be ready to file charges against Snape until next Monday or Tuesday, so I recommend scheduling a hearing on the morning of the first of August." She got up. "Thank you for your time Professor."
"Have a good afternoon, Director." Dumbledore left to have dinner with Professor Chang.
ooo CCC ooo
The old scribed realized that there was a big difference between not guilty, and innocent.