Scene Phoebe's bedroom, Phoebes Looking at an old album of her and Cole, and her and Jason."Cole if your back why go after Jason, why not me or Paige. I loved you Cole, but your lies cost you any trust I had for you. I tried to make it work, I did, but you messed that up when you tried to kill me sisters. Looks like love doesn't counter all, does it." Phoebe says and starts to cry when she hears a notice and turns around to see someone standing there. "Now why would you go and say that" the person says
Manor Attic Piper and Paige are still fighting when Leo notices something in the book "guys" Leo says fed up. "I thought you said you vanquished him" Piper yells at Paige. "I thought I did" Paige yells right back "guys" Leo yells as loud as he can "what" Piper and Paige says after they stop yelling "that's not Cole that attacked Jason, it was him" Leo turns the around so the girls can see him.
Scene Phoebe room "Colin, you scared me" Phoebe says as her hearts stop pounding. "Sorry, you ready to go house hunting, let me tell my sister" Colin says. Phoebe goes to the attic not paying any attention to Piper, Paige and Leo and starts talking. "Guys I'm going house hunting be back" Phoebe say as she starts to leave. "Wait just one minute" Piper says running up to her to stop her from going. "What" Phoebe say sounding like her wants to leave everything she know for years behind. "We know who attacked Jason, and it wasn't Cole" Paige says sound censer for once.
"Then who was it" Phoebe says getting all mad. "Him" Paige says pointing to a page in the book. Phoebe go over to look at him "Phoebe, I' sorry but it true" Paige says hugging Phoebe. "No that can't be why my new boss would, attack his best friend" Phoebe says as she sounds sure that that's not the demon that killed Jason. "You know him" Paige asks. "But he's not Red and black, he's" Phoebe says thinking to when she first meet him, she knew him some out, but she couldn't figure out how.
"Well" Paige ask impertinently. "Well I'm going call me if you need me" Phoebe said trying to change the subject. Phoebe Leave soon enough they here a door slam. "If it not him then who is it" Piper starts flipping through the book. "I'll go call Richard make sure he's still alive" Paige say then leaves. Piper looks at Leo. "I'll go check with the elders" Leo says trying to find away to leave. "O, no, you don't, you stay right here" Piper say. She starts walk over to him. "what did I do this time?" Leo says nervously. Piper goes over to him and starts to hug him "how about you and I have a little time for our self" Piper say with a look at say something else. "Right after I go check with the elders" Leo says walking away from Piper, then he orbs out