Knowing that by removing Demona wanted Puck to kill all the humans in Manhattan just like she how wanted the human Elisa Maza to no longer exist. Luckily for him that Demona was not exact with her wording thus there was a lot of wiggle room for him to do what he wanted without going against what she said. What she said and what she wanted were not the same thing after all. To make so that human Elisa Maza did not exist he merely turned her into a gargoyle thought this was how she was since she was originally hatched. When she wanted all the humans in Manhattan removed similarly. He just turned them all into gargoyles as well since that is what she asked for was to have what she did to Elisa repeated even though she would later get mad at him for doing so.
Only to be reminded that this was more her fault than his as he did want she said not what she wanted. She was not clear enough in her intention which she did not correct though when she wanted her mistake fixed. Though rather than having something they knew to belong to Titania mostly likely (That was from the fact that Demona had the mirror stolen and might have used to summon Puck was now chained up) facing them directly. The mirror was facing the opposite direction as them and was covered up. Thus Puck's spell did not work as they were not in the way of the mirror itself.
Manhattan Clan not being turned into humans was not the only thing that did not happen as given it was called Titania's mirror. It was likely that Titania herself was aware of the usage of her mirror and normally in most scenarios she was the one that prevents the world outside of Manhattan from noticing that a million plus gargoyle just appeared in the city that never sleeps. This lead to several cases that would have happened otherwise with not everyone that was now a gargoyle actually staying within the city itself. Along with other unforeseen actions not happening either.
Thus a teenage gargoyle named Oliver was staying with her Uncle named Niles at his home which was a building that had a comic book like store which was located on the ground level. The ones above that floor were either for customers that wanted to play games or off limits to customers. Those floors that were off limit to customers were Nile's floors for himself as well as those he had over as guests. Of course, they had come through his business but the stairs were done in such a way that you could go straight to the upper floors without having to deal with the lower ones.
Though what no one but a few was aware of was that Niles was actually a mage. Not overly powerful or important one but just an average mage that excelled at making a barrier and illusion spells which were what he sold those that required them. He was aware that there were more than just humans in this world. He was not aware of gargoyles though since there were not really that many of them in the Americas or Europe anymore. Thus knowledge of them was lost to the ages nor was he on a level where he would notice that Manhattan had just been turned into gargoyles either.
However since the building was still built with humans in mind despite everyone now being gargoyles, his nephew Oliver by mistake hit the right spot that unknowingly activated the barrier around his building. It did not keep anyone from entering or leaving however what it did do was prevent spells from affecting those that were inside at the time.
A woman came to see Niles in a rush and a seemingly panic as well.
"What did she do this time" he said sighing
"Nothing at least I hope its nothing but is Ray and her club here tonight" she asked
"Nope as she wanted to me come with her though claiming that she was going part of something dealing with the Pack though. Pretty sure they got arrested but maybe it's a new version since Fox did get out of jail recently herself" Oliver stated.
The woman who was not related to Ray by blood but had been her guardian her entire life had look on her face as if all the blood had just drained from it. Though that look was frozen in place as the sun rose and all three of them turned to stone on the spot as things with Demona and Puck took longer as well thus everyone was standing there on a building a good distance away from the tower Puck used to boost his powers the first time around.
This was where his decision not to include all the humans at once would backfire on him as he managed to change the majority of the citizens of Manhattan back to normal except for those within barriers that block his powers, left the city overnight, and well Elisa herself. Puck did not fix her along with everyone else in the city either because he could not because he had used two different spells after all. One for her and then one for the city of Manhattan itself. That or he just did not want to do them all at once but whatever the reason the sun rose and all the gargoyles in the city still turned to stone. This included the Manhattan Clan(who were never changed to human in this scenario)...and Elisa herself as well.
She saw the sun coming up as she looked out at it and then downwards at her hands. Trying to then look at Goliath with a worried expression on her face but the sun cut her off though. Elisa turned to stone just standing there as the spell that Puck used hit her just a moment too late. A flash of the light accord but when it died down Elisa the gargoyle was still standing there a statue now in stone sleep like a typical gargoyle would be.
"Great now whose going to set me free" Puck said to himself
Goliath and Demona were standing there as statues that were going to be able to help him anytime soon. Since they seemingly could no longer turn Elisa back into a human they might not ever free him because he could not keep his side of their deal after all.
"Oh, I think I could get you some help" a new yet familiar voice said to him.
"Ummm...I think I will just wait for the gargoyles to awaken at night then" Puck said
"Oh no, I insist as I have been wondering what happened to my mirror that went missing a while back after all" they told Puck.
"I guess she could come along as well" was heard as Puck, the Mirror, and Demona all vanished
Though Goliath, the others, and Elisa were all alone on the roof of the building but set so that they would look as if the building had gotten some gargoyle installed on it. At least that is what it would look like those that flew over and/or observed the roof of the building during the day