Angel quietly broke into the police station and took out the file on Kate's murder and disappearance and found the investigation closed due to lack of evidence and no witnesses or murder weapon to tie anyone to her murder. Angel was very upset and went back to question Jasmine and find out what she told the cops.
She opened the door wrapped in a blanket and just smiled at Angel. "Angel. What do I owe the pleasure of this visit?" she asked softly. "What did you tell the police Jasmine?" "About what? Poor Detective Kate she was killed but I didn't have anything to do with it." She replied with a soft smile and just looked at him. Angel turned and left and decided it was time to tell Penn what really caused him to come back.
Angel went back to work and saw the light in Penn's little office was still on and he went in to talk to him and he found Penn looking at a picture the an artist had done for them. It showed Jasmine and Penn sitting in the garden at her old home and they were so happy. Angel knocked and the sound jolted Penn out of his memory of how she was changed and what he had done to her.
He turned and looked at the door and saw Angel standing there. "Angel can I help you with something?" he asked quietly. Angel just walked in and sat down across from him. "Penn I need to tell you something about your love, Jasmine." He said slowly. "Well what about her is she alright." He asked urgently. "She killed Kate to bring you back. There was a spell and it required the blood of the person who killed you and then she let those vampires kill her so that there wasn't any evidence linking it to her." Angel said in one breath and then he sat there and let it all sink into Penn's mind.
Penn turned to look at Angel and all he saw was his love letting an innocent person die and how it didn't seem to bother her even with her soul. "You are lying." He whispered to Angel "Your just jealous of her love for me. You always were jealous that she loved me more than you Angel." He said trying not to cry. Angel comforted Penn the best he could but in a way her was right. He was jealous that he had made Jasmine into what she was and she didn't even love him.
In a way this was payback for that he had liked Kate and she had killed her and now he was destroying the one thing she cared for, her love for Penn and his for her. In a way it was justice and he just stood there as Penn stormed out into the night to confront his wife.
Jasmine sat on the couch waiting for Penn to come home and just hold her. Angel had left her felling very sad and scared. Outside it had started to rain so she lit a fire and waited for Penn to come through the door. Penn walked in and slammed the door and Jasmine knew that Angel had told him the truth and now she had to face it.